The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Don't Even Touch Combinations Page 2 of 3
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
"Every thing in allopathy doesn't suppress!" ...can you tell us specifically what does NOT suppress so people can better judge for when it comes to taking allopathic medications.
Thanks, Loree
Thanks, Loree
loree last decade
Hi loree
Allopathic medicines like Aspirin,crocin don't suppress.In fact,when you are taking homeopathic medicines for chronic problem,it is advised by Vithoulkus,not to take another hoemopathic medicine,but take one of these two,in case of minor problems like headache,bodyache etc.
Of course,there is a rider,provided you use them in moderation.
It is my experience also.(Lest Astra will pounce on me,for believing Vitholkus.Hahaha.)
I mostly use a "non camphor" balm for minor headaches.
Murthy
Allopathic medicines like Aspirin,crocin don't suppress.In fact,when you are taking homeopathic medicines for chronic problem,it is advised by Vithoulkus,not to take another hoemopathic medicine,but take one of these two,in case of minor problems like headache,bodyache etc.
Of course,there is a rider,provided you use them in moderation.
It is my experience also.(Lest Astra will pounce on me,for believing Vitholkus.Hahaha.)
I mostly use a "non camphor" balm for minor headaches.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
I found this forum very interesting. I will be checking this more often and will try to put my opinions what i think.
Thanks for nice comments and critical thinking about use of homeopathy-classical homeopathic practice
thanks,
Thanks for nice comments and critical thinking about use of homeopathy-classical homeopathic practice
thanks,
Raj last decade
"Allopathic medicines like Aspirin,crocin don't suppress.In fact,when you are taking homeopathic medicines for chronic problem,it is advised by Vithoulkus,not to take another hoemopathic medicine,but take one of these two,in case of minor problems like headache,bodyache etc."
Interesting! are you saying only for the OCCASIONAL acute issue? say if someone can pin-point the exact cause...say an occasional muscle strain or overwork headache, etc? What is "crocin?" So those are the only two?
I am learning the Hom approach with Intercurrent acute prescribing with chronics (has to be more moderate to severe symptomology, as yes you are interfering with chronic remedy).
For me, if remedies not holding, my next line of defense would be try Herbs, then allopathy.
Thanks Murthy! Loree
Interesting! are you saying only for the OCCASIONAL acute issue? say if someone can pin-point the exact cause...say an occasional muscle strain or overwork headache, etc? What is "crocin?" So those are the only two?
I am learning the Hom approach with Intercurrent acute prescribing with chronics (has to be more moderate to severe symptomology, as yes you are interfering with chronic remedy).
For me, if remedies not holding, my next line of defense would be try Herbs, then allopathy.
Thanks Murthy! Loree
loree last decade
HI new here: I am on Effexor and Klonopin and just started taking a daily supplemlent of "Greens" and also Vit C in big doses and Omega 3. I am just now after 3 days noticiling I have pain inthe liver area and am guessing this is some form of detoxing. I wonder if pain is ok or if perhaps it is not. Any input would be appreciated. Thank you
mjgreen40 last decade
Loree
Crocin is paracetamol.
Even if the cause is known,if the acute problem can be controlled by mild allopathic pain killers,it is better to use them,as they don't interfere with the action of the chronic remedy.
But,for minor problems,if you interfere with a homeopathic remedy,there is a chance of antidoting the previous remedy,and you may have to retake the case afresh,after the acute problem subsides.
I found the following highly useful,in fevers.
I normally allow the fever to run for a day,without any medicine,and based on the symptoms I chooose the medicine,and start giving in plussed water doses,frequently.
Once,I start the homeopathic dosing,I use crocin to give relief to the patient,from headache,bodyache etc.,particularly before going to bed,as then he/she will have better sleep.
I continue with the homeopathic medicine,frequently.I never failed to cure fevers and they get resolved maximum in three days.
I know,many people sneer at this approach,but I find it helps the patient a lot,and helps to reduce the suffering.
Murthy
Crocin is paracetamol.
Even if the cause is known,if the acute problem can be controlled by mild allopathic pain killers,it is better to use them,as they don't interfere with the action of the chronic remedy.
But,for minor problems,if you interfere with a homeopathic remedy,there is a chance of antidoting the previous remedy,and you may have to retake the case afresh,after the acute problem subsides.
I found the following highly useful,in fevers.
I normally allow the fever to run for a day,without any medicine,and based on the symptoms I chooose the medicine,and start giving in plussed water doses,frequently.
Once,I start the homeopathic dosing,I use crocin to give relief to the patient,from headache,bodyache etc.,particularly before going to bed,as then he/she will have better sleep.
I continue with the homeopathic medicine,frequently.I never failed to cure fevers and they get resolved maximum in three days.
I know,many people sneer at this approach,but I find it helps the patient a lot,and helps to reduce the suffering.
Murthy
bandarbabu2000 last decade
Definately interesting. I like Pankja's remark:
Karma Rules!!!
Why the argument? Why are we trying to press our methods on one other as the "only way to go?" People will do what they darn well please.
I give instructions to my clients and they do not listen. Told one woman to use 10 little grains in a glass of water and take by spoonful and she dumped the whole package in the glass, then complained she was out of remedy.
Let's be a little more tolerant and do the best we can for the good of all.
Combinations have been offered and used for 100 years. If one has memorized enough to find "the" single remedy, more power to them.
If Chris is that good, then what does the woman need in the darning needle posting??
Come on, give us some help. Sabra
Karma Rules!!!
Why the argument? Why are we trying to press our methods on one other as the "only way to go?" People will do what they darn well please.
I give instructions to my clients and they do not listen. Told one woman to use 10 little grains in a glass of water and take by spoonful and she dumped the whole package in the glass, then complained she was out of remedy.
Let's be a little more tolerant and do the best we can for the good of all.
Combinations have been offered and used for 100 years. If one has memorized enough to find "the" single remedy, more power to them.
If Chris is that good, then what does the woman need in the darning needle posting??
Come on, give us some help. Sabra
♡ sabra last decade
We had some discussion way back in 2004.
The thread is revived for the benefit of new comers.
Murthy
The thread is revived for the benefit of new comers.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Let people decide for themselves...a lot has been said.
Clinical Data
Statistical Analysis of users ....are lacking all over.
Clinical Data
Statistical Analysis of users ....are lacking all over.
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Essentia Aurea ...is a very useful combination medicine for heart ailments.
Even heart patients who go through By-pass surgery...the allopathic doctors tell them that the life of a By-pass is around 10 years. When those patients (after their By-pass) take Essentia Aurea at regular intervals...in their case the life of the By-pass increases by many more years.
(If 'supression' was taking place in their case...the life of the By-pass would have reduced).
Some people are writing here against Combination meds....I can only say they 'lack experience'.
Pankaj Varma
Even heart patients who go through By-pass surgery...the allopathic doctors tell them that the life of a By-pass is around 10 years. When those patients (after their By-pass) take Essentia Aurea at regular intervals...in their case the life of the By-pass increases by many more years.
(If 'supression' was taking place in their case...the life of the By-pass would have reduced).
Some people are writing here against Combination meds....I can only say they 'lack experience'.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
First of all, the person needed by-pass, because he suppressed some other problems earlier in his life.
(Read 'the theory of suppression' thread)
If he goes for constitutional treatment atleast after by-pass, no more clots will form, and he can live useful life for many years longer.
Instead of doing that, if he wants to use essentia aura, it is nothing but allopathic thinking.
If you suppress the clots formation, by using essentia aura, regularly, you may get a brain stroke, and get paralysis.
These things are observed in many cases.
Murthy
(Read 'the theory of suppression' thread)
If he goes for constitutional treatment atleast after by-pass, no more clots will form, and he can live useful life for many years longer.
Instead of doing that, if he wants to use essentia aura, it is nothing but allopathic thinking.
If you suppress the clots formation, by using essentia aura, regularly, you may get a brain stroke, and get paralysis.
These things are observed in many cases.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Allopathic doctors have confirmed through clinical tests that by taking Essentia Aurea....clots in the blood are dissolved.
Itna bhi knowledge aur experience nahien hai !!!!
If I laugh (he he he..) ...you get blood clot in your heart.
Pankaj Varma
Itna bhi knowledge aur experience nahien hai !!!!
If I laugh (he he he..) ...you get blood clot in your heart.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
May be. But they never attempted to find out what is happening in more important areas.
I have not finished my
'Theory of suppression' thread yet.
I will tell you about the possible problems if you don't treat heart problems properly, but suppress them.
Have a look there, after some time.
mera knowledge kya hai aur tumhara knoweldge kya hai, sub log dekh rahe hai, padh rahe hai..aur record bhi ho rahe hai..future keliye..
Jara soach samajh ke bath karlo, varna paschatovogi.
Murthy
I have not finished my
'Theory of suppression' thread yet.
I will tell you about the possible problems if you don't treat heart problems properly, but suppress them.
Have a look there, after some time.
mera knowledge kya hai aur tumhara knoweldge kya hai, sub log dekh rahe hai, padh rahe hai..aur record bhi ho rahe hai..future keliye..
Jara soach samajh ke bath karlo, varna paschatovogi.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
asimattar last decade
Combination remedies are the last bastion of those who neither understand the founding principles of Homoeopathy, or who are too lazy to take a proper case, and therefore prescribe many remedies at a time hoping to hit the correct one by chance.
They are NOT Homoeopathy.
They are NOT Homoeopathy.
Hahnemania last decade
dear all,if u dont even touch combination ,its up to u . but i do and i will keep on doing it. Because i m doing it since seven years.i will say THANK U COMBINATIONS.I am not a dr but i keep for self help.now i got R2,R3,R5,R6,R9,R18,R25,R40,R42,R 85,PK15,R60,R64,R76,DIACARD,ESSENTIA AREA,BROOKS 5 AND 6,BIOPLASGEN 20,BIO PL 4, THESE ARE few which i used by me and friends,Believe me combination works.and for people like me who got little knowledge but love homeopathy combinations r like gold,though old minded homeopath who know only to walk on line may b right.also thousand people taking these from chemist directly with out consulting any homeopath.believe me lot of combination making labs r making millions. rest to morrow. Please dont mind u asked for information so i provided u .they can perform miracles just like u some time i feel safe with comb than single remedy.
purdaysee last decade
A discussion is to hear all the views. Good to know that, there are atleast a few enthustiasts, who swer by them.
However, it is not homeopathy.
Murthy
However, it is not homeopathy.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
can any body translate this frase into english to murthy , in good english.
oap lukeer kay faqir hain murthy not me.when i need milk and i get milk ,i dont care what murthy call it as long as it is milk.
murthy keep on smilling and stop following hundered years old thoughts,we dont fly spitfire we r going for one better and we will keep on finding easy and new ways.i might agry to forum but not .....u know in asia people use to believe that a bull carrying the world on his one horn ,when move it to other horn we get earth quakes,i dont follow that so i dont follow ur homeopathy. please dont mind ,u asked r opinion.thank u .
oap lukeer kay faqir hain murthy not me.when i need milk and i get milk ,i dont care what murthy call it as long as it is milk.
murthy keep on smilling and stop following hundered years old thoughts,we dont fly spitfire we r going for one better and we will keep on finding easy and new ways.i might agry to forum but not .....u know in asia people use to believe that a bull carrying the world on his one horn ,when move it to other horn we get earth quakes,i dont follow that so i dont follow ur homeopathy. please dont mind ,u asked r opinion.thank u .
purdaysee last decade
Dear purdaysee
It is your will and pleasure. All opinions are welcome.
I am not forcing anybody to subscribe to my way of thinking.
I am just telling about why one should avoid combination medicines, in a logical way.
If you feel, my knowledge is 100 year old, and yours is ultra modern, plese feel free to feel so.
I am not coming in your way.
Thank you, for your opinion.
Murthy
It is your will and pleasure. All opinions are welcome.
I am not forcing anybody to subscribe to my way of thinking.
I am just telling about why one should avoid combination medicines, in a logical way.
If you feel, my knowledge is 100 year old, and yours is ultra modern, plese feel free to feel so.
I am not coming in your way.
Thank you, for your opinion.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
murthy
please no hard feeling. Thanks for sharing knowledge. u keep on ur good work , i had to keep on serviving every way .thanks again,pls.
please no hard feeling. Thanks for sharing knowledge. u keep on ur good work , i had to keep on serviving every way .thanks again,pls.
purdaysee last decade
hi all
well all the comments are fine .single remedy is single remedy no doubt.
but many people using combinations are also satisfied and combinations worked for them alot.i also used combinations alot and got very good results.i only used combinations from dr willmar schwabe and Madaus and co germany .they are really effective and work very well.
now after reading about single remedy i started using single remedy and now will see how single remedy works for me.
but as far as my experience is concerend combinations are not as bad.
i will sujjest that if you really want to use combinations than first go through the materia medica of all the combinations which are used and then match your symptoms,if these symptoms match 80 percent in you than take the combination...
no problemo
otherwise dont
thanks
well all the comments are fine .single remedy is single remedy no doubt.
but many people using combinations are also satisfied and combinations worked for them alot.i also used combinations alot and got very good results.i only used combinations from dr willmar schwabe and Madaus and co germany .they are really effective and work very well.
now after reading about single remedy i started using single remedy and now will see how single remedy works for me.
but as far as my experience is concerend combinations are not as bad.
i will sujjest that if you really want to use combinations than first go through the materia medica of all the combinations which are used and then match your symptoms,if these symptoms match 80 percent in you than take the combination...
no problemo
otherwise dont
thanks
asimattar last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.