The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Would this patient get well?
A patient reported his case to 6 different homeopaths and all of them selected different rubrics and then finished off with 6 different remedies.Why does this happen mostly?
Is the selection of six different remedies correct?
Whether the patient will got cure from these six remedies or only one remedy will cure the patient?
Dr. MAS on 2004-09-28
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
happens due to biased un-astute observations ...personal predjudices-mind patterns---personal illness...etc
the selection of 6 different remedies CAN be correct--but is based upon homoeopath's (in question) ability to follow up on 1st prescription choice..and so on and on til cure is eminent.....
yes cure is possible from these six or one as long as there is at least some homoepathicity in remedy choice....
the selection of 6 different remedies CAN be correct--but is based upon homoeopath's (in question) ability to follow up on 1st prescription choice..and so on and on til cure is eminent.....
yes cure is possible from these six or one as long as there is at least some homoepathicity in remedy choice....
♡ John Stanton last decade
Can you give us the list of symptoms and names of the 6 different remedies that were recommended ?
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Can you give us the list of symptoms and names of the 6 different remedies that were recommended ?
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Can you give us the list of symptoms and names of the 6 different remedies that were recommended ?
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
I will analyse it for you and come back with a reply.
Best,
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Moderator,
The software problem is showing up.
I didn't click "Enter" three times.
Best,
Pankaj varma
The software problem is showing up.
I didn't click "Enter" three times.
Best,
Pankaj varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Depending on the similarities in symptoms, a patient can be treated partly with differant remedies with possibilities of spoiling the case. However, cure can be possible with only one true remedy.
Logical last decade
Yes, this is common observation that a case in written form was dispatched to three homeopaths via email and all of them came with three different remedies with different case analaysis. All quoted famous homeopaths quotations. All supported their suggestions with organon aphorisms. :D
Maximum last decade
It is very common that 6 doctors prescribe 6 different medicines.
I agree with John that it is partly due to their training and experience.
What is important is the ability of the doctor, to follow up the case,to have the ability to understand what is happening,and the ability to know how long to wait and when to intervene.
So, eventhough the initial prescription may be different in each case,all the six doctors can cure the patient, if they are really competent.
Murthy
I agree with John that it is partly due to their training and experience.
What is important is the ability of the doctor, to follow up the case,to have the ability to understand what is happening,and the ability to know how long to wait and when to intervene.
So, eventhough the initial prescription may be different in each case,all the six doctors can cure the patient, if they are really competent.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
bandarbabu2000 last decade
Step 1. Patients visits at your clinic
Step 2. He or she tells you his/her story
Step 3. Doctor asks few further questions to him/her
Step 4. Doctor diagnose the state of patients condition acute or chronic.
Step 5. Doctor decides the method of treatment constitutional, miasmatic, similimum (Totality based) or disease based etc
Step 6. Doctor finalized all decided rubrics
Step 7. Doctor suggests a medicine and potency.
Upto six steps, (which are not final steps)academic qualificaiton, professional qualification, professional skill and clinical experience and medicinal experience will count here. These will play an important role.
When you have finalized all rubrics (step 6) then you (all) can decide on one symtpom but not before six steps.
Story (patient case history) of patient could be same (but not 100 %) but each doctor will extract rubrics according to his her qualificaiton, skill and experience. Hence the remedy would be different in all cases.
Do you agree?
Step 2. He or she tells you his/her story
Step 3. Doctor asks few further questions to him/her
Step 4. Doctor diagnose the state of patients condition acute or chronic.
Step 5. Doctor decides the method of treatment constitutional, miasmatic, similimum (Totality based) or disease based etc
Step 6. Doctor finalized all decided rubrics
Step 7. Doctor suggests a medicine and potency.
Upto six steps, (which are not final steps)academic qualificaiton, professional qualification, professional skill and clinical experience and medicinal experience will count here. These will play an important role.
When you have finalized all rubrics (step 6) then you (all) can decide on one symtpom but not before six steps.
Story (patient case history) of patient could be same (but not 100 %) but each doctor will extract rubrics according to his her qualificaiton, skill and experience. Hence the remedy would be different in all cases.
Do you agree?
Dr. MAS last decade
Even after extracting proper rubrics,the doctor has to give weightage to them,and match the symptom severity with that of the remedy.
Perhaps,in common acute cases many doctors prescribe the same medicine,as the totality is easily seen.
It becomes complicated in chronic cases.
Murthy
Perhaps,in common acute cases many doctors prescribe the same medicine,as the totality is easily seen.
It becomes complicated in chronic cases.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
In consideration of homeopathic magnitude, if one person involved on memory basis, possibilities of duplicacy, triplicasy...in remedies chracteristics & symptoms---it may be possible that differant remedies may come out with differant homeopaths. However, similar can also not be denied in other systems whose magnitude is alike it.
Logical last decade
Dr. Mas and all others. following are my comments:
You (Dr. MAS) have placed the questions in a very logical, sequential and interesting manner.
First and fore-most, the mental symptoms are to be considered and the physical symptoms are to follow.
Next, to consider is the history of illnesses of the patient.
Next, analyse the 'taints" from heredity.....from side of both parents.
Then analyse the unique combination of symptoms/aggravations/ameliorations and match it with the "drug picture".
Make sure, some symptoms are not left out of the consideration list (as that can cause havoc in the selection of the medicine and lead to a wrong answer).
If, all these factors have not been taken into account...surely the choice of the medicine can go wrong.
Ultimaltely, it is the education, skill and experience of the doctor that comes into focus.
That is why, no homeopathic software can provide a complete analysis...the "doctor" at the other end will make the difference.
Best rgds,
Pankaj Varma
You (Dr. MAS) have placed the questions in a very logical, sequential and interesting manner.
First and fore-most, the mental symptoms are to be considered and the physical symptoms are to follow.
Next, to consider is the history of illnesses of the patient.
Next, analyse the 'taints" from heredity.....from side of both parents.
Then analyse the unique combination of symptoms/aggravations/ameliorations and match it with the "drug picture".
Make sure, some symptoms are not left out of the consideration list (as that can cause havoc in the selection of the medicine and lead to a wrong answer).
If, all these factors have not been taken into account...surely the choice of the medicine can go wrong.
Ultimaltely, it is the education, skill and experience of the doctor that comes into focus.
That is why, no homeopathic software can provide a complete analysis...the "doctor" at the other end will make the difference.
Best rgds,
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
"Ultimaltely, it is the education, skill and experience of the doctor that comes into focus.
That is why, no homeopathic software can provide a complete analysis...the "doctor" at the other end will make the difference."
Well said,Pankaj
Murthy
That is why, no homeopathic software can provide a complete analysis...the "doctor" at the other end will make the difference."
Well said,Pankaj
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
Dear Murthy
I fully agree with you. software only provides help and not prescribe for u. most of the time it gives sulphur (polychrest at top always) although sulphur was not the remedey. when i brought into the notice of other members, they shunted me down... ha ha ha ha aha
I fully agree with you. software only provides help and not prescribe for u. most of the time it gives sulphur (polychrest at top always) although sulphur was not the remedey. when i brought into the notice of other members, they shunted me down... ha ha ha ha aha
Dr. MAS last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.