≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

 

Remedies:

Boiron Arnicare ®: $11.99

 

 

Similar posts:

Remedy for Pain in Shoulder and Pelvic muscles 3back /shoulder muscles/joint + knee pain + acidity, etc. 24pain in neck and shoulder muscle 101

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

muscle pain right shoulder

years ago I found a remedy in store that specifically targeted pain in shoulders. (in the back of neck and shoulders) it was great! I have tried arnica and bryonia alba, but not very effective. can you tell me what that remedy might be? the stores don't seem to carry it anymore.
Many thanks.
 
  barb.chadha on 2010-11-30
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hello barb chadha

Can you say a bit about what kind of pain you have.

Boring, Tearing, Cutting, Burning, Pulling, Stinging, Shooting, Pressing pain.

And, is there anything that helps the pain? Heat, motion, etc. Or if it's making it worse?

Parakletos
 
Parakletos 9 years ago
this pain is from overuse of my arm. I am a very hard worker and I am scrubbing, cleaning, gardening etc. all day.
the pain is pressing, and now getting worse and is burning and stinging.
aspirin, of course helps, as does Ben Gay.
motion of course makes it worse.
a few years ago it was just my shoulder in the back, now it travels up my neck and all around the area of my right arm.
 
barb.chadha 9 years ago
Quite frankly, I do not think homeopathy, alone, will be able to help you. Maybe in the short term. As long as you continue this job, resulting in overuse of the shoulder., It will only be a temporary relief.
What you also have to do is physiotherapy.
This is my opinion, or what I think.

When it comes to what homeopathy medicine you need, it's 2-3 that are relevant.
You have already tried Bryonia, but in what potency?

Does it hurt most when you work, or when you are at rest?
Does it feel better when you massage the painful shoulder?
Or is it best to keep your arm perfectly still. And at what time, is the most hurt?
 
Parakletos 9 years ago
Pain in right shoulder is indicative of a Liver dis order.
Get Liver tests done and come back.

Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
Dear Punkaj Varma Jee,

How are you doing?

I agree with you, it sounds like a liver malfunction.

However, Dr. Parakletos may consider suggesting to the patient for this chronic case, a high potency Bryonia for his severe pain at the moment.

May The God Almighty keep on blessing you at all times to come.

Regards
Nawaz
 
nawazkhan 9 years ago
Dear Nawaz Khan ji,
Very right.
For the time being Bryonia is ok. If liver is in bad shape then ...Chellidonium...is a better answer.
Best regards,
Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
I have now tried arnica 200. that seems to be the answer!
pain gone completely.
how often is it safe to take that strong of a dose????
 
barb.chadha 9 years ago
Then it is a muscle pain !
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
If the pain is gone, and the shoulder is good, oyu dont need to take any moore.
just if the pain comes back



To; doomsday homeopath, Pankaj Varma: next time read what the patient writes.

Sincerly; Parakletos
 
Parakletos 9 years ago
I was waiting for you to respond Parko.

Wanted to see your comments.

Such name calling is not acceptable at ABC Homeopathy Forum...I have to report this to the Moderator.

Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
To scare people, that they have liver disease, is that correct?
You have no basis to make such a statement, especially when you read that this woman has problems because of her hard work.

Parakletos.
 
Parakletos 9 years ago
It is not a matter of scaring.
It was a possibility....in many cases here at ABC itself it turned out to be true and the persons were thankful for having pointed out the possibility.

If you can't read the signals of symptoms...it is rather unfortunate.

Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
I can read the signals, so I saw that this was a muscle / joint problems.
So I suggested physical therapy, along with Homeopathy. but I never got any answer.
The patient found out, on your own, what remedy she needed.

Fortunately it does not seem like she cared so much about what you wrote, but another person could have been very frightened.
One can not make such statements, as you do, without having any basis for this. No serious homeopath would act in such a way.

Parakletos.
 
Parakletos 9 years ago
Dear Parko....rather than getting into arguments...better we both help some more people here at ABC Forum.

Best regards,
Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
Maybe you want to be called a bigger and better homeopath. I have no such pretenses.

I do this work as my offering to my Guru...Sathya Sai Baba...coz he says service to society is service to God.

May be in your eyes ...what appears to be an error, in some one elses eyes it might be just the right thing to have pointed out...and for him / her to take up necessary investigation.

I will treat this as a closed chapter and not answer any of your arguments on this matter any further. Better spend time helping some more people.

Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
I'm sorry this caused such controversy. I appreciate any input. If the arnica 2oo didn't work, Yes, I would have gone to my Internist for a simple blood test to check for liver problems.
I love this forum and depend on it a lot! Thanks to everybody for all the help over the years!!!!!
 
barb.chadha 9 years ago
Thanks Barb. !!

It is always good to know the health of your liver from time to time...specially if you are used to taking a few drinks.

Punkaj Varma
 
PANKAJ VARMA 9 years ago
Hi Barb,

what was the dosage for Arnica 200 for shoulder muscle pain?

can this be used for upper arm
muscle pain?

Thanks
Nick
 
nsmith 9 years ago
to nsmith-my dosage is pretty much whenever I overuse my right arm-such as operating a fairly heavy leaf blower! I'm 67 years old and have been doing all the heavy chores around the house for 30 years as I am pretty strong-but because of this,that whole area of muscle is weaker!--but one dose a day of 200 helps all day.,I don't know your individual problem, but did you check with the doctors??
 
barb.chadha 9 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.