Should I continue my treatment ?

Is it useful to take another dose now, or wait another week before taking another dose, or stop and change remedy?

Repeat every second day at least for two weeks and observe..Have it before 11 AM.Then decide to stop or change.

Dr. Luke De Schepper a famous homeopath and Md. is retired But you can find his advice online.
He advises start with one dose of 30c wait 24 hours-. If no reaction try another dose if 30 c. Wait 24 hours.If no reaction try a dose of 200 c- Again wait a couple days- If no reaction the remedy is wrong.
It seems to me that repeating the 200 c will just end up giving you proving symptoms and cause distress and confusion.

I have not seen any proving by repeating doses.Banarji protocol is mostly in 200 potency to be continued for three months.Mother Tinctures if repeated for a long time ends up in proving.

What will happen if more pills are taken than advised or what will happen if repeated more than advised In homoeopathy we have the pills of different sizes ranging from 10 to 60, so depending upon how many pills make a

single dose, that many are advised to be taken at a time. It is the number of times the medicine is repeated that is important and not how many pills are taken (unlike in allopathy). Because every repetition stimulates the body, but even the whole bottle taken once will be treated as one dose only, so it is a waste to have more pills than advised but it is bad to repeat more than prescribed. Therefore many a times when children swallow all pills from the bottle there is nothing to worry as it is treated as a single dose - at the most a cup of coffee is given to prevent any trouble.

It is said that homoeopathy first increases the disease and then improves, is this true

This is largely a myth and has come to surface because in a few cases, when the medicine chosen is absolutely perfect, but if repeated more than need of the patient then it may increase the present complaint, but it would subside on its own as soon as medicine is withdrawn. Sometimes after treatment is started, the old symptoms of the patient (which he is not having now, but had earlier) may again reappear and this is a welcome sign to the homoeopathic doctor, for the medicine is perfect, and cure is being achieved as we believe that the old masked symptoms coming out are according to the law of cure. For those symptoms which came last will go first and first symptoms always last. So for example, after treatment for asthma a patient may again get old skin complaints or an ear discharge, these are good signs and no external application should be used and the doctor informed about it.


A Patients Guide To Homeopathy

DR FAROKH MASTER

We have different opinions. I have seen tons of proving by repeating doses too often. How can you say that? Parents gave spongia for child cough/ one dose- child improved but they followed bottle “ridiculous instructions” take every 4 hours. Asap child symptoms came back on second dose.
They let it wear off and wellness returned -child only needed two doses-one more a few days later.
Bannerji protocols are not mainstream homeopathy practice.
[Edited by simone717 on 2024-10-26 16:29:29]

I have seen tons of proving by repeating doses too often. I have never ever seen a proving.

Banerji protocols are not mainstream homeopathy practice.But very popular and most effective for all ailments.

How can you say that?Because I have never encountered any patient like that in my 40 years of treatment.

I have seen tons of proving by repeating doses too often. Aggravation could be.Not proving.
[Edited by anuj srivastava on 2024-10-26 16:41:02]

I think we are having some miscommunication.
About definitions. I follow Dr Luc methods.
As far as Banerji - I have read criticism of some of their newer protocols - like repeated lycopodium doses that cause unbearable digestive pain and patients had to stop per their homeopath.
I’m not current with their newer protocols.

We should indulge in such debates,they are extremely beneficial for all.

In IBS I FOLLOW Banerji PROTOCOL most effective.

unbearable digestive pain and patients had to stop per their homeopath.one odd person having such issues should be ignored.

I’m not current with their newer protocols.They are good for caseer also.

Haha-been awhile since we argued.
You are right-the example I gave was aggravation not proving.Btw, what is the IBS protocol of Bannerji you use?

Haha-been awhile since we argued.YES ON CELL SALTS THERE WAS AN ARGUMENT BUT THEN BARTHOLIN CYST WAS CURED BY A SINGLE CELL SALT.SO EFFECTEVE THESE SALTS ARE.

Lycopodium 200 and Ars alb 6/3 two times a day.Such a divine protocol for IBS.

Yes- I have you to thank for my cell salt education- they are wonderful and many , many things are handled and balanced before they turn into a problem.
So-how long do your patients need to use this protocol? Is there permanent cure?
I just looked up the IBS Bannerji protocol- it said Tub200 every other day?? Nux v 30 2x a day. I hope that’s wrong!
I have their book but it’s out of date now.

So-how long do your patients need to use this protocol? Is there permanent cure?No timeline when you start feeling good I suggest you stop.Mentals are directly proportional to the gut.

hope that’s wrong!I will send you the details on your mail.

Biochemic remedies.

suggest you order “Natural Healing with Cell Salts”. By Dr Skye Weintraub-( very inexpensive.The book lists hundreds of ailments and what salts to use.
Cell Salts-are 12 remedies in low x potency- It is a method developed by Dr Schuessler in 19th century to balance out the right amount of minerals in our cells. If the cells are balanced the body is well- And does not develop into a chronic illness.

Please google the article- Cell Salts- a reliable friend in homeopathy(by the homeopathy school)
It gives the right info- Yes these are 12 specific mineral remedies but in potency 6x or 12x- bc these potencies have actual minerals - also are sold all in one tab called biochemical- but biochemic never seems to function the way the right individual salts work.
The book has what to take for 100’s of conditions. For instance, if you start to get a cold? Take Ferrum phos 6x 3 or 4 times on first or second day- Ferrum phos raises your red cell count and kicks out the cold- but you have to start it when the cold begins.
I did not put a link in my post- the site must be doing this now- that’s new on here-

Take the 3 together-use 6x. Try it twice a day for 5 days and see what response is.

yes.