≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

plz help me

well i had problem and i am very much hurted from this problem.i had this problem when i was in 5th class that whatever i eat it comes into my mouth again and again.or just try to come up slowly and stays at the chest.i tell this symptoms to a doctor he said u have gerd and your lower valve is weaker.is there any remedy to which can make stronger this valve.
and my weight is 50 kg.i have often indigestion which causes a soureness my tounge taste often is tasteless.if i drink milk it has no effect rather i feel weak.
 
  shabbir_bzu on 2006-05-25
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Dear Shabbir bzu,
I advise you to take Nux Vomica 30 one dose daily for 7 days.
Do not take spicy,fried food.

Report after 7 days.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Thanks for replying.well plz mention a remedies which can fullfill my strength and removes weakness.i dont like to do any work.
 
shabbir_bzu last decade
Natrum Phos 3x,5 tablets four times daily for certain period of time alongwith nux will solve your problem.


sajjad.
 
sajjadakram635 last decade
Sajjad

I am glad to note that others also prescribe Nat Phos for GERD.

I presume that you are aware that Nat Phos 3x in the dose you have recommended of 5 tablets x 4 times daily will be a gross overdose. I have sometimes used NP 6x with 3 tablets 3 times daily and the patient noticed a bitter taste in his mouth.

In this case I would recommend Nat Phos 6x dose 2 tablets taken after lunch and dinner and you might like to know that I have helped hundreds of cases of GERD with this simple remedy which is very effective when taken in this dosage. It also cures the ailment which some have suffered from for many years. In the majority of cases this remedy will cure it within a month when the patient can stop the daily dosage but in others it may be necessary to take it for longer periods depending on the state of the esophagus which is usually badly eroded by the regurgitation of gastric juices right up to the throat for years when in some cases the throat muscles are also damaged and the patient has difficulty in swallowing food. Even these extreme cases have reacted favourably to the Nat Phos 6x used daily but this will usually take a few months.

I noticed that someone had prescribed Nux Vomica 30 but I do not think that this can help the patient at all.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,
I dont know about your experience but I have seen results.As Dr.Sajjad has prescribed Nat.Phos 6x... It will help patient with Nux Vomica 30.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Dear Dinesh,

I note that you question my experience in Homeopathy and you may like to know that although I have not qualified in this science and do not have a diploma in Homeopathy like you, Sajjad and a few others on this forum, I do have spent a lifetime in the study of this science which I at first could not accept. I have been born with a very rational and logical mind and was at first a skeptic who did not believe that a substance when diluted to infinitesimal proportions could still work. It was only when I was cured of my frequent colds in 1968 that I decided to make a study of Homeopathy in my free time and when I felt sufficiently competent to help others I did so later when I discovered that I had that God given gift of healing. I then came across the ABC and other forums dedicated to Homeopathy where many patients post in the hope of finding a cure. If you are interested you can click on my name above and read some of my posts on this forum which I believe are now approaching the 3000 mark, the majority of which have resulted in the cure of the patient's ailment.

I do not use the strictly classical method of case taking and of prescribing only for the symptoms and causative factors of an ailment as I prescribe directly for the ailment as I did in this case by prescribing Nat Phos 6x for GERD which I have used to cure countless grateful patients. I use my prior experience in the use of a remedy and it is only when I am satisfied that it will help a patient that I then prescribe it.

You may like to know that I use Radar 9.1 whenever I am confronted with a difficult case which I an not familiar with and as you may know, this software enables one to use the same classical method which you have been taught to use during your studies and you may like to know that it far superior to the knowledge that you may have gathered during your studies in your homeopathic college, as it uses the collective works of about 50 specialists in Homeopathy to suggest a remedy.

Homeopathy to me is only a Hobby as I am at 76 years the CEO of a very old family owned business organization in Sri Lanka established in 1924. I now have some free time after I was joined by my sons and I use it to help anyone in distress which I have always done free of charge with my knowledge of Homeopathy. I have proved beyond any doubt that my own direct allopathic method of prescribing for the ailment is far more effective than the classical method that I presume you use where you prescribe after the usual case taking procedure which in the many cases you may have handled does not always give the same dramatic results that I mentioned above. I have discovered that the direct approach method that I promote is far more positive as the results can be expected usually within 24 hours like the case of the 7 year old boy who was a chronic asthmatic who responded to Nat Sulph 6c in the Split Dose which you may have have read on:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/55717/5

I do not blame homeopaths like you for insisting that a cure can only result if the case is taken in the classical manner because you were taught so, but my request to you and to other classical types is that you should also use my own direct method as I have found that it works wonderfully well. You must remember that as a professional homeopath who charges for the time and the experience that you spend in treating a patient, the patient's quick recovery is the primary concern and it is your duty to prescribe a remedy that will help him to recover ASAP. There is no use experimenting with various remedies by following the classical case taking method that you have been trained to use in your studies which you will see from the link above of the asthmatic boy, did not work while in direct comparison my direct approach method did work; and it did so in such a spectacular manner that even I considered was incredible, as his response was almost immediate.

I would urge you to step down off the pedestal that you seem to have elevated yourself after you obtained your diploma in homeopathy. I mention this point as I was shocked to read the thread that you started last week entitled: 'Doctors do not interfere with others.'
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/64052/

You will observe that many homeopaths who have been present on this forum purely on a voluntary basis to help anyone who posts their ailments here have rebuked you in no uncertain terms, and I too gave you some food for thought. I would ask you to remember that on a forum such as the ABC we the prescribers, are all equal. The mere fact that you may have a diploma which you feel entitles you and a few others to insist on prefixing your name with Dr. does not mean anything at all to the patients and to the homeopaths on this forum. I could have myself have used this prefix as many who know me and have been cured by me address me as Dr. but I always tell them that it is not the 'doctorate' that matters. It is the giving of one's knowledge and experience which is in my case also added to by my giving the necessary remedies to the patient who sees me personally, to help him to cure his ailment for which he sought my assistance.

We do not criticize you for your views and we expect that you will reciprocate by respecting ours. I believe that your main failing is that you lack the humility that is essential to mark your progress through life and this does not include only homeopathy. I do not know how old you are and what your experience and qualification are and quite frankly I do not care. I do however care when you stoop to questioning my own credentials and my experience in prescribing any remedy and you may like to know that I and a few others are the senior members on the ABC and is it is possible that I may be the most senior. The fact that we have been consistently been on this forum may give you some indication of the regard that most members hold us in.

I am 76 years of age and I am perhaps old enough to be your grandfather. I hope that you will take my advice and not unnecessarily take that same uppity attitude in questioning me on this thread and also in trying to 'teach your grandmother to suck eggs' as the proverbial English saying goes, which is precisely what you did in your own holier than thou thread 'Doctors do not interfere with others' which I hope for your own sake, you will not repeat in future.

Joe De Livera
Colombo
Sri Lanka
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Hi Joe ....I thought you were all for a free exchange of views on the Forum ??

You now brought in a 'grandma with her basket of eggs and a walking stick' into the Forum.....'how risky after a whisky !!!'.

Nobody have absolute monopoly over knowledge.

All progress in the world takes place coz the younger generation is coming up with new ideas...so this argument of being '76 year old big brother with unmatched knowledge and skill' doesn't gel.

Tomorrow, someone will come here and say I am 80 years of age ..so I have superior knowledge and skill ...as compared to you all....will you accept it??

Dear Sajjad Akram and Dinesh Sharma..I am all for a healthy discussion...and posting of different experiences.

Those guys who cannot 'take opposing views' in their stride...better take 'Lycopodium".

Best wishes,

Pankaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Pankaj,

I believe that you have missed the point about my argument as per my last post. I have no problem with anyone prescribing any remedy, within reason of course, on this forum.

However I did take umbrage against Dinesh when he questioned my experience which lead to my choice of the remedy, in this case Nat Phos 6x for this obvious case of GERD and the manner he did so by stating:

'I dont know about your experience but I have seen results.As Dr.Sajjad has prescribed Nat.Phos 6x... It will help patient with Nux Vomica 30. '

It is his choice of words 'I dont know about your experience' that I felt was worthy of my strong rejoinder to remind him that it is not only those who have been through a diploma course that can prescribe but those who have the experience born of years of treating patients which remedies that have been observed to work satisfactorily. I do not for a moment question his prescribing Nux Vomica which he has every right to do on an open forum such as this.

It is just the outlook of the present generation who feel that age and experience in anything falls only second to their own pseudo classical methods they have been taught in college and they refuse to even consider the advice and in this case the prescription that I have used of Nat Phos 6x for countless cases of chronic GERD.

I would request you to please read my last post over again and if you have anything more constructive to discuss after doing so, I shall await your response.

Joe De Livera
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Hi Joe...tonite...lets have a drink together...and chat it out !!
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Joe,
Why are you creating mess here again.
I just said I dont know about your experience means I dont know you had got results or not.Simple.Why you have taken it otherwise.
Infacrt I supported Nat Phos.As Dr.Sajjad and you also prescribed it.

Dont make it a prestige issue.

Relax.
Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
And it was you who said this about my prescription joe....

I noticed that someone had prescribed Nux Vomica 30 but I do not think that this can help the patient at all.

Mind it.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Dear Pankaj,

No hard feelings !

It is just that I could not understand your viewpoint as expressed in your post which you had obviously made in a hurry without really reading the full impact of my post and I had to elaborate my position to you in my last post.

I do wish that I can accept your invitation but if I ever visit Mumbai where I presume you live, I shall not fail to take you up on your offer.

Kind Regards

Joe
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Not done in a hurry Joe !!
My offer stands.

Best wishes,
Pankaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Dinesh,

I would request you to please note that it was not I that was responsible for 'creating mess here again'.

I was merely replying to Pankaj who had obviously misread my post and I felt that I had to correct the impression that he had made that I was talking out of turn.

As I have already stated in a previous post, I have been blessed with a very precise mind and it has always been my failing that if I am feel that some injustice has been done to not only myself but even anyone else, I have to either justify my position as I have done in my last post or in the case of anyone else I have always rushed to their defense to ensure that justice is done.

In the case of Pankaj, I believe that he misinterpreted the gist of my post and this resulted in my post in defense of my viewpoint which I feel was justified in the circumstances. It is only unfortunate that I had to criticize him whom I still consider a friend, in doing so.

It is a pity that I had to be rather harsh on you too in my two posts and I hope that you too will reflect about what I have stated in these posts and you must understand that it is for your own good that I did so, especially in view of your other post entitled 'Doctors do not interfere with others.'
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/64052

I am of opinion that this post was totally uncalled for and you will observe from the comments of many who joined me in our criticism of your attitude, that we are all of this same opinion.

As far as my treatment for GERD is concerned you have only to refer to many of my posts in the past on the ABC to know that I have always used it as my default remedy as I have ample evidence that it works. It can work very quickly in the case of new cases of this ailment but if it is chronic it may take a few weeks before the esophagus is slowly healed inside and I then supplement it with Arnica 30c to ensure that the repair of the tissue damaged by the gastric juice is accelerated.

If you read your post again you will notice that my interpretation of it where I felt that you were questioning my credentials was justified although I note that what you wished to imply was only to question my use of Nat Phos 6x for GERD which as you now know, I have used for many years very successfully. You may also like to know that I discovered that NP 6x is the ultimate remedy to reduce weight and it does so at the rate of about 0.5 to 1kg per week.

I shall be happy to see you continue on this forum and hope that you will remember the advice that I have given you.

Joe De Livera
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,
Don't mount your gun on my shoulder...deal with Dinesh directly...he is objecting to the fact that you said Nux Vomica will do no good.

I reproduce your exact words:
(Last line of your post dated 26-05-2006 addressed to Sajjad).
'I noticed that someone had prescribed Nux Vomica 30 but I do not think that this can help the patient at all'

If you think Nux Vomica will do no good in this case..sorry ...many knowledgeable people feel otherwise ...including me.

Best wishes,
Pankaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear joe,

I dont need any favour from your side.And if you have read that post then from its title it is very much clear that please do not interfere and if you have any other medicine in mind then talk to doctor instead of saying like as you did on 26/05/06 addressed to Sajjad..
'I noticed that someone had prescribed Nux Vomica 30 but I do not think that this can help the patient at all'

Never do this again.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Dear Dinesh,

You are upbraiding me again for having advised the patient that Nux Vomica 30c could not help him. In my experience I have used it twice in the past and discovered that it did not have the slightest effect to relieve GERD. In the case of Nat Phos 6x however the results are usually felt within 15 minutes and the patient who comes in real distress is quickly relieved. You may like to know that I have used some of the other remedies that are listed in Boricke but none of them have the same curative effect of Nat Pho 6x.

I am aware that Nux V is one of the remedies listed in the Repertories and I shall copy Boricke on Hyperacidity below:

HYPERACIDITY (hyperchlorhydria) -- Acet. ac., Anac., Ant. c., Arg. n., Atrop., Bism., Caffeine, Calc. c., Calc. p., Carbo v., Cham., Chin. ars., Cinch., Con., grind., Hydr., Ign., Iris, Lob. infl., Lyc., Mag. c., Mur. ac., Nat. c., Nat. p., Nux v., Orexine tan., Petrol., Phos., Prun. v., Puls., Robin., Sul., Sul. ac.

You will observe that over 35 remedies are listed but the chances of any one of them beating Nat Phos 6x for a quick response and the eventual cure of this condition are remote. I have helped many cases with Nat Phos 6c Biochemic Cell Salt and use it as my default remedy today for GERD as it invariably works almost instantly.

It is the patient who seeks a cure and not this form of argument over whether or not Nux V can or will help him. I am sure that this patient Shabbir Bzu may be wondering what sort of verbal duel he has instigated on the ABC when all he wanted was a remedy for his GERD. It was only when Sajjad prescribed a massive overdose of Nat Phos 3x with 5 tablets taken 4 times daily that I felt that I should join the thread to warn the patient that this could be a massive overdose.

It was when you questioned my experience in Homeopathy that I felt that I should put you in your place especially since you had already ruffled the feelings of other advisors on this forum a few days before with your other post entitled 'Doctors do not interfere with others.' http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/64052

I would urge you to read the comments of both Pankaj and me on that thread and also on the present thread before you commence to resurrect this verbal dual which has taken a good part of my time to reply and which I can see is just wasted on types like you who seem so overwhelmed with your own importance and knowledge merely because you have that piece of paper, your diploma in Homeopathy.

You will observe that in my last 2 posts addressed to you I was advising you on the niceties of behaviour on a public forum such as this and all you can think of now is to harp back to the Nux Vomica 30c for GERD which I reject even today as I am convinced that it cannot help the patient as Nat Phos 6x does.

I was however pleased to note that you have joined Sajjad in supporting this remedy by stating that
'Infacrt I supported Nat Phos.As Dr.Sajjad and you also prescribed it. '

If this is in fact the case what is the purpose of carrying this argument on and on indefinitely ?

You are only wasting my time in doing so.

Joe De Livera
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,
Again You are defending yourself for your experience.
My friend I supported this medicine and still I am not denying it.
What I want to say never ever say like

'I noticed that someone had prescribed Nux Vomica 30 but I do not think that this can help the patient at all'
this again.I will not tolerate this.
I dont know what are your experiences with Nux Vom and I am least concern about your experience.

So my friend never do this again.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Dear Dinesh,

I can see that you are a person who is so very engrossed with your own importance that you do not seem to lack the ability to think straight.

We are talking at cross purposes. I am talking of Apples and you are talking of Oranges. (If you know what I mean)

I feel that I have wasted enough time it trying to open your mind to what I feel is your lack of humility and you still keep on talking shop.

I am convinced that Nux Vomica cannot by any means be compared with Nat Phos 6x for the relief of GERD and shall continue to prescribe it to other patients who suffer from this ailment in future as I have done in the past. You are free to suggest Nux Vomica to them and I shall repeat this same performance on those threads if you dare to do so.

In conclusion, may I suggest that you use Nat Phos 6c biochemic on your next GERD patient and observe the results ? This may open your own mind to the efficacy of this remedy in comparison to the Nux Vomica which you so ardently advocate.

Please note that I shall not reply any further posts on this thread as you have wasted enough of my time already in replying your posts which show up your one track mind.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,

Instead of blaming me try be more flexible and accept that you have done mistake and again you are showing your obstinate behaviour.
I already advised Nat Phos as Dr.Sajjad and you proposed it.
But be flexible.Having bad experience with Nux doesnt mean others can not prescribe this.
So dont show this haughty attitude.If so then I advise you to take Lycopodium.Potency you know.

Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Dear Dinesh,

Although in my last post I stated that I will not reply you again, I felt that my response to Shiny which I have just made can perhaps open your mind to what others whom I have helped on this and other forums think of the part that I have played in their lives.

http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/55717/6

Re: 7 yr old with nocturnal asthma
From shiny
on 2006-05-28
Dear Joe
I shall post his treatment plan in aday or two as it will require some time. Really you are doing a fabulous job.Hats off to you for helping everyone even after so much of criticism.I wish these people would try these remedies before drawing conclusions and trying to prove it wrong.

Shiny


Re: 7 yr old with nocturnal asthma
From Joe De Livera
on 2006-05-28
Dear Shiny,

I have always maintained that Truth will always Prevail.

I would like to quote a profound statemtent by Arthur Schoepenhauer who was a world renowned Philosopher and lived over two centuries ago. His statement applies to my own philosophy of life where in spite of the all the tribulations that have assailed me throughout my 76 years on this earth I am blessed with that spark of originality which helps me to overcome all those who like to villify me, especially in Homeopathy perhaps through jealousy at my success in helping others freely which I do because I have the satisfaction of curing their ailments like your son's Asthma almost like magic.

Here is the statement:

All truth passes through three stages.

First, it is ridiculed.

Second, it is violently opposed.

Third, it is accepted as being self-evident.

--- Arthur Schopenhauer ---
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Quite a battle...my shoulder wud have broken down with the 'weight of the gun".
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Pankaj,
lol I quit this battle.Any way I think Joe needs lyco.


Dr.Dinesh Sharma
 
drdineshsharma last decade
Thank God Arnica does not anti-dote Lyco.
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Is jhamele mein Shabbir Bzu ka kya hoga !!

(What about Shabbir BzU ?)
 
PANKAJ VARMA last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.