Homeopathic Remedies Homeopathy Forum

Similar conversations:

Acid Phos
29 threads


Homeopathy Forum

Acid Phos Proving - Please Help

1. I took Acid Phos-1m two or three doses between one week. The following symptoms occured:-

(a) Pain, discomfort or enlarged feeling in gastro­intestinal tract which include colon, spleen, liver, part of chest etc.

(b) Weak feeling in chest from talking.

(c) Emission at stool.

(d) Pain in baby finger during typing. It was old symptom, probably some increased by this remedy.

(e) Grief and anxiety.

2. After identify Acid Phos proving, I take Coffea-30 as an antidote. 70% recovered after first dose. But after repeating several doses, I guess that, problems either unchanged or increased. As the remedy coffea already taken too much before, so probably it (coffea-30) may have started to producing proving symptoms.

3. I have added another problem by taking one dose caladium-30 for antidote the Acid Phos. But I'm not sure, whether the remedy caladium itself wrong selection for me, or the remedy I purchased is not pure. Because, according to my experience, taking corrupted and polluted remedy cause proving symptom even by one single dose. As the shops are closed in Tuesday, so I still have not able to collect pure version of caladium, which can reverse the bad affect of impure version.

The symptoms occured by corrupted dose of Caladium are as follows:-

(a) Extremely sensitive to noise. Although I am already sensitive to noise, but probably it has increased by it.

(b) Deep breathing prevented; Breathing impeded; Eructations. Fullness of chest and stomach. Chest feels constricted.

(c) Sometimes dry cough. But I do not know whether it is associated with any remedy proving or not.

Now I am in a confusal condition that, my symptoms are now actually occured by Acid Phos, Coffea, or corrupted Caladium. I could not detect, which remedy are doing good for me and which are act bad.

** Now main issues are as follows:-
(a) Pain in colon and pit of stomach.
(b) Constricted chest; Pain and tightness in right lung, sensation as a ball in the right lung area.
(c) Sensitivity, Irritability, Intolerance, Impatience, Impulsive.
[Edited by sadeqahmed on 2018-05-18 04:46:28]
  sadeqahmed on 2018-04-17
This is an internet forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Anybody please help.
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

more you take, more you get confused so please stop taking any remedies and wait until the symptoms subside.
Tui 5 months ago

I took pure dose of Caladium and condition seems improved.
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

At present, my main case is Pain and tightness in right lung, sensation as a ball in the right lung area. It may be lung, or may be behind the sternum.
Which remedy may be responsible for this condition? Which remedy could be taken to cure it? Although I hope it will be go away by time, but what to do, if this symptom persist?
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

I have no idea which remedy is doing what so I can only suggest not to take anything for a while and just wait until the symptoms subside.

And remember, the homeopathic remedies can not create pathology because nothing in there but energy.
The potentised homeopathic remedies have dynamic effect only, meaning that the remedies are so diluted that they can have no physical, physiological or biological action at all.

Having said that, I have seen some cases where proving lasted for more than a month, but it usually subside within a week.
Tui 5 months ago

I have now another symptom probably produced by Acid Phos: Dry cough from tickling in chest.

Is the Camphor suidable as antodote
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

Yes, camphor may antidote, but are you sure you are not coming down with cold or something? Are those symptoms are really from acid phos and/or coff?

I'm just concern that if you are having a cold, flu or something else which has nothing to do with the remedies, then you need to be treated properly....
Tui 5 months ago

Yes, in 14 April 2018 (1 Boishakh) afternoon, I was out of home during summer storm (kalbaishakhi) and get touch by some rain particle come with storm air. Then at end of night, I started to feel headache (ache in forehead).
In 17 April 2018 (4 Boishakh), I fall into rain. But I could not exactly remember, my dry cough started before or after 17 April.
My other proving symptoms (pain or discomfort in Colon and Chest) still persist, although the intensity has reduced.
[Edited by sadeqahmed on 2018-04-19 12:56:50]
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

At last I found that, irritability has probably caused by Coffea.
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

So are you saying that you have never irritated in your life?

If so, yes you are probably proving coffea.

You may take camphor 200c, just one dose and see how that affect.
[Edited by Tui on 2018-04-19 22:46:52]
Tui 5 months ago

Actually Irritation is not new in my life, but probably has some increased after taking coffea.

Regarding the cough and throat pain, it may be influenced by remedy and weather together. Because, in Coffea modality, it is written that, "Worse: excessive emotions (joy), narcotics, strong odors, noise, open air, cold, night."

At this moment, I feel my main problem is in my right chest (probably lung) around the breast [Sensation as a ball or disc in there].

I have tried to antidote coffea with nux, but I also felt irritation after taking Nux. It seems that, Nux has acted on me as a inimical relation with Coffea.

At the severe stage of proving, when lung and chest affected after colon, dry cough and right chest pain was happened both day and night. But in later, when the intensity has reduced either by antidoting or by time passing, Dry cough increased only at night, and Right Chest/Lung pain/tightness is feeled mainly at morning after wakeup.

At last, I have taken Pulsatilla and Causticum. Now I feel, intensity has reduced and conditions become stable.

In this recent proving experience, I got Coffea as partial antidote agaist Acid Phos, pure caladium against corrupted caladium (usually any remedy's pure version antidote corrupted version), and Pulsatilla and Causticum against Coffea.
[Edited by sadeqahmed on 2018-04-24 14:44:11]
sadeqahmed 5 months ago

If you want to take another remedy for your current symptoms, please answer the following questions. I may be able to find something for you.

1. Exact location

2. Sensation

3. Modalities (better by and worse by)

4, Is there anything else going on at physical, mental, emotional level?
Tui 5 months ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.