The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Page 1 2
Boil in my right breast
Sir,I am Kalpana Ravi. My age is 45.
I am 5feet tall and 62kg. I have two children of normal delivery.
Now, my problem is i had painful boil in my right breast 5months before. I took hepar sulph30. It vanished and i did not have anything after. Now,again, i started getting boil in the same plane and two more painful boils in other place. If i take Hepar Sulph30 it goes and again it comes back. Please let me know what is the remedy for this.
kalpanar on 2012-06-18
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
shouse_nsk last decade
So, i have to buy only 6tablets of Antharaxinum-1m. What happened to hepar sulph? Should i continue to take or stop? And also when should i take this antharoxinum and is there any food restrictions.
kalpanar last decade
You need to take only 6 pills (one dose). Take it in the moring when your stomach is empty. Then do not take any medicine on that day. From the next day you can continue Heper Sulph as you are taking it.
Keep the bottle of Antharaxinum-1m with you. If we feel that it has given some results, we will decide to take one more dose.
R.P. Tamhankar
Keep the bottle of Antharaxinum-1m with you. If we feel that it has given some results, we will decide to take one more dose.
R.P. Tamhankar
shouse_nsk last decade
Pl tell me what happened when you took Antharaxinum-1m..?
I want a feedback of that medicine.
R.P. Tamhankar
I want a feedback of that medicine.
R.P. Tamhankar
shouse_nsk last decade
Nothing had happened. I was feeling sleepy. I don't know wheather it's due to this medicine or naturally feeling sleepy.
kalpanar last decade
I have taken one more doses. Now i am taking hepar sulph30 three times daily. Is this enough to completly become alright.
kalyanis last decade
R.P. Tamhankar Sir, I took Antharaxinum-1m -6 pills 2 days as told by you and also i am taking hepar sulph30 daily. All the other boils have gone. One boil which comes back in the same place in my under breast has subsided but not gone fully some lump is there. Pl, advice.
kalpanar last decade
Kalpana
If boil is redish and painful then take
1. Belladona-30 6 pills 2 times a day
2. Hepar Sulph-200 6 pills 2 times a day ( In stead of 30 power)
Pl keep 30-40 minutes gap between 1 and 2
Pl again take one dose of Antharaxinum-1m
Inform me after one week of treatment
R.P. Tamhankar
If boil is redish and painful then take
1. Belladona-30 6 pills 2 times a day
2. Hepar Sulph-200 6 pills 2 times a day ( In stead of 30 power)
Pl keep 30-40 minutes gap between 1 and 2
Pl again take one dose of Antharaxinum-1m
Inform me after one week of treatment
R.P. Tamhankar
shouse_nsk last decade
R.P. Tamhankar Sir,
It was reddish. But now it has subsided and became black, but painful lump is there.(Same place it's coming again and again. Once i take hepar sulph it subside and again when i stop it's coming again.) Other boils have gone. Only this is there. I want this to go completely.
It was reddish. But now it has subsided and became black, but painful lump is there.(Same place it's coming again and again. Once i take hepar sulph it subside and again when i stop it's coming again.) Other boils have gone. Only this is there. I want this to go completely.
kalpanar last decade
I have prescribed Antharaxinum-1m for recurrance of boils. But It is not to be given daily.
Other medicines I suggested you. Pl take Belladona and Heper Sulph as suggested. and Take one weekly dose of Antharaxinum-1m (6 pills)
Pl give me feedback after 10 days.
R.P. Tamhankar
Other medicines I suggested you. Pl take Belladona and Heper Sulph as suggested. and Take one weekly dose of Antharaxinum-1m (6 pills)
Pl give me feedback after 10 days.
R.P. Tamhankar
shouse_nsk last decade
If Hepar helped, why not try a higher potence. For example, 200C.
And how on earth did you come up with Antharaxinum, without asking a single question?
Where is the patient's anamnese?
(If, you want to try Hepar 200 C,. You must begin with the potency you took last time, 30C.)
Dr.P
[message edited by Parakletos on Sat, 07 Jul 2012 14:00:19 BST]
And how on earth did you come up with Antharaxinum, without asking a single question?
Where is the patient's anamnese?
(If, you want to try Hepar 200 C,. You must begin with the potency you took last time, 30C.)
Dr.P
[message edited by Parakletos on Sat, 07 Jul 2012 14:00:19 BST]
♡ Parakletos last decade
His Highness P
I have already suggested Hepar Sulph-200. Pl take some pains to see my post.
R.P. Tamhankar
I have already suggested Hepar Sulph-200. Pl take some pains to see my post.
R.P. Tamhankar
shouse_nsk last decade
For Parakletos:
Please stop trespassing into the post which is under R.P. Tamhankar treatment. If you have any discussion-query-doubts you can use abc-gossip thread (http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/289184/). You are raising questions in the thread which is owned by the patient (kalpanar) and is under treatment R.P, this will create unnecessary misunderstanding to patient and result in derailment of treatment. Request you to please adhere to it.
Nikkie.
[message edited by Nikkie on Sat, 07 Jul 2012 16:54:41 BST]
Please stop trespassing into the post which is under R.P. Tamhankar treatment. If you have any discussion-query-doubts you can use abc-gossip thread (http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/289184/). You are raising questions in the thread which is owned by the patient (kalpanar) and is under treatment R.P, this will create unnecessary misunderstanding to patient and result in derailment of treatment. Request you to please adhere to it.
Nikkie.
[message edited by Nikkie on Sat, 07 Jul 2012 16:54:41 BST]
♡ Nikkie last decade
Dr. P,
If your experience does not align with another doctor, the only request is to be professional and polite to challenge.
After 20 to 30 years of active clinical experience and open mindedness leads to prescribe medicines without much details. I know Homeopaths who does not ask single question and prescribe based on sitting posture and facial expressions after talking for 2 minutes. His success rate was much higher than any doctors I have seen and he developed this out of dedication for 40 years of practice. So... there are people with different skills and they dont have to be stuck with classical teachings or align to your experience.
If your experience does not align with another doctor, the only request is to be professional and polite to challenge.
After 20 to 30 years of active clinical experience and open mindedness leads to prescribe medicines without much details. I know Homeopaths who does not ask single question and prescribe based on sitting posture and facial expressions after talking for 2 minutes. His success rate was much higher than any doctors I have seen and he developed this out of dedication for 40 years of practice. So... there are people with different skills and they dont have to be stuck with classical teachings or align to your experience.
♡ Reva V last decade
The big difference here, Mr. Reva V, is that there are no facial expressions to relate to. And I do not think that shouse nsk has such experience, as the homeopath you are referring to.
On that basis we have here, we can not relate to other than questions and answers. The patient's medical history. We do not propose a remedy out of thin air, we must have a good foundation first. If you are a serious homeopath, I think you probably agree with this?
The patient should be the one we should concentrate on, and his health. Homeopathy is not as harmless as some think it is.
On that basis we have here, we can not relate to other than questions and answers. The patient's medical history. We do not propose a remedy out of thin air, we must have a good foundation first. If you are a serious homeopath, I think you probably agree with this?
The patient should be the one we should concentrate on, and his health. Homeopathy is not as harmless as some think it is.
♡ Parakletos last decade
Tamhankar Sir,
I am taking
Belladona-30 6 pills 2 times a day
Hepar Sulph-200 6 pills 2 times a day as told by you. But the lump has not gone. Should i take it for some more days.
kalpana.
I am taking
Belladona-30 6 pills 2 times a day
Hepar Sulph-200 6 pills 2 times a day as told by you. But the lump has not gone. Should i take it for some more days.
kalpana.
kalpanar last decade
Parakletos
I think you should kindly retract your rather rude remark re Shouse Nsk. Mr Tamhankar is an extremely good and naturally god gifted homeopath. Following his advice has cured many of my family members including myself - where more 'professional' or 'experienced' homeopaths have failed miserabley Dr Tamhankar has time and again shown success with his remedies. To even compare yourself to him is a great insult I feel.
I follow his posts diligently and am learning a lot from his methods - all of which give remarkable results.
I would ask therefore to please not show rude behaviour. Not only do i consider him my teacher but also a friend who has helped me without charging fees or shouting to the world how successful he is - something which a lot of you homeopaths on this site love doing !
Sorabh Sharma
I think you should kindly retract your rather rude remark re Shouse Nsk. Mr Tamhankar is an extremely good and naturally god gifted homeopath. Following his advice has cured many of my family members including myself - where more 'professional' or 'experienced' homeopaths have failed miserabley Dr Tamhankar has time and again shown success with his remedies. To even compare yourself to him is a great insult I feel.
I follow his posts diligently and am learning a lot from his methods - all of which give remarkable results.
I would ask therefore to please not show rude behaviour. Not only do i consider him my teacher but also a friend who has helped me without charging fees or shouting to the world how successful he is - something which a lot of you homeopaths on this site love doing !
Sorabh Sharma
SorabhSharma last decade
Dear Sorabh Sharma.
Rude? Where do you see that I'm rude?
I asked R.P. Tamhankar how he manages to find 'the right medicine' without asking even a single question ?
One of the first things I learned during my homeopathic education, was to ask good questions. How do we know what kind of medicine to give, without asking questions? And especially on a forum like this, where you have nothing else to relate to.
The important thing here is the patient, and how best to help.
Thank you.
Parakletos.
[message edited by Parakletos on Thu, 26 Jul 2012 16:00:29 BST]
Rude? Where do you see that I'm rude?
I asked R.P. Tamhankar how he manages to find 'the right medicine' without asking even a single question ?
One of the first things I learned during my homeopathic education, was to ask good questions. How do we know what kind of medicine to give, without asking questions? And especially on a forum like this, where you have nothing else to relate to.
The important thing here is the patient, and how best to help.
Thank you.
Parakletos.
[message edited by Parakletos on Thu, 26 Jul 2012 16:00:29 BST]
♡ Parakletos last decade
Dear Parakletos
''Rude? Where do you see that I'm rude? ''
''And I do not think that shouse nsk has such experience, as the homeopath you are referring to. ''
I have quoted you above in your response to Mrs Reva - there was really no need to say that Mr Tamhankar has not enough experience. He is a brilliant homeopath and a very kind gentleman.
''I asked R.P. Tamhankar how he manages to find 'the right medicine' without asking even a single question ? ''
The patient has already said she responds to Hepar Sulph. Did you then consider why Dr Tamhankar prescribed Antharaxinum?
Agreed. The patients health comes first and as long as she sticks to Dr Tamhankars advice i am confident she will be cured. I have myself had excellent results with him after 2 years of suffering! If only i had met this genius doctor before.
We need to really ask ourselves - if the traditional homeopathic approach of try one medicine and then wait a lifetime before trying another isnt working - then we should all perhaps look for alternative methods of applying homeopathy. I definately agree with what Dr Reva has said.
Thanks
Sorabh
''Rude? Where do you see that I'm rude? ''
''And I do not think that shouse nsk has such experience, as the homeopath you are referring to. ''
I have quoted you above in your response to Mrs Reva - there was really no need to say that Mr Tamhankar has not enough experience. He is a brilliant homeopath and a very kind gentleman.
''I asked R.P. Tamhankar how he manages to find 'the right medicine' without asking even a single question ? ''
The patient has already said she responds to Hepar Sulph. Did you then consider why Dr Tamhankar prescribed Antharaxinum?
Agreed. The patients health comes first and as long as she sticks to Dr Tamhankars advice i am confident she will be cured. I have myself had excellent results with him after 2 years of suffering! If only i had met this genius doctor before.
We need to really ask ourselves - if the traditional homeopathic approach of try one medicine and then wait a lifetime before trying another isnt working - then we should all perhaps look for alternative methods of applying homeopathy. I definately agree with what Dr Reva has said.
Thanks
Sorabh
SorabhSharma last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.