Loss of smell

Write about following:
Age/Gender/Location/Country/Ethnicity. Height / Weight /Skin color/Eye color.

PLease explain everything in detail. Don't try to cut short.

All your past and present health in sequence oldest to newest. All details of previous treatments (oldest to newest) and their effects.

Write in detail about you – emotions, fears, sentiments, etc. your personality, physical parameters, habits, feelings about life, etc.

Write in detail about your life: social, family, occupational, schooling, childhood, etc. You should mention about incidences that might have influenced or impacted your mind / health / life considerably.

Write about what common opinions most people have about you; what most people comment /say about you frequently; how they react / interact with you & why?

Write something unique about you (how you are different from others or what makes you special).

take kali bichromium 10m daily single dose for three days only and report back

Hi Nisha

Can you please enlighten us as to why you always prescribe higher potencies like 10M and above?

What is the philosophy behind it?

People without any professional ethics and die hard dirty habits keep intruding.

vtechy1, you must follow only one advice and let me know if you want to follow me and post the details.

because its chronic disease ,i am not here to disturb,you got the point...

taking few dose of high potency ,can know better about improvements, for chronic complains giving below 1m is not acceptable for me.

Nisha,
What is your education in homeopathy? What is your background ? You have nothing about yourself in your profile?

The owner/ of forum believes as do probably everyone on here that prescribing high potency ONLINE is dangerous.

We have never had anyone on here doing this before .. There can be long term effects and cause health problems by doing this.
.

I can guess somethings about her. She is everything of reading Dr. V Krishnamurthy and is impressed. After reading a lot she is under delusion that she has reached his caliber or she sees herself in his shoes but she lacks experience with such high potencies which she wants to experiment on desperate vulnerable people without risking herself.

Well, prescribing High potencies sometime is not a big problem I feel but the way she is doing is very unprofessional and cheap practice. She seems to be in euphoria and needs herself some doses first.

Prescribing high does have risks even when seen in person. I have helped people on here who saw real homeopaths/USA and uk who were proving remedies so badly they lost their jobs.
Krishnamurthy has been on here himself saying things like Bach flowers prescriptions work 100 percent. Nothing works 100 percent and when I and others dared to say rescue remedy had zero effect on us .he did not like it and stopped posting. There are some other well known USA homeopaths who follow him, and their sites also list cases that are exaggerated sure fire results.

So to tell me that rescue remedy is 100 percent and discount actual results of people? Sounds like his fame has gone to his head and he just has yes men around him.

Even though this is a forum for insurance purposes .. We all know it is also a clinic. Unfortunately it is up to clinic members to police people asking to be emailed, interupting cases, telling half truths, and experimenting with no experience etc

I find it disturbing to see wonderful help being given, learning from posts and at same time people getting advice that can ruin their health bc they do not check out their prescribers previous posts.

Dear vtechy,
Sorry your thread got disturbed.
Please let dr k know if you would like him to continue on with your case.

Yes, I have gone through V krishnamurhty's books and I could realise that his claims and proposals are exaggerated. I had even sent couple of patients to him. They reported hardly any benefit. That doesn't mean his claims and methods are 100% fake or his caliber is questionable. However, his statements should be taken with pinch of salt.

Nice way to put it.:)

so,yes

here is my response for chossing kali bich


see homoeopathic therapeutics
by samuel lilienthal
under Ozaena or ozaena syphili

read kali bich its matches the patient exactly.

This is from Lilienthal,Ozaena chapter.

Kali-bichrom [Kali-bi]
NOSE FEELS UNNATURALLY DRY, being obstructed by large clinkers of dark-greenish, foetid, hardened masses, hawked up from post- nasal space, (<) morning till noon; rapid exfoliation and ulceration; loss of smell; PERFORATING ULCERS ON SEPTUM AND ELSEWHERE; desires and fulness from inflammation of frontal sinuses; ropy, tough mucous discharge from posterior nares, offensive or not; polypus nasi

**********

Yes. This covers the nose symptoms. But, what about his gum disease and tooth symptoms?
[message edited by gavinimurthy on Sun, 25 Sep 2016 17:42:48 UTC]

see,gums,diseases of...

under the same remedy kali bich

you get answer for gums and tooth,

if a homeo doctor covers only symptoms thats lead to big failure.better start come out of from maya,they miss important point,

ok anyway let the patient itself can decide whom to follow.....

More over

Even as per Lilienthal, loss of smell is there in other remedies too.

Alumina : WEAK OR ENTIRE LOSS OF SMELL.

Graphites : loss of smell, dryness of nose.

Sanguinaria, sepia,

Alumina is of the highest grade. Of course he mentions sinus only in Kali bich.

But, that alone won't justify your choice. As I asked earlier what about his gum disease?

For your information, kali bich covers swelling of gums and loose teeth too, but so does sepia.

In such a case, how do you choose between sepia and this? You have to get more information to confirm your choice.

Of course, Kali bich is the first medicine that comes to our minds, when you talk about sinus. Nothing wrong in trying it. But better to start with a few doses of 200 potency and observe.

You should have the knowledge on how to follow up, if your selected remedy fails.

If you depend only on Lilienthal, how do you proceed in case Kali bich fails to relieve?

That is why a homeopath should be thorough with repertory, and should have knowledge of many materia Medicas. Of course, he must be aware of the philosophy too.

Our posts have crossed. I confirmed what you said. But, what about sepia?

And what about my other questions?

"If a homeo doctor covers only symptoms, that leads to big failure."

This is what you said. What exactly did you do in this case?

You prescribed on the symptoms only. Why you didn't ask for more info, if you know that prescribing on symptoms will lead to failure?

In fact, if you read Lilienthal properly, sepia is mentioned in gum diseases too. In fact ,alumina too covers all the symptoms.

What are your comments?

we will see tomorrow morning.

In fact, there are many case histories where sepia and alumina too helped for cases like these.

As you said, symptoms are only one side of the patient. PQRS symptoms and the generals of the patient are the key.

Ok. Take rest.

I think patient retreated due to all this chaos.

you should ask or interrupt the patients,he only himself can tell about his/her problems,after completing his speech,we can ask some of his past history,

this is what successful homeo doctors did in the past.

now all are quotation to fill is utter waste.

Hi nisha

We are discussing about your prescription of Kali bich 10M. I am telling that with the limited information we have, we can't zero in on the similimum , and there are other possibilities.

I am also suggesting that, it is better to start with 200 potency of a probable remedy.

Discuss on this, instead of evading the discussion with general , vague answers.

I can see that you are not comfortable with English. You can try Hindi too, to express yourself clearly.