≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Similar posts:

Lump in Throat 19Lump on throat and pain on left side of neck 3Globus pharyngeus (lump in throat) 2Husband suffering from sensation of lump in throat, trouble breathing anxiety, fatigue 10Lump in Throat / Globus Hystericus 27Small Lump in Throat 5Post pregnancy throat lump 2lump in throat due to vocal strain 26lumps in throat 1Lump in throat sensation 1

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

lump in throat

I have feeling for many years that a lump is in my throat and also if i eat some thing after two or three hours the food eaten raises to my mouth and excess salivation



Please suggest remedies for this and advice me accordingly
[message edited by sdharmm1972 on Thu, 24 Feb 2011 22:20:38 CST]
 
  sdharmm1972 on 2011-02-18
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
It is very likely that you are suffering from GERD (Gastro Esophagal Reflux disease) and I shall copy the therapy I have prescribed to hundreds of patients who presented GERD, the large majority of whom have been cured.

Your remedies are as follows:

Nat Phos 6x dose 3-4 tablets taken immediately after each of 2 meals
Arnica 30c in the Wet dose taken twice daily.

You can expect relief from your ailment hopefully within 24 hours.
Do not eat large meals. Eat small meals but more often if you feel hungry.
It is important that you do not go to bed for at least 2 hours after dinner as food will take about this time to digest and it is best to stay awake and upright to enable your food to digest before going to bed.

No fatty food, alcohol, coffee, preserved meats like sausages, ham, bacon as they contain Saltpeter which will antidote the remedies listed immediately.

If you suffer from a stomach ache or you feel your stomach puffing up before a meal during the day between meals this is usually due to hunger pains, caused by your gastric juices attacking the inner wall of your stomach. The simple remedy is to eat some food like a biscuit or a banana to keep the gastric juice away from digesting the stomach wall when you will experience a stomach ache which in some cases can be very acute.

The Wet dose of any Homeopathic remedy is made as follows:

Order the remedy in a 5ml Ethanol pack also referred to as Liquid Dilution in a bottle preferably with a dropper arrangement.
Get a 500ml bottle of Spring Water from the nearest supermarket.
Pour out about 3cm of water from the bottle to leave some airspace.
Insert 3 drops of the remedy into the bottle and shake the bottle hard before you sip a capfull of the bottle or a large teaspoonful which is the dose.
Shaking the bottle hard is homeopathic succussion and this shaking must be done every time before sipping a capful of the bottle twice daily.

Please visit the links below which record the cases of other patients whom I have treated for GERD.

http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/66811/

http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/25315/

http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/209144/

STOP using all other drugs and report progress in a week.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
thank you for your reply i will try.

Also Please suggest remedy while sleeping I munch my mouth like chok chok my wife says its disturbing in night and in the morning i feel lot phlegm in my mouth.
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
The Nat Phos and Arnica will help with your problems.

Report progress in a week.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Thanks again will report the progress
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
As per the earlier advice i was able to take only nat phos, arnica is of no stock.

Almost more than a 15 days my left eye lid is twitching slightly.

Further I would like to add during sleep one of the nostril gets stuffed and also phlegm gets accumulated I think this creates the chok sound during sleep. In the morning I have nausea. A dull pain on my left chest.

Please suggest me remedy
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
please suggest remedy
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
I note that you have only taken the Nat Phos but not the Arnica as prescribed.

If you wish to be helped it is essential that you take the 2 remedies I have prescribed.

After you have done so I shall then try to help with the two other problems that you have reported which have no bearing on your GERD.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
there is lot of relief after taking Arnica 30 as prescribed.

even now some erucation is there. I never had burning sensation for your information.

Please suggest remedy for my other problems
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
Also all report I have bad breath while speaking

Please suggest remedies
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
How many tablets of Nat Phos do you take after a meal?
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Five to six
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
Joe,
Sorry to interfere here. For the feeling of lump in throat (Globus Hystericus) is prompty cured every time I give Ignatia 30, twice a day for a few days. I have cured several patients and the results are permanent. Rarely I follow up with Asaefoetida 6.

Information sharing purpose only. Please continue with your protocol, esp if it helps the patient.

Reva V
 
Reva V last decade
Thank u reva

The lump feeling is reducing gradually now my symptoms are neck pain, phlegm in morning and vomiting sensation while brushing and nervousness due to work and other factors.

Please suggest remedies
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
joe


The lump feeling is reducing gradually now my symptoms are neck pain, phlegm in morning and vomiting sensation while brushing and nervousness due to work and other factors.

i need ur assistance
 
sdharmm1972 last decade
The gagging/desire to vomit on brushing the teeth, the lump in the throat (clearly suppressed now), the accumulatuion of mucous in the mouth, the waterbrash, the sensation of choking, the general quality of nervousness - all these symptoms point to the remedy Coccus cacti.

It would be in your best interest to try a remedy that suits all of your symptoms rather than just one of them. A better result can be achieved when tying all your symptoms into one picture and prescribing on that.

Would you be willing to try Coccus cacti 30c?
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
have you experienced any emotional issues before the lump in the throat started? If so take Ign, sounds like it would be just from what you have said.
 
anna_jenkins last decade
To Sdharmm

You have reported that your GERD and your problem with your lump in your throat are slowly abating and it is best not to take other remedies when your present therapy is helping. You can also try brushing your teeth after a cup of tea instead of doing so immediately after you wake up as this can make the difference. Please report.

I note that David Kempson has suggested Coccus Cacti 30c but after reading up on this remedy on Boericke, I do not see the relevance. Perhaps he can explain how he singled out this remedy.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
I agree with Joe. Continue with Joe's protocol, since it is already working.

Prescribers asking 100s of questions, ends up with try this, try this and still not confident with what they selected and does not know whether it will work (ample evidence by reading thier cases!). Joe knows the action of remedy and he will guide you.


Reva V
 
Reva V last decade
The only symptom that is reducing is the lump in the throat - this is not 'working' - this is one symptom improving while leaving the rest of the case untouched (as very often happens with 'Joepathy'). Homoeopathy should improve many if not all symptoms, not just one. One symptom improving only, is failure not success.

Nausea/gagging/desire to vomit on brushing the teeth is a specific keynote for Coccus cacti - and the other symptoms are also found in this remedy. Boericke does not give the complete picture found by looking in other materia medicas and repertories. This keynote is taught to all students of homoeopathy and immediately brings the remedy to mind.

Not only are all the mentioned symptoms found in this remedy, but the Choking is highly indicative of both this remedy and Insect remedies in general.
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
I find it strange that David still persists in prescribing Coccus Cacti in this case where the patient first reported:
'I have feeling for many years that a lump is in my throat and also if i eat some thing after two or three hours the food eaten raises to my mouth and excess salivation'

In this case the patient has already confirmed that he had noticed considerable relief from his original condition after a few days on my therapy. He has so far referred to his Lump in his throat and his gagging when brushing his teeth and it would be of interest to learn if he has noticed any improvement in his general condition especially in the regurgitation of food after a few hours.

This is due to the Pyloric Valve in the stomach not opening to permit the passage of food into the small intestines. The Nat Phos when taken immediately after a meal ensures that the passage of food is accelerated into the intestines thereby preventing the refluxing of food up into the Esophagus and Throat. The lump in the patient's throat is in my opinion due to the refluxed gastric juice which has affected and perhaps burnt his throat and even damaged his vocal chords. The gagging may be due to an involuntary spasm of his throat muscles when brushing his teeth in the morning and I believe that when his GERD is stabilized all his other ailments will also abate.

This is another example of how in classical homeopathy the prescriber insists on fitting the ailment to the remedy instead of the other way round to prescribe the remedy for the ailment. I have in this case, prescribed the 2 remedies based on my past experience in treating hundreds, perhaps unknown thousands of patients who suffer from GERD, the large majority of whom were helped usually within 6 hours on my default therapy, (Nat Phos 6x and Arnica 30c) when their acute symptoms abated.

David states:
'The only symptom that is reducing is the lump in the throat - this is not 'working' - this is one symptom improving while leaving the rest of the case untouched (as very often happens with 'Joepathy'). Homoeopathy should improve many if not all symptoms, not just one. One symptom improving only, is failure not success. '

The Joepathy I prescribed has obviously helped the patient in about a week and I would not recommend that he stops my therapy and changes over to Coccus Cacti that David prescribes merely because it is listed in the Keynotes and data found in the other (unknown) MM's and Repertories that David refers to which he considers essential to cure the patient who has strangely enough already confirmed that his condition has improved in this short time. It is my hope that his ailments will improve in the future with my therapy.

If however they do not, David can take over and use his classical expertise to cure the patient.

I would like to place on record that this is by no means the first time that David has criticized my Joepathy which he has done in other cases on the ABC in a manner similar to this present case even after the patient has confirmed that he was helped or even cured. He seems to delight in his unfailing criticism of my Joepathy on many occasions on the ABC, merely because it does not conform to his Classical Diktat.

He must understand that my Joepathy is designed to help the patient towards an eventual cure and not be the source of continuous attacks and criticism from just one individual who seems obsessed with the idea that it is only Classical Homeopathy, as interpreted by David Kempson, that can do so.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Joe,

I am sorry you take so much of your time in writing long explanation that will have less returns.

Please save your time in future and I would advice to 'ignore' and continue your good work.

Reva V
 
Reva V last decade
May God bless you all? Please let's move forward by helping this patient without creating anymore confusion. Alternative suggestions and constructive criticism is good, but, we must love and respect each other.

Kind Regards
Nawaz
 
nawazkhan last decade
My thanks go to you both, Reva and Nawaz for having advised me to ignore the ravings of this impostor whom I have classified as a Hypocrite in another thread where he dared to override my warning to the mother not to give Arsenic 6c and advised her that it was absolutely OK to continue to give her son Arsenic 6c in the Dry Pellets purely because he could not fall asleep.

It is precisely this form of errant nonsense that gets my goat and I was compelled to show David up for the classical impostor that he is.

I hope that he will at least now desist from criticizing my therapy in future.

Warm Regards

Joe
 
Joe De Livera last decade
To Lycopidium

It is quite late here in Sri Lanka where I live but I felt that I should reassure you that my Joepathy has never harmed anyone unlike the classical form of this science that some misguided individuals insist on enforcing on unsuspecting members of this Forum which has in one case resulted in the patient whom I was treating ending up in the ER as another classical homeopath had prescribed a remedy which had caused her grave distress.

If you are interested in my therapy aka 'Joepathy' please type this term into Google and read the many thousands of my choice cases that have been singled out by Google without any influence from me, to illustrate my curative approach to Homeopathy which is slowly gaining more acceptance daily from the suffering public who have been duped by classical homeopathy as practiced today.

It is heartening for me to note that the majority of practicing Homeopaths in this part of the world do not subscribe to classical homeopathy as they have found that my direct 'this for that' method which you too classified as Allopathic in its approach, works far more effectively than the classical method which the more expensive homeopaths use as it gives them the right to dupe the patient and charge unconscionable fees.

In direct contrast the therapy that I prescribe both on the Forums and at home here in Sri Lanka is absolutely free of charge as to me it is the Joy of Healing that matters at my advanced age of 82 years.

May I also invite you to visit my own website

joedelivera.com
 
Joe De Livera last decade
To Lyco

I would like to reassure you that I do not categorically rule out the use of the classical approach to cure with Homeopathic remedies. You may like to know that I use Radar software which I have on my computer to solve a case that is not responding to my Joepathy. The point I wish to make is that the classical approach is sometimes abused by the classical homeopath who feels that it is the only approach towards healing with Homeopathic remedies.

It is just that I resent the continued intrusions of the classical homeopaths into the cases that I am trying to heal on this and other Forums, especially when they adopt that holier than thou attitude born out of their arrogance which they feel gives them the license to belittle the therapy I prescribe to the patient who in a case I was treating a few days ago had already confirmed that his condition had improved vastly after a few weeks on my therapy.

I have never been an arrogant type throughout my long life and I expect others who wish to comment on the cases that I am treating not to criticize my therapy with that supercilious arrogance that they feel they are entitled to, merely because they possess that piece of paper from their colleges that qualifies them to be addressed as 'doctor'.

As I stated in my last post, it is the Joy of Healing that motivates me to be present on this ABC of which I was one of the first members shortly after it was established by Simon Broadley in the early years of this Century and it now is the most visited Homeopathic Forum with about 10000 hits daily. It is the first hit you get on any Search engine when you type in the word 'Homeopathy'. It is my hope that I will be around here for as long as I live and all I ask these classical types is to leave me in peace and only criticize my Joepathy if they discover that the therapy I have prescribed has harmed the patient.

They are free to comment but not to criticize which some of them do, unfairly.
 
Joe De Livera last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.