The ABC Homeopathy Forum
1)Pulsatilla2)Calcarea Carb- Respected David, please suggest Page 2 of 4
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
A few observations after pulsatilla 1M:
I am feeling more sleepy.Sleepy even after having 8 hours sleep.
Eczema on chin , has started drying out.
weight after nat mur increased horribly..10+kg.How ever as if now I am eating only butter.
I am feeling more sleepy.Sleepy even after having 8 hours sleep.
Eczema on chin , has started drying out.
weight after nat mur increased horribly..10+kg.How ever as if now I am eating only butter.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Probably i m getting converted to Calcarea Carb from pulsatilla.No complete evacuation inspite of eating heavily for few days.Can this also be a part of aggravation?
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Sat, 22 Nov 2014 06:43:09 GMT]
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Sat, 22 Nov 2014 06:43:09 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
If I remember rightly you had constipation as one of your main problems when I was treating you previously. So I would assume it is an aggravation.
It is important not to be wanting to change remedies as soon as something happens. This is often the main mistake self-prescribers make. You must wait out the effects of every dose to see if it results in a positive change. Trying to treat specific things will usually result in suppression or antidoting, and make a mess of your case.
It is important not to be wanting to change remedies as soon as something happens. This is often the main mistake self-prescribers make. You must wait out the effects of every dose to see if it results in a positive change. Trying to treat specific things will usually result in suppression or antidoting, and make a mess of your case.
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
I have not taken any remedy yet.I stated this transition on basis of change in my personality.
Previously i would mold myself as per opinion from other's.
There is a major change,I have seen.Suddenly I have started reacting.While previously this reaction was limited to being soft and getting suppressed rather than putting my point.Suddenly i see, I have started reacting.If some body is harsh, i am harsh , how ever when i was pulsatilla , if some body even insulted me, i could not protect myself and listen the same.
This change , makes me conclude and say that there has been a change in my remedy.
More over there has been no motion and my stomach is bloated badly/hard.Its been4-5 days no motion and before that there was incomplete evacuation.
I have read that pulsatilla is one constitution that might get converted into other, which could be nat mur or calcarea with age.I am not sure, how true is this, but can this be the case, if gut mind has become less active, as from what it was before?
Please advice
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Mon, 24 Nov 2014 08:52:57 GMT]
Previously i would mold myself as per opinion from other's.
There is a major change,I have seen.Suddenly I have started reacting.While previously this reaction was limited to being soft and getting suppressed rather than putting my point.Suddenly i see, I have started reacting.If some body is harsh, i am harsh , how ever when i was pulsatilla , if some body even insulted me, i could not protect myself and listen the same.
This change , makes me conclude and say that there has been a change in my remedy.
More over there has been no motion and my stomach is bloated badly/hard.Its been4-5 days no motion and before that there was incomplete evacuation.
I have read that pulsatilla is one constitution that might get converted into other, which could be nat mur or calcarea with age.I am not sure, how true is this, but can this be the case, if gut mind has become less active, as from what it was before?
Please advice
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Mon, 24 Nov 2014 08:52:57 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
You did just take Puls 1M didn't you?
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
Yes I did.
Here it is :
When I took pulsa for the first time,I think i was highly emotional.Probably remedy worked on me and it was then my constitution changed.After that no remedy clearly worked and I started wondering what next.Then I came across an article, stating if pulsatilla layer is gone, other could be nat mur or calcarea.Then I tried nat mur, but i had eczema.
Now I think I should try calc carb, as i have read one of the symptoms of this remedy is no motion for a few days.As a child /teen i have been suffering from same.I would not get motion for weeks if I do not take laxative.
Wat do you suggest.
Reason I say , i might not be pulsa, is I am seeing, change in my feelings.I am becoming more of intellectual from emotional.
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 06:41:08 GMT]
Here it is :
When I took pulsa for the first time,I think i was highly emotional.Probably remedy worked on me and it was then my constitution changed.After that no remedy clearly worked and I started wondering what next.Then I came across an article, stating if pulsatilla layer is gone, other could be nat mur or calcarea.Then I tried nat mur, but i had eczema.
Now I think I should try calc carb, as i have read one of the symptoms of this remedy is no motion for a few days.As a child /teen i have been suffering from same.I would not get motion for weeks if I do not take laxative.
Wat do you suggest.
Reason I say , i might not be pulsa, is I am seeing, change in my feelings.I am becoming more of intellectual from emotional.
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 06:41:08 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
I took Cal Carb and got motion.It was getting very difficult for me
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
I don't think I can be involved in this any further. You are making all sorts of mistakes here, and not properly understanding anything about homoeopathy and how our medicines should be used.
You are putting yourself in grave danger here. I cannot predict the harm you might do with this kind of reckless self-prescribing.
[message edited by Evocationer on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 13:26:11 GMT]
You are putting yourself in grave danger here. I cannot predict the harm you might do with this kind of reckless self-prescribing.
[message edited by Evocationer on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 13:26:11 GMT]
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
why you feel this.I did not get motion for more than 3 days, while my food intake was quite good.I was badly bloated.Even this could be a scenario for aggravation?
and you are very much required...I think since you are there , I can try finding my remedy.
Let me update you, on this
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 15:44:53 GMT]
and you are very much required...I think since you are there , I can try finding my remedy.
Let me update you, on this
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Tue, 25 Nov 2014 15:44:53 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Hello,
After many days I am feeling good.
I am not lazy.7 hours sleep was more than sufficient.previously I had this feeling when I was on pulsatilla.
Complete evacuation.
I did not like going out.Today I went out for a walk.Not forcefully but i felt like.
I am feeling balanced ,mentally.
If this remedy proves to be false, I will stop analyzing what am I
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Wed, 26 Nov 2014 05:58:39 GMT]
After many days I am feeling good.
I am not lazy.7 hours sleep was more than sufficient.previously I had this feeling when I was on pulsatilla.
Complete evacuation.
I did not like going out.Today I went out for a walk.Not forcefully but i felt like.
I am feeling balanced ,mentally.
If this remedy proves to be false, I will stop analyzing what am I
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Wed, 26 Nov 2014 05:58:39 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
http://abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/276256/
I read description of Calcarea Carb mentioned in the thread above by you.
This matches me.
I read description of Calcarea Carb mentioned in the thread above by you.
This matches me.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
I have tried a number of remedies that are close to pulsatilla, but when i have to choose the best possible health condition , it is only with pulsatilla.
One major disease that comes up with any other remedy is eczema on my chin, in form of beard.These acne have small hair inside,how ever as soon as i take 1dose 30 potency pulsatilla, this eczema dries and i have a clean chin.
how ever this time, motion is not that regular as it was when i took pulsatilla for the first time and same is with weight, not getting reduced with that speed as it got reduced with the first dose of pulsatilla.
One major disease that comes up with any other remedy is eczema on my chin, in form of beard.These acne have small hair inside,how ever as soon as i take 1dose 30 potency pulsatilla, this eczema dries and i have a clean chin.
how ever this time, motion is not that regular as it was when i took pulsatilla for the first time and same is with weight, not getting reduced with that speed as it got reduced with the first dose of pulsatilla.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Thank you very much for remembering my case.
I am on pulsatilla and feeling very much better and balanced as when i took nat mur, Calcarea Carb and silica.
How ever only problem i felt and i feel with pulsatilla was/is emotional vulnerable.
I don't know, if this is my basic nature as since birth I was constipated and so now,since no constipation and no emotional suppression and lack of confidence (which was of course there before).
I just read about Graphite';s and i want your inputs on how we differentiate between pulsatilla and graphites.
After pulsatilla , my tongue is amazingly clean, how ever I still have spots on my chin, which will either take some time to go away once the hair wrapped inside comes out and skin becomes dead and gets removed OR graphite might help .
I read this:
Now, you may say, how are we going to distinguish this from PULSATILLA ? Like Graphites, Pulsatilla has late and scanty menses, with pale or dark flow in chlorotic or anaemic patients; also in patients who are apt to be chilly, and who are low-spirited, crying at every imaginary trouble. How will you distinguish between these remedies? The main distinction lies in this: The Graphites patient always has some skin symptoms to aid us, Pulsatilla scarcely any. The Graphites patient has a rough, harsh, dry skin, with very little tendency to sweat. Little pimples, whether containing pus or not, appear on the body, and are apt to be worse at the menstrual periods. While in Pulsatilla there is strong tendency to diarrhoea, in Graphites there is strong tendency to constipation. These symptoms are sufficient to always enable you to distinguish between these two closely allied remedies
and if i think, I always had constipation and never diarrhoea.
Please help me with understanding to which remedy I am more close.
As if now,I am on Pulsatilla 1M.
I am on pulsatilla and feeling very much better and balanced as when i took nat mur, Calcarea Carb and silica.
How ever only problem i felt and i feel with pulsatilla was/is emotional vulnerable.
I don't know, if this is my basic nature as since birth I was constipated and so now,since no constipation and no emotional suppression and lack of confidence (which was of course there before).
I just read about Graphite';s and i want your inputs on how we differentiate between pulsatilla and graphites.
After pulsatilla , my tongue is amazingly clean, how ever I still have spots on my chin, which will either take some time to go away once the hair wrapped inside comes out and skin becomes dead and gets removed OR graphite might help .
I read this:
Now, you may say, how are we going to distinguish this from PULSATILLA ? Like Graphites, Pulsatilla has late and scanty menses, with pale or dark flow in chlorotic or anaemic patients; also in patients who are apt to be chilly, and who are low-spirited, crying at every imaginary trouble. How will you distinguish between these remedies? The main distinction lies in this: The Graphites patient always has some skin symptoms to aid us, Pulsatilla scarcely any. The Graphites patient has a rough, harsh, dry skin, with very little tendency to sweat. Little pimples, whether containing pus or not, appear on the body, and are apt to be worse at the menstrual periods. While in Pulsatilla there is strong tendency to diarrhoea, in Graphites there is strong tendency to constipation. These symptoms are sufficient to always enable you to distinguish between these two closely allied remedies
and if i think, I always had constipation and never diarrhoea.
Please help me with understanding to which remedy I am more close.
As if now,I am on Pulsatilla 1M.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
That description is false. Both remedies are full of skin symptoms, because ALL remedies are full of skin symptoms, as they are of symptoms in every part of the body. You cannot differentiate remedies on the basis of what body part is or isn't being affected.
I would discard this information, it will not help you in the slightest, and in fact will only confuse. These are not important points which will help decide between Graphites and Pulsatilla.
It would be a mistake to try and take a remedy for the external symptoms. A remedy must suit the whole case, and if it does, it will cure everything that needs to be cured. When changing remedies, you are looking for a change in the general state. Trying to treat the skin independently will only result in suppression.
I would discard this information, it will not help you in the slightest, and in fact will only confuse. These are not important points which will help decide between Graphites and Pulsatilla.
It would be a mistake to try and take a remedy for the external symptoms. A remedy must suit the whole case, and if it does, it will cure everything that needs to be cured. When changing remedies, you are looking for a change in the general state. Trying to treat the skin independently will only result in suppression.
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
OK.If that is the case, I am happy with pulsatilla.
Every thing is smooth.Recently I had slight eye number, though i do not misuse my eyes, not sure why this happened.
I think skin will be come fine in some time,i will keep you posted on that.
My food intake is normal, as in it has become same as it was before I was trying any remedy and probably weight is also coming under control.
as if now I think I am getting cured and it is such a wonderful feeling.
Every thing is smooth.Recently I had slight eye number, though i do not misuse my eyes, not sure why this happened.
I think skin will be come fine in some time,i will keep you posted on that.
My food intake is normal, as in it has become same as it was before I was trying any remedy and probably weight is also coming under control.
as if now I think I am getting cured and it is such a wonderful feeling.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
Hello,
Last dose I took was of pulsatilla 1M.I feel I need higher potency .Please let me know, which is next potency level.
Last dose I took was of pulsatilla 1M.I feel I need higher potency .Please let me know, which is next potency level.
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
10M? Really? I rarely even use that potency - it is very powerful. Why would you need to go so high so soon?
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
2 reasons:
This is for the second time I took Pulsatilla 1M.I told you before when i took 1M dose before.
First time I faced bad aggravation but not this time.So i feel 1M might not be required any more b my body.
Secondly if Pulsatilla is my remedy, and when i know , this is a highly chronic disease/body malfunctioning , i feel why not to take higher dose to get cure permanently.
I know this does not sound logical but can this be assumed?
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Wed, 14 Jan 2015 05:29:54 GMT]
This is for the second time I took Pulsatilla 1M.I told you before when i took 1M dose before.
First time I faced bad aggravation but not this time.So i feel 1M might not be required any more b my body.
Secondly if Pulsatilla is my remedy, and when i know , this is a highly chronic disease/body malfunctioning , i feel why not to take higher dose to get cure permanently.
I know this does not sound logical but can this be assumed?
[message edited by HoneyKhanna on Wed, 14 Jan 2015 05:29:54 GMT]
HoneyKhanna 9 years ago
It would be extremely rare to need 10M so soon, or even at all. 10M is a rarely needed potency for most people.
The only reason to go higher is if the lower potency has ceased working, and there are clear signs of relapse, plus the symptoms clearly point to the same remedy. Otherwise the case must be retaken, and the symptoms examined closely to see what needs to be done to continue progress. It is not appropriate to just go straight up to the next potency, especially when the jump from 1M to 10M is so extreme.
If 10M is the wrong step, it may not only undo any progress you have had, but create new symptoms.
[message edited by Evocationer on Thu, 15 Jan 2015 01:59:28 GMT]
The only reason to go higher is if the lower potency has ceased working, and there are clear signs of relapse, plus the symptoms clearly point to the same remedy. Otherwise the case must be retaken, and the symptoms examined closely to see what needs to be done to continue progress. It is not appropriate to just go straight up to the next potency, especially when the jump from 1M to 10M is so extreme.
If 10M is the wrong step, it may not only undo any progress you have had, but create new symptoms.
[message edited by Evocationer on Thu, 15 Jan 2015 01:59:28 GMT]
♡ Evocationer 9 years ago
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.