≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Dr. Rajesh Shah Feedback

Has anybody tried getting treatment from Dr. Rajesh Shah. He seems to be promoting classical homeopathy and have big setup in India. Is he competent? Any feedbacks in this regard will be appreciated.

Thanks,
-s
 
  ssss- on 2007-02-06
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
'He seems to be practicing classical Homeopathy', I also felt the same and tried him for one of my patients.

Classical Homeopathy means, Remedy is prescribed on the totality of the symptoms, one remedy at a time, and minimum dose given - that's what I understand.

I didn't see any of these from his practise. I don't know what you meant 'Classical Homeopathy'

sthil
 
sthillaiyah last decade
Yes, I meant exactly what you have stated i.e. remedy for totality of symptoms, min dose and single remedy.

Strange, its mentioned on his website that he practices classical homeopathy and he has patients from all over the world.

So how was your patient's experience with him. How would you like to rate him?

-s
 
ssss- last decade
I don't think I can discuss about an individual at this site further.

I trusted on my own knowledge and understanding of homeopathy and treated the patient, and found some progress.

If you need to know my experience with Dr.Rajesh Shah, dorp me an e-mail, you can find it from my profile.

sthil
 
sthillaiyah last decade
Dear sthil

I just wanted to have the feedback, as I may consider getting treatment from him. I initiated this thread to have a neutral feedback apart from testimonials mentioned on his website. It would be nice if you share the experience on the public forum so that it may benefit others who might be considering getting treatment from him.

sincerely,
-s
 
ssss- last decade
Dear ssss-

I am not comfortable of giving personal opinion, on a public forum, that may negatively affect the intergrity of an individual.

Whatever Dr. Shah practise is not homeopathy. This is my opinion. That much I can say.

Whoever need to get homeopathic advice, the best place is a public forum one like this. Advice given in open forum. There are many learned and experiences homeopaths participating in this forum, watching one another. There are chances for getting a second opinion as well, and afterall, this is free.

Regards,
sthil
 
sthillaiyah last decade
I agree with sthillaiyah. His reputation is not good despite the tall claims.

it is also a fact that what is said on the website about single remedy etc.. is not followed in practice.

Murthy
 
gavinimurthy last decade
Homeopathy as a science works , irrespective of single or multiple. Whats more important ? Are you able to help a suffering individual and relieve him of his pains or debate about phylosophical issues pertaining to debatable concepts?
 
wakeupsid last decade
As for the ever lasting single v/s multiple debate that will continue for ever..

Did homeopathy ever say : 'I will work alone and not in groups' She still works !!!

Classical Homoeopathy is classical, we all appreciate classic's. Lets move on now and look ahead at the dawn of a new era, that's mordern homeopathy.

With no baggages to carry and independent in spirit.

'Sapere Aude'
 
wakeupsid last decade
Let us set aside the debate about single vs multiple remedies and look at the reputation this Dr. Rajesh Shah has.

If we go by internet feedbacks it is no good.

Murthy
 
gavinimurthy last decade
Internet is a free democratic space with choices given to individuals to express their minds which are again subject to and influenced by other peoples perceptions.

Lets have some constructive debate and dialogue to help rather than to react on some comments about some people.

I strongly feel, every homeopath, allopath or naturopath worth his name and salt will always have people whom they cannot satisfy.

True, isnt it. A lot of people may like you and a lot of people may not like
you. Does that make you something you are not?
 
wakeupsid last decade
The thread starter requested the feedback and that is what he got it.

I am yet to see a single positive comment on the net so far other than on his websites.

Murthy
 
gavinimurthy last decade
I haven't heard anything good about Rajesh Shah and Batra's ever. They are not effective at all.
 
Dubai2009 last decade
I saw Dr Shah website. Looks very impressive. So many patients being treated. I think he is doing a good work..
 
rupa1 last decade
Dr Shah and dr batra are treating so many people across the world. i think these people should be encouraged to promote homeopathy internationally . at least they are contributing in their own manner for homeopathy globally. Cheers.

As for good word , i think with 100 patients treated all doctors will have at least 20 - 30 dissatisfied people. What do you say?
 
Rimmy Singh last decade
Take my word for Dr Rajesh Shah, M.D. He's the best of a lot of them there. He helped me with WHAT THEY CALL TRIGEMINAL NEURALGIA. I owe a lot to him.

I have no words to describe the eefectiveness of homoepathy as my life was terrible and he saved me from a lot of pain. Who says he's not effective?
 
minukhan last decade
Thank you for posting your experiences with Dr Shah. I think Mr Murthy should have enough reasons to get back after seeing some positive words about his favourite pastime : blogging bull s**t.
 
wakeupsid last decade
How about asking him for permission to talk to his patients? They would be able to give you first hand account of his service and effectiveness.
 
homeo12242 last decade
I think Dr Rajesh Shah has over 10,000 patients all over the world here.

If, lets take for once, none of his patients are happy with his services and that his treatments are not effective at all, then probably according to you he is a q uack. Right?

This kind of attitude is un fortunately characteristic and found selectively in 'Homeopaths' and no amount of maturity will ever dawn on them.

Homeopaths remind me of 'cockroachs' and the story that goes along with them.

They were all in a bottle and whenever one tried to get out of it, the others would pull him down....

Cant help you guys.
 
wakeupsid last decade
Forum user profile: rupa1

3 posts to date.

View all this user's posts
View posts started by this user

This user shares their IP address with users below. This is not necessarily proof that this user is the same person - they may share a computer, a workplace or in exceptional circumstances, the same ISP.

wakeupsid
Rimmy Singh
Natasha F
minukhan
sahej1
justdoit
swatti
 
gavinimurthy last decade
Gavini it is no surprise. Rajesh Shah and his cronies are trying to get some cheap publicity here. The medical scene in India is full of such thugs.

Strong words but true.
 
Dubai2009 last decade
Its surprising to see how some of these guys used the same IP to crowd out the sane voice of a real patient - sthil.

As the moderator put it aptly in one of those threads, it seems 'they have the same English teacher'.

This is a well organized, blatant attempt to divert some traffic to the site of the man who is not interested in curing people but in fleecing them of their money.
 
Dubai2009 last decade
It is really un fortunate to see how 2 patients can spoil and affect the response of so many like minded people.

While doing some search I found these people who started it off.

1. Forum user profile: sarayu1979
2. Forum user profile: mwmwmw

If we really see them closely we will know there problems.

1. Sarayu1979

I can understand what a person has to suffer when he has a problem like this.

Please see his Forum Post:

Forum user profile: sarayu1979
I am suffering from abdominal bloating problem and I saw a similar case in the forum and the remedy for that I saw is Lycopodium, so I am trying this for the past 2 weeks but no change so far.Does it take more than 2 weeks to affect a medicine?

HE SAYS DR SHAH IS A CHEAT who took money from him and he did not get well. OK

Lets see his activities now.
This guy is visiably desperate..

Re: Follow-up to Dr.Rishimba2008-09-05
I am taking carboveg 30 for 10 days, but this time it did not work. Can you tell me why once worked ...

Re: Follow-up to Dr.Rishimba2008-07-15
Hi doctor, I took China 30c 3 times a day for 3 days.Still no change.I am very depressed and sad be...

Re:Abdominal bloating Follow-up to Dr.Rishimba2008-06-18
Hi doctor Rishimba,I am taking Sepia for 10 days,so far no change. Can you please tell me whether I ...

Re: Abdominal bloating2008-06-04
Thankyou once again. I stopped taking Lycopodium 200c.How many days I have to wait for taking Sepia ...

Abdominal bloating2008-06-02
I am suffering from abdominal bloating problem.I used Carboveg 200c weekly one day 2 times for 2 mon...

Its unfortunate that he could not benifit from treatment. But then spoiling some senior homeopaths name by saying he's a cheat and all others perhaps great??

Ask your self this question before you join the bandwagon again.

DO YOU REALLY THINK DR SHAH IS NOT GOOD AND ALL OTHERS ARE JUST BECAUSE THIS ONE PATIENT DID NOT DO WELL UNDER TREATMENT?
 
wakeupsid last decade
As for this other case of vitiligo.

Forum user profile: mwmwmw
I have tried a lot of things but nothing is working. I have tried lifeforce Homopathic Med, Vitiligo-TCM and now GNC products nothing is giving me any results. I had some results but not full recover from Vitiligo-Tab. This is the best product I have tried.

I can only case that we all homoeopaths will find a case of vitiligo not that easy to cure. We will have our successes and have more than expected our share of failures. Not necessarily failure of a homeopath or homeopathy BUT because of the nature of this disease.

Just because this patient of vitiligo get not get his desired results and he did not get them with other things that he tried , should we say , DR SHAH IS A CHEAT and he took money form them ?

DO YOU REALLY THINK DR SHAH IS NOT GOOD AND ALL OTHERS ARE JUST BECAUSE THIS PATIENT DID NOT DO WELL UNDER TREATMENT?

PLEASE ASK YOUR SELF.
 
wakeupsid last decade
This is the sort of defence that is expected which should have come much earlier before the bungling with multiple IDs.

The fundamental objection to Dr.Shah's way of treating is websites by name of specific diseases.

Anyone who has even basic knowledge of homeopathy knows that any attempt to cure by the name of disease is more often than not a failure, simply because it is against the basic philosophy of homeopathy..

Cure the person who has the disease and never go by the disease name.

That being the case the purpose of multiple websites is to lure patients by giving them false hopes.

Let us hear the response before we proceed further.

Murthy
 
gavinimurthy last decade
KIND ATTENTION: MODERATOR, MR MURTHY AND OTHERS

Though, as a well qualified doctor with relevant certified knowledge about medicine,
I am not supposed to be answerable to Mr. Murthy for these quite amusing and child like questions, I would still take this opportunity to this back to him since I believe in giving knowledge.

This goes for attention to the moderator of this forum as well as to the many other people who with limited knowledge of ether Dr Rajesh Shah’s achievements worldwide or just blunt disrespect for colleagues.

Contention No 1
IP address the same for many people
There are so many Doctors that work in Life Force Homeopathy owned by Dr Rajesh Shah, M.D. So its no surprise that you may find the same static IP address been reflected with other people. This goes with patients and Doctors as well.

Dr Rajesh Shah's Life Force Homeopathy is a huge organization which has qualified and well knowledgeable Doctors working for it as well as patients those who visit the global support center are free to use this facility.

All doctors associated with Dr Rajesh Shah have the right to make there opinion visible through their own computers , probably since the moderator rightly mentioned you may find that coming out of the same IP address but you have live and positive individuals posting the comments here not machines.

Contention No 2
About disease specific websites
For a physician and for a patient the most important first step in treatment is to KNOW what he is suffering from. Perhaps a nosocomial diagnosis or a name to his pain rather than perhaps an: acute exacerbation of a psoro-sycotic miasmatic dyscracias. Did you get this one? Perhaps you could get a dot com for that available.

Contention No 3
Purpose of Multiple websites to lure
Please be informed, a lot of people all across the world don’t even know about homeopathy. They come searching for complaints and disease names. When they come to our websites like www.lichenplanus.com . Its there first experience with the world of homeopathy, which otherwise they never would have had the opportunity to experience. We are introducing homeopathy to them every hour, every day all across the world.

YOU MADE US LOOK LIKE VILLAINS WHERE AS WE ARE PROMOTING HOMEOPATHY IN PLACES AND COUNTRIES YOU DON’T EVEN KNOW THE NAME OF?

What’s wrong with doctors and patients visiting life force and using the facilities in voicing an opinion in positive? May be the same IP address. Yes. Your right

What’s right with people who join in with limited knowledge of ether homeopathy or a senior homeopath just to malign an individual who is sincerely trying to spread a word across the world? Just because there were 2 patients who were not satisfied with the treatment results according to their expected outcome of diseases of which they have limited knowledge of?

As for Mr. Murthy: The Self Proclaimed Champion of this cause to Save Homeopathy and the innocent people from this villain and evil called Dr Shah.

Rightly put by him in his user profile : (I missed that one out and actually though he is a qualified doctor)

Forum user profile: gavinimurthy
I am not a qualified homeopath. I am an engineer by education, and a manager by profession. I believe classical homeopathy is the only answer for a 'cure.' I try to promote it and make people understand what is classical homeopathy.

4917 posts to date.

This on is for the moderator.

I know this is an open platform and people can speak what they like. But, this is UN ACCEPTABLE

How can ABC HOMEOPATHY allow Mr. Murthy NOT A QUALIFIED HOMEOPATH, ENGINEER BY EDUCATION AND MANAGER BY PROFESSION post 4917 about Five Thousand times and advise people on homeopathy with strong comments on doses and medicines to gullible and innocent patients who came here just for a free advice?

Please note this. I find it very un professional. Will all due respect to Mr. Murthy’s profession and his liking for homeopathy or what ever he names it “classical’ western or Hindustani what ever
 
wakeupsid last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.