The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Nothing "working" - Chronic mental health and physical tension
Hello,What can be done if homeopathy doesn't seem to "work" for you or your family? I have had trouble with anxiety and depression, along with "brain fog" and self-esteem issues for decades. I understand this isn't an overnight fix. However, I have tried many different remedies (20+) in 30c potency, and I haven't noticed a response (positive or negative) to any of them. I find it odd that so many can get a benefit from a huge spectrum of issues (acute and chronic) and others seem to derive no benefit. My family has noticed the same, as we have a 36 remedy Helios kit and have tried it for many first aid issues without noticing much if anything.
Is there anything that can be done to "clear the way" for homeopathy to work in someone that hasn't noticed anything from it? I have seen a licensed homeopath and I didn't notice anything under their treatment either.
Oiviorv on 2023-02-16
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
The Success of the prescription depends largely upon your ability to describe your symptoms. Let modesty not prevent a full statement.
Give details. Check QUESTIONNAIRES available in the forum. Also pen down the remedies and potencies you have taken.
Give details. Check QUESTIONNAIRES available in the forum. Also pen down the remedies and potencies you have taken.
♡ anuj srivastava 3 months ago
Thanks for your response. At this point I am not seeking the correct remedy. I have already worked with two competent homeopaths, and I am confident in their ability to prescribe. I gave both very detailed symptom profiles. I am simply asking if there are any protocols to apply when homeopathy as a system doesn't seem to be working?
Oiviorv 3 months ago
None.
In homoeopathy individualization is important.. The medicine for your complaint is exclusively selected depending on symptoms.. so either you have not elaborated symptoms properly or physician didn't select medicine properly.... There is no other reason for homoeopathic medicines to not act.
[Edited by anuj srivastava on 2023-02-16 11:39:27]
In homoeopathy individualization is important.. The medicine for your complaint is exclusively selected depending on symptoms.. so either you have not elaborated symptoms properly or physician didn't select medicine properly.... There is no other reason for homoeopathic medicines to not act.
[Edited by anuj srivastava on 2023-02-16 11:39:27]
♡ anuj srivastava 3 months ago
OK. I appreciate your feedback. I don't think its comprehensive though.
As mentioned previously, none of the remedies in 30c potency seem to have any affect (positive or otherwise) on my family or I. I have also tried my potencies in the 3c to 9c range for more acute type symptoms, and I haven't noticed anything from them either. Same goes for my family. I do understand that a constitutional remedy is very specific to the individual, but I am wondering why some of the lower potencies (which should help with more general symptomology, regardless of constitution) seem to make a big difference for some, but have no affect on others.
As mentioned previously, none of the remedies in 30c potency seem to have any affect (positive or otherwise) on my family or I. I have also tried my potencies in the 3c to 9c range for more acute type symptoms, and I haven't noticed anything from them either. Same goes for my family. I do understand that a constitutional remedy is very specific to the individual, but I am wondering why some of the lower potencies (which should help with more general symptomology, regardless of constitution) seem to make a big difference for some, but have no affect on others.
Oiviorv 3 months ago
I find it really strange that none of your homeopathy kit has no effect on any of your family … ever. Is this a boiron kit? Or where / who made it?
Also if you do purchase other remedies where are you buying them?
In homeopathy there is something called - a block to the cure. This can be some undiagnosed underlying problem, or it can be something like taking Western meds or herbs or supplements or antidepressants that do not allow the homeopathic remedy to work. Also, situations like war, ongoing abuse, bad work environment etc-you have to get out of the situation to get cured from trauma.
If the remedy is a good match-even if low potency(under 30c) there should be some type of even small reaction-unless the remedy does not fit.
[Edited by simone717 on 2023-02-17 02:39:18]
Also if you do purchase other remedies where are you buying them?
In homeopathy there is something called - a block to the cure. This can be some undiagnosed underlying problem, or it can be something like taking Western meds or herbs or supplements or antidepressants that do not allow the homeopathic remedy to work. Also, situations like war, ongoing abuse, bad work environment etc-you have to get out of the situation to get cured from trauma.
If the remedy is a good match-even if low potency(under 30c) there should be some type of even small reaction-unless the remedy does not fit.
[Edited by simone717 on 2023-02-17 02:39:18]
♡ simone717 3 months ago
Oiviorv
What do you need clarification OR cure
If u need cure
Narrate ur symptoms
Before you started homeopathy treatment
The treatment u took
Symptoms now
You can learn once u see changes in yourself
What do you need clarification OR cure
If u need cure
Narrate ur symptoms
Before you started homeopathy treatment
The treatment u took
Symptoms now
You can learn once u see changes in yourself
♡ Kaps 3 months ago
Thanks for your response. My 36 remedy 30c kit is from Helios. I get most of my remedies from Boiron (thru Amazon), but I have tried a few from Washington Homeopathic, as well.
I am currently working at home for myself. I can't think of any outside circumstances that I could say are blocking a healing response.
I am currently working at home for myself. I can't think of any outside circumstances that I could say are blocking a healing response.
Oiviorv 3 months ago
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.