≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

your assitance needed/carcinison

your assistance needed/carcinosin

Hi to all,

I would kindly ask for your assistance in understanding carcinosin path of action. Our homeopath is very very little of words and thanks to this forum Ive managed to get some clue…Unfortunately no change of homeopath is feasible at the moment ( so it is take it or leave it)
What does it mean that carc is deep acting med? how deep? When do you know its time for new dose? How carc relates to other remedies for acute conditions like cold, fever, cough, injury? OK to administer it? Is carc working?
Case summary:

Im mother of 34 month old boy delivered by caesarean section two weeks prior estimated time of delivery. Im concerned about his socio/emotional development including Ever since he was born he was very calm baby, very mature/serious eye look/face expression-one would say he was never a baby ( he got nick names Buda-baby and Zen baby). All other skills including motorics are within usual development milestones, he is very bright and intuitive. I've suspected on kind of 'light' autism /PDD NOS but in country Im writing from no proper assessment is available for so cold “mild/light cases” We have consulted neurologist, psychologist, physic , speech and behavior therapist -all he will be OK!!! we are told that his IQ is over average. His medical record: atopic pneumonia at 7mnths;frequent bronchitis i.e. each would start from the running nose ( also he was born with the running/blocked nose-left side) , terrible coughs for mnths and mnths, nose postnasal discharge I would say that his improvement started ever since he had chicken-pox (very severe) ,seven months ago.

He is on homeopathy since year 1.He has greatly benefited from arnica (from potency 30 up to 1M) - like there was a wake-up call for him and Natrum Muriaticum (from potency 30 up to 1M))-opened him up to express emotions, some attention to others/parents.
Based on additional assessments 3 weeks ago he has been prescribed carc 30 C .Gave him 4 pills during 1 day and then observed :
SLEEP: From a day 1 to date his sleep, for which we ‘ve thought is OK!!!, improved big time
SELF Stemming Occurred in increased form until day 15th - hand flapping and toe walking. From day 15th to date very much reduced
CONSTIPATION Increased constipation followed by hard/ dark/ balls/very smelly stools until day 15th. From day 16th to date more regular stool once per day but only just before bad/sleeping time
OTHER: From day 1 to date observed large amounts of yellow nasal discharge (before it would always be postnasal trickling down the throat and different types of cough. Not so intense now days.During the first 7 days eyes inflammation occurred with yellow discharge. OK now
From the 2nd week slightly increased body temperature is noted. Now he feels chilled after bath when before he used to be indifferent to temp changes. Enjoys and lets hair to be washed.

SENSORY AND COGNITIVE AWARENESS/ Sociability/ Speech and language

On a day 1 following administered dose slight increase in all fields was noted. Then nothing else then calmness/being tuned in/something different in eye look was observed until day 8 followed by significant daily improvements until day 15th : improved eye contact, increase in expressive language and non verbal communication, acceptance of touch, ticklish, seeking for cuddling, desire for interaction, improved behavior, reduced hyperactivity, increased self awareness.

Following day 15th to nothing new much is going on

Thanks
rgds
 
  SAKVA on 2010-11-23
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
In my opinion, based on your report, it appears that your homoeopath has done quite well for your son. Looking at the pattern of treatment, it seems necessary to go from 30c up to 1M to get the full effects of any remedy for him. Since you have only started with 30c Carc so far, you probably have not yet seen the full result of what Carc can do for him.

Why would you want to change homoeopaths? Is it just because of the lack of information? This forum might make up that lack :)
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Sounds like your son might be on the autism spectrum and yeah, that the homeopathy is certainly helping him. Your story is sounding like a very positive one from reading your son's case.
I am not a homeopathy expert, rather I stumbled into your post because I am currently taking Carc (I'm an adult) and I volunteer with adolescents on the autism spectrum. My partner also is borderline asperger's.
I hope your son continues along this path of health. :)
 
Daniellie last decade
TVM for response.Well homeopath prescribed carc is the new one and I really lack feedback info from him.The one we were dealing with in the past is just wonderfull but she had/has her own issues to deal with during past months and I really didnt want to waste time and loose momentum of success.
So yes pls. I need info also considering the dosage practice is different.With previous meds we would start with 30C one a week and wait.Then it would be 3 days one and wait.Following it waterydosage would be used for up to 3 weeks...etc
Currently on carc he has been given 4 during one day and now we are at 4th week of observation and are supposed to get in touch with homeopath in 15 days time.My inner feeling says there is nothing much since second week but what Im to expect...and pls. what about acute conditions cold, injury may I give him anything but not to influence of carc.
rgds
 
SAKVA last decade
brisbanehomoeopath reading your comments on this forum I really feel need to express my RESPECT!!!I would kindly ask for your opinion on following.potency 200C of any remedy never had any impact on condition of my son..30,100,1M proven to be of right potencies well never went beyond 1M... is there reasoing behind.Also when/how do you know that rem this time carc did the best and gave its maximum ie. when to start considering introduction/assesment for normal/regular constitutional remedy or which of sympotms that led to carc prescription are of greater 'importance' to follow progress. thanks in advance
 
SAKVA last decade
Ah it is a different homoeopath? Ok then there is no saying if Carc will help - that is a shame you had to change practitioners.

In my experience every patient has a perfect potency as well as remedy. It has something to do with the parts of the person where the disease expresses itself most strongly. The level represented by 200c must be a level his disease is not prominent on.

Potency is not an easy concept to get a hold of however, but getting the correct potency is vital for curing the patient in the long term as well.

Another experience I have had with potency, is that the higher you go, the more precise the remedy must be for that patient. If you get a good result at a lower level but no result at a higher level, the remedy is not exact enough. Once you reach the right potency, with the right remedy, the change in the patient's health is profound and long lasting.

It is hard to judge in this case what to expect - I can't tell why the remedy was given, what the homoeopath is looking at. However, you should see improvement within 2 weeks on any remedy that is beneficial.

The use of a nosode as an intercurrent is only necessary when the miasm has not been addressed by the previous treatment. This process of 'zig-zagging' is a method of using a series of remedies in place of the simillimum to move the patient towards cure, usually because the simillimum cannot be found.

Having said that, this method can still produce excellent results.

When I give an intercurrent, it still needs to match symptoms in the case, and once it works those symptoms should change. You should not need to depend on your homoeopath to tell you that the change has happened, you should see it.
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Uhh Ive just lost my reply to you...
 
SAKVA last decade
Seems that everything happens with a reason..even lost of my previous reply to you. Thanks for clarifications.Tdy we met our homeopath,she is back to our lifes:-) absolutly OK with prescribed carc also gratfull to collegue for viewing case from fresh point.She suggested we still in parallel consult Mr.little words so will do...you too:-)She laughed when I said that her way of dealing with cases/leading thru spoiled me even if Im realising that it makes her job more difficult.But since its not about me but being responsible for my child well being its my duty to ask/obtain answers/try to understand...all the best to you.
 
SAKVA last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.