The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Severe Pain in my Left thigh
27th Sept, 2016Sir,
Till yesterday 26th afternoon I was perfectly alright. By evening I felt shooting pain in my left thigh.
Pain is severe after walking a couple of feet (say around 20 to 30).
Today I have taken 3 tablets of anti inflammatory pain killers and by late evening I have not have had any relief.
About me
I am a male of 74 yrs, Weight 65 kgm and Height 169 cm. A non diabetic Today's sugar was 82
I take medicens for BP
My photo is at facebook.com/ashochha
I know I am writing too early since it could be masculer too but I am a only worried if it is not a serious problem since my father died of bone problem at Military Hospital Delhi.
I am otherwise quite active and healthy.
Kindly help me
ashochha on 2016-09-27
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Please start with following prescription:
1. BELLADONNA 200C , pills (buy minimum qty dispensable at the shop), take 5 pills (for one dose) A SINGLE DOSE once only in the EVENING on first day, (NO EXCESS DOSES PLEASE).
Nothing else to eat or drink 1 hour before and 1 hour after the doses.
IF THIS DIDN'T HELP IN 24 HOURS, Take
2. NITRIC ACID 200C, sam way single dose.
Do’s & don’ts:
1. Stay away from Strong odors.
2. Do not touch medicines or spill them. Use the cap of container (of same medicine) to transfer the medicines.
3. Place the prescribed dose under the tongue and let it dissolve. Keep the dose for at least 2 minutes in mouth.
4. Keep medicine containers airtight, away from direct sunlight, heat, any smell and children.
5. Avoid strong smells and odors AFAP.
6. Do not take any other medicines for any health problems. Most symptoms go as they come within 24-72 hours.
7. Report any problems & seek appropriate advice.
8. Otherwise report progress after 1week.
1. BELLADONNA 200C , pills (buy minimum qty dispensable at the shop), take 5 pills (for one dose) A SINGLE DOSE once only in the EVENING on first day, (NO EXCESS DOSES PLEASE).
Nothing else to eat or drink 1 hour before and 1 hour after the doses.
IF THIS DIDN'T HELP IN 24 HOURS, Take
2. NITRIC ACID 200C, sam way single dose.
Do’s & don’ts:
1. Stay away from Strong odors.
2. Do not touch medicines or spill them. Use the cap of container (of same medicine) to transfer the medicines.
3. Place the prescribed dose under the tongue and let it dissolve. Keep the dose for at least 2 minutes in mouth.
4. Keep medicine containers airtight, away from direct sunlight, heat, any smell and children.
5. Avoid strong smells and odors AFAP.
6. Do not take any other medicines for any health problems. Most symptoms go as they come within 24-72 hours.
7. Report any problems & seek appropriate advice.
8. Otherwise report progress after 1week.
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
In case both didn't help comeback with more details especially, any specific incident that might have happened a within last 10 days span.
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
Thank you very much sir, I'll take Belladona 200C as advised and will then go over to the next medicen.
The pain is acute and shooting that yesterday I had to go to a medical specialist and he has diagnosed it as Sciatica and has given pain killers. Last night also I could get no more then 4 hours of sleep. I was not comfortable in any posture.
Ashok
The pain is acute and shooting that yesterday I had to go to a medical specialist and he has diagnosed it as Sciatica and has given pain killers. Last night also I could get no more then 4 hours of sleep. I was not comfortable in any posture.
Ashok
ashochha 7 years ago
Dear sir,
On day one I took Beladona 200 Five Pills One dose!
- No improvement
Second day I took Nitric Acid 200 Onne dose!
- No improvement
In fact pain has come at the thigh joint and in left testicle.
But overall I feel very un-comfortable with the Age 74, and sciatica
I can walk only about 15 to 20 steps when it becomes unbearable.
Please help me
Ashok Chhabra
On day one I took Beladona 200 Five Pills One dose!
- No improvement
Second day I took Nitric Acid 200 Onne dose!
- No improvement
In fact pain has come at the thigh joint and in left testicle.
But overall I feel very un-comfortable with the Age 74, and sciatica
I can walk only about 15 to 20 steps when it becomes unbearable.
Please help me
Ashok Chhabra
ashochha 7 years ago
Need more details now.
Write about following:
Age/Gender/Location/Country/Ethnicity. Height / Weight /Skin color/Eye color.
Weather tolerance / preference (Heat /cold). Thirsty / Thirstless.
Please explain everything in detail. Don't try to cut short.
When & how your present trouble started? Mention location / side (right or left) of each complaint. What is the probable cause of each of your health problem according to you?
All your past and present health conditions in sequence oldest to newest. All details of previous treatments (oldest to newest) and their effects.
Write in detail about you – emotions, fears, sentiments, feelings, etc. your personality, physical parameters, habits, feelings about life, etc.
Write in detail about your life: social, family, occupational, schooling, childhood, etc. You should mention about incidences that might have influenced or impacted your mind / health / life considerably.
Write about what common opinions most people have about you; what most people comment /say about you frequently; how they react / interact with you & why?
Write something unique about you (how you are different from others or what makes you special).
Write about following:
Age/Gender/Location/Country/Ethnicity. Height / Weight /Skin color/Eye color.
Weather tolerance / preference (Heat /cold). Thirsty / Thirstless.
Please explain everything in detail. Don't try to cut short.
When & how your present trouble started? Mention location / side (right or left) of each complaint. What is the probable cause of each of your health problem according to you?
All your past and present health conditions in sequence oldest to newest. All details of previous treatments (oldest to newest) and their effects.
Write in detail about you – emotions, fears, sentiments, feelings, etc. your personality, physical parameters, habits, feelings about life, etc.
Write in detail about your life: social, family, occupational, schooling, childhood, etc. You should mention about incidences that might have influenced or impacted your mind / health / life considerably.
Write about what common opinions most people have about you; what most people comment /say about you frequently; how they react / interact with you & why?
Write something unique about you (how you are different from others or what makes you special).
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
Name Ashok Chhabra
(my photo can been at facebook.com/ashochha)
Age 74
Gender Male
From Delhi NCR, India
Height 5' 7”
Weight 65 Kg
Skin Fair
Eyes Black
Weather Tolerance I feel very hot in summer and very cold in winter. Prefer winter.
Thirst I don't feel thirsty. I can stay without water for a long time.
General Generally I remain on low profile. Young age I was very cool now in old age I feel irritated very soon but I don't speak out. I keep every thing to myself. Up to the age of 12 I was a fearful boy. Latter on too I loved to remain on low profile (not shy) with a friend circle of my own.
I was a non veg till 2001. Now in old age I have become emotional. Not emotional but very emotional. To the extent If I happen to see a sad scene I feel like weeping.
I dont't like to go out not even movies. Ones I see are only on TV
Health
I rarely fall ill. major illnesses I remember are
Chiken pox 1952
Typhoid 1967
Dangu 1980 or 82
Back ache Spond.. 1999 (Longest illness for 6 months)
Present Sciatica It was a couple of days before that I was hit with sciatica that my Grand Son insisted on playing Badminton (this is the game I was most interested in from my childhood). I played with him and got a little jerk and had a slight pain in my back but thats it. It was all fine. After a few days (say 3 to 4 days) suddenly on an evening I felt pain in my left hip then on the second day it extended to my left thigh and finally on the third day it went to my leg (below the knee). This is when I saw my Doctor who put me on to pain killers. Pain killer is Ketral
(my photo can been at facebook.com/ashochha)
Age 74
Gender Male
From Delhi NCR, India
Height 5' 7”
Weight 65 Kg
Skin Fair
Eyes Black
Weather Tolerance I feel very hot in summer and very cold in winter. Prefer winter.
Thirst I don't feel thirsty. I can stay without water for a long time.
General Generally I remain on low profile. Young age I was very cool now in old age I feel irritated very soon but I don't speak out. I keep every thing to myself. Up to the age of 12 I was a fearful boy. Latter on too I loved to remain on low profile (not shy) with a friend circle of my own.
I was a non veg till 2001. Now in old age I have become emotional. Not emotional but very emotional. To the extent If I happen to see a sad scene I feel like weeping.
I dont't like to go out not even movies. Ones I see are only on TV
Health
I rarely fall ill. major illnesses I remember are
Chiken pox 1952
Typhoid 1967
Dangu 1980 or 82
Back ache Spond.. 1999 (Longest illness for 6 months)
Present Sciatica It was a couple of days before that I was hit with sciatica that my Grand Son insisted on playing Badminton (this is the game I was most interested in from my childhood). I played with him and got a little jerk and had a slight pain in my back but thats it. It was all fine. After a few days (say 3 to 4 days) suddenly on an evening I felt pain in my left hip then on the second day it extended to my left thigh and finally on the third day it went to my leg (below the knee). This is when I saw my Doctor who put me on to pain killers. Pain killer is Ketral
ashochha 7 years ago
The data is bit insufficient.
I wish you confirm few more points:
1. How were you in your studies? Did you study on your own or avoided?
2. How did you do you job at your occupation. Did you complete your work in time?
3. Do you like to read? What?
4. Did you fulfill your family responsibilities in time?
5. Why don't you like to go out of home? How do you pass your time generally?
I wish you confirm few more points:
1. How were you in your studies? Did you study on your own or avoided?
2. How did you do you job at your occupation. Did you complete your work in time?
3. Do you like to read? What?
4. Did you fulfill your family responsibilities in time?
5. Why don't you like to go out of home? How do you pass your time generally?
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
Name Ashok Chhabra
(my photo can been at facebook.com/ashochha)
Age 74
Gender Male
From Delhi NCR, India
Height 5' 7”
Weight 65 Kg
Skin Fair
Eyes Black
Weather Tolerance I feel very hot in summer and very cold in winter. Prefer winter.
Thirst I don't feel thirsty. I can stay without water for a long time.
General Generally I remain on low profile. Young age I was very cool now in old age I feel irritated very soon but I don't speak out. I keep every thing to myself. Up to the age of 12 I was a fearful boy. Latter on too I loved to remain on low profile (not shy) with a friend circle of my own.
I was a non veg till 2001. Now in old age I have become emotional. Not emotional but very emotional. To the extent If I happen to see a sad scene I feel like weeping.
I dont't like to go out not even movies. Ones I see are only on TV
Health
I rarely fall ill. major illnesses I remember are
Chiken pox 1952
Typhoid 1967
Dangu 1980 or 82
Back ache Spond.. 1999 (Longest illness for 6 months)
Present Sciatica It was a couple of days before that I was hit with sciatica that my Grand Son insisted on playing Badminton (this is the game I was most interested in from my childhood). I played with him and got a little jerk and had a slight pain in my back but thats it. It was all fine. After a few days (say 3 to 4 days) suddenly on an evening I felt pain in my left hip then on the second day it extended to my left thigh and finally on the third day it went to my leg (below the knee). This is when I saw my Doctor who put me on to pain killers. Pain killer is Ketral
The data is bit insufficient.
I wish you confirm few more points:
1. How were you in your studies? Did you study on your own or avoided?
2. How did you do you job at your occupation. Did you complete your work in time?
3. Do you like to read? What?
4. Did you fulfill your family responsibilities in time?
5. Why don't you like to go out of home? How do you pass your time generally?
Answers to your questionnaire
I was not very good at studies till 1958 but Matriculation Exam (10th class) on-wards I was okay with a good div in matriculation and even won scholarship in engineering which I cleared in 1966 and since then I was in service and at the point of leaving was Manager Sourcing then I started my own ancillary manufacturing Motor shafts. In 2012 at the age of 70 I have handed over my manufacturing unit to my eldest son who is managing it.
As far as I am concerned I do nothing and am staying with my younger son on the ground floor. I have developed a hobby of developing websites. I make websites for myself only and its not for commercial purpose though its not by choice. Anybody who wants have it will ask me to visit their site which I will not.
I do not like to go out because I think I feel insecure. Till today I also didn't think for the reason of my not going out. Your question has made be ponder over the reason. I feel comfortable with my old friend circle but not with new people. Hope you understand. Even going to the market place is a problem. My try will be to see how I can do without going.
At work I had been very efficient worker. I couldn't go home without completing my job even if it means working overnight. Even at home I love helping every member of my family be it my wife, son, daughter-in-law or my grandsons.
I like reading. Usually I read books on interesting subject which include political, spiritual and fiction. Life after death and near death experiences is my favorite subjects. Read many books on the subject.
One last thing, which you have not asked, tension is my way of life. If I have to go out for some work at a particular time I am full of tension till I leave and before leaving I must go to toilet.
I hate, and am fully tensed, if my son tells me to consult a Dr for a particular ailment.
Hope I have answered all questions.
Ashok Chhabra
(my photo can been at facebook.com/ashochha)
Age 74
Gender Male
From Delhi NCR, India
Height 5' 7”
Weight 65 Kg
Skin Fair
Eyes Black
Weather Tolerance I feel very hot in summer and very cold in winter. Prefer winter.
Thirst I don't feel thirsty. I can stay without water for a long time.
General Generally I remain on low profile. Young age I was very cool now in old age I feel irritated very soon but I don't speak out. I keep every thing to myself. Up to the age of 12 I was a fearful boy. Latter on too I loved to remain on low profile (not shy) with a friend circle of my own.
I was a non veg till 2001. Now in old age I have become emotional. Not emotional but very emotional. To the extent If I happen to see a sad scene I feel like weeping.
I dont't like to go out not even movies. Ones I see are only on TV
Health
I rarely fall ill. major illnesses I remember are
Chiken pox 1952
Typhoid 1967
Dangu 1980 or 82
Back ache Spond.. 1999 (Longest illness for 6 months)
Present Sciatica It was a couple of days before that I was hit with sciatica that my Grand Son insisted on playing Badminton (this is the game I was most interested in from my childhood). I played with him and got a little jerk and had a slight pain in my back but thats it. It was all fine. After a few days (say 3 to 4 days) suddenly on an evening I felt pain in my left hip then on the second day it extended to my left thigh and finally on the third day it went to my leg (below the knee). This is when I saw my Doctor who put me on to pain killers. Pain killer is Ketral
The data is bit insufficient.
I wish you confirm few more points:
1. How were you in your studies? Did you study on your own or avoided?
2. How did you do you job at your occupation. Did you complete your work in time?
3. Do you like to read? What?
4. Did you fulfill your family responsibilities in time?
5. Why don't you like to go out of home? How do you pass your time generally?
Answers to your questionnaire
I was not very good at studies till 1958 but Matriculation Exam (10th class) on-wards I was okay with a good div in matriculation and even won scholarship in engineering which I cleared in 1966 and since then I was in service and at the point of leaving was Manager Sourcing then I started my own ancillary manufacturing Motor shafts. In 2012 at the age of 70 I have handed over my manufacturing unit to my eldest son who is managing it.
As far as I am concerned I do nothing and am staying with my younger son on the ground floor. I have developed a hobby of developing websites. I make websites for myself only and its not for commercial purpose though its not by choice. Anybody who wants have it will ask me to visit their site which I will not.
I do not like to go out because I think I feel insecure. Till today I also didn't think for the reason of my not going out. Your question has made be ponder over the reason. I feel comfortable with my old friend circle but not with new people. Hope you understand. Even going to the market place is a problem. My try will be to see how I can do without going.
At work I had been very efficient worker. I couldn't go home without completing my job even if it means working overnight. Even at home I love helping every member of my family be it my wife, son, daughter-in-law or my grandsons.
I like reading. Usually I read books on interesting subject which include political, spiritual and fiction. Life after death and near death experiences is my favorite subjects. Read many books on the subject.
One last thing, which you have not asked, tension is my way of life. If I have to go out for some work at a particular time I am full of tension till I leave and before leaving I must go to toilet.
I hate, and am fully tensed, if my son tells me to consult a Dr for a particular ailment.
Hope I have answered all questions.
Ashok Chhabra
ashochha 7 years ago
Please start with following prescription:
1. ARGENTUM NITRICUM 30C , pills (buy minimum qty dispensable at the shop), take 5 pills (for one dose) 1 DOSE AT ABOUT 8PM 2ND DOSE AT 10PM, (NO EXCESS DOSES PLEASE).
Nothing else to eat or drink 1 hour before and 1 hour after the doses.
(This dose works for several days. So, keep patience).
Do’s & don’ts:
1. Stay away from Strong odors.
2. Do not touch medicines or spill them. Use the cap of container (of same medicine) to transfer the medicines.
3. Place the prescribed dose under the tongue and let it dissolve. Keep the dose for at least 2 minutes in mouth.
4. Keep medicine containers airtight, away from direct sunlight, heat, any smell and children.
5. Avoid strong smells and odors AFAP.
6. Do not take any other medicines for any health problems. Most symptoms go as they come within 24-72 hours. Do not apply any cream etc for skin itching / eruption, if any.
7. Report any problems & seek appropriate advice.
8. Otherwise report progress after 1week.
1. ARGENTUM NITRICUM 30C , pills (buy minimum qty dispensable at the shop), take 5 pills (for one dose) 1 DOSE AT ABOUT 8PM 2ND DOSE AT 10PM, (NO EXCESS DOSES PLEASE).
Nothing else to eat or drink 1 hour before and 1 hour after the doses.
(This dose works for several days. So, keep patience).
Do’s & don’ts:
1. Stay away from Strong odors.
2. Do not touch medicines or spill them. Use the cap of container (of same medicine) to transfer the medicines.
3. Place the prescribed dose under the tongue and let it dissolve. Keep the dose for at least 2 minutes in mouth.
4. Keep medicine containers airtight, away from direct sunlight, heat, any smell and children.
5. Avoid strong smells and odors AFAP.
6. Do not take any other medicines for any health problems. Most symptoms go as they come within 24-72 hours. Do not apply any cream etc for skin itching / eruption, if any.
7. Report any problems & seek appropriate advice.
8. Otherwise report progress after 1week.
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
Dear sir,
I started the treatment on 18th after procuring the medicen.
Initially I had to take 3 to 4 pain killers a day. I really had a very bad time, but you asked me to have patience so I waited.
Its after 6-7 days I felt a markable improvement. Since I was asked to have patience i have waited for almost 2 weeks to give you some positive feedback. Every day was better then the previous day
Today I feel I have very little painleft. Till yesterday I had to take a painkiller but today I have taken none.
Now I would like to know if I need to take any other medicen or repeat of Argentum Nitricum 30
Please give your advise.
A bundle of Thanks for all the help!
Ashok Chhabra
I started the treatment on 18th after procuring the medicen.
Initially I had to take 3 to 4 pain killers a day. I really had a very bad time, but you asked me to have patience so I waited.
Its after 6-7 days I felt a markable improvement. Since I was asked to have patience i have waited for almost 2 weeks to give you some positive feedback. Every day was better then the previous day
Today I feel I have very little painleft. Till yesterday I had to take a painkiller but today I have taken none.
Now I would like to know if I need to take any other medicen or repeat of Argentum Nitricum 30
Please give your advise.
A bundle of Thanks for all the help!
Ashok Chhabra
ashochha 7 years ago
Dear Dr.k.
I wish the poly prescribers look into this thread to understand how effectively proper homeopathy works.
The way you take the case is an education itself. Your steadfastness in sticking to a single/few doses of the indicated remedy shown your confidence in remedy selection.
May this forum continue to have your good services forever.
Regards
Murthy
I wish the poly prescribers look into this thread to understand how effectively proper homeopathy works.
The way you take the case is an education itself. Your steadfastness in sticking to a single/few doses of the indicated remedy shown your confidence in remedy selection.
May this forum continue to have your good services forever.
Regards
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy 7 years ago
Good.
But I had asked not to take any other medicines (pain killers, etc) I didn't know why you took them. I understand Sciatica is just intolerable. However, had you refrained from taking pain killers probably relief could have been quicker. In many cases the homeopathic remedy may not work at all with such interference. However, I should say you are lucky, it still worked for you.
Well, it is good to learn that you are relieved. But still the curing process is on. Just avoid any medicines, creams, etc. and let it run it's own course. No repetition of any dose is required now.
But I had asked not to take any other medicines (pain killers, etc) I didn't know why you took them. I understand Sciatica is just intolerable. However, had you refrained from taking pain killers probably relief could have been quicker. In many cases the homeopathic remedy may not work at all with such interference. However, I should say you are lucky, it still worked for you.
Well, it is good to learn that you are relieved. But still the curing process is on. Just avoid any medicines, creams, etc. and let it run it's own course. No repetition of any dose is required now.
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
Thank you Mr. Murthy.
I have umpteen experience of single dose cures in my practice. Therefore, I hardly ever feel like giving more doses unless otherwise indicated. In fact, why should anyone?
When single dose is capable of accomplishing unnecessary repetitions can spoil the case even when remedy is perfect.
Actually, in several cases, I see here that prescribers are spoiling their own good prescriptions either by unwanted repetitions or by unwanted combinations.
I can't afford time for forums but one of the intentions of joining here was to discuss, learn, educate about authentic homeopathy but unfortunately there is very little scope here.
Even responses from patients also is disappointing here. You can understand by this case waiting at least 2 weeks is essential (it was not even chronic case).
Well. thanks again.
I have umpteen experience of single dose cures in my practice. Therefore, I hardly ever feel like giving more doses unless otherwise indicated. In fact, why should anyone?
When single dose is capable of accomplishing unnecessary repetitions can spoil the case even when remedy is perfect.
Actually, in several cases, I see here that prescribers are spoiling their own good prescriptions either by unwanted repetitions or by unwanted combinations.
I can't afford time for forums but one of the intentions of joining here was to discuss, learn, educate about authentic homeopathy but unfortunately there is very little scope here.
Even responses from patients also is disappointing here. You can understand by this case waiting at least 2 weeks is essential (it was not even chronic case).
Well. thanks again.
DrKulkarni 7 years ago
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.