The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Page 1 2
commercial remedies (Sinusalia?)
Hi:I am breastfeeding my 9 month old son. We both have colds, and I have severe sinus pressure and pain on the right sinus cavity, but cannot breath through my left nostril. I have tried allopathic remedies to no avail. When I saw a homeopath (years ago) I was prescribed pulsatilla. I know Boiron makes a remedy called Sinusalia...my question is is it Ok to take? What should I be looking for in my son -in case of an adverse reaction?
Thank you.
anart on 2005-02-12
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
bandarbabu2000 last decade
If the puls worked well for you then take it again. It will go through you to baby who will be able to take the remedy this way.
It won't have adverse effects on either of you if it is the correct one.
It won't have adverse effects on either of you if it is the correct one.
parachute last decade
hi Parachute
I don't think the remedy goes through milk - where did you find such info?
only material substance goes through body this way-not dynamized!
I don't think the remedy goes through milk - where did you find such info?
only material substance goes through body this way-not dynamized!
Astra2012 last decade
Hi Astra,
I got it from Mr Derek Briggs, the director of the Auckland colllege of homeopathy NZ, many years ago.
Regards
parachute
I got it from Mr Derek Briggs, the director of the Auckland colllege of homeopathy NZ, many years ago.
Regards
parachute
parachute last decade
Astra
This is what Hannemann said regarding 'sucklings'.It was in chronic diseases.I will give the exact reference,in the evening.
Murthy
This is what Hannemann said regarding 'sucklings'.It was in chronic diseases.I will give the exact reference,in the evening.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
I have "chronic diseases" BUT although Hahnemann was a genius and explained many things much better than his contemporaries--they didn't know that much about anatomy and physiology at that time--he did only the best he could AT THAT TIME. It doesn't mean that we have to repeat like parrots everything he said--he would be the first to adjust homeopathy to science if he lived now.
Only material substances are carried with blood--the dynamized forms of remedies are not. They are not transferred with milk any more than when mother hugs her kids after taking the remedy. Why would they concentrate in milk only?
Only material substances are carried with blood--the dynamized forms of remedies are not. They are not transferred with milk any more than when mother hugs her kids after taking the remedy. Why would they concentrate in milk only?
Astra2012 last decade
Hello Parachute,
I'm NEVER criticizing you.Your statement triggered a discussion-which is a great thing in homeopathy.
Besides, I just question everything. Such a character.
I'm NEVER criticizing you.Your statement triggered a discussion-which is a great thing in homeopathy.
Besides, I just question everything. Such a character.
Astra2012 last decade
Hi Astra,
I saw three different women with three different remedies treated in such a manner. Long time back in my student days.
All reported good results for them and the baby. Put the mother right with the correct remedy, it follows that the antibodies in breast milk will take care of the baby.
As for the experimentation, there are people who do this, I'm one, but yet some don't have the basics of homeopathy understood when they do it.
Many times I read these pages and more often than not, the disease is still being treated by all sorts of roundabout ways instead of finding the simillium to match the patient with the remedy, not the disease. Granted there are remedies that can be used for certain stock troubles, and there are countries that laws have determined how homeopathy gets practiced, which may account for some differing opinions, Classical homeopathy isn't easy, especially over the net but it's the only way I practice.
warm regards
parachute
I saw three different women with three different remedies treated in such a manner. Long time back in my student days.
All reported good results for them and the baby. Put the mother right with the correct remedy, it follows that the antibodies in breast milk will take care of the baby.
As for the experimentation, there are people who do this, I'm one, but yet some don't have the basics of homeopathy understood when they do it.
Many times I read these pages and more often than not, the disease is still being treated by all sorts of roundabout ways instead of finding the simillium to match the patient with the remedy, not the disease. Granted there are remedies that can be used for certain stock troubles, and there are countries that laws have determined how homeopathy gets practiced, which may account for some differing opinions, Classical homeopathy isn't easy, especially over the net but it's the only way I practice.
warm regards
parachute
parachute last decade
Hello Parachute,
In homeopathy results count more than (my) understanding, so if it worked - it must be the right way even though I THINK it isn't.
Still-it seems to me there must be other way. Why would it be only in milk? Antibodies, vitamins etc-yes, because they are material--but dynamized? And what's the final potency?
very warm regards (I'm happy you understand my "inquiring mind").
In homeopathy results count more than (my) understanding, so if it worked - it must be the right way even though I THINK it isn't.
Still-it seems to me there must be other way. Why would it be only in milk? Antibodies, vitamins etc-yes, because they are material--but dynamized? And what's the final potency?
very warm regards (I'm happy you understand my "inquiring mind").
Astra2012 last decade
Hi Astra
Perhaps Parachute is close to truth.How does an infection gets cleared,after the homeopathic medicine? Obviously it is helping the body produce antibodies,and these antibodies,may help the childern also.
Looks to be logical.
Murthy
Perhaps Parachute is close to truth.How does an infection gets cleared,after the homeopathic medicine? Obviously it is helping the body produce antibodies,and these antibodies,may help the childern also.
Looks to be logical.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
I don't know that it is "just in the milk"
I know there is a vibration that heals, how to proove it or get others to even acknowlege there is one, is not possible untill it is experienced, without any doubt in mind.
Whether it was the remedy, or suggestion, or devine intervention that made these three women better, there is really no way of telling. Except they were given hpathic remedies on purpose.
I would love to be able to say how homeopathy works and be able to proove it , but all I can really do is put my two cents in and let the world make its own mind up.
best of both worlds to all.
parachute
I know there is a vibration that heals, how to proove it or get others to even acknowlege there is one, is not possible untill it is experienced, without any doubt in mind.
Whether it was the remedy, or suggestion, or devine intervention that made these three women better, there is really no way of telling. Except they were given hpathic remedies on purpose.
I would love to be able to say how homeopathy works and be able to proove it , but all I can really do is put my two cents in and let the world make its own mind up.
best of both worlds to all.
parachute
parachute last decade
Homeopathic remedy which is similimum vibrates with the same pattern as body's vital force. The vital force mobilizes (is?) body's defence mechanism which heals wounds, fights infections (with antibodies), cures diseases. imo
Vital force permeates the whole body- is not just in one organ or secretion. By treating coma patients through the skin we know that you do not have to actually eat the remedy. So the remedy would be transferred through the milk as well as through the hug!
But it isn't so. Because of the affinity, I think.the right remedy gets "stuck" to the vf-the wrong just disperses into Universe.
If the nursing mother takes the remedy right for the child wrong to her-it will be dispersed as soon as she takes it.
Of course this are only my views. Not a one "smarty pants" ever wrote such brilliant musings.
Vital force permeates the whole body- is not just in one organ or secretion. By treating coma patients through the skin we know that you do not have to actually eat the remedy. So the remedy would be transferred through the milk as well as through the hug!
But it isn't so. Because of the affinity, I think.the right remedy gets "stuck" to the vf-the wrong just disperses into Universe.
If the nursing mother takes the remedy right for the child wrong to her-it will be dispersed as soon as she takes it.
Of course this are only my views. Not a one "smarty pants" ever wrote such brilliant musings.
Astra2012 last decade
"If the nursing mother takes the remedy right for the child wrong to her-it will be dispersed as soon as she takes it."
Hmmm..Very likely.
Astra
This point I totally missed when I wrote about antidotes etc.
This topic needs wider discussion.I will post it in other forums also.Let us see the response.
Murthy
Hmmm..Very likely.
Astra
This point I totally missed when I wrote about antidotes etc.
This topic needs wider discussion.I will post it in other forums also.Let us see the response.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
Great! I wonder what others think.
homeopathy is judged by results--I never had a chance to give remedy to a nursing baby- but I'd certainly give it to a baby and not mother.
homeopathy is judged by results--I never had a chance to give remedy to a nursing baby- but I'd certainly give it to a baby and not mother.
Astra2012 last decade
oyla,
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
arnika last decade
oyla,
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
arnika last decade
oyla,
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
arnika last decade
oyla,
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
arnika last decade
oyla,
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
why you all discus so much ?
if the picture of choosen remedy matches with the picture of patient , it will work . if it is not , will not help but also will make no harm.
this is charm or the best thing of homeopathy.
very simple and why make complications out of facts ?
z.
arnika last decade
Astra and Murthy,
we are talking about breastfed babies, and as such I think the link between mother and child is so strong that it would be reasonable to assume they are the same remedy untill the child is weaned. Unless there are obvious differences to really distinguish a different remedy, I'll go with what I know.
regards
parachute
we are talking about breastfed babies, and as such I think the link between mother and child is so strong that it would be reasonable to assume they are the same remedy untill the child is weaned. Unless there are obvious differences to really distinguish a different remedy, I'll go with what I know.
regards
parachute
parachute last decade
Dear parachute and Arnika
though I tend to agree with you,what do we do,when the child has fever but the mother doesn't?
We keep on telling that, a medicine is as if taken nothing,if the symptoms don't match.
By this hypothesis,the medicine can't work on the mother,and doesn't produce any reaction in her.Then,how does it help the fever in the child?
Would like to here your comments.
Murthy
though I tend to agree with you,what do we do,when the child has fever but the mother doesn't?
We keep on telling that, a medicine is as if taken nothing,if the symptoms don't match.
By this hypothesis,the medicine can't work on the mother,and doesn't produce any reaction in her.Then,how does it help the fever in the child?
Would like to here your comments.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
Hi Murthy,
in this situation the babe would be treated only, not through the mother, no point.
The original post was for both at the same time. But if you were stuck for a remedy I would look at the mother and ask her how the child was reacting.
regards
parachute
in this situation the babe would be treated only, not through the mother, no point.
The original post was for both at the same time. But if you were stuck for a remedy I would look at the mother and ask her how the child was reacting.
regards
parachute
parachute last decade
Astra2012 last decade
I think ,they should be treated separately, they are two persons with different
picture of person , mind ,
behavior etc.
Because of the way of healing in homeopathy this is
only possible way.
Dear Mutrhy!
Will you explane me ,why you hate combinations?
Do you think , is possible, for instance ,
if I have bladder infection,
pains in stomach and nervousness all at the same time-- cover all simptoms with one remedy???
And why are comb. so popular
all over the world ?????
They shouldn't be in pharmacies if they are not efficiant.At the end , people recognised if something helps them or not.
This way market works - you sell if it's good ( sorry but this is meant also for medicines if we like that or not ).
I also think, if Dr. Hahnemann had a chance to try to make experiments with comb. - he would like them.But he only had time for LM pot. at the end of his life .
Maybe is our task ,to try new ways of homeopathy.
Have a nice day
picture of person , mind ,
behavior etc.
Because of the way of healing in homeopathy this is
only possible way.
Dear Mutrhy!
Will you explane me ,why you hate combinations?
Do you think , is possible, for instance ,
if I have bladder infection,
pains in stomach and nervousness all at the same time-- cover all simptoms with one remedy???
And why are comb. so popular
all over the world ?????
They shouldn't be in pharmacies if they are not efficiant.At the end , people recognised if something helps them or not.
This way market works - you sell if it's good ( sorry but this is meant also for medicines if we like that or not ).
I also think, if Dr. Hahnemann had a chance to try to make experiments with comb. - he would like them.But he only had time for LM pot. at the end of his life .
Maybe is our task ,to try new ways of homeopathy.
Have a nice day
arnika last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.