The ABC Homeopathy Forum
How to regain reactivity
Dear All,I have consulted several hom. drs. and all they agreed about my constitutional remedy (Calcarea).-The fact is that even after trying it in dif. potencies and using nosodes in high potency, i dont seem to be getting any reaction at all from the remedies.If anyone has a suggestion about this, please let me know.-
So far I have been given Calcare Carbonica 200, M, 10M, 100M and also Psorinum, Medorrhinum, Luesinum, Tuberculinum, psycotic co.
thank you,
Albert.
♥ Albert on 2007-02-06
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
You must remember what 200C means. A 1C solution is 1 part medicine with 99 parts water. A 2C solution is 1 part medicine and 9,999 parts water. 3C is 999,999 parts water to 1 part medicine. I do not think I need to go any further. I leave you to work out what 200C, M, 10M and 100M means.
It should be obvious from this what the answers to your questions are.
It should be obvious from this what the answers to your questions are.
robot last decade
Hi Robot, thank you for your response.I know what centesimal scale stands for, but my question is about methods to reconquer reactivity when a well choosen remedy seem to have no effect at all,
stay well.
stay well.
♡ Albert last decade
If you know what 200C means you will be able to answer these questions (assume that the solvent is water)
How many grams of Calcarea are there in one Kg of the diluted medicine you were given?
1. What is the difference between water and the medicine?
2. How could you detect the difference?
Before I respond again to anyone, I will need good answers to the above.
If I were a homeopath, I would give you one of these answers to your question
1. It is a deep acting medicine, you need to wait.
2. Take another dose and come back later
3. Let us try another medicine.
How many grams of Calcarea are there in one Kg of the diluted medicine you were given?
1. What is the difference between water and the medicine?
2. How could you detect the difference?
Before I respond again to anyone, I will need good answers to the above.
If I were a homeopath, I would give you one of these answers to your question
1. It is a deep acting medicine, you need to wait.
2. Take another dose and come back later
3. Let us try another medicine.
robot last decade
You have good questions robot.
But what i would like is someone to give me some advices about ways to regain reactivity as the title of my post says.
thank you
But what i would like is someone to give me some advices about ways to regain reactivity as the title of my post says.
thank you
♡ Albert last decade
I think I detect a skeptic, dun dun dun...you can always spot them as they obviously know nothing about the subject.
Albert, have you repeated the Calc since the administration of any of the above nosodes?
Albert, have you repeated the Calc since the administration of any of the above nosodes?
JCS2006 last decade
Hi JCS, yes i did take several doses of (Luesinum)Syphyllinum 10M and then go back to Calcarea....nothing happened with the nosode and nothing after the repetition of Calc..-If you have a suggestion to make, go ahead, thank you for reading,
Albert.
Albert.
♡ Albert last decade
Dear ALbert, it is hardly suprising you had no further effect from the Calc after giving Syphilinum, as this is an anti-syphilitic, as Calc is not even an anti-syphilitic.
You have also been given the other three chronic miasmatic nosodes, and I do not see why. Miamsatic prescribing is not a hit and miss therapy, it is not a question of trying all the nosodes in sequence in the hope of hitting the nail on the head, a proper miasmatic diagnosis needs to be performed before the application of ANY remedies. The nosodes will also not bring about any improvement unless they are indicated to begin with, and just because a miasm is present, this does not automatically mean the nosode is indicated. They have complex drug pictures and etioligies exactly like any other remedies. If the nosodes have not advanced the case for you at all, then they were probably never indicated. If the Calc is no longer providing benefit, then it too is probably no longer indicated. Too many practitioners assign the label of 'constitutional remedy' to the first which provides any benefit for the patient. It has probably simply come to the end of it's benefit, and it is time to retake the case.
Perhaps look at Lycopodium.
-Best wishes.
You have also been given the other three chronic miasmatic nosodes, and I do not see why. Miamsatic prescribing is not a hit and miss therapy, it is not a question of trying all the nosodes in sequence in the hope of hitting the nail on the head, a proper miasmatic diagnosis needs to be performed before the application of ANY remedies. The nosodes will also not bring about any improvement unless they are indicated to begin with, and just because a miasm is present, this does not automatically mean the nosode is indicated. They have complex drug pictures and etioligies exactly like any other remedies. If the nosodes have not advanced the case for you at all, then they were probably never indicated. If the Calc is no longer providing benefit, then it too is probably no longer indicated. Too many practitioners assign the label of 'constitutional remedy' to the first which provides any benefit for the patient. It has probably simply come to the end of it's benefit, and it is time to retake the case.
Perhaps look at Lycopodium.
-Best wishes.
JCS2006 last decade
Thank you for your response.I was wondering if another remedy of the 'carbonicums' family could be related and similar in its action to Calc, e.g. 'Natrum Carbonicum'.-
By the way, i have been given Lyc. in the past with no results....in fact i have been given almost every polichrest in the past 15 years and there were no reaction at all, except for an initial agg. with a dose of Sulphur MM.
thank you for your help,
Albert.
By the way, i have been given Lyc. in the past with no results....in fact i have been given almost every polichrest in the past 15 years and there were no reaction at all, except for an initial agg. with a dose of Sulphur MM.
thank you for your help,
Albert.
♡ Albert last decade
Dear Albert.
In my experience, it does not usually follow that there are too many similarities between remedies of a similar chemical 'family' as it were, but I guess there are usually a few here and there.
I would personally recommend sticking to the more mainstream remedies if your problem is chronic, as these are, unsuprisingly, the most frequently indicated. I realise you have stated the fact you have taken many of them already, but there must be a reason why these have not acted. I would be happy to look into this for you as I enjoy a good challenge, but I do not take full cases etc here on this forum.
-Best wishes.
In my experience, it does not usually follow that there are too many similarities between remedies of a similar chemical 'family' as it were, but I guess there are usually a few here and there.
I would personally recommend sticking to the more mainstream remedies if your problem is chronic, as these are, unsuprisingly, the most frequently indicated. I realise you have stated the fact you have taken many of them already, but there must be a reason why these have not acted. I would be happy to look into this for you as I enjoy a good challenge, but I do not take full cases etc here on this forum.
-Best wishes.
JCS2006 last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.