≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Remedies:

Silicea: $6.59First Aid Kit: $180.00

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

can you give silica to someone with a rod in their back?

Hey,

Homeopaths. I have a question about silica. I know that you are not supposed to give it in high potencies if the person has some piece of metal in their body, correct?

Well, I have a friend who I am helping with homeopathy. I repertorized her symptoms and came up with 3 possible choices. One of them was silica. Then later she told me that she is so scattered, and that's what she needs help with he most. I asked her to describe the scattered feeling, and she said it was like shattered glass. Aha! Perfect. Silica it is.

(Plus, she has many of the keynotes: scoliosis, fine bone, etc..) The problem is, I know silicae is perfect for her, but she had such terrible scoliosis, that when she was young, she had surgery and they had to put a bar in her back.

Well, here's my question. Is it safe to give silica to someone with a metal bar in their back? I don't want to make things worse for her. I know not to give 200c, but she is so scattered, and I know that the silica is her remedy. What would happen if I just give LM1 silica? Would that heal her mental/emotional symptoms, and prevent any problems with the rod in her back?

Thank you!
 
  nature_girl on 2013-10-23
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
You can search this thru the forum
search box - and here is another link on this http://www.homeopathyworldcommunity.com
put is silicea safe with implants in
the search the site box and a discussion
will come up.
[message edited by simone717 on Wed, 23 Oct 2013 06:27:21 BST]
 
simone717 last decade
Yes, I know I can search through the forum. I am well versed with this forum. I was asking for an opinion, and I wanted an opinion on this case.

You know, the last time I posted a question on here, you told me to stop asking opinions and to go see a medical doctor. And now you're telling me to go search the forum.

If you don't have an answer, or an opinion on the case, please stop answering my posts with things like 'go see a doctor' or 'go search the forum.' It's just not helpful.
[message edited by nature_girl on Wed, 23 Oct 2013 06:34:14 BST]
 
nature_girl last decade
Hi,

There was a past interesting discussion on this on the forum that
I had read awhile back, with Kadwa saying it is ok bc this is not
a foreign body in the tissue. There was another 'real homeopath'
or 2 in that discussion. I was looking for that link to put in for you
but it was not showing up for me when I searched for it. The other
discussion on the Homeopathic world community is all by real homeopaths with a practice and they agree
with Kadwa.

Sorry if I irritated you on your other post, I was not trying to say
you should not get an opinion on here, just that you might get a
more accurate one if things were ruled out by the doctor in that
particular issue that you had.

btw, the only real homeopaths on here often right now,who actually have a practice
are Dr. Mohla, Dr. Mahfooz, Parakletos, Dr. Showrav, and Dr.
Deoshlok Sharma ( who is rarely on)

Hope you are able to help your friend.
[message edited by simone717 on Wed, 23 Oct 2013 08:12:39 BST]
 
simone717 last decade
Dear
I have read your statement and come to the conclusion that you want to take her silicia inLM potency on her mental symptoms and not on physical symptoms whereas the paitent is suffering from physical. Please avoid to give her silicia and see the second choice or give her detail symptom so that we may consider her case.


dr. mahfooz
 
Mahfoozurrehman last decade
No homeopath 'real' or 'unreal' will ever tell you to give Sil when there are any implants in the body since the body doesn't know the difference between wanted & un-wanted foreign bodies.

Especially knowing that carefully chosen remedies are very difficult if not almost impossible to antidote.

My advise, DON'T even think about Sil if there are any implants.

You may start learning about the dark side of homeopathy first hand if you embark on this journey.
 
fitness last decade
Sorry Fitness, but that is not true according to the
discussions of homeopaths with real patients in clinic,
if you read the Homeopathy World Community discussion,
you can see that Gina Tyler, a well known Los Angeles
homeopath has had hundreds of -hollywood type
patients, who have teeth implants, breast implants,
and probably a lot of plastic surgery implants and
none of her patients ever had a problem with silicea.
[message edited by simone717 on Wed, 23 Oct 2013 16:27:57 BST]
 
simone717 last decade
Thanks. Definitely news for me. I will try to read about this.

You live & you learn!
 
fitness last decade
Yes, I was of the same opinion as you and even reading
those discussions about real patients, it seems that when
the body has accepted some of these 'things' the silicea
will not try to dislodge them.

However, I would not want to take the risk of doing this.
 
simone717 last decade
I'd agree. Having read the classic literature, I'd not give Sil to a patient who has any implants.

Better be safe than sorry.
 
fitness last decade
I have to agree with 'fitness'. I have personally seen a case where a normally functioning 'shunt' in a severe case of congenital hydrocephalus was rendered non-functional once Silica was given. And, this was after years of flawless functioning of the 'shunt' where one would think the body had 'accepted' it as a normal pathway.

In my mind, Silica should not be given when there are foreign bodies inside the organism which are essential to the functioning.
[message edited by sameervermani on Thu, 24 Oct 2013 20:29:54 BST]
 
sameervermani last decade
Yes, I agree, and what also came to mind here is the women
who have IUD coils put in. These are of course, not good for
you, many people have terrible problems with cramps( the body trying to get rid of the coil on its own) hair fall,
and migration of the coil cutting something and somehow
do not associate the coil with these things.

The coils are not a 'permanent fixture' but I thought
this could be a big problem with taking silicea and having
cramping and migration of the coil.
 
simone717 last decade
Probably this is an example of no matter who vouches for it, your own senses raise a big alarm to steer clear!
 
fitness last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.