The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Dr.Luc's article on pseudo-homeopathy Page 6 of 6
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Ofcourse.
He helped the Tsunami victims by coming all the way to Srilanka.
He may not be able to help individuals, but when a calamity hits, we can count on his support.
In fact he advised the remedies for this year's flu epidemic in U.S.A. on his forums.
Perhaps you are not aware of his forums where even a common man like me is answered promptly.
http://www.minimum.com/bb/viewforum.php?f=37&sid=e951824...
He is the most approachable person among the celebreties, and the only one among them to come forward to help the Tsunami victims.
Murthy
He helped the Tsunami victims by coming all the way to Srilanka.
He may not be able to help individuals, but when a calamity hits, we can count on his support.
In fact he advised the remedies for this year's flu epidemic in U.S.A. on his forums.
Perhaps you are not aware of his forums where even a common man like me is answered promptly.
http://www.minimum.com/bb/viewforum.php?f=37&sid=e951824...
He is the most approachable person among the celebreties, and the only one among them to come forward to help the Tsunami victims.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Well Gavini, I admit you are right. May be we both (me and you) should post our ailments there. I mean reaction and amusement and stuff.
♡ girilal last decade
It is very likely that Dr Luc would consider Mr. Murthy a pseudo-homeopath.
According to Dr. Luc, several hours of case taking would define true homeopathy and I'm afraid that Mr. Murthy's prescribing at this site would also fall under his definition of pseudo- homeopath.
Dr. Luc most likely considers only a college educated person at a college of his liking to be considered a non pseudo-homeopath.
Why do you post information that is detriminal to anyone including yourself?
This post is either going to cause people to avoid homeopathy as it is too much trouble or to pretend to agree with it in order to get your help.
Others will ignore it completely.
This post is not going to have any profound affect on anyone in a positive way.
According to Dr. Luc, several hours of case taking would define true homeopathy and I'm afraid that Mr. Murthy's prescribing at this site would also fall under his definition of pseudo- homeopath.
Dr. Luc most likely considers only a college educated person at a college of his liking to be considered a non pseudo-homeopath.
Why do you post information that is detriminal to anyone including yourself?
This post is either going to cause people to avoid homeopathy as it is too much trouble or to pretend to agree with it in order to get your help.
Others will ignore it completely.
This post is not going to have any profound affect on anyone in a positive way.
allergic last decade
Hi allergic
Your comments show that you don't know the difference between acute and chronic prescribing.
The problem is that people make loose comments without reading Dr.Luc's books.
Homeopathic medicines can sometimes be prescribed even without asking a single question, just by observing the patient.
Some times we need to ask about the location, sensation, modality and concomitant aspects alone and can prescribe based on that information alone.
Some times we need to take a complete case, before prescribing.
There are so many case taking techniques. Which one to be used when, depends on the nature of the complaint, the pain aspect, and the chronicity of the complaint along with many other factors.
However, the fundamental principle of
Similar medicine
Single medicine
Minimum dose
is to be adhered to whatever may be the method you choose for case taking.
For your information Dr.Luc knows about me , and considers me a good homeopath. :-)
No informaion is detrimental. People won't believe any thing blindly. So, let them understand the pros and cons and decide what is best for them.
Even if 10% of the seekers understand and refrain from following the poly pharmacy, alternations, complex homeopathy, unnecessary repetetions, I feel the purpose of this thread is more than served.
In fact I have proof that many seekers understood the dangers of poly pharmacy after reading this thread and said so many times on this forum itself.
There are many cases still suffering from the effects
of this senseless poly prescribing again on this forum itself.
It is not scaring away people. It is enlightening them.
Won't we prevent a person who is going to take poision unknowingly?
Murthy
Your comments show that you don't know the difference between acute and chronic prescribing.
The problem is that people make loose comments without reading Dr.Luc's books.
Homeopathic medicines can sometimes be prescribed even without asking a single question, just by observing the patient.
Some times we need to ask about the location, sensation, modality and concomitant aspects alone and can prescribe based on that information alone.
Some times we need to take a complete case, before prescribing.
There are so many case taking techniques. Which one to be used when, depends on the nature of the complaint, the pain aspect, and the chronicity of the complaint along with many other factors.
However, the fundamental principle of
Similar medicine
Single medicine
Minimum dose
is to be adhered to whatever may be the method you choose for case taking.
For your information Dr.Luc knows about me , and considers me a good homeopath. :-)
No informaion is detrimental. People won't believe any thing blindly. So, let them understand the pros and cons and decide what is best for them.
Even if 10% of the seekers understand and refrain from following the poly pharmacy, alternations, complex homeopathy, unnecessary repetetions, I feel the purpose of this thread is more than served.
In fact I have proof that many seekers understood the dangers of poly pharmacy after reading this thread and said so many times on this forum itself.
There are many cases still suffering from the effects
of this senseless poly prescribing again on this forum itself.
It is not scaring away people. It is enlightening them.
Won't we prevent a person who is going to take poision unknowingly?
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
poly pharmacy is just a way to take business away from mainstream pharmacy.
I doubt this thread is having any significant affect on anyone.
I doubt this thread is having any significant affect on anyone.
allergic last decade
I doubt it very much if Dr. Luc would be supportive to you being a prescriber over the internet in the manner in which you are doing it here.
He would even co as far as calling it crimminal.
Have Dr. Luc give you an endorsement here if he approves of the manner in which you are prescring her. . He can also add your name to his websites as you being someone who he approves of.
He would even co as far as calling it crimminal.
Have Dr. Luc give you an endorsement here if he approves of the manner in which you are prescring her. . He can also add your name to his websites as you being someone who he approves of.
allergic last decade
I am not really interested in anybody's endorsement, but since you rised the issue, let me clarify.
Read this discussion I had with Dr.Luc to know what he thinks of me. There are many more interactions with him, where he approves my methods and way of handling the patients. The above is just a sample.
http://www.minimum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=1215&highlight...
You can have your own views about my methods, but in stead of generalising come to the threads where you find my method objectionable and express your doubts, so as I can clarify to you.
Murthy
Read this discussion I had with Dr.Luc to know what he thinks of me. There are many more interactions with him, where he approves my methods and way of handling the patients. The above is just a sample.
http://www.minimum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=1215&highlight...
You can have your own views about my methods, but in stead of generalising come to the threads where you find my method objectionable and express your doubts, so as I can clarify to you.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Does Dr Luc follow your every move and how do you know his true method of treatment? Do you follow him around 24/7 like he does you?
allergic last decade
He has written very good books that are popular among homeopaths who matter.
if you are interested let me know.
Murthy
if you are interested let me know.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
hello sr
iam from pakistan and iam 21 year old st i have mixed astigmatism in my left eye.so can it be treated by homeopthic if it can be so sr plz tell me the best medicine or eye drops for mixed astigmatism which will be able to improve my eye within months
[message edited by khan4 on Mon, 29 Aug 2016 10:47:55 UTC]
iam from pakistan and iam 21 year old st i have mixed astigmatism in my left eye.so can it be treated by homeopthic if it can be so sr plz tell me the best medicine or eye drops for mixed astigmatism which will be able to improve my eye within months
[message edited by khan4 on Mon, 29 Aug 2016 10:47:55 UTC]
khan4 7 years ago
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.