ABC Homeopathy Forum


The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Always thinking of past girlfriend

Hi all, I am 32 years old now. I suffer chronic fatigue syndrome and depression. When I was 17 I broke up with my girlfriend of 2 years. I did not cry about it, but rather became closed off emotionally from women for years. When I started relationships again, I chose women who were not emotionally available.

Whenever I do deep healing ceremonies like shamanic work or deep hypnotherapy, or even emotional detoxifying yoga, the same thing keeps happening. I keep crying about this girl I broke up with when I was 17. I actually enjoy it, it makes me feel alive, and it brings about a sentimental sadness that I like to live in for a while.

I dream about her a few times a week for years now, and whenever I try to talk to her I am never able to get to the point where I bring up anything important about the feelings I have.

It feels like I am still suffering deeply over the loss of a girl who I was deeply in love with. It is at the point where I can almost not feel love for anything anymore. It is as if my heart is closed off from all love, even the love of God. The only thing that makes me feel alive is the sentimental sadness I get when I think deeply about the girlfriend I had and I weep a little.

I have been to an expert homeopath who has prescribed many remedies, but we never went beyond 30c. I was prescribed Nat Mur at 30c with no reaction. I would think this is a 100% Nat Mur case from all the readings, but something also tells me this could possibly be an Aurum case too, with how deep and long my depression has been, over 10 years and I am only 32. The depression did reach suicidal levels, but I have been on medication for it and the deep depression went away.

I guess I am kind of hoping someone tells me to try a higher potency of Nat Mur, or try Aurum 30c. Maybe this is a really easy case. I did not communicate my suffering so well with my homeopath because I did not see the theme running through my life as well as I do now. Thanks for reading.
  LifeisMagic on 2019-04-22
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
To sum up in a shorter way:
I want my heart to open up to love again. I feel no love when I pet my dog. I feel no love when I hug my parents or my brother. The only time I feel a bit of feelings in my heart is when I am alone and cry deeply to a movie or music, or thinking about my past or my ex girlfriend (music can bring up these thoughts). I feel if my heart could just be open to receiving love again my body and mind would be healed.
[Edited by LifeisMagic on 2019-04-22 20:57:33]
LifeisMagic 10 months ago

You know a lot more than most people on here.

I thought I remembered you and clicked your name.

You were studying Herscu method( which I don’t
Agree with) going to work with Philip Bailey
Who has a popular “personality” remedy book
Based on only his patients( widely panned by

You had a lot of concussions - your case as you know
Is very complicated. You are trying to diagnose
The remedies needed now and that is very difficult.

My advice is contact/ Mary Aspinwall , homeopath
In Santa Barbara ,ca by phone. She does phone
Consults- she is a homeopathic teacher and decades
Of practice- very successful healer. Let her retake
Your case.
[Edited by simone717 on 2019-04-22 22:12:47]
simone717 10 months ago
Wow Simone, I can't believe you remembered me! Amazing memory. Thank you so much for taking your time for replying. I don't think I can do a phone consult with Aspinwall, as I do not have the money right now. I may be receiving money in the future, but for now I am poor :(
LifeisMagic 10 months ago
Well, no harm in asking her if she can do a payment plan?
You need someone of that experience level.

Unfortunately, the forum has no homeopaths
Or really experienced prescribers on here for some time.
Your entire case history, physical history, all drugs,
All meds and homeo meds and results have to be
Included. Nothing left out.

The only homeopath is Reva, who does
His own way of using herbs, foods, remedies
Etc to cleanse and strengthen the system first
(Usually) so he is not going to get into discussions
About remedies like you had with Brisbane homepath(evocationer)

You could click Reva’s name and email him to see
If he has the time on here and read his threads
After clicking to get a sense of how he works.

Always click user names on here and read past
Threads of people you talk to.

Best wishes,

[Edited by simone717 on 2019-04-22 23:12:35]
simone717 10 months ago
Also, you could go over to the hpathy site.
I find that site overcomplicated and it used to be that
Some very good homeopaths will prescribe from
That site- all prescriptions have to be vetted by
Mannish Bhatia the site owner. Homeopaths
Have to show him the basis for their prescription,
So it was not done that often.

I do not know what they are doing now but you
Could probably write to Dr Bhatia if you cannot
Figure it out. At least it is free.
simone717 10 months ago
Ah, I did not know that there was no more homeopaths on this forum. I can see it being extremely difficult to prescribe through text. I may try the hpathy site, thanks for your response Simone.
LifeisMagic 10 months ago
On hpathy- a frequent contributor is “snoopy”
Her name is elaine( forgot last name) but she
Does list the complete name often on there.

She does treat for free- perhaps by phone or
Skype. She works in a layer by layer fashion-
Her mentor is dr robin murphy( famous) Aussie
Naturopath and homeopath. She is quite well known
And friends with Brisbane homeopath.
simone717 10 months ago
Lewis is Elaine's last name, this is her website.


I believe her preference is consultation via email but that may have changed. I don't know if she does treatments for free anymore but you won't know unless you contact her.

As far as the Hpathy Discussion Forum it does not look very active anymore.


but their website and facebook page seem to be a major hub for homeopathy now.

Anyway all the best LifeisMagic in finding an answer to your health issues.

JS123 10 months ago
Thank you JS 123. Elaine used to say she would
Do free consults for those who cannot afford-
Or a sliding scale. Of course it makes sense to
Ask what her policy is now.

It is too bad that discussion site does not work
Well- and there was a prescription part - sometimes
I could find it and sometimes not. They kept redesigning
simone717 10 months ago
Thank you JS, I may try to contact Elaine.
LifeisMagic 10 months ago
Yeah just checked Elaine, she costs over $300, so I can't do it now. My frustration with homeopathy was that I have had so many complicated things in my past that the 3 homeopaths that I saw over a 4 year period focused so much on that past stuff, instead of what my current state is like. I never really got to tell them about my core feeling, which I stated above, is that its extremely hard to feel emotions in my heart.
LifeisMagic 10 months ago

I contacted Elaine about 3 years ago hoping she might be able to recommend a homeopath near where I live because I no longer feel well enough to travel. She was not able to but offered to help me via email. After careful consideration I decided not to take her up on her offer as I do not like to write and I believe a face to face consultation with a homeopath is best for me.

The reason I contacted Elaine is I had had a few discussions with her several years earlier on another homeopathy discussion forum and I liked her approach to homeopathic treatment. Over the years I have worked with a few homeopaths but none of them have been able to help me. In fact the first homeopath I consulted who started me on high potency remedies left me far worse off then before I started the treatment. For this reason I am very cautious when it comes to homeopathy.

For some reason I have not given up on homeopathy but one day I may. I am currently working with a homeopath I worked with before but so far I have not experienced any positive results.

I figure it can't hurt to contact Elaine to see if she might be a good fit but if not there must be other options for you.

All the best.

JS123 10 months ago

In the past you have worked with David Kempson. I have read some of his posts not only on this forum but others. Based on what I have read I consider him to be a very knowledgeable homeopath. I would like to know what Simone thinks about his skills as a homeopath. If she agrees with my beliefs on his skill level maybe he would be willing to try to help you again if you are willing.

JS123 10 months ago

I don't know why the Hpathy discussion forum is no longer active but the website certainly has interesting information. Their Facebook Public Group is a very active site if you are not aware of it.

In addition one day I may ask you if you know of a homeopath near where I live who may be able to help me but for now I will continue to work with a homeopath I have worked with on and off for several years.

JS123 10 months ago
Hi JS123,

David Kempson left the forum some years ago.
I had heard ( do not know if this is true) that he is no longer with us.
I tried to find out more information at the time,
But could not.

I am happy to help you with any request.Thanks for
The fb info on hpathy- I did not know about it.
[Edited by simone717 on 2019-04-23 07:17:35]
simone717 10 months ago
For JS123:

Since you cannot travel and do not want email
Consults, I want to give you a couple female
Homeopaths, who do their consulting on the phone.

One is Lia Bello, head of nurse homeopathic association.
I used to have her phone number, but you can email
Her about consult and indicate you want the phone
Interview. I have suggested her to people on the
Forum who were in emergency situations and
She was treating acutes with follow up for $50.
These were situations where not just homeopathic
But good allopathic experience was needed-
And she could give good advice because of her nursing
Career. People found her very easy to talk to
And had excellent outcomes. Last time I
Suggested her was some years ago and she
Was taking a year off. You can google her-

The other person is Mary Aspinwall, Santa Barbara-
She also does consults by phone besides in person.

I wanted you to know you are not limited to email.

simone717 10 months ago

Unless someone has assumed his identity David Kempson has resumed his practice in Brisbane and presence on the internet. I realize that he was dealing with some serious issues including a severe automobile accident. I believe it was Joe De Livera that referred to him as the "late David Kempson" which also made me believe that "he is no longer with us" but about a year ago I did a search on the internet and found his website and facebook page. Since that time I have also found other posting made by him and interviews.

I exchanged a few brief emails with him in which he offered to help me or at least give me some advice but due to my dislike of writing I never completed my story and therefore never followed up fully. I now believe it is too late to bother him again but there really is no point considering I still have to finish writing that story of mine.

I do not have any formal homeopathic training but I do consider David's posts on the internet to be of great value. He always offered great guidance, advice, help and never hesitated in pointing out improper and dangerous homeopathic methods and prescribing. I know this got him into some heated discussions but most people respect his advice. I also realize he prefers to treat people in person as consultation via the internet limited his ability to take a case properly especially in difficult cases. I have proven to be a difficult case and therefore prefer the face to face in person consultation. Even consultation via internet video chat has it's limitations.

I appreciate you referring me to Lia Bello and Mary Aspinwall and I may consider them if I cannot find what I consider a suitable homeopath to meet with in person. I have not given up on the homeopath who is currently trying to help me and I do live in a city with a number of homeopaths not only trained in North America but also from other parts of the world. So there may be someone where I live that may be able to help me.

I believe you said you were thinking of leaving this forum because of all the flak that is going on. I hope you decide to stay. Someone needs to be on the forum to do what they can to keep things in order and protect the unsuspecting from potentially dangerous advice.

All the best,

JS123 9 months ago
Hi JS123,

Thank you for writing, and I am certainly glad to hear that news
About David. Joe had emailed me that wrong information, but I
Never found any verification of it.

I do hope you can find the right person to help
You. Thanks for the kind words.

Best wishes,

simone717 9 months ago

From what I had read Joe and David never got along and they had a long ongoing dispute. David's Facebook page is easy to find but not his website. He is currently working out of West End Wellness in Brisbane where there is a link to his website.

Anyway it is time I stop hogging LifeisMagic's thread.

Take care,

JS123 9 months ago
Glad to hear Kempson is doing well, he was very polite and gave a lot of himself.

To JSE and all those who homeopathy has not worked for, I was in such a deep hole before homeopathy. My brain was so messed up from concussions that I could not even make eye contact with people without losing my thinking for 30 seconds. I had no ability to connect with others. Then I was prescribed Arnica 200c and after an intense 24 hour healing crisis my brain changed. I am now much better off cognitively, and can also look people in the eyes, and sometimes make emotional connections. I am only 50% better, looking to get 100%.

So just saying, it is like a gift from God to get the right homeopathic.
LifeisMagic 9 months ago
Dear Life is Magic,

Another suggestion:

You could write to jiteshsharma2007 at gmail.
He and his father do classical prescribing,
Are very busy with their homeopathic hospital
In India. They are rarely on here due to time
Constraints. You can list your thread title and user
Name.. get his opinion.

In order to get accurate opinion:
Give your history up to now -
Give medical history up to now-
List all homeo and allopathic meds taken.
And anything being taken now.
Put attachments of scans and mri in the mail.

My feeling is you have to have an experienced
Person take a new look.
simone717 9 months ago

I am glad to hear that you have benefited from homeopathy. Hopefully you will be 100% soon. For me your comment on your experience with homeopathy is encouraging.

Thank you,

JS123 9 months ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.