≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Similar posts:

IT IS GOOD TO KNOW THIS - Homeopathic aggravation 83"Modalities" in homeopathy 5Homeopathy medicinal herb of the day 406Need Homeopathic expert’s opinion “Rectal Fistula” 43The Banerji Protocol - Is it Homeopathy? 57interpreting responses from a homeopathic remedy 25Homeopath tonics 24Homeopathy is not for everyone 1Homeopath doesn't tell the name of remedies! 5Expiration date of homeopathic (Boiron) pills 3

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

looking for homeo help for 9 1/2 yr old son in homeo

Hi- I need help to understand whethere homeopathy can help my son. He has mild asperger symptoms. He is almost 10 and has the following symptoms:
a) finger flapping when excited
b) social issues, not understanding personal space, fails to get social cues, etc..
c) awkward body movement, not very athletic...
d) as far as education is concerned, he is a reluctant reader, lacks comprehension of abstract concepts or implied reasoning in a text.
he has trpuble with multiple step word problems in Math.
e) repeats sentences..its like he is processing them aloud. His vocab is limited.

He is strong in Math, conputing and facts are very good, his body is not very flexible or athletic but over couple yrs, he is very interested in sports ands plays tennis and does fine compared to where he was when he started. He likes to work out as well. He is extremely friendly and loves to talk to everyone, but since he repeats a lot, he does not have many freinds..he tends to lie and show off just to be in good books with friends..he is quite smart that way, over the las one yr he has gone smarter.......he has always been a very nice child, very empathatic, he relates to people a lot, he makes friends with almost everyone he meets, he loves to help and share. He strikes a chord with people. He is also thoughtful, but gets stuck in one part or goes off tangentially in some other direction, that;s why he has attention issues, but its not like he cannot sit down and work by himself for a long time, he does his work himself. He is very organized, likes to keep things organised,certain way but that is in his room, does his homework well, is very focused on tasks when given but if its lecture then he loses attention. He is not very mature in some ways, but very mature in the other, like he is responsible, handles multiple level tasks or chores on his own, etc. He is very loving, loves food, enjoys eating, is well built and tall for his age. He has is mildly asthmatic, had a history of wheezing due to reactive airways, but has no allergies, he was tested thrice but his wheezing is due to his ariways reacting to some infection in the body, so he wheezes when he is sick. He has been a sick child, in that he uesd to get very sick growing up, once every 2 mths and used to be on preventive medicine until i stopped this like 2yrs ago, when we moved out of the US to Asia. All the poreventive medicine were not helping his wheezing, he would get an oral steroid lot sof times when he little for his wheezing since his lungs needs the extra strength, Even now he gets in small dozes but he falls sick 3-4 times a yr like other children..so its not that bad. he has shown dramatic improvement with age as far as health is concerned, change in weather and just exposure to a different country and getting older has helped him here. He still gets siock when catches something from other sick kids and then one time he may wheeze and get treatments on neb and oral steroid but its not as bad as it was when he was growing up....
He is fine with change in plans or schedules, we trael quite a bit and plans always change and he is jiust fine....he seems pretty good as far as anything else is concerned, in fact he is normal in all other ways....he s naughty, funny and smart as well...but is not worldly wise and not mean or selfish at all...he loves to help and enjoys playing with little kids...he has the ability to interact very well with kids..he loves to be the teacher and show other kids what he knows....he loves to show offf.
he understands that he has trouble reading and focus when i talk to him about ut and tell him that he needs to work harder than other kids and he accepts that and is quite a hard worker!

With the above history, can you suggest if there is homeopathy medicine to improve focus, cut down on finger flapping and repeating sentences. Do you think there is something we can give him that can help? Its hard to see him struggle for friendships and at school. Can you please help?
 
  indonesiamom on 2012-02-15
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Unfortunately you have given alot of postive traits here, which are not useful for prescription.

So what we need to do is focus on the negative traits as these are the only real indications of his disease, which is matched by the remedy.

Can you please describe more on these things. It is best to be as verbose as possible, describing your observations and even thoughts about it. If he ever says anything about the symptom or problem, that is of extreme importance.

Finger flapping

Not understanding personal space

Failing to get social cues

Awkard, not athletic

Reluctant reader

Lacks comprehension

Repeats sentences

Limited vocabulary

Not flexible

Gets stuck in one part

Goes off in some other direction

Not very mature
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Thanks for the response. Here are the details.


Finger flapping - He does it when he is excited abous something, when we are done with a discussion and he goes to his room, he is finger flapping. He thinks of something exciting and finger flaps. he tends to stop when he sees us. We tell him to be aware and stop it himself. he told me about a yr ago that his friends a=in school asked him why he does it and one time he even cried a lot asking me 'how come i do it, no one else does it, am not able to stop it, it just comes' etc etc....i told him to tell his friends that its involuntary and that its not in his control, so there is nothing he can do about it. I told him to explain this to anyone who asks about it. And after that he has never cmoplained about anyone teasing him. But he still does it quite a few times. The reason I think its 'cos excitement is that there are hours when I dont see him finger flap, like in the morning when he wake sup, has breakfast, goes to school etc then never have i seen him do it, cos he is busy. Its usually when he is relaxed maybe, over rhe weekends, i have not seen him do it when he is at tennis or maybe just once.

Not understanding personal space: He used to ask perosnal Q to people, there was a time he asked for home numbers, age, and more number related Q...but then not so much now. He used to touch his sister;s hair few yrs ago few time and that stopped. These traits have stopped since. But then there are others, like he is not bashful to ask anything. But i must say that he can keep a secret and that way he shows maturity. am not trying to list positives but explain that none of these symtoms can be applied in totality and he is gradually changing.


Failing to get social cues : When some friend is not interested in him, he still pursues thenm, he will apologize dor something he diod not do, just to be friends. he does not get the fact that they are not intertested. Sometimes he feels agressive, like hoping those kids get hurt, etc, just so they also suffer like he is sufferneing etc. He gets frustated 'cos he is unable to connect, he is not an expert at anything. He gets angry once in a while but understands that he needs friends and changes himself for that, smoetimes he cries at home, rarely at nights when we have our talks telling me about how mean his friends were. Its always in the past, its like he is trying to handle these situations by himself.

Awkard, not athletic- His posture is not very good, he cannot stand straight for long time, He can in the sense its posisble, but he always prefers to lean on soemthing, he sits striaght for long time only 'cso he is doing that to learn vocal music. So its like he can do it, but his body needs support. He takes time to learn a sport, since his legs and arms are not very well coordinated, he tries to do something and cannot do it. In tenis it took lots of time for him to learn to connect, but that was 2 yrs ago and since then he plays well. What am trying to say is that it takes him way longer to learn something, whetehr academic or sport.

Reluctant reader- He does not like big words nor abstract reading. His reading level is good, but comprehension is very poor. he will nto get implied meaning in a text. it has to spelled out well. So he has trouble with reading. he can read well, he reads good books, but he does not like to read, though he does nto accept this. He reads lower levels way better than his level. His comprehension is not to the level that he reads. Long sentences we havr to explain it to him, its like he loses interest in even trying to understand the text, he just reads and moves on w/o understanding.

Lacks comprehension- covered above.

Repeats sentences he tends to do this most, more then finger flapping...its like when he asks me 'when are we going to xyz's plce? i answer' sunday' then he would say 'sunday we are going to their place' he repeats what he hears as though he is processing it. His processing abilities, word processing seems slow and thats also one reason he does not undertstand complicated sentences/text. He repeats 3-4 times several sentences. I have to remind him to astop and then he says' ok ok' and stops.

Limited vocabulary- His poor word decoding, pronounciation and comprehension have lead to limited vocab. He talks in simple sentences, simple but good sentences. He takes time to correct a mistale, like if he says 'so fun' and i correct him to say 'so much fun' then though he corrects it righ then, he continues to say it wrong another day. This is jsut an example.

Not flexible- This is w.r.t the body posture andmovements and the hand-legs coordination. I covered this above in the awkward gait para.

Gets stuck in one part- If we are relating an incident, he goes off ona tangent, like if we were to say we are renting a car to go to this important place, etc...he will ask about hemake of the car, when the issue is not that. if he has thoughts in the middle, he gets lost in those thoughts without listening to the whole conversation.

Goes off in some other direction- same as above. I have to tell him come back to the cnoversation. Smoethies we are dong math and he is trying to underdtasnd something, he will ask me a Q about smoething totally unrelated to Math and am like 'can we come back to the topic' and he says 'ok ok' and then tis fine. But its like he tends to zone off sometimes in his own thoughts.

Not very mature - He still has his child like innocence, I have seen kids who seemt o know much more at his age than he does. It does not sound like problem, maybe this is not one.
 
indonesiamom last decade
What is finger flapping though? What does it look like? What does he actually do?
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Hi

Here is my pennysworth for what it is worth

I will stick my neck out and say yes homeopathy can help ... and the reason I say this is based on my own clinical experience with treating autism, aspergers, ADHD, ADD, etc

However .... it is not something you should be prescibing for via an internet forum

You give your sons history and symptoms very well and this is indeed valuable ... however, you are his Mom ... and you are not objective by definition ... which will obscure the view

You need a homeopath who , as well as take the history from you can meet your son, observe him, speak to him, and watch his behaviours, expressions, etc as well as the lack of these.

The guy who 'invented' homeopathy 200 yrs ago said, even back then, that a full case take would involve taking information from other sources (friends, family, teachers etc) and by observation also .. and in fact he spends much time talking about the skill of observation in a case take.

In addition, even if you happen upon a good remedy for him right now, then there are other factors to consider ... dose, form, frequency of repetition etc ... and this is actually a combination of science and art :)

And even, supposing you get it spot on first time ... its unlikely that will be the end of the story. Sometimes (often actually) the picture changes, and needs to be 'chased' and re-prescribed for over a period of time.

And then there is the issue of the remedy works and then improvement stops or he goes backwards again. You wouldnt know whether to repeat the same remedy / dose, decrease it, stop it, increase it or change it .... and indeed you are not meant to know. Thats what you pay a good homeopath for ... for their years of training, and even many more years of experience :)

I am not trying to be negative as I know homeopathy works .. and aspergers in no exception ... however, to get the best out of it, for the sake of you and your son, go see a homeopath and help him heal.

One final thing ... you mae a very good point about his innocence and immaturity ... this is indeed part of aspergers .... but is it a problem or a pay off ? Again, sometimes objectivity from external sources in the know can help here :)

I wish you and your son well .... and I hope my ramblings help you
 
naturalnurse last decade
Sharon I would like to preface this post by saying I agree whole heartedly with everything you have said, and it is a pleasure to hear someone with a good professional grounding in homoeopathy talk on this forum.

I was actually of the same opinion as you when I first came to this forum. When I watched the unqualified homoeopaths and their methods of dealing with internet cases I spoke up and urged people to see someone face-to-face. Since most of my experience as a homoeopath is in clinical situations I couldn't see how this medium could possibly be successful.

For a variety of reasons I actally chose to attempt to help some people out - people who were unable to get to a homoeopath (not out of choice), or people who cannot afford a homoeopath (as in America where the fees are quite high). Some people were already seeing a homoeopath in person and were either getting terrible results or were actually being harmed by them. There appear to be many 'qualified' homeopaths too who regularly break some of the most basic principles, one of those being the direction to do no harm.

So I began the process of trying to take cases via the written word only. It is difficult, tricky, takes far longer than a consultation in person would, and the patients are far more likely to hide important information from you. Many people simply cannot give you what you need this way (for which they will blame the practitioner and not the method of getting this information). I always advise people here that this is a highly artifical method of case-taking and is much more likely to fail than if you were seeing someone in person.

However, I have had my successes here. Some signficant ones. I certainly fail more often than I do in my own clinic, but understanding the difficulty level of what I do here I have to accept that is the price paid. I have been forced to adapt my case-taking techniques to this medium, and it certainly is possible to get to the right remedy. In many ways the challenge of this medium has actually improved my case-taking in some ways.

Having said that, some of the most important tools are simply useless here, and for this reason I would always prefer someone try to find a good, qualified, experienced practitioner to develop a relationship with. There are people here, especially with mental health problems, that I will urge to find someone in person and not risk this.

But for those I have been able to help, it is still a good thing, a rewarding experience. And a surprising one - I would never have guessed this is possible.

David Kempson
Professional Classical Homoeopath
Dip.Hom.Med.1994
Member Australian Traditional Medicine Society

(since I hate anonymity on a forum like this)
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Thu, 16 Feb 2012 23:22:52 GMT]
 
brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Hi David

Yes I am aware that internet can be used as a medium for treating, and indeed have done so many times myself elsewhere in the past. And like you I have had many successes ... from dying newborn kittens and their mother, through to kids, and adults with all kids of problems.

It does indeed take much longer .... and is harder work and more likely to be unsuccessful but it can work. However, I do still feel one to one is preferable and so I always encourage that .... but, if they will not or cannot, and I feel I can assist, then I will.

What I do find useful is Skype .... or similar .... especially if they have a webcam as you can at least interact better, and get some observation to include in the case analysis.

But like you, I too am wary of the charlatons .... though they are around on the internet and in the 'real' world also and so at the end of the day, everyone has to make their own, hopefully informed, choices - whether in the virtual world or not.

Anyways, nice to meet you. Perhaps we will cross paths on other threads though I probably wont contribute to that many really, as I am extremely busy and dont have alot of time for this sadly at the moment

Take care
Sharon
 
naturalnurse last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.