≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

hair falling plss help mmmmeeeeeeee Page 3 of 4

This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Sir
Hi how r u,

Now again my hair falling is incresing day by day now i m taking arnica 30c & surlfpur 1m and arnica mint. aply on head pls suggest me if u think i need another medicine
 
anilsharma last decade
I find in your case that you have been using high potency remedies like Sulphur 1M which I prescribed just once weekly on a daily basis.

You have also used other remedies in a manner that I have not prescribed.

It is no wonder that you are not observing any improvement in your hair loss as it is possible that you may have used a
 
Joe De Livera last decade
continuation.......

remedy in a manner not advised.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
QUOTE: 'Shell i take another alopethic medicine with these medicine actully i m suffring pack pain thats way i m asking so pls reply me'

So let's see here, some amelioration of the scalp problems, immediately followed by the emergence of back pain (which, btw, is also a PROVING symptom of Arnica), sounds very much like the scenario painted elsewhere to me.

And Sulphur 1M daily for a week and then report back? Tell me Joe, how is the patients vital force meant to react to the stimulus of the remedy when it is being continually appplied in this manner?
 
Hahnemania last decade
And on what are you basing these remedy selections...if I may ask?

You have gone from Arnica, to Phytolacca, and then Graphites to Sulphur, without asking for any further information at all, and all four remedies are very different in nature, what are these selections based upon?
 
Hahnemania last decade
Mr Joe de liver had suggested me these medicine after some time taking this medicine i got some relief but again same problem has been started
 
anilsharma last decade
Mr Joe De livera pls suggest me another medicine but stil i m not taking sulphur 1m pls sir help me plssssss
 
anilsharma last decade
QUOTE: 'Mr Joe de liver had suggested me these medicine after some time taking this medicine i got some relief but again same problem has been started'

This is because the treatment is not taking into account your full constitution, and only being prescribed for one symptom.

My advice before even considering remedies would be to check nutritional intake. A very high percentage of hair loss cases can be halted by mere supplementation, and it has been estimated by leading nutritionalists around the world that this figure may be as high as 80%.

For those not CLASSICALLY trained in Homoeopathy, looking into the lifestyle of the patient before prescribing a multitude of deeply acting remedies for a condition, especially one which is suspected to have a nutritional deficeit as it's cause, can be as important as remedies themselves, but of course those who wish to achieve a high cure rate for their own purposes, just blast the whole thing with remedy after remedy, which often makes the condition even worse...
 
Hahnemania last decade
I would have you know that I was not responsible for the patient taking 'remedy after remedy' which you seem to be adducing to me.

You are no doubt aware that some others had prescribed what you have yourself described:

'And on what are you basing these remedy selections...if I may ask?

You have gone from Arnica, to Phytolacca, and then Graphites to Sulphur, without asking for any further information at all, and all four remedies are very different in nature, what are these selections based upon?'

I have placed my cards on the table in other posts on this forum and would appreciate if you do not in future persist in 'teaching your grandmother (grandfather?) to suck eggs.'
 
Joe De Livera last decade
I also had hair fall problem some years back.I used R.S.Bhargava pharmacy's BALS tablets.


COMPOSITION: Acid Phosphoricum 3X,
Oleum Santalis 6X, Jaborandi 6X, Acid
Fluoricum 3X, Arsenic Album 3X,
Badiaga 6X, and Calc. Phos. 3X. In sugar
of milk base.
 
ashish_jain last decade
'would have you know that I was not responsible for the patient taking 'remedy after remedy' which you seem to be adducing to me.'
Oh, have you not recommended four completely unrelated remedies without asking for any further information then? I must have imagined this.

'I have placed my cards on the table in other posts on this forum and would appreciate if you do not in future persist in 'teaching your grandmother (grandfather?) to suck eggs.'
As I thought, there IS no basis for your remedy selections, you are just randomly prescribing remedies because one symptom is listed in their drug pictures.

As for teaching my grandmother to suck eggs Joe, which I actually found quite amusing, this phrase means to not preach to someone who has greater knowledge, and I'm afraid this is very much NOT the case in this situation, as you have very little knowledge of how to use Homoeopathy at all. So full marks for self appraisment on that, but 0 for actual reality.

I will continue to post questions here, as I have above, because it interests me on what basis people such as yourself prescribe as you do, and if you have nothing to hide from your mode of application, I see no reason why such questions cannot be answered, rather than avoided, as they were above...
 
Hahnemania last decade
I shall look forward to similar encounters with you and you will discover that you have a very powerful adversary in me who although not a qualified homeopath as you may pretend to be, I may be able to show you a clean pair of heels judging by my performance on this and other Homeopathic forums in the sheer number of cases that I have successfully resolved all of which have not succumbed to your warnings of dire gloom which would result of my therapy. I do admire what is popularly known as your 'cheek' to even suggest this matter as according to you it is only the therapy that I prescribe that bring forth these dire manifestations which only exist in your fertile imagination. You do not take into account the many hundreds of cases that have been mauled by your classical bretheren who discover that they are cured very quickly by my therapy. I refer especially to case of Asthma, GERD and Eczema to name just three.

I do admire your self aggrandizement where you seem to have taken upon yourself the mantle of being superior to me merely because I help others with my own 'Joepathy' in a manner that you would never dare to do. You can read the many cases that I have treated successfully from so many hundreds, perhaps even thousands of cases on this and other forums where grateful patients have recorded their cures.

You have only recently joined this forum and you are already showing up to be the acme of perfection in this science but strangely enough I do not seem to see any positive response so far from your patients who should by now should have benefitted from your therapy.

It is homeopaths like you who are the bane of Homeopathy today as it is practiced by your classical brethren who under the pretense of practicing in accordance with the tenets of your classical system, invariably compel your patients who come to you for relatively minor ailments to return again and again on a weekly basis for reasons best known to your type, to whom Homeopathy is another means of amassing wealth at the expense of the poor patient.

It is deplorable that you are so full of your own pomposity and superior knowledge you have collected during your studies that you do not for a moment consider that there may also be some truth in the homeopathy that I practice as it has invariably yielded positive results so far.

I would request you to remember that it is not the piece of paper that you have received that is important in the practice of one's therapy, but it is the results that the patients you treat derive from your efforts to help them.
 
Joe De Livera last decade
Okay, seeing as you seem to have become a little confused, not to mention unduly agitated, and pretty offensive (which usually occurs when one becomes defensive of assertions which have no basis in reality I have found)I will try to put you right on a few things:

Firstly, I pretend to be nothing. I have not given my credentials here, I have merely questioned a system of practice which goes against everything I KNOW to be true from my own experiences, not to mention those of 200 years of Homoeopaths.

As stated previously, none of the cases I have seen on this forum have had proper follow up, so whether or not they have indeed been 'cured' or merely palliated or supressed is of course still up for debate. In the few cases I HAVE read of your treatment (which btw I DID read in their entirety, and not as you assumed, 'just glanced over'), I still see no evidence of either cure or long term follow up as detailed above.

It is nothing to do with 'my cheek' as you quaintly put it, but as stated above, based upon my own experience and that of 200 years of classical Homoeopaths, and the long term effects of such treatments do not exist only in my 'fertile imagination', they are well recorded throughout our entire history, as you would know if you had an in depth knowledge of the subject. I would estimate that in app. 30% of all my cases over the years I have first had to sort out the absolute MESS caused by others calling themselves Homoeopaths, such as yourself, and by those self-prescribing.

I have NO allegance to any brethren, least of all the mainstream Homoeopathic community, I am merely a classical Homoeopath, and I work alone...for now.

I have no self agrandizment, and it was actually YOU that insinuated you had more knowledge than I have, by your use of the phrase 'do not teach your grandmother to suck eggs', I merely responded in a like manner.

As for you helping patients in a manner I would never dare to, this is quite laughabale. You are treating patients in the most superficial manner possible, with no proper case taking or as stated, no follow up treatment. Also, for the record, as mentioned above, I have no allegance to anyone, and in fact I have also been shunned by the majority (but not all) of the Homoepathic community I have encountered over the years, my ideas being to 'radical' for them (which is again laughable, because they are nothing more than the true concepts), who in my opinion, like you, albeit to a lesser degree, simply do not understand the subject at all.

You have not seen any results from my recommendations, as no one has actually accpeted treatment from me yet, so I find your statement regarding this point quite illogical.

Homoeopaths like me? You do not know me, and I would disagree, it is Homoeopaths like YOU and your mode of treatment (which you frequently promote) who are the bane of Homoeopathy, as it is NOT Homoeopathy you are practicing at all, and such modes will only serve to give us ALL a bad name.

As for your assertion that I compel patients to come back to me again and again, for 'reasons best known to my type, to whom Homeopathy is another means of amassing wealth at the expense of the poor patient', I am DEEPLY insulted by this comment. Homoeopathy is a vocation to me, and always has been, I charge my patients only what they can afford, I even have one old lady who bakes me cakes for payment! and I dedicate a lot of my time volunteering my services to allopathic hospitals and clinics. If I was provided with some other means on which to live, I would also quite happily give treatment 100% for free. I have also over the last twelve years gone through immense suffering by way of self-proving some 300 remedies so I may be able to see these in my patients, and provide PROPER cure of their conditions. How DARE you make such an assumption, you do not know me, or anything about me, and I think this statement alone speak volumes about YOUR reasons for practicing. You have elevated yourself to this 'saviour' type person, who is so wonderful he treats everyone for free, and basks in the reverance of his 'goodness', but in reality what you are actually doing is providing short term relief for mostly chronic ailments with neither little interest nor concern of how this practice is affecting people in the long term, as long as you are seen to be the good guy, and recieve adulation for this, you are happy, and to me that is not only irresponsible, it is downright selfish.

In closing, I am FULLY aware that an academic training in Homoeopathy is only a VERY small part of what is required to practice this noble art, and as stated above, I have in 12 years of REAL LIFE practice, which amounts to many thousands of cases, ALL of which have recieved full follow up to make sure cure is both complete and full, only had ONE case in which the patient has not responded, and this patient is still very much under treatment as we speak.

Prior to this post I have been neither derisory nor insulting toward you or your methods, I have merely questioned their long term efficacy, and tried to understand where others have been so quick to dismiss, but as you chose to initiate this level of discourse, there, THAT ^^^ is my view.

You are NOT a Homoeopath, and you are promoting a mode of treatment which in my opinion based on my own experiences, and that of 200 years of Homoeopaths, will ONLY provide more suffering to the patient in the long term.

I have no further interest in continuing this discussion, or in 'understanding' your methods, as from what I have seen, they are quite simply NOT Homoeopathy, have no place therein, and I refuse to sit here and listen while you make casual assumptions, and insultive remarks.

I would say good luck, but I will wish this on your so called 'patients', as in the long term I feel they may need this more than you.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Dear Hahnemania - you seem to be Jacob from JCS site. Welcome to our world, where you are trashed for speaking the truth while misguided individuals make preposterous claims. Please follow the asthma threads which I and my colleagues have been monitoring - these are meant to be CURES!!! Any attempt to bring sanity to proceedings is met by derisive attacks and accusations. We are trying to feather our nests. We must be A, B or C. We do nothing to help, while the grandfather who teaches us to suck eggs is so devoted - never mind where that devotion is leading others. Sad state of afairs for homeopathy.
 
ripas last decade
Mr Joe De Livera and Mr Hahnemania y u r fighting to each other pls give me soloutiong of this problem i know u both have good exp.So pls tell me now which medicine i should have to take because i m problem is incresing day by day plss sir help meeeeeeeeeee
 
anilsharma last decade
Haha, hello ripas, I am indeed, and thankyou for the welcome!

I actually joined this forum because I became sick of people coming to my own (hmm..maybe I should take Arnica wet dose and Nat Phos 6x for this, what do you think? heh), with horror stories of the type of treatment that was being recommended here, and of the detrimental effects they had experienced from such advice, but I must admit, until I saw it with my own eyes, I would never have believed it.

'Take this. What? Oh no, we don't need to know anything about you, just take this. What's that you say? It didn't work? Oh well try this instead. No, no, we don't need to ask for any further information to make a selection, just take this for the next two months and you will be cured!'

Sorry...no. Someone has to inject some sanity here in the name of Homoeopathy, and the more of us there are, the better.

Thanks for the support, and I will most definitley be checking out the asthma threads ;)


-Jacob.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Dear anilsharma.

The first thing you need to do, is calm down. Your condition is treatable, but only if approached in a rational and relxaed manner. You will derive no benefit from simply swallowing remedy after remedy.

As stated above, some 80% of cases of rapid hair loss are linked to chronic nutritional deficiencies, and many cases can be sucessfully treated simply by supplementation alone. I have seen this in clinical practice many times.

Go to your local health store and purchase a good multivitamin containing at least 25mg of all 11 B-complex vitamins listed below (one or two are listed in micrograms, this is fine), and a good quality multi-mineral which MUST contain Magnesium, zinc, iodine, manganese & copper as part of the entire formulation. If you are able to get products made by Solgar, so much the better. This company also offers a mail order service online.

B1 (Thiamin)
B2 (Riboflavin)
B3 (Niacin)
B5 (Pantothenic acid)
B6 (Pyridoxine)
B12(Cyanocobalamin)
Choline
Inositol
Folic acid
Biotin
Para amino benzoic acid (PABA)

If you do not feel calmer within one week of taking these supplements, then it is likely there is also something else at play, and based on your general demeanour, I would recommend you take Aconite 30c one dose, report back after, and continue with the supplementation.

Do bare in mind however, the actual falling of the hair may take a little while to fully resolve itself under supplementaion, but the first thing we need to do is calm you down, as such anxiety is often the cause of this rapid type of hair loss.

If the above superficial approach does not work (although I am pretty certain it will), I am happy to look into your case more deeply, as I am sure many others are also.

Best wishes.


-Jacob.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Mr Jacob

Thanks for ur reply but pls tell me any medicine name where all these vitamins is contains and will be get easily i m from india (delhi) and secondlay rite now i m taking sea seven (fish oil) capsul it will be continue or not

pls reply me
 
anilsharma last decade
Dear anilsharma.

I am pretty sure Solgar Vitamins ship to india, and they have a catlogue online.

I would reccomend:
VM-75 1 tablet daily with food
and one of their chelated mulit-mineral supplements (of which there are many) 1 tablet per day.

The fish oil in addition is fine, unless there is any history or suggestion of liver problems.

Best wishes.


-Jacob.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Dear Mr Jacob

VM -75 is a homeopathic medicine or alopathic medicine and what is the meaning of multi mineral supplements pls suggest me any company name or any medical store where i can purchase easly

regards

anil sharma
 
anilsharma last decade
VM-75 is a multi-vitamin supplement
A multi-mineral supplement is a supplement containing the full spectrum f minerals necessary for health.

I have given the company name...Solgar, and this brand is stocked by virtually all health stores, and as mentioned above will also ship remedies around the world, when ordered online.


-Jacob.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Mr Jacob
How r u,Sir i m little bit confused its a homeopathic medicine or alopathic because yesterday when i go for purchase these medicne to alophathic medicine store he told that its a homeopethic medicine so pls tell me that where from i can get these medicne from homeopathic store or alophathic pls psl thanks

regards

anil sharma
 
anilsharma last decade
one more thing i want to tell u that i have huge dandruff and hair graying problem so tell me solution too of this problem
 
anilsharma last decade
Mr Jacob

what happend sir,pls give mer eply pllsssssssssss
 
anilsharma last decade
A Multi-VITAMIN, is a VITAMIN supplement, it is neither allopathic nor allopathic.
 
Hahnemania last decade
Homoeopathic*
 
Hahnemania last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.