≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum




Hepar Sulphuris Calcareum: $3.99Professional Constitutional Kit #2: $160.00First Aid Kit: $160.00


The ABC Homeopathy Forum

How many days need to start working Hepar Sulphur 1M and 10M?

When anybody take 3 dose HS-1M by 3 days gap between each dose, or take 3 dose HS-10M by 3 days gap between each days, action will take place after how many days of last dose in case of Asthma patients?
  riyad202 on 2013-10-29
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
If the remedy is right, you will most likely have a severe reaction (aggravation) by such drastic dosing method.

If the remedy is wrong and you are lucky, probably nothing otherwise you may get proving symptoms.

Certainly this dosing is not given by a homeopath !
fitness 8 years ago
Dear Fitness,
Thanks for your reply. This remedy was given by a qualified well stablished homeopath in Dhaka.

For prevention and control cold allergy, sinus and asthma, doctor was given to my child 3 dose HS-1M by 3 days gap between each dose. After 7 days of last dose, my child fall into asthma. Was this problem caused by this medicine?

Similarly, doctor was given to my wife 3 dose HS-10M by 3 days gap between each dose. After one moth of last dose, my wife experience breathing problem. Have this condition caused by this medicine?

Now doctor has given 3 dose HS-10M to my child by 7 days gap between each dose. Should I give it to my child?

Actually I'm not sure about my past experience whether it was happened by this remedy or not. Because, I do not know the actual action time and proving time of particular remedy for particular potency.

Can you please say, usually proving symptoms start after how many days of how many dose?
riyad202 8 years ago
The duration of action for HS is 40-50 days.

Normally, if the medicine is correct, 3 days after taking the first dose would bring some aggravation and after that there should be continuous relief. It may also bring out some old symptoms which were suppressed.

From your post, it seems that neither your wife nor child had any such problem, however, the medicine was given for prevention only. If this is the case and HS has brought asthma, then they are more likely proving the HS.

It is always advised to start treatment with a medium potency which is 200.

If you require further information, please write me.

mani_jee 8 years ago
From what you have told, that homeopath is helping people ruin their health.

STOP his prescription right away.

Find a homeopath who works:

After taking full case history by asking at least below questions
Gives single remedies
Gives not more than a single dose if above 200c potency

1. Your age & sex

2. Describe your appearance i.e. weight, height, body type

3. What are the symptoms of your main health problem

4. How & when did this main problem begin

5. What makes the main problem better and what makes it worse

6. What other health problems do you have

7. How do you feel emotionally

8. Describe your personality

9. How do you relax

10. Do you normally fight or flight

11. What are you afraid of (situations, animals etc)

12. What occupies your mind mostly

13. How do you respond to consolation & sympathy

14. Do you want to stay alone or with people

15. How is your sleep

16. Do you have any recurring dreams

17. What type of weather do you like and how it affects your complaints

18. Do you normally feel hot or cold

19. What types of clothes you wear

20. What foods you love & hate

21. What taste you love & hate (sweet, salty, sour, bitter)

22. Do you want to eat indigestible foods (chalk, mud….)

23. How is your thirst

24. Do you have dry lips & mouth

25. Any coating on tongue first thing in the morning

26. How is your skin

27. Details about your sweat (perspiration)

28. Any problems with ears, nose, chest, throat

29. How is your stool & urine

30. How is your sexual life & desire

31. Males genitals (erection, pain etc.)

32. Females menses details for regularity, flow, clots, discharge other than menses

33. What illnesses are running in your family, mother’s side & father’s side & brothers/sisters
fitness 8 years ago
Thanks both of you for your reply. Sinus, Allergy, Cold and Breathing Problems was old problem of my wife and child; Not actually newly brought by HS. But when HS was given, condition was not acute. Usually doctor use Bryon, CV, ANTIM TART etc. in acute condition to cure cough and breathing problem. It seems that, HS is given when mentionable symptoms are not present.

Now I am not sure, the conditions occured after taking HS was actually by this remedy, or by any other cause or any other remedy.
riyad202 8 years ago
Sorry, I had a little mistake. I have check my prescription again and see, my child was given HS-1M daily dose, not dose between 3 day gap. And breathing problem was occured after 11 days of last dose, not after 7 days.

Now I want to be sure that, if any child take 2 dose HS-1M within 24 hours, is it possible to get proving symptoms after 10 days?
riyad202 8 years ago
As stated by you that sinus and allergy & breathing problems were old problems, then it is likely that HS is bringing out the old issues to re-appear.

Advise - Do not repeat the remedy,let it complete its 'Duration of Action' which is 40-50 days.

mani_jee 8 years ago
HS-1M was given to my child 10 months ago. So now no issue of 'Duration of Action'. Now it has prescribed again in 10M potency. Should I start?
[message edited by riyad202 on Thu, 31 Oct 2013 11:54:10 GMT]
riyad202 8 years ago
Then its fine. You may give it in 10m, but only 1 dose, dont repeat with 3 days gap.

mani_jee 8 years ago
Thanks for your reply.

Now in order to clear the matter, I need to know two short question:

1. How many days need to start proving symptoms after completing 3 dose HS-1M daily dose?

2. How many days need to start proving symptoms after completing 3 dose HS-10M half weekly dose?

If I get answer of above two question, then I can take final decision.
riyad202 8 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.