The ABC Homeopathy Forum
dr kadwa please help Page 3 of 3
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Mr.Kadwa,
Thanks for your reply, no I am not starting practice now or in near future as I am in a learning process at the moment, I just want to gain as much knowledge about homeopathy as I can besides doing my homeopathy course as I understand that homeopathy is also a spirual healing method (I like the idea of body healing itself).
Besides, I took Calc. Carb 1 M 3 days back & started my periods again yesterday, again heavy bleeding with small clots & pain in lower abdomen.
I have also read about the following medicines:
Bellis Perrinis
Ustilago maydis
Thalaspi Bursa
Do you think I also take some help from any of the above medicine?
pls advise
Thanks for your reply, no I am not starting practice now or in near future as I am in a learning process at the moment, I just want to gain as much knowledge about homeopathy as I can besides doing my homeopathy course as I understand that homeopathy is also a spirual healing method (I like the idea of body healing itself).
Besides, I took Calc. Carb 1 M 3 days back & started my periods again yesterday, again heavy bleeding with small clots & pain in lower abdomen.
I have also read about the following medicines:
Bellis Perrinis
Ustilago maydis
Thalaspi Bursa
Do you think I also take some help from any of the above medicine?
pls advise
alice2010 last decade
Dr Kadwa,
My periods started on time this month. But the flow is still heavy though clots size has reduced to half almost with intense pain in my lower abdomen & legs.
One more thing whereever this menstrual blood touches around genitals it burns & itches the skin greatly.
Before my periods I got very depressed & weepy.
I feel weakness & headache(right sided mostly) all the time.
Pls. advise
My periods started on time this month. But the flow is still heavy though clots size has reduced to half almost with intense pain in my lower abdomen & legs.
One more thing whereever this menstrual blood touches around genitals it burns & itches the skin greatly.
Before my periods I got very depressed & weepy.
I feel weakness & headache(right sided mostly) all the time.
Pls. advise
alice2010 last decade
One more thing is that I got pimples like pumps on my head before the start of menses that are reducing in size now but always appear on onset of menses
alice2010 last decade
Hi Alice
Read this carefully and come back with your comments.
************
LECTURES ON HOMOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA
by JAMES TYLER KENT, A.M., M.D.
Late Professor of Materia Medica in Hering College, Chicago.
Kreosotum
Characteristics: There are three things that stand out most prominently in Kreosotum, and when they appear together the symptoms in minor degree will be likely to be associated.
These three characteristics are:
1. Excoriating discharges;
2. Pulsations all over the body, and
3. Profuse bleeding from small wounds.
When these three things arc associated in a high degree Kreosote should be examined. A prick of a pin will cause the oozing of bright red- blood, and mucous membranes bleed easily. Any pressure upon the mucous membranes will cause oozing.
Bleeding here and there about the body. The lachrymation is excoriating. It excoriates the margins of the lids and checks, and they become red and raw, and smart. If there is a purulent discharge it is acrid. The corners of the lips and mouth are red and raw, and' the saliva burns and smarts. The moisture about the mouth, whatever it may be, excoriates and the mouth is raw. The eyes smart and burn as if raw.
The leucorrhoea causes smarting and burning about the vulva, so that the mucous surfaces of the labia are red and raw, sometimes inflamed, but always burning. The vagina burns during coition, and there is bleeding after coition; granulations of the vagina and os uteri, so that the pressure of the act of coition brings on bleeding and burning, smarting and excoriation. And the male organ will smart and burn after coming in contact with the secretion of the vagina during coition.
The urine burns and smarts. This tendency to excoriation from the excretions and secretions applies to all the tissues of the body.
Every emotion and exciting circumstance is attended with throbbing all over the body, pulsations to the ends of the fingers. Every emotion is attended with tearfulness, Music that will in the slightest way excite the emotion, minor strains and music that strikes home to the heart, pathetic music, will bring out tears that are acrid, and palpitation and pulsations that are felt to the extremities.
When the Kreosote sore throat is present the least pressure of the tongue depressor will establish oozing, little drops of blood will appear. During the coryza there is nosebleed. When the eyes are red and raw and inflamed, they will bleed easily. If an individual pricks the finger the blood will not merely be a single drop, but a good many will flow. Prolonged haemorrhage from the passages; hemorrhage from the kidneys, from the eyes, the nose, the uterus. Haemorrhage after coition. Tumors bleed easily.
These are the most marked features of Kreosote. If these are fixed in your mind, we have what may be known, as a Kreosote constitution out of which may come all the rest of the symptoms in all their minutiae, and little symptoms and fragments in every organ. You have in this one group the strong features of Kreosote. No matter how many particulars you may have in a case, if you do not have something of these general features you need not expect to find your patient constitutionally cured or relieved by Kreosote. These may be considered essentials.
Mentally the patient is so irritable that there is nothing that will suit him. The wants are so numerous that nothing satisfies. The patient wants everything and is satisfied with nothing, that is, he wants something and when he has it he does not want it. That is the state of irritability and lack of satisfaction in a chronic condition.
You see the child in the mother's arms. It wants a toy, and when given it throws it in the face of somebody; it wants this and that and is never satisfied, always wanting something new, a new toy which it throws away the moment it gets it and then calls for something else.
The lips are red and bleeding, the corners of the month are raw, the eyelids red and the skin excoriated. If it has, in connection with all this, loose passages from the bowels and you examine the fissure between the nates, you will find it is red and raw. If the child be old enough to make such motions he will put the hands upon the sore genitals and fissures and cry out in a most irritable way, because of the smarting.
Such is the Kreosote baby. It may be suffering from cholera infantum; it may be subject to wetting the bed; it may have spells of vomiting, in which it vomits all its food; it is a Kreosote baby.
Kreosote has attacks of diarrhoea and vomiting; all sorts of disturbances of the urine; great distension and trouble with the bowels; abdomen distended from flatus. You look over the whole case at once as a Kreosote case, because of these general features that can be summed up in the aspect of the child.
The Kreosote face has a yellowish pallor; it is a sickly countenance, semi-cachectic, intermingled with blotches that are reddish looking, as if erysipelas were going to set in. In olden times this countenance was called a scorbutic countenance.
Take a woman with this kind of countenance; at every menstrual flow she complains of much swelling and rawness of the genitals; the flow is copious, clotted, stops and then starts again, comes too soon and lasts too long; at times it is black, very foetid, produces rawness upon the thighs and the genitals, with much swelling; at every menstrual period there is rawness of the lips and fissures in the corners of the mouth; the tears become acrid; at the menstrual period all the fluids of the body seem to be acid and they burn wherever they touch.
Very often there is a loose stool, which is also acrid and smarts the anus at the menstrual period. All the symptoms are worse at the menstrual period, sometimes in the early part, sometimes at the middle, sometimes all through, and sometimes at the close. Something more about the scorbutic constitution is brought out in relation to the gums; the gums become puffed and red and tumid and settle away from the teeth.
They become spongy and bleed easily. In the mouth there is much ulceration and little ulcers spread from aphthous patches, smarting and burning; the tongue has ulcers upon it, which bleed easily upon touch.
At the close of a typhoid fever haemorrhage from the bowels, bleeding from the mucous membranes. The mouth becomes raw, and wherever there is a mucous membrane there is a rawness, and the fluids that ooze continue to, eat and cause ulceration. If at the close of a typhoid fever, when the time comes for convalescence, vomiting comes.
Vomiting, bleedings, diarrheas. The fluids vomited from, the stomach are so acrid that they seem to take the skin off from the mouth, set the teeth on edge, make the lips raw. So excoriation from acrid fluids, as well as throbbing all over the body, are features that you must bear in mind with Kreosote.
The discharges from the body are offensive; offensive, bloody, acrid discharges from the nose; offensive, watery discharges from any part of the body; sometimes even putrid; the leucorrhea is very offensive. Rapid emaciation, with spongy, burning ulceration, pus acrid, ichorous, foetid and yellow. Sometimes the inflammatory condition will run so high in an ulcer, only a small ulceration, that gangrene will set in, and hence we have a gangrenous ulceration; gangrene of parts that are inflamed.
Very low formations occur upon the margins of mucous membranes; crusts form. Indurations under the crusts and the crusts continue to form.
The circulation is so poor, so feeble in the parts all about the margin of the lips and the corners of the mouth, and corners of the eyes, and eyelids, and upon the genitals, and there is so much venous engorgement that crusts form and ulcerate and bleed and pile up, and this continues until a phagedenic spot comes. This condition is so much like epithelioma that Kreosote has cured epithelioma.
Stomach: The next striking thing in Kreosote is its stomach symptoms, Soon after eating there comes a burning pain in the stomach, and then a sense of fullness and an increasing nausea, ending in vomiting of the food, which looks as it did when taken; it looks undigested, but it is sour and acrid, coming up an hour or two after eating. Vomiting, the stomach seems unable to digest, and after the patient empties it there is constant nausea. After a swallow of water a prolonged bitter taste remains in the mouth.
There is aggravation from eating cold things and relief from warm diet. In malignant diseases of the stomach when this symptom is present, Kreosote becomes a great palliative; it relieves the burning and improves the digestion for a while, but the trouble comes again. Many times our remedies furnish us the greatest known palliation in cancerous affections. Homoeopathy should at all times furnish a degree of palliation in cancerous and other incurable malignant diseases of the stomach.
This palliation will bring more comfort to the stomach than can possibly be brought about by Morphine. I have watched patients under Morphine and under homeopathic medicine, and as a mere matter of comfort I will take the homoeopathic medicines.
This has been the experience of many. When you hear a homoeopath say that he prefers anodynes in cancerous affections of the stomach and in other painful affections, it is pretty sure evidence that he is not able to find the medicines that are suitable for the patient. These cases test the ability of the physician.
Diarrhea: Kreosote is a great remedy for diarrheas in the summer, especially for infants. The infant that I described as to his temper may be the infant suffering from the worst form of summer complaint, or having a light attack of cholera infantum. Or he may be 'teething,' and suffering from the troubles that are sometimes associated with teething. Infants have troubles at the time of teething only because they are sick, and if the child were not in disorder he would not have trouble when teething. Teething is a crisis, and the things that are within will come out at the time, just as there are troubles that are likely to come out at the time of puberty and at the climacteric period.
A marked feature of the Kreosote constitution is that when the desire to urinate comes, he must hurry or the urine will escape. The urine is passed during sleep. Bloody urine; clots in the urine; acrid and excoriating urine; weakness of the bladder; inability to hold the urine.
Smarting and burning in the pudenda, during and after micturition.
'Sugar in the urine.'
It has cured diabetes. Generalize the symptoms given and you will see what kind of a diabetic patient will need Kreosote.
*********
Murthy
Read this carefully and come back with your comments.
************
LECTURES ON HOMOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA
by JAMES TYLER KENT, A.M., M.D.
Late Professor of Materia Medica in Hering College, Chicago.
Kreosotum
Characteristics: There are three things that stand out most prominently in Kreosotum, and when they appear together the symptoms in minor degree will be likely to be associated.
These three characteristics are:
1. Excoriating discharges;
2. Pulsations all over the body, and
3. Profuse bleeding from small wounds.
When these three things arc associated in a high degree Kreosote should be examined. A prick of a pin will cause the oozing of bright red- blood, and mucous membranes bleed easily. Any pressure upon the mucous membranes will cause oozing.
Bleeding here and there about the body. The lachrymation is excoriating. It excoriates the margins of the lids and checks, and they become red and raw, and smart. If there is a purulent discharge it is acrid. The corners of the lips and mouth are red and raw, and' the saliva burns and smarts. The moisture about the mouth, whatever it may be, excoriates and the mouth is raw. The eyes smart and burn as if raw.
The leucorrhoea causes smarting and burning about the vulva, so that the mucous surfaces of the labia are red and raw, sometimes inflamed, but always burning. The vagina burns during coition, and there is bleeding after coition; granulations of the vagina and os uteri, so that the pressure of the act of coition brings on bleeding and burning, smarting and excoriation. And the male organ will smart and burn after coming in contact with the secretion of the vagina during coition.
The urine burns and smarts. This tendency to excoriation from the excretions and secretions applies to all the tissues of the body.
Every emotion and exciting circumstance is attended with throbbing all over the body, pulsations to the ends of the fingers. Every emotion is attended with tearfulness, Music that will in the slightest way excite the emotion, minor strains and music that strikes home to the heart, pathetic music, will bring out tears that are acrid, and palpitation and pulsations that are felt to the extremities.
When the Kreosote sore throat is present the least pressure of the tongue depressor will establish oozing, little drops of blood will appear. During the coryza there is nosebleed. When the eyes are red and raw and inflamed, they will bleed easily. If an individual pricks the finger the blood will not merely be a single drop, but a good many will flow. Prolonged haemorrhage from the passages; hemorrhage from the kidneys, from the eyes, the nose, the uterus. Haemorrhage after coition. Tumors bleed easily.
These are the most marked features of Kreosote. If these are fixed in your mind, we have what may be known, as a Kreosote constitution out of which may come all the rest of the symptoms in all their minutiae, and little symptoms and fragments in every organ. You have in this one group the strong features of Kreosote. No matter how many particulars you may have in a case, if you do not have something of these general features you need not expect to find your patient constitutionally cured or relieved by Kreosote. These may be considered essentials.
Mentally the patient is so irritable that there is nothing that will suit him. The wants are so numerous that nothing satisfies. The patient wants everything and is satisfied with nothing, that is, he wants something and when he has it he does not want it. That is the state of irritability and lack of satisfaction in a chronic condition.
You see the child in the mother's arms. It wants a toy, and when given it throws it in the face of somebody; it wants this and that and is never satisfied, always wanting something new, a new toy which it throws away the moment it gets it and then calls for something else.
The lips are red and bleeding, the corners of the month are raw, the eyelids red and the skin excoriated. If it has, in connection with all this, loose passages from the bowels and you examine the fissure between the nates, you will find it is red and raw. If the child be old enough to make such motions he will put the hands upon the sore genitals and fissures and cry out in a most irritable way, because of the smarting.
Such is the Kreosote baby. It may be suffering from cholera infantum; it may be subject to wetting the bed; it may have spells of vomiting, in which it vomits all its food; it is a Kreosote baby.
Kreosote has attacks of diarrhoea and vomiting; all sorts of disturbances of the urine; great distension and trouble with the bowels; abdomen distended from flatus. You look over the whole case at once as a Kreosote case, because of these general features that can be summed up in the aspect of the child.
The Kreosote face has a yellowish pallor; it is a sickly countenance, semi-cachectic, intermingled with blotches that are reddish looking, as if erysipelas were going to set in. In olden times this countenance was called a scorbutic countenance.
Take a woman with this kind of countenance; at every menstrual flow she complains of much swelling and rawness of the genitals; the flow is copious, clotted, stops and then starts again, comes too soon and lasts too long; at times it is black, very foetid, produces rawness upon the thighs and the genitals, with much swelling; at every menstrual period there is rawness of the lips and fissures in the corners of the mouth; the tears become acrid; at the menstrual period all the fluids of the body seem to be acid and they burn wherever they touch.
Very often there is a loose stool, which is also acrid and smarts the anus at the menstrual period. All the symptoms are worse at the menstrual period, sometimes in the early part, sometimes at the middle, sometimes all through, and sometimes at the close. Something more about the scorbutic constitution is brought out in relation to the gums; the gums become puffed and red and tumid and settle away from the teeth.
They become spongy and bleed easily. In the mouth there is much ulceration and little ulcers spread from aphthous patches, smarting and burning; the tongue has ulcers upon it, which bleed easily upon touch.
At the close of a typhoid fever haemorrhage from the bowels, bleeding from the mucous membranes. The mouth becomes raw, and wherever there is a mucous membrane there is a rawness, and the fluids that ooze continue to, eat and cause ulceration. If at the close of a typhoid fever, when the time comes for convalescence, vomiting comes.
Vomiting, bleedings, diarrheas. The fluids vomited from, the stomach are so acrid that they seem to take the skin off from the mouth, set the teeth on edge, make the lips raw. So excoriation from acrid fluids, as well as throbbing all over the body, are features that you must bear in mind with Kreosote.
The discharges from the body are offensive; offensive, bloody, acrid discharges from the nose; offensive, watery discharges from any part of the body; sometimes even putrid; the leucorrhea is very offensive. Rapid emaciation, with spongy, burning ulceration, pus acrid, ichorous, foetid and yellow. Sometimes the inflammatory condition will run so high in an ulcer, only a small ulceration, that gangrene will set in, and hence we have a gangrenous ulceration; gangrene of parts that are inflamed.
Very low formations occur upon the margins of mucous membranes; crusts form. Indurations under the crusts and the crusts continue to form.
The circulation is so poor, so feeble in the parts all about the margin of the lips and the corners of the mouth, and corners of the eyes, and eyelids, and upon the genitals, and there is so much venous engorgement that crusts form and ulcerate and bleed and pile up, and this continues until a phagedenic spot comes. This condition is so much like epithelioma that Kreosote has cured epithelioma.
Stomach: The next striking thing in Kreosote is its stomach symptoms, Soon after eating there comes a burning pain in the stomach, and then a sense of fullness and an increasing nausea, ending in vomiting of the food, which looks as it did when taken; it looks undigested, but it is sour and acrid, coming up an hour or two after eating. Vomiting, the stomach seems unable to digest, and after the patient empties it there is constant nausea. After a swallow of water a prolonged bitter taste remains in the mouth.
There is aggravation from eating cold things and relief from warm diet. In malignant diseases of the stomach when this symptom is present, Kreosote becomes a great palliative; it relieves the burning and improves the digestion for a while, but the trouble comes again. Many times our remedies furnish us the greatest known palliation in cancerous affections. Homoeopathy should at all times furnish a degree of palliation in cancerous and other incurable malignant diseases of the stomach.
This palliation will bring more comfort to the stomach than can possibly be brought about by Morphine. I have watched patients under Morphine and under homeopathic medicine, and as a mere matter of comfort I will take the homoeopathic medicines.
This has been the experience of many. When you hear a homoeopath say that he prefers anodynes in cancerous affections of the stomach and in other painful affections, it is pretty sure evidence that he is not able to find the medicines that are suitable for the patient. These cases test the ability of the physician.
Diarrhea: Kreosote is a great remedy for diarrheas in the summer, especially for infants. The infant that I described as to his temper may be the infant suffering from the worst form of summer complaint, or having a light attack of cholera infantum. Or he may be 'teething,' and suffering from the troubles that are sometimes associated with teething. Infants have troubles at the time of teething only because they are sick, and if the child were not in disorder he would not have trouble when teething. Teething is a crisis, and the things that are within will come out at the time, just as there are troubles that are likely to come out at the time of puberty and at the climacteric period.
A marked feature of the Kreosote constitution is that when the desire to urinate comes, he must hurry or the urine will escape. The urine is passed during sleep. Bloody urine; clots in the urine; acrid and excoriating urine; weakness of the bladder; inability to hold the urine.
Smarting and burning in the pudenda, during and after micturition.
'Sugar in the urine.'
It has cured diabetes. Generalize the symptoms given and you will see what kind of a diabetic patient will need Kreosote.
*********
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dr murthy,
Thanks for your reply in such a detail. Yes I read it & I agree I have most of the symptoms except the following
- No sugar in urine or blood(got tested)
- have constipation (no diarhea) with no symptoms of rectum
- usually dont loose interest in things as quickly but loose interest if I dont get it anyway
I appreciate your further advise
Dr Kadwa I will also wait for your answer as you know my case for long.
Thanks for your reply in such a detail. Yes I read it & I agree I have most of the symptoms except the following
- No sugar in urine or blood(got tested)
- have constipation (no diarhea) with no symptoms of rectum
- usually dont loose interest in things as quickly but loose interest if I dont get it anyway
I appreciate your further advise
Dr Kadwa I will also wait for your answer as you know my case for long.
alice2010 last decade
Hi Alice
No one will have all the symptoms listed in the materia medica. It is enough if the essence matches.
Homeopathy does wonders when we treat based on PQRS symptoms. Peculiar, Queer, Rare and Strange symptoms.
The excoriation you feel is peculiar. Not many will have this. That immediately brought my attention to Kreosotum.
I normally don't prescribe on the forums. Let Dr.Kadwa come back and proceed with your case.
Since you seem familiar with homeopathy I thought I should bring this remedy to your and Kadwa's notice.
Murthy
P.S. I am not a doctor.
No one will have all the symptoms listed in the materia medica. It is enough if the essence matches.
Homeopathy does wonders when we treat based on PQRS symptoms. Peculiar, Queer, Rare and Strange symptoms.
The excoriation you feel is peculiar. Not many will have this. That immediately brought my attention to Kreosotum.
I normally don't prescribe on the forums. Let Dr.Kadwa come back and proceed with your case.
Since you seem familiar with homeopathy I thought I should bring this remedy to your and Kadwa's notice.
Murthy
P.S. I am not a doctor.
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dr gavinmurthy,
I did not mean to offend you as I really appreciate your concern.
OK please tell me how to use this remedy in what potency
Pls advise
I did not mean to offend you as I really appreciate your concern.
OK please tell me how to use this remedy in what potency
Pls advise
alice2010 last decade
I am not offended at all.
Kadwa is my best friend and he will no doubt continue to help you.
As I mentioned earlier the remedy suggestion was to Kadwa as much as to you.
Let him think over it.
He will come back.
Murthy
Kadwa is my best friend and he will no doubt continue to help you.
As I mentioned earlier the remedy suggestion was to Kadwa as much as to you.
Let him think over it.
He will come back.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dear Murthy
Kreosotum is no doubt a very good selection. What i think is that the prime symptoms of kreosotum like acrid menses and profuse menses are also covered by Sulphur. Sulphur is also indicated in constipation.
i suggest that the pt takes..
Lycopodium 30c thrice a day at a gap of 4 hours for only one day.
wait for 2 days...
after 2 days, Sulphur 200c thrice a day at a gap of 4 hours for only one day and see how it goes in the next few days.
i know that it is very difficult to prescribe by consensus but i welcome participative prescribing as it brings forth good options.
Kreosotum is no doubt a very good selection. What i think is that the prime symptoms of kreosotum like acrid menses and profuse menses are also covered by Sulphur. Sulphur is also indicated in constipation.
i suggest that the pt takes..
Lycopodium 30c thrice a day at a gap of 4 hours for only one day.
wait for 2 days...
after 2 days, Sulphur 200c thrice a day at a gap of 4 hours for only one day and see how it goes in the next few days.
i know that it is very difficult to prescribe by consensus but i welcome participative prescribing as it brings forth good options.
♡ kadwa last decade
Hi Kadwa
I too appreciate that the prescriptions vary between homeopaths for the same set of conditions.
Complicated cases do need series of medicines and that series may vary between two homeopaths. However in capable hands both of them should work.
Please go ahead with your thinking. I wil chip in on and off. :-)
Murthy
I too appreciate that the prescriptions vary between homeopaths for the same set of conditions.
Complicated cases do need series of medicines and that series may vary between two homeopaths. However in capable hands both of them should work.
Please go ahead with your thinking. I wil chip in on and off. :-)
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Gavini,
This is the first occasion where I have come in on a thread to criticize your therapy in the manner that you have attacked me, but I felt that I should butt in to expose your miserable attempts to enforce, what you feel is your own pseudo classical homeopathic therapy on other prescribers on this forum, but failed miserably in this instance.
You copied Kent's lecture on Kreosotum presuming that Kadwa had never read it before and Alice was duly impressed with the text of the lecture which she thought was all your own original work. She requested you to prescribe the dosage but you did not oblige.
It is the statement you made which I was duly surprised to read, that prompted me to come in on this thread:
'I normally don't prescribe on the forums. Let Dr.Kadwa come back and proceed with your case. '
Kadwa did come back and politely told you not to interfere with his case as he had already prescribed the remedy Alice was taking already.
I have observed this trait (weakness?) on your part of never prescribing a remedy to a patient and have often wondered why you do not do so. All you do is to attack my therapy even after the patient has confirmed a cure. Is it because you are not sure of your own therapy which is largely book knowledge, or is there some other more sinister reason why you never take the responsibility of helping a suffering patient as all of us do on this and other Homeopathic Forums? After all there must be some reason why you always butt in on my posts and invariably criticize them and waste my time on this forum.
You may like to know that it is the sheer joy that I get from healing a difficult case which has been through the gamut of allopaths and later classical homeopaths that keeps me active here on the ABC at my advanced age of 81 (remember GOM?). It seems a shame that I have to waste my time in dealing with your inanities but I have proved that I can do so with always a more positive response to your taunts.
I have noticed that in the recent past you invariably shadow all my posts warning that my therapy has only driven the ailment deep down and that it will soon materialize in some form of grave disease like cancer !
Don't you have any other mission in life other than to infest the ABC and criticize my therapy?
Can you give me one reason for shadowing all my posts on the ABC in the hope that you can create some ruckus which distracts the patient and annoys me? You have always predicted doom and gloom to my patients in the hope that they will reject my therapy but as you can see my patients depend on my therapy, especially my Joepathy which has indeed worked miracles as anyone can read on this forum. As you are no doubt aware, there has not been a single case which you can quote to prove your dire predictions. Patients have confirmed their seemingly miraculous cures and I can think of 2 recent cases:
Robert Ray who was a paraplegic since 2002 after his third stroke and was walking in just 5 days:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/228108/
and
Sachin who was convinced that he was an Epileptic and is now almost cured:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/229694/
There are of course hundreds of other cases too numerous to mention here, as I do not have their records.
I am now immured to your inanities and take them in my stride on a daily basis. It is rarely that I go out of my way to berate you as I am now doing to expose you for the imposter and the fake that you are, which some would qualify you as a Q U A C K who does not have the courage of his own convictions and only pretends to be highly qualified but never uses his book knowledge to help a patient.
I believe that if you too try to help patients on this forum and Manish's Hpathy which you do not seem to have visited in the recent past, there is yet a slender chance that you may change your attitude towards Homeopathy which on your own admission you have only studied on a 24x7 basis but do not have any hands on experience in helping a patient, judging by your performance on the ABC.
You must remember that your delusions of grandeur which you miserably fail to project on the ABC do not fool the members and the patients and only serve to detract from the true reason for the existence of the ABC which is to heal with Homeopathy.
Do I dare state Heal with Joepathy ?
Remember that you coined this term 'Joepathy' to deride my therapy and this term has come to stay internationally as it now shows about 1500 hits on Google where they have listed my more outstanding cases of cures.
I hope you realize that the hatred you project against me and my Joepathy due to your insane jealousy at my success in helping patients, will eventually prove to be your damnation.
It also helps to spread the success of my Joepathy.
Joe De Livera
This is the first occasion where I have come in on a thread to criticize your therapy in the manner that you have attacked me, but I felt that I should butt in to expose your miserable attempts to enforce, what you feel is your own pseudo classical homeopathic therapy on other prescribers on this forum, but failed miserably in this instance.
You copied Kent's lecture on Kreosotum presuming that Kadwa had never read it before and Alice was duly impressed with the text of the lecture which she thought was all your own original work. She requested you to prescribe the dosage but you did not oblige.
It is the statement you made which I was duly surprised to read, that prompted me to come in on this thread:
'I normally don't prescribe on the forums. Let Dr.Kadwa come back and proceed with your case. '
Kadwa did come back and politely told you not to interfere with his case as he had already prescribed the remedy Alice was taking already.
I have observed this trait (weakness?) on your part of never prescribing a remedy to a patient and have often wondered why you do not do so. All you do is to attack my therapy even after the patient has confirmed a cure. Is it because you are not sure of your own therapy which is largely book knowledge, or is there some other more sinister reason why you never take the responsibility of helping a suffering patient as all of us do on this and other Homeopathic Forums? After all there must be some reason why you always butt in on my posts and invariably criticize them and waste my time on this forum.
You may like to know that it is the sheer joy that I get from healing a difficult case which has been through the gamut of allopaths and later classical homeopaths that keeps me active here on the ABC at my advanced age of 81 (remember GOM?). It seems a shame that I have to waste my time in dealing with your inanities but I have proved that I can do so with always a more positive response to your taunts.
I have noticed that in the recent past you invariably shadow all my posts warning that my therapy has only driven the ailment deep down and that it will soon materialize in some form of grave disease like cancer !
Don't you have any other mission in life other than to infest the ABC and criticize my therapy?
Can you give me one reason for shadowing all my posts on the ABC in the hope that you can create some ruckus which distracts the patient and annoys me? You have always predicted doom and gloom to my patients in the hope that they will reject my therapy but as you can see my patients depend on my therapy, especially my Joepathy which has indeed worked miracles as anyone can read on this forum. As you are no doubt aware, there has not been a single case which you can quote to prove your dire predictions. Patients have confirmed their seemingly miraculous cures and I can think of 2 recent cases:
Robert Ray who was a paraplegic since 2002 after his third stroke and was walking in just 5 days:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/228108/
and
Sachin who was convinced that he was an Epileptic and is now almost cured:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/229694/
There are of course hundreds of other cases too numerous to mention here, as I do not have their records.
I am now immured to your inanities and take them in my stride on a daily basis. It is rarely that I go out of my way to berate you as I am now doing to expose you for the imposter and the fake that you are, which some would qualify you as a Q U A C K who does not have the courage of his own convictions and only pretends to be highly qualified but never uses his book knowledge to help a patient.
I believe that if you too try to help patients on this forum and Manish's Hpathy which you do not seem to have visited in the recent past, there is yet a slender chance that you may change your attitude towards Homeopathy which on your own admission you have only studied on a 24x7 basis but do not have any hands on experience in helping a patient, judging by your performance on the ABC.
You must remember that your delusions of grandeur which you miserably fail to project on the ABC do not fool the members and the patients and only serve to detract from the true reason for the existence of the ABC which is to heal with Homeopathy.
Do I dare state Heal with Joepathy ?
Remember that you coined this term 'Joepathy' to deride my therapy and this term has come to stay internationally as it now shows about 1500 hits on Google where they have listed my more outstanding cases of cures.
I hope you realize that the hatred you project against me and my Joepathy due to your insane jealousy at my success in helping patients, will eventually prove to be your damnation.
It also helps to spread the success of my Joepathy.
Joe De Livera
♡ Joe De Livera last decade
Even with the limited knowledge of MM and philosophy I have, it is so easy for me to prescribe 'this for that'.
However I won't do that for reasons oft repeated here.
You can't prescribe for anything else other than fistula, flatulence and a couple of other things. Even there we observe that your standard recipes won't work for majority of the patients.
I have cured.. underline the word cured.. multiple complex problems like bone spurs, cervical displasia, cervical spondylosis, IBS, canker sores..among many others. Of course not with standard recipes..but by following proper homeopathy.
You 'log in to observe progress' on the side lines, where as I chip in with my opinions when required.
I colloborate with other prescribers some times when I feel they should look into some other remedies along with those they are prescribing.
I don't fly into a rage when they think otherwise and accept it.
There is no comparision whatsoever between your sillipathy and the way I prescribe/ intervene.
As I told earlier, a day will come when people won't touch you/ your prescriptions even with a barge pole.
We are nearing that day very fast and you hasten it by provoking me endlessly.
It is better for you to lead a peaceful life at your advanced age rather than yearn for name and fame.
Your sillipathy will be forgotten the day you stop posting. Your dreams of becoming another Hahnemann will never come true.
Better to realise it sooner than later. I see hundreds of prescribers like you in my country. They are not known even to the next lane doctor.
Similarly you are an unknown entity for the millions who folllow homeopathy except for the few who visit these forums.
A frog in the well thinks that whatever it sees is the world. You are in a similar delusion. I know it is difficult to come out of that mental state at advanced age without the help of proper therapy. I wish you get good psychiatric help soon before it is too late.
Murthy
However I won't do that for reasons oft repeated here.
You can't prescribe for anything else other than fistula, flatulence and a couple of other things. Even there we observe that your standard recipes won't work for majority of the patients.
I have cured.. underline the word cured.. multiple complex problems like bone spurs, cervical displasia, cervical spondylosis, IBS, canker sores..among many others. Of course not with standard recipes..but by following proper homeopathy.
You 'log in to observe progress' on the side lines, where as I chip in with my opinions when required.
I colloborate with other prescribers some times when I feel they should look into some other remedies along with those they are prescribing.
I don't fly into a rage when they think otherwise and accept it.
There is no comparision whatsoever between your sillipathy and the way I prescribe/ intervene.
As I told earlier, a day will come when people won't touch you/ your prescriptions even with a barge pole.
We are nearing that day very fast and you hasten it by provoking me endlessly.
It is better for you to lead a peaceful life at your advanced age rather than yearn for name and fame.
Your sillipathy will be forgotten the day you stop posting. Your dreams of becoming another Hahnemann will never come true.
Better to realise it sooner than later. I see hundreds of prescribers like you in my country. They are not known even to the next lane doctor.
Similarly you are an unknown entity for the millions who folllow homeopathy except for the few who visit these forums.
A frog in the well thinks that whatever it sees is the world. You are in a similar delusion. I know it is difficult to come out of that mental state at advanced age without the help of proper therapy. I wish you get good psychiatric help soon before it is too late.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
respected joe,
i keep reading your posts and amused with such great results with arnica,but my experience is not that good with arnica(to be dead honest)pl. dont take it otherwise,i started cervical pain with wet dose of 30 and i immly stopped it ithought why unnecessaryly damage your statics.
i unprejudicely welcome ur guidence you are doing social service selflessly,i know you arnica is not your production,nor you have any personal interest,but iwud request you not to universalise a medicine for all the problems.or if yes as per pl.add my case in the other pan of your balane of statistics,this is all with humble an regards to you.i honour you for your dedication.pl. no anty issues.
*************
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/132126/
Our GOM convenently ignores such posts and highlights one or two posts of improvement that could have been due to natural remission of the disease/ temporary palliation.
Instead of acknowledging that there is a possibility that even Arnica can have negative effects on some people he flies into a fit of rage even if some one hints so.
So much for his ability to be unbiased.
When will he realise that Arnica is not the panacea for all the ills of the total humanity?
When will he realise that it may help a few but the majority won't get any benefit out of it?
When will he realise that there are people who get negative effects by using Arnica?
Perhaps never.
Murthy
i keep reading your posts and amused with such great results with arnica,but my experience is not that good with arnica(to be dead honest)pl. dont take it otherwise,i started cervical pain with wet dose of 30 and i immly stopped it ithought why unnecessaryly damage your statics.
i unprejudicely welcome ur guidence you are doing social service selflessly,i know you arnica is not your production,nor you have any personal interest,but iwud request you not to universalise a medicine for all the problems.or if yes as per pl.add my case in the other pan of your balane of statistics,this is all with humble an regards to you.i honour you for your dedication.pl. no anty issues.
*************
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/132126/
Our GOM convenently ignores such posts and highlights one or two posts of improvement that could have been due to natural remission of the disease/ temporary palliation.
Instead of acknowledging that there is a possibility that even Arnica can have negative effects on some people he flies into a fit of rage even if some one hints so.
So much for his ability to be unbiased.
When will he realise that Arnica is not the panacea for all the ills of the total humanity?
When will he realise that it may help a few but the majority won't get any benefit out of it?
When will he realise that there are people who get negative effects by using Arnica?
Perhaps never.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Gavini
Here is what you stated on my post 'Nat Phos the Ultimate Cure for Obseity' in 2004, the day before Sri Lanka was afflicted by the Tsunami, the worst tragedy in our history when we lost over 50000 lives in a matter of a few hours.
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/15923/
Re: The Ultimate Cure for ObesityFrom bandarbabu2000 on 2004-12-25
On Joe's advice I started taking Nat.Phos 6x,as advised,and I am glad to report that it seems working.
I started just a week back and I can already see improvement in terms of feeling of lightness,and improved agility.
I am now 112Kg and will report back on 1st Jan'05.
Murthy
I am copying below what you stated only yesterday but this time under another pseudonym 'Bapu4' on another old post dated January 30 2008 which you dug up by doing a search for High BP which you knew I would respond to and post my default Arnica therapy which has helped literally hundreds of patients throughout the world.
Do you spot any similarity between your first ID in 2004 'bandarbabu2000 on 2004-12-25' and your new specially coined ID 'Bapu4' ?
It simply amazes me to realize that you will stoop to a low level such as this to post under another new ID purely to have the satisfaction of getting what you thought was a valid reason to show how dangerous Arnica was for your alter ego 'Bapu4' after taking just ONE dose of Arnica 30 in the Wet dose. Do you notice that within the time frame of just under 24 hours Bapy4 stated:
'i started cervical pain with wet dose of 30 and i immly stopped it ithought why unnecessaryly damage your statics. '
I presume that you want me and those who will read this thread to believe this utterly impossible status that with just ONE DOSE of Arnica in the Wet dose, Bapu4 was affected by an imagined some Cervical pain !!!
If you wanted your Bapu4 to be believed, you should have replied to my post a few days into the future instead of jumping the gun and shooting yourself in the foot as you have obviously done today.
All I can state at this stage is that you absolutely DISGUST me. Your hatred against me and the jealousy that you project cannot be fathomed let alone equalled by anyone else except you yourself. You have advised me to seek psychiatric help and here again it is the classic Biblical case of pointing out the Mote in my eye when you cannot see the Beam in your own eye.
Mathew 7:5
'Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.'
It seems such a shame that your old sidekicks Nisha and Jacob Scott are no more present on this forum to join you as they did prior to 2006, in attacking me. Your trio were all birds of a feather motivated by jealousy against the Joepathy I was sharing with patients which worked in some wondrous miraculous manner to heal the ailments presented by patients on the ABC.
One remarkable fact that your trio held as a record what they all of you NEVER helped a patient and existed on the ABC purely to attack me.
I note that you referred in your reply to your 'CURES' of various imagined ailments and I would like to have their links to enable me to study them.
I will not be surprised at all if you invent yet another ID to support yourself in your filthy endeavour to discredit me with other fairy tales in the future and I shall deal with them in due course if you dare to do so.
I advise you to use another ID which cannot be traced back to you, the next time your devious mind impels you to cast any aspersions against me in the future.
I hold you in UTTER CONTEMPT.
In Utter Disgust
Joe De Livera
Re: High BP please help From bapu4 [Log on to view profile] on 2010-06-25
dr.girilal,i am following the case with interest i am also bp patient. pl.respond to zuzi.
regards
Re: High BP please help From Joe De Livera [Log on to view profile] on 2010-06-26
To Bapu
I believe that I was the first person who discovered the potential of Arnica to reduce Hypertension (Blood Pressure) about 15 years ago and I recorded my discovery on the ABC and other Homeopathic forums that I visited at that time.
I am now 81 years of age and my BP is
Here is what you stated on my post 'Nat Phos the Ultimate Cure for Obseity' in 2004, the day before Sri Lanka was afflicted by the Tsunami, the worst tragedy in our history when we lost over 50000 lives in a matter of a few hours.
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/15923/
Re: The Ultimate Cure for ObesityFrom bandarbabu2000 on 2004-12-25
On Joe's advice I started taking Nat.Phos 6x,as advised,and I am glad to report that it seems working.
I started just a week back and I can already see improvement in terms of feeling of lightness,and improved agility.
I am now 112Kg and will report back on 1st Jan'05.
Murthy
I am copying below what you stated only yesterday but this time under another pseudonym 'Bapu4' on another old post dated January 30 2008 which you dug up by doing a search for High BP which you knew I would respond to and post my default Arnica therapy which has helped literally hundreds of patients throughout the world.
Do you spot any similarity between your first ID in 2004 'bandarbabu2000 on 2004-12-25' and your new specially coined ID 'Bapu4' ?
It simply amazes me to realize that you will stoop to a low level such as this to post under another new ID purely to have the satisfaction of getting what you thought was a valid reason to show how dangerous Arnica was for your alter ego 'Bapu4' after taking just ONE dose of Arnica 30 in the Wet dose. Do you notice that within the time frame of just under 24 hours Bapy4 stated:
'i started cervical pain with wet dose of 30 and i immly stopped it ithought why unnecessaryly damage your statics. '
I presume that you want me and those who will read this thread to believe this utterly impossible status that with just ONE DOSE of Arnica in the Wet dose, Bapu4 was affected by an imagined some Cervical pain !!!
If you wanted your Bapu4 to be believed, you should have replied to my post a few days into the future instead of jumping the gun and shooting yourself in the foot as you have obviously done today.
All I can state at this stage is that you absolutely DISGUST me. Your hatred against me and the jealousy that you project cannot be fathomed let alone equalled by anyone else except you yourself. You have advised me to seek psychiatric help and here again it is the classic Biblical case of pointing out the Mote in my eye when you cannot see the Beam in your own eye.
Mathew 7:5
'Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.'
It seems such a shame that your old sidekicks Nisha and Jacob Scott are no more present on this forum to join you as they did prior to 2006, in attacking me. Your trio were all birds of a feather motivated by jealousy against the Joepathy I was sharing with patients which worked in some wondrous miraculous manner to heal the ailments presented by patients on the ABC.
One remarkable fact that your trio held as a record what they all of you NEVER helped a patient and existed on the ABC purely to attack me.
I note that you referred in your reply to your 'CURES' of various imagined ailments and I would like to have their links to enable me to study them.
I will not be surprised at all if you invent yet another ID to support yourself in your filthy endeavour to discredit me with other fairy tales in the future and I shall deal with them in due course if you dare to do so.
I advise you to use another ID which cannot be traced back to you, the next time your devious mind impels you to cast any aspersions against me in the future.
I hold you in UTTER CONTEMPT.
In Utter Disgust
Joe De Livera
Re: High BP please help From bapu4 [Log on to view profile] on 2010-06-25
dr.girilal,i am following the case with interest i am also bp patient. pl.respond to zuzi.
regards
Re: High BP please help From Joe De Livera [Log on to view profile] on 2010-06-26
To Bapu
I believe that I was the first person who discovered the potential of Arnica to reduce Hypertension (Blood Pressure) about 15 years ago and I recorded my discovery on the ABC and other Homeopathic forums that I visited at that time.
I am now 81 years of age and my BP is
♡ Joe De Livera last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.