The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Bad Homeopathic Practice
I sent my cousin to see a homeopath. She prescribed her a remedy and didnt tell her what it was. The remedy has shown positive results. I told her to find out what it is and what potency. She called and the homeopath refused to tell her. She just mentioned that it is from the Geranium Family. Can someone please tell me the remedies that are from the geranium family. So we can try to figure out what the remedy is.Im pis.sed off at this homeopath. I know she doing this so my cousin will keep going back to her and spending more money.
Thanks,
Jay
Jay 15 on 2006-11-03
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Apart from the above 2, there is geranium sanguinem which is less known. These three are used as herbal supplements as well as in homeopathic potency.
Mainly remedies from this genus and family geraniaceae are used as an astringent(constrict tissues opposite to dilator). Therapeutic uses are haemorrhages including pulmonal, acne, swollen breasts, luecorrhoea, kidney affections, jaundice, stomach ulcers.
Mainly remedies from this genus and family geraniaceae are used as an astringent(constrict tissues opposite to dilator). Therapeutic uses are haemorrhages including pulmonal, acne, swollen breasts, luecorrhoea, kidney affections, jaundice, stomach ulcers.
♡ maheeru last decade
She is suffering from panic attacks. Im sure other things were discussed as well. Does this possibly jive with one of these three remedies?
Jay 15 last decade
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
I have to get myself a Materia Medica!!!
Im assuming all three have panic attacks and its a matter of reading through each remedye thouroughlly to find out which one was likely prescribed.
Im assuming all three have panic attacks and its a matter of reading through each remedye thouroughlly to find out which one was likely prescribed.
Jay 15 last decade
Hello Jay15
Geranium Maculatum is more widely known and also the only remedy from this family to be described in Boericke's Materia medica. But this doesn't have strong indication of panic attacks.
But it sometimes is used in troubles of menopause. So there's a chance that it'd have been prescribed for associated menopause troubles.
May be remedy doesn't belong to geranium family as Murthy said above.
Geranium Maculatum is more widely known and also the only remedy from this family to be described in Boericke's Materia medica. But this doesn't have strong indication of panic attacks.
But it sometimes is used in troubles of menopause. So there's a chance that it'd have been prescribed for associated menopause troubles.
May be remedy doesn't belong to geranium family as Murthy said above.
♡ maheeru last decade
Bad homeopathic practice . With positive results?
Unless this dr is over charging, why not let it be ?
Unless this dr is over charging, why not let it be ?
Sycotic last decade
It's a good practice to talk and
discuss openly about the medicine and treatment protocol.
A patient has every right to know what goes in his/her body. Also transparency helps to antidote earlier medicines in case of problem and also for further treatment with another physician.
When this is good practice, the contrary is bad obviously!!!
discuss openly about the medicine and treatment protocol.
A patient has every right to know what goes in his/her body. Also transparency helps to antidote earlier medicines in case of problem and also for further treatment with another physician.
When this is good practice, the contrary is bad obviously!!!
♡ maheeru last decade
Homeopath may have lied about Geramium family to keep you in total dark. People rarely use this remedy.
kuldeep last decade
Sycotic,
Maybe its not a bad practice or unusual practice, to me I just question the reason for not telling even when she was specifically asked what it was. My only thought is that if she does not disclose the remedy, the patient will keep comming back, possibly much longer than she needs to.
Maybe its not a bad practice or unusual practice, to me I just question the reason for not telling even when she was specifically asked what it was. My only thought is that if she does not disclose the remedy, the patient will keep comming back, possibly much longer than she needs to.
Jay 15 last decade
I agree somewhat I have no problem with sharing the remedy and even studing it out with the patient if they wish. Not all homeopaths have the time or take the time or care to do so. You could understand the dilema. Its alot about the time it takes to work with a patient like this , and I could imagine some may not be comfortable with this. Be thankful they took the time to find a good remedy for your friend.
Regards
Ps if they are on an LM potency this does entail more frequent contact at first. If they have been given a c potency they should not really be seen more than once a month even two months , under normal circumstances.
Regards
Ps if they are on an LM potency this does entail more frequent contact at first. If they have been given a c potency they should not really be seen more than once a month even two months , under normal circumstances.
Sycotic last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.