≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Remedies:

Pulsatilla: $6.59Professional Constitutional Kit #1: $180.00First Aid Kit: $180.00

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Pls Advice-Pulsatilla and Natmur combination

Can Natmur and Pulsatilla be taken together?
 
  HoneyKhanna on 2014-08-04
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
You shouldn't do that, as the two remedies are almost polar opposites. Nobody would need both, at least not at the same time.

Mixing remedies is only done because practitioners cannot find one remedy that suits, not because you actually are two remedies at the same time. Doing this creates problems - possible antidoting of each other, possibility of interacting with each other in unforseen ways, complicated proving symptoms being added to the symptoms you already have.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Can these be taken under category of mixing remedies.I have observed I have layers indicating pulsatilla and Natmur where it's more natrum and little pulsatilla.pls advice
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
I don't believe in layers - one vital force, one state, one remedy. That is how I have seen it in clinic. People can change from one remedy to another over time, but not exist in two states at once, no more than you can be two people at once.

If someone needed Pulsatilla in the past, that does not mean the remedy will do anything for them now if the state calls for Nat-mur, nor would they ever necessarily need the remedy again.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
I agree with you,but hoe do we evaluate that previous layer, if pulsatilla is cured.
Please help me in judging that.
Regards
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
I don't really understand. What do you mean 'evaluate the previous layer'?
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Honey,

Evocationer is saying - prescribe on the totality of the present time.

There is only one totality in present time.

He does not believe in the 'layer' theory. Remedies work when they
Match the totality in present time. If a remedy stops working, etc
then the homeopath looks at your case again and comes up with
-What is the totality NOW- after you have taken the previous remedy.
 
simone717 9 years ago
Thanks Simone :)

My confusion is:
In book by Philip B.
I read
'Once the intellect begins to take over and 'edit' the
child's emotional life, the Pulsatilla state has gone.'

The next closest stage mentioned here is Nat mur.
This is what I see in me.

With respect to what I mentioned above, I wanted to know, how do we get sure that Pulsatilla stage is gone and nat mur has started.

I have been on pulsatilla30 single dose.This worked for me for 20 days or more, how ever Natrum LM dose is just working for a week.
So please help me in knowing, how to understand ,which dose and what potency is required for total cure.
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Hi Honey,

You can't go by the book by Philip B-actually that book got some severe
criticism by other homeopaths. You want to go by matching your
state now- taking your case and matching the physicals, mentals, what makes
things better and worse- like cures like-according to Hahnemann.

Who is prescribing for you now?

What do you mean Nat Mur LM ( what LM potency) is working for a week-
you mean it is working or it stopped working?

It sounds like your case has to be re-taken.
[message edited by simone717 on Thu, 07 Aug 2014 07:52:04 BST]
 
simone717 9 years ago
Yeah do not trust Bailey's book - it is full of many unfortunate statements that have confused students and lay people alike, as it is doing with you.

You will not get any cure trying to use that as some kind of template for curing yourself. It makes no sense from a homoeopathic point of view anyway.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Rather I have been fortunate enough when its about this book.When I was in problem and was not able to get any help , this book helped me.
I have also checked my symptoms and as if now,my remedy is nat mur.
Request you to help me with dosage.
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Thu, 07 Aug 2014 11:33:43 BST]
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
As I requested before, please help me with dose for nat mur.
Regards
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Dear Honey,

You would have to do a new post for Evocationer.

He would have to take your case and decide for himself if he thinks
Nat Mur at this time Matches your totality.

Only then would he go over LM's and what you are doing with them if he
thinks they are the right medicine at this time.
 
simone717 9 years ago
I can do that.
I just saw,Evocationer is Doctor David
 
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Well I am not a doctor - a homoeopath yes, but not a medical doctor.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.