≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Remedies:

Arnica Montana: $6.59

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

My 6yr old son crying in the night if no Arnica 30c

Hi,

We have been having problem with our child...he complained of stomach pain and gave him 30C for three days...

Then i learned later that he fell from a hut...and seems that he is blinking during sleep and that his thumb is going inside his palm...

So since that is a fall injury and we do not know how many days have passed since the injury, I gave him arnica 30c 2-3x a day. Then i read from the post that giving 30c for long days will cause aggravatin so I stopped maybe on the 6th day. Then on the night that I stopped giving the arnica, he is shouting during his sleep. But during the following day he seemed okay. Then the next night without arnica, he is crying and shouting again and kept scratching his skin. Out of desperation, I gave him arnica 30c again and after 1-2 crying spell, he fell asleep. He also sleep better if he takes arnica.

Now, my question is is it okay to give arnica 30c again tonight and daily aftewards? I learned from the postings of Mr Joe de Livera that he takes and directs his patients to take arnica daily...

My son's illness is complicated and will post later on his diagnosis. But as of the moment, I want to know if daily dose of arnica 30c is fine. Although i did notice that his eczema seems to worsen with the arnica. Its difficult to get 6c because we are far from a homeopath.
THank you!
 
  Jane77 on 2014-11-01
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
What are his symptoms, everything that is bothering you.
 
fitness 9 years ago
No daily doses of 30c are not fine. You should not need to give the remedy that often to maintain the effect. This is what we call palliation in homoeopathy, and eventually palliation turns into suppression. Suppression causes the original problem to be pushed deeper into the person, often reappearing as something worse.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Ayes, it seems what you said is true....before he is very much better after a few doese of arnica...nor he is crying more in the evening with more itching....

So what should i do now? Stop the arnica and wait and see....then answer your questions on what his
Present symptoms are? I will try to answer the soonest but we are travelling right now because we're going to the city for his evaluation/diagnosis...i think it is best if we know his diagnosis before selecting a ny remedy?

By the way he got too constipated after taking a baking soda in water(which is the cause of much of his present problems) and for around 2wks he got nomrelief even after taking antibiotics for 10days...so the other night i gave him 1 dose of Nux Vomica 30C. The following morning he has better bowel movement..he is so happy...

But im afraid of nux vomica 30c because ive seen some thread where they got aggravation after taking nux vomica for days...
Can you recommend any book or website that discusses the dosaging of homeopathic meds?
Thank you so much again!
 
Jane77 9 years ago
Oh I am sorry, I did not notice...who is going to take our case? Is it Evocationer or fitness? Or could both of them take our case?

By the way in the Philippines it is hard to get homeopathic meds...I have to source out internationally becuase our local homeopath here stores only a few remedies from weleda and the local meds are in powder form and alcohol form in 6C onlsy...my kids are very allergic to milk or lactose....we are currently using Boiron pellets and I dissolve them in water...

Thank you
 
Jane77 9 years ago
I just checked out Evocationer's profile...he specializes in mental health...and thtat is what I need for me and my kids...

So Can you please take our case Evocationer? Fitness i dont mean to be rude I just want someone who specializes in mental health...

Thank you so much!
 
Jane77 9 years ago
colocynth200 one drop in bed time
 
dr a kundu 9 years ago
Jane, let evocationer take up the case. Homeopathy is his day job.

Ignore all what else is posted here.
 
fitness 9 years ago
Thank you, Fitness..I will let Evocationer take the case. Will you please, Evocationer?
 
Jane77 9 years ago
Hi there. Sorry I missed your request.

Let me post a questionnaire for you to use. I don't know how old your son is, so some of these questions may not be appropriate. Answer as many as you can though.

CASE PRESENTATION FOR CLASSICAL HOMOEOPATHIC PRESCRIBING

General Guidelines:

1. Try to be as descriptive as possible. When describing pains or sensations use descriptions along the lines of ‘feels as if someone is squeezing it with their hand’ or ‘it is like an insect crawling around inside’ or ‘it is as if someone is standing over me threatening to kill me’. Long descriptions are always better than short ones. One word answers are difficult to use successfully.

2. Another important part of symptom description for homoeopathy are the ‘modalities’. These are situations, events, activities or conditions which modify the symptom in some way. We usually refer to this as what makes them ‘better’ or ‘worse’ (amelioration/aggravation). The situation may actually provoke the symptom into appearing, make it vanish altogether, or just increase or decrease it in some way. Modalities are vital information for prescribing.

Modalities are typically related to (but not exclusively) the following situations:

A. Temperature, weather
B. Time (day, night, specific times, frequency, periodicity, season)
C. Position, activity
D. Emotions, thoughts
E. Food and drink
F. Drugs, medication

3. How the symptom is perceived is important too – odour, appearance, sound, touch. What colour is it, what is its texture? For gestures, describe what it looks like the patient is doing, or what you feel you are doing while making the movement eg. ‘they look like they are swatting flies’ or ‘I feel like something is pushing my hand upwards’ or ‘it is like I stick a fork in an electrical outlet which throws my body backwards’. Description – it is key to accurate prescriptions.

4. When did the symptom or set of symptoms start? The apparent cause can be useful in determining the remedy, although it is not of the same importance as the previous factors. It may have been a specific event, a disease, an accident or even an emotional experience.

5. Use your own words. Do not copy phrases or descriptions found in our various remedy pictures. Try not to use other people’s ideas or thoughts or words. If you are reporting on behalf of someone else, report their exact words, however you can also report your own observations of them (not opinions).

6. Does the symptom occur alongside another specific symptom? Do particular symptoms only occur together? Does a particular symptom occur with a particular thought or emotion? For example, a headache that always comes with visual disturbances, or stomach pain that appears alongside anger, or anxiety that makes you feel like running down the street screaming.

7. Each complaint should be described fully before going on to describe another complaint. Try not to mix different symptoms or complaints together. Each modifying feature must be clearly attached to a particular symptom/set of symptoms. Any mistake you make here is a mistake the homoeopath will also then make.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Describe each physical complaint/associated set of symptoms in detail. Please include the following when doing this:

1. Appearance
2. Sensation or pain
3. Situations/events/triggers for making it worse
4. Situations/events/triggers for making it better
5. Event that seemed to start the complaint
6. Other sensory features – smell, sound, taste, tactile etc

Make sure each complaint is done separately. Do not group them together. This is for physical complaints/diseases.


MENTAL STATE OF THE CHILD (IMPORTANT)

1. When the physical complaint is active, what is his/her emotional state like? What does he/she do? What does she/he want you to do?

2. Does he/she describe any unusual sensation or pain in the body, especially when they are complaining of something?

3. What fears does he/she have? How does she/he react?

4. Was there any incident in the past that had a great impact? What happened at the time? Is there any ongoing reaction to this event? How does he/she talk about it?

5. Is there any story (book, fairytale, cartoon, movie etc) that seems to really resonate with her/him? What does he/she say about it?

6. What kind of fantasies does she/he describe to you? How does this translate down into play, games, toys? Does he/she tend to draw particular things over and over? If so what are they? If you point to these images, what does she/he say about them?

7. Does he/she describe any dreams or nightmares to you, and what are they? How does she/he react on waking from them?

8. How is he/she when interacting with other children? What about sports or games? How about obeying rules or social conventions?

9. How is she/he when interacting with older people? Is there any difference between family or friends and strangers in terms of reactions and behavior?

10. What kind of activities does he/she enjoy doing? Which of these do she/he spend the most time at?

11. What qualities seem to make your child different from other children?

12. How does your child cope with school, school work, study, deadlines, speaking in front of others, following directions etc?

13. What kind of questions does he/she tend to ask you or other adults?

14. What makes her/him laugh? What makes him/her cry?

15. What makes him/her angry or irritable?

16. What does your child do when alone?

17. Is there a particular person or type of person that he/she reacts to, and what kind of reaction?


GENERAL STATE OF YOUR CHILD

1. What position does he/she sleep in?
2. Is there any position he/she seems unable to sleep in?
3. Any unusual behaviour during sleep?
4. Any problems with sleep?
5. What foods are craved (cravings are strong desires) What foods are hated?
6. What drinks are craved? What drinks are hated?
7. How does he/she react when hungry, or hunger is prolonged?
8. How does the weather affect?
9. How does the temperature affect?
10. Are there any other environmental influences negative or positive (season, noise, music, moon, light, dark, day, night, time, smells etc.)
11. Problems with stool or bowel habit?
Problems with urine or bladder habit?
12. Where does he/she sweat most? Does it stain or smell unusual?

PREGNANCY AND BIRTH

1. What kind of health problems occurred while you were pregnant with your child?

2. Were there any other stresses or traumas that occurred?

3. Did the birth itself have any problems?

4. Do you remember if any symptoms occurred suddenly during pregnancy that then vanished after your child was born? Especially important are any emotional or mental changes during this time.
 
Evocationer 9 years ago
Evocationer thank you. But I will put a thought on each question as this I know will determine the accuracy of the remedy to be prescribed...Will hope to describe what I know (follow up answers aftr I get some diagnosis). Thank you Evocationer!
 
Jane77 9 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.