The ABC Homeopathy Forum
I gave Nat Mur 1M to my son
Dear Jacob and Rishimba,I gave Nat Mur 1 M on wednesday. As usual his symtoms aggravted like shrieking and dwelling in past etc. Difference is that earlier it was more happy past and now its more sad past. Well, i like to wait as long its needed to see any result after aggravations. When should one expect the aggravation to come down. After aggravation if he comes to same state where he was.. what does that mean it is not working or we should try higher dose or we contiue with same potency for more weeks ?
Dipika on 2006-11-24
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Dear Dipika, if there is no improvement after 1 week, then I think it's fair to assume he is, and always was proving the remedy, and I will tell you how to antidote this, and then suggest the correct remedy for his case. Do not give him any other remedies in the meantime.
-Jacob.
-Jacob.
JCS2006 last decade
in my opinion this is an aggravation which will stay for 48 hours.
you have to note his mentals for the next 15 days.
you have to note his mentals for the next 15 days.
♡ rishimba last decade
Dear Jacob and Rishimba,
You are right the aggravation was for 48 hrs. Constipation is as usual except that yesterday he showed little urge but could'nt do much!
Now after the aggravation got over his other behaviour is same ... talking about his own world those are mostly happy past. If Nat mur showed aggravation why it did'nt showed the reduction his autistic behaviour after the aggravation passsed over. If you says I should wait for a week or 15 days ..i will wait.
I want to add his dwelling in past is not like nat mur. Those are more like happy memories. For example he will say 'what do you want ice-cream or fanta' .. this is some thing his grandpa asked him sometime 4-5 years back ... sometimes like sounds or phrases are recurring e.g ' Miss Linda is busy' .. he heard in school sometime before. 80-90 % times he will talk these recurring talks which people talked in past. He asked me to repeat with him.
He loves other sounds which are periodic e'g trains and washing machines. Do you think sulphur have some connection with this?
Yesterday ... i was going through his physical aspect in the homeopathy software tool the first three came as Calc Carb, sulphur and Phosphorus.
Please enlighten and express your ideas.
As Rishimba suggested also after Nat mur I will try Calc carb.
Here is the grid:
calc.
graph.
phos.
sulph.
nux-v.
lyc.
sil.
con.
agar.
ars.
sep.
acon.
hearing; too sensitive;
hearing; too sensitive; better music;
hearing; too sensitive; sounds of a hammer;
hearing; too sensitive; voices and talking;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to the odour of fish;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours; stool;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours; unpleasant odours;
stool; chopped food;
stool; clay-like;
stool; odour; offensive;
stool; odour; putrid;
stool; odour; sour;
genitals; male; masturbates frequently;
genitals; male; sexual passion; increased;
genitals; male; sexual passion; increased; easy excitement of passion;
extremities, limbs; better pulling up limbs;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; corns;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; corns; soles; ;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; thick skin of soles;
extremities, limbs; sensation of lightness;
extremities, limbs; numbness;
extremities, limbs; numbness; better movement;
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; ;
calc.
graph.
phos.
sulph.
nux-v.
lyc.
sil.
con.
agar.
ars.
sep.
acon.
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; extending to tips of fingers; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; bend of elbow; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; hand; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; fingers; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; foot; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; foot; back of foot; ;
Equal priorities 52% 45% 45% 52% 42% 39% 42% 48% 45% 42% 42% 39%
Thanks!!
Dipika
You are right the aggravation was for 48 hrs. Constipation is as usual except that yesterday he showed little urge but could'nt do much!
Now after the aggravation got over his other behaviour is same ... talking about his own world those are mostly happy past. If Nat mur showed aggravation why it did'nt showed the reduction his autistic behaviour after the aggravation passsed over. If you says I should wait for a week or 15 days ..i will wait.
I want to add his dwelling in past is not like nat mur. Those are more like happy memories. For example he will say 'what do you want ice-cream or fanta' .. this is some thing his grandpa asked him sometime 4-5 years back ... sometimes like sounds or phrases are recurring e.g ' Miss Linda is busy' .. he heard in school sometime before. 80-90 % times he will talk these recurring talks which people talked in past. He asked me to repeat with him.
He loves other sounds which are periodic e'g trains and washing machines. Do you think sulphur have some connection with this?
Yesterday ... i was going through his physical aspect in the homeopathy software tool the first three came as Calc Carb, sulphur and Phosphorus.
Please enlighten and express your ideas.
As Rishimba suggested also after Nat mur I will try Calc carb.
Here is the grid:
calc.
graph.
phos.
sulph.
nux-v.
lyc.
sil.
con.
agar.
ars.
sep.
acon.
hearing; too sensitive;
hearing; too sensitive; better music;
hearing; too sensitive; sounds of a hammer;
hearing; too sensitive; voices and talking;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to the odour of fish;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours; stool;
nose; smell; acute, over sensitive; sensitive to strong odours; unpleasant odours;
stool; chopped food;
stool; clay-like;
stool; odour; offensive;
stool; odour; putrid;
stool; odour; sour;
genitals; male; masturbates frequently;
genitals; male; sexual passion; increased;
genitals; male; sexual passion; increased; easy excitement of passion;
extremities, limbs; better pulling up limbs;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; corns;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; corns; soles; ;
extremities, limbs; hands and feet; thick skin of soles;
extremities, limbs; sensation of lightness;
extremities, limbs; numbness;
extremities, limbs; numbness; better movement;
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; ;
calc.
graph.
phos.
sulph.
nux-v.
lyc.
sil.
con.
agar.
ars.
sep.
acon.
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; extending to tips of fingers; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; elbow; bend of elbow; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; hand; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; fingers; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; foot; ;
extremities, limbs; numbness; foot; back of foot; ;
Equal priorities 52% 45% 45% 52% 42% 39% 42% 48% 45% 42% 42% 39%
Thanks!!
Dipika
Dipika last decade
yes, i remember i had suggested CALC for your son based on some symptoms you had presented.
now, the mental symptom that the same thoughts / sentences get repeated in the mind is also covered by CALC.
you can try it after few weeks.
dipika, you have to wait for at least a week to notice some changes in his mental sphere. as you already know, such cases are not straight forward and it takes quite a bit of time hitting the right remedy.
lets get on with it.
now, the mental symptom that the same thoughts / sentences get repeated in the mind is also covered by CALC.
you can try it after few weeks.
dipika, you have to wait for at least a week to notice some changes in his mental sphere. as you already know, such cases are not straight forward and it takes quite a bit of time hitting the right remedy.
lets get on with it.
rian1 last decade
This is great to know that calc carb covers the symptom of recurring thought and sentences ..because this is his main problem and he lives in that.
But... i understand ... i will wait with Nat Mur for one more week and let you know if he shows any changes and what to do next.
Thanks!!
But... i understand ... i will wait with Nat Mur for one more week and let you know if he shows any changes and what to do next.
Thanks!!
Dipika last decade
How many pellets of Nat Mur did you give him? You should give less so there is no aggravation.
TreeFrog last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.