≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum



Similar posts:

I have a question about the following combinations for severe asthma 11


The ABC Homeopathy Forum

question about the following combination and asthma

I have been needing to take my DuoNeb breathing treatments 20 times a day on a good day and more than that on a bad day, until I started on the following Combination:
Urtica Urens 30C (Tincture)
Plantago Lanceolata 30C
Allium Cepa 30C
Arsenicum Iodatum 30C
I ran out of all of them and have gone from needing 1 breathing treatment a day to anywhere from 3 on a good day to 7 on a bad, I'm just curious why there isn't anything about Asthma or Allerigies on them all? Could someone clear this is up as to why this combination works? PLease let me know if you can
  jhsif12 on 2012-03-10
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hi- how did you get this
combination? were they all prescribed
by a homeopath individually?

simone717 last decade
I was doing some digging on the net and found this site called Native Remedies and ordered their product called SOS Histadrops, when I took it to my Homeopathic Doctor he tested me and said I needed 15 drops 9 times a day. What the advertisment said about it was that it lowers Histamine levels, I'm wondering if that's Eosinophils also, I've never been able to find anything I'm allergic to but always have extremely high Eosinophils, the higher the more the severe the asthma.
jhsif12 last decade
Hi if you look up all those remedies
on the ABC store I am sure you will
find they all have something to do
with breathing, sneezing and so on.
I know Allium Cepa does.

so the question is - did your
homeopath try to treat your condition
before you got this combo remedy
with any other homeo medicine??

If he did I guess he failed bc you
would not have bought this. Is he
a classical homeopath or is he
a naturopath/homeopath? bc I assume
he 'muscle tested' you for this,
which is not normal homeopathic

It is great that it has relieved you,
however perhaps just one of those
remedies is enough to totally cure
you if prescribed in the right dosage.
or you need another constitutional
remedy-bc it sounds like you
have to keep taking this 'formula'
everyday which can lead to trouble
bc one of those remedies can start
to 'prove' itself and then you won't
know what is going on.
simone717 last decade
I'll double check, the first one, the Utrica Urens is used for Gout for some reason. I've had my Uric Acid Level tested before and have high levels, no pain in my big toes but some everywhere else. I'm thinking of getting these ingredients seperately in different (please forgive my ignorance if I get this term wrong) potency, such as something higher than 30C for each and see how well that works. I wonder if there could be a connection between high Uric Acid levels and asthma. I've had lower back pain when I urinate since I've had asthma but never connected the two, not sure if that is a symptom of high uric acid levels or not, haven't noticed it lately.
Appreciate the feedback
jhsif12 last decade
Hi Jason.
I am not a homeopath- in this post
you are going to be hearing from
some homeopaths !!

do not go out and get a higher potency
of this stuff. Look at how other people
post their case on here- the questions
and post your case. and put in what you
are taking. You will get some good
opinions of what to do and what potency
to take of what- bc what you want
is a total cure here.

The wrong potency can totally
backfire on you- so please post
your case and get some correct
advice on the remedies and dosing of
the remedies.

Regards, simone
simone717 last decade
The Urtica under nose- has itching
and swelling- so it would'erase'
itching and swelling allergic reactions-
you just click on the ABC store
and read the nose chest etc parts
and you see they all have something
to do with this. However they
are not to be taken for months on end
bc the way it works is one of them-
or another one will totally STOP
all the symptoms and that is
where the homeopath finds out
what one, and what dose to do it in-
SAFELY. You don't have enough
info to experiment with this-

Wait for guidance here.
simone717 last decade
You are not being treated in a homoeopathic fashion. Whoever you are getting this advice from is breaking many of the most basic guidelines for prescribing.

Homoeopaths do not use combinations. People who pretend to be homoeopaths do.

Homoeopaths do not 'test' patients, they interview them and use their own knowledge of materia medica to prescribe a single remedy. There is no 'test' to work out your remedy, there is only hard work and skill.

Homoeopaths do not prescribe a medicine 9 times in a day. This breaks the Law of the Minimum Dose, and in fact is a very dangerous practice. Overdosing in this way is very likely to palliate or suppress your condition. A properly prescribed medicine improves or cures your problem with only a few doses, and does not need daily repetition.

Palliation requires you to continually take the medicine, and when you stop the condition again worsens. This is the opposite effect from a homoeopathically prescribed medicine, which initially worsens the condition then improves it, with the improvement remaining without repeated dosing.

Suppression often occurs when palliation has gone on for awhile. The patient will develop new symptoms, a new disease, very often worse than the original one. Suppression can make a patient much worse, and even kill them.

We have a number of guidelines that help us to determine if a remedy is curing the patient or just palliating/suppressing the disease. Primarily we look at the Direction of Cure (the way in which the symptoms move around after the remedy, which improves and which worsens). Understanding the hierarchy of the body/mind helps with this, as does a detailed history of the patient (since symptoms can reappear from the past, or disappear in reverse order of how they appeared).

If by some remarkable chance you have stumbled on your constitutional remedy in that mixture, then it may produce genuine improvement. However this means the other 3 are wrong for you, and in time they will produce side effects. Since you don't know which remedy is helping you, there is no way to move up in potency to continue the cure. You cannot simply keep taking higher and higher doses of incorrect remedies without putting your health at risk.

It would be better for you to get each remedy individually and try them one at a time. This approach will allow you to work out a long term treatment plan. You should also be taking single doses only, with assessment taking place roughly a week after the dose. Repetition should only happen when the symptoms relapse.
brisbanehomoeopath last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.