Diagnosed with weak osephagul sphicter

I note that you have used Nat Phos 6x to help your GERD with success but that it has not helped with the leakage of gastric juice into your Esophagus.

I presume that you have suffered from this condition for some time, perhaps years, and that you have been prescribed the drugs that are used to help this condition.

You do not mention however that you have used Arnica 30c which I have used in many cases like yours to help to build up the eroded esophagus and hopefully will also help with the repair of your Lower Esophagal Valve which is not performing its function.

I would like you to use Arnica 30c in the wet dose 1 teaspoonful 3 times daily and report your response. Please note that this is not a quick fix as you will have to take it for some time to let the organs that have been eroded by the gastric juice to recover.

In the meanwhile I would like you to use Nat Phos 3x dose 2 tablets taken 3 times daily and report if you find it more effective than that 6x.

Chahat has already tried this Arnica and Nat.phos therapy.

*********

Can i take more than 1 remedy a day?? From chahat on 2006-10-04
14 replies 228 views
Hello

I am currently taking nat phos 6x and arnica 30c for gastric problems as suggested by members and i must say it has helped a lot.

**********

Though Chahat felt that it is helping at that time, obviously it didn't help.

Dear Chahat

I have gone through your previous posts. Your best bet is to consuly a competent classical homeopath in person, who gives you one medicine at a time, and wait for responses.

This for that therapies won't work.

Murthy

To Murthy


Chahat has clearly indicated that he is now only using the Nat Phos 6x but NOT the other essential part of my standard therapy for GERD which has worked in many hundreds of cases. He has probably stopped it for some time and his present condition is serious as he is considering surgery which will not help him and perhaps leave him a patient for life.

This is the reason why I spent some time to prescribe it to him and all you do is to butt in as usual with your standard prescription to see a 'classical' homeopath.

Why don't you prescribe that elusive 'single remedy' to cure Chahat of his chronic GERD ? All you can do is to suggest the patients who has obviously run the gamut of doctors and also 'classical' homeopaths and has finally landed on the ABC and asks for help.

What makes you think that any 'classical' homeopath can help him with a single remedy which you can also prescribe ?

You are advised to spend more time in helping patients instead of jumping in on every thread that I prescribe on, instead of wasting your time on investigating the past posts of everyone on this ABC which now run into millions.

I know that you cannot resist your urge to upset everyone especially me on this forum but as you have seen I am made of sterner stuff that your obese self with a clear mind even at my age of 77, old enough to be your father.

Remember that age and the experience that comes with it helps especially if one in not as conceited as you obviously are.

I believe that you would have been the over grown schoolboy throughout your life and cannot even at your age of 50 years, overcome your bullying tactics that are getting you nowhere, at least on this forum where you are recognized to be the Homeopathic Troll.

To Chahat

You can help your GERD with the addition of Asafoetida 6c which you take in the dry pellets twice daily.

Please report your response after 2 days on this remedy.

addition???

That makes it three remedies together.!!!

What an irresponsible way of prescribing.!!

I wish there is some law somewhere so as the receipients of such outrageous advices can sue these prescribers for the sufferings the patients are going to face.

Can the prescribers play with the health of unsuspecting patients in this manner?

I am appalled.

Murthy

To Murthy

I have prescribed each remedy to help with alleviating the patient's obvious distress and if you can fish out your 'SINGLE' classical remedy guaranteed to help him you are welcome to take over.




.

Dear Chahat

My advice still stands.

The presriptions that are being dished out through these forums are useless/dangerous for your condition.

You can still be helped through homeopathy, but, you need to be seen personally by a competent homeopath.

I have your best interest at heart.

Murthy

To Murthy

I wonder if it ever occurred to you that the standard advice you give a patient on this forum :

'You can still be helped through homeopathy, but, you need to be seen personally by a competent homeopath. '

This only confirms that you do not consider yourself in that elevated category of a 'competent homeopath' and are therefore not capable of helping the patient with the meager experience you have accumulated during the past 4 years of your homeopathic studies.

What you lack is the love of healing suffering humanity and not of vilifying those who have done so for more than 25 years and practice this science for the sheer joy of curing someone especially those who have spent much of their life in consulting doctors and 'classical' homeopaths with no signs of any cure.

Dear Chahat

The reason why I can't prescribe on each and every thread is given below.

**********

As to 'alternate prescriptions' it is not easy for those who follow the classical way.

Most of the times the information is insufficient, and further questioning consumes lot of time.

That is why the work load is distributed among classical prescribers like Rishimba,Rajiv,Maheeru,Sajjadakram,and a few others.

I do take up cases, if you care to see.

'This for that' prescribers don't have to go through all this drill. They have standard medicines on their lips,and they won't work most of the time. Sometimes they just palliate, and some times they lead to dangerous suppressions too.

If you want me too prscribe 'this for that way' it is a matter of seconds to me.But, that is not my philosophy.

Hope, you will understand it.

Murthy

To Chahat

I am glad to note that you have been helped by the therapy that I have often prescribed for cases of GERD like yours which have been chronic, in your case for 3 years.

It may take some while for your problem to be cured as we are dealing with an organ which is constantly in use producing acid and enzymes and digesting food. It is obvious that your total dedication to following my instructions are followed as in the recent past you have only used the Nat Phos as it gives you almost instant relief but not a cure.

I would like to change your therapy as follows:

Change the potency of Nat Phos 6x to 3x. Dosage to remain at 3 tablets tds.

Arnica 30c will remain as at present.

Asafoetida 6c in the dry dose 3 pellets taken twice daily sublingually. This will prevent reverse peristalsis thereby preventing gastric juice leaking into the esophagus.

Report response in a week.

Dear Chahat

One medicine at a time is proper homeopathy.

Read the articles

Pseudo homeopathy

The theory of Suppression.

Try Nat.Phos alone, as you yourself are inclined to do.

If no response, come back.

Murthy

Sorry. You already tried it.

You wanted to try Arnica.

Go ahead and use it alone.

Report after a week.

Murthy

To Chahat

Asafoetida powder cannot help you and in any case I have no experince with its use.

It is the Homeopathic remedy that you will have to get and use as prescribed.

Asafoetida powder is traditionally used in cooking certain dishes in indian families, for its medicinal powers.

just a few grains are added in curries like dal, sambar.

Murthy