The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Can homeopathy help me revive: please suggest me some remedy Page 4 of 5
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Dubai2009, right on all counts (also agree his patients show him respect as well). Yes, I look forward to brisbanehomeopath's advice. Thats all I need for now :)
Completely respect the concept for money for service and promote that concept too. I've already spent good $$$ visiting local homeopaths (there are only two, none of whom I have found to be effective.
The reason why I am looking for a technically sound, but practiced homeopath is that he will, through his clinical experience know where the organon's directives may afford for deviations in real life. You just cannot know that unless you practically treat and cure over several years.
Completely respect the concept for money for service and promote that concept too. I've already spent good $$$ visiting local homeopaths (there are only two, none of whom I have found to be effective.
The reason why I am looking for a technically sound, but practiced homeopath is that he will, through his clinical experience know where the organon's directives may afford for deviations in real life. You just cannot know that unless you practically treat and cure over several years.
aske123 last decade
'And Lycopodium is a Psoric remedy not a sycotic one - as clearly stated in Hahnemann's Chronic Diseases, and most other reference works regarding Miasm.'
Hmm...nice, this is once again probably not taught in degrees, and I will have to explain :)
A remedy must cover many features of a Miasm to be capable of treating it, not just one, or a few, or even a peculiar modality, and the highest of all these features is the personality/emotionality/mentality, and Ph-ac just does not cover sycosis in this way.
Anti-miasmatic classification is a very complicated business, and in my opinion. Most of the 'modern' anti-miasmatic lists which exist are completely inaccurate though, and I have even seen some which cite remedies such as Nux Vom as treating all four miasms, when of course this remedy has no anti-miasmatic properties at all.
Lycopodium is no doubt one of three cardinal anti-psorics of Hahnemann but I will tell you why Lycopodium covers sycosis too:
Go to any 'good' repertory:
Search the following rubrics:
Mind; Selfish
Mind; Jealousy
Mind; Deceitful
Mind; Suspicious
Mind; Ailments from egotism
Mind; Dictatorial
Mind; Power; love of
Mind; Reading agg.
and you will see why it covers the mental picture of sycosis.
Now about the primary lesions of sycosis like condylomata for example:
Skin; excrescences ; condylomata ; You will see Lycopodium again as a grade 2 remedy.
Go to the primary infection; urethra; discharge; gonorrheal;chronic; You will see Lycopodium appear again.
It covers sycosis at mental, physical and primary infection levels.
Lycopodium is an anti-sycotic remedy.
Q.E.D :)
I hope the above was helpful in understanding Lycopodium better.
Hmm...nice, this is once again probably not taught in degrees, and I will have to explain :)
A remedy must cover many features of a Miasm to be capable of treating it, not just one, or a few, or even a peculiar modality, and the highest of all these features is the personality/emotionality/mentality, and Ph-ac just does not cover sycosis in this way.
Anti-miasmatic classification is a very complicated business, and in my opinion. Most of the 'modern' anti-miasmatic lists which exist are completely inaccurate though, and I have even seen some which cite remedies such as Nux Vom as treating all four miasms, when of course this remedy has no anti-miasmatic properties at all.
Lycopodium is no doubt one of three cardinal anti-psorics of Hahnemann but I will tell you why Lycopodium covers sycosis too:
Go to any 'good' repertory:
Search the following rubrics:
Mind; Selfish
Mind; Jealousy
Mind; Deceitful
Mind; Suspicious
Mind; Ailments from egotism
Mind; Dictatorial
Mind; Power; love of
Mind; Reading agg.
and you will see why it covers the mental picture of sycosis.
Now about the primary lesions of sycosis like condylomata for example:
Skin; excrescences ; condylomata ; You will see Lycopodium again as a grade 2 remedy.
Go to the primary infection; urethra; discharge; gonorrheal;chronic; You will see Lycopodium appear again.
It covers sycosis at mental, physical and primary infection levels.
Lycopodium is an anti-sycotic remedy.
Q.E.D :)
I hope the above was helpful in understanding Lycopodium better.
sameervermani last decade
Hi David
Nice to see you here.
You need to spend lot of time if you feel like commenting on other's prescriptions.
Some are good , some are bad and many are, to say the least, simply irresponsible.
Serious prescribers like you are very much needed here, but I doubt whether you can survive the hostilities.
Murthy
Nice to see you here.
You need to spend lot of time if you feel like commenting on other's prescriptions.
Some are good , some are bad and many are, to say the least, simply irresponsible.
Serious prescribers like you are very much needed here, but I doubt whether you can survive the hostilities.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
And, regarding following the Organon, any homeopath who deviates from the Organon (he can build upon the Organon, no problem), is probably on a very shaky ground anyways, and so would be his patients. And, one of the main directives is about not repeating the same dose (without changing the dynamization) once your body has started to respond to it :)
Wow..finally..yes finally, I think I said something which brisbanehomeopath and I would agree on :)
Wow..finally..yes finally, I think I said something which brisbanehomeopath and I would agree on :)
sameervermani last decade
Dear Mr Sameer,
I understand this is an open forum but totally disapprove the visit of three 'uninvited arrogant guests' in this thread.
I am convinced and satisfied with what you have been prescribing me here.
And I have every respect for your 'philanthropy' because I believe money is a sh*t which even a prostitute can earn with ease.
I am sorry for using offending language here. I apologize and promise I will not do it again.
But, at the same time, I want to share with you that I have a strong feeling that these three people consider themselves not less than the great Hahnemann. This show their emptiness and nothing else as he who is endowed with the gift of knowledge will first be humble and decent in all respect.
And, the Pseudonyms they have used in dropping in this forum, indicates they are not at all honest but stalkers, deceptive. They want to keep their original names with them because they do not have enough courage to come to light.
I wish they do not come here again. They do not know me well.
I would like to request you Sir, let's move forward from here giving deaf ear to these 'pseudo-intels'. I have every faith in you.
Following your advise, I will take the medicine. I am confidant this time I'll be updating you on timely.
I am a big procrastinator and this is part of my problems.
Regards,
Prakash
I understand this is an open forum but totally disapprove the visit of three 'uninvited arrogant guests' in this thread.
I am convinced and satisfied with what you have been prescribing me here.
And I have every respect for your 'philanthropy' because I believe money is a sh*t which even a prostitute can earn with ease.
I am sorry for using offending language here. I apologize and promise I will not do it again.
But, at the same time, I want to share with you that I have a strong feeling that these three people consider themselves not less than the great Hahnemann. This show their emptiness and nothing else as he who is endowed with the gift of knowledge will first be humble and decent in all respect.
And, the Pseudonyms they have used in dropping in this forum, indicates they are not at all honest but stalkers, deceptive. They want to keep their original names with them because they do not have enough courage to come to light.
I wish they do not come here again. They do not know me well.
I would like to request you Sir, let's move forward from here giving deaf ear to these 'pseudo-intels'. I have every faith in you.
Following your advise, I will take the medicine. I am confidant this time I'll be updating you on timely.
I am a big procrastinator and this is part of my problems.
Regards,
Prakash
kumarprakash last decade
The person who started the thread has clearly asked for some of us to leave this thread and so I will respect their wishes and do so.
And nice to see you to Gavin :)I had no idea this forum was such a hostile place - but I do remember a certain prescriber on hpathy.com that was very similar to Sameer - not sure if you remember him and what happened to him.
And nice to see you to Gavin :)I had no idea this forum was such a hostile place - but I do remember a certain prescriber on hpathy.com that was very similar to Sameer - not sure if you remember him and what happened to him.
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Once again, it is bad manners to be discussing someone(me) with a third person(Gavini), especially in that person's presence.
I hope that what I wrote above is a good enough explanation of why Lycopodium is an anti-sycotic remedy and why this case is sycosis. I would love to hear your comments on that before you leave (if you have any), otherwise I would assume that we are in agreement on that.
I hope that what I wrote above is a good enough explanation of why Lycopodium is an anti-sycotic remedy and why this case is sycosis. I would love to hear your comments on that before you leave (if you have any), otherwise I would assume that we are in agreement on that.
sameervermani last decade
I originally only posted here to offer a different perspective on Ph-ac, the patient has asked we leave so I will probably make a seperate post about Miasms.
I do agree that Lycopodium has mental symptoms that could place it in the Sycotic miasm. My understanding is that miasm is about Pace and Depth though, not just mental symptoms which belong more to the remedy. You are not the first person to propose shifting Lyc to that miasm, although it has not as yet ever been done.So the real question is what is the pace and depth of Lyc - is it Sycotic depth or Psoric depth?
I regret my comments here, but I can see that I have reacted with deep hurt at your personal attacks on me Sameer. Clearly I will have something to talk to my homoeopath about when I go to visit her.
I am always particularly hurt when someone else who clearly enjoys homoeopathy attempts to hurt me through this one thing I love above all else, and I have reacted badly. I would appreciate it if you kept your comments professional from now on, as I will. If we can agree to disagree then both of us can attempt to have a more pleasant time here. That means no more derision of those of use who have studied and run practices please.
I do agree that Lycopodium has mental symptoms that could place it in the Sycotic miasm. My understanding is that miasm is about Pace and Depth though, not just mental symptoms which belong more to the remedy. You are not the first person to propose shifting Lyc to that miasm, although it has not as yet ever been done.So the real question is what is the pace and depth of Lyc - is it Sycotic depth or Psoric depth?
I regret my comments here, but I can see that I have reacted with deep hurt at your personal attacks on me Sameer. Clearly I will have something to talk to my homoeopath about when I go to visit her.
I am always particularly hurt when someone else who clearly enjoys homoeopathy attempts to hurt me through this one thing I love above all else, and I have reacted badly. I would appreciate it if you kept your comments professional from now on, as I will. If we can agree to disagree then both of us can attempt to have a more pleasant time here. That means no more derision of those of use who have studied and run practices please.
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
'So the real question is what is the pace and depth of Lyc - is it Sycotic depth or Psoric depth?'
I never said it does not cover psora, it is an anti-psoric par excellence (that is its deepest plane), but it covers sycosis very well as well. For that matter it even covers pseudo-psora very well. The fact that it covers multiple miasms, is the reason you see so many types of Lycopodium in practice. It is one of the few gems which are a monument to Hahnemann, and have ability to hit multiple miasms.
Ofcourse it is not as strong an anti-sycotic as a remedy like Thuja or Medorrhinum (Med being a remedy this case will almost certainly need at some point), but it does cover quite substantial part of sycosis, and I have used it to cure sycotic cases quite often.
And, sure, I will also be professional in future, but the reason of my irritation was that you were not open to the idea that someone self taught (till now) can have the knowledge to apply this wonderful science which was totally unfair to my passion and hard work.
I never said it does not cover psora, it is an anti-psoric par excellence (that is its deepest plane), but it covers sycosis very well as well. For that matter it even covers pseudo-psora very well. The fact that it covers multiple miasms, is the reason you see so many types of Lycopodium in practice. It is one of the few gems which are a monument to Hahnemann, and have ability to hit multiple miasms.
Ofcourse it is not as strong an anti-sycotic as a remedy like Thuja or Medorrhinum (Med being a remedy this case will almost certainly need at some point), but it does cover quite substantial part of sycosis, and I have used it to cure sycotic cases quite often.
And, sure, I will also be professional in future, but the reason of my irritation was that you were not open to the idea that someone self taught (till now) can have the knowledge to apply this wonderful science which was totally unfair to my passion and hard work.
sameervermani last decade
'You are not the first person to propose shifting Lyc to that miasm, although it has not as yet ever been done'
Well, I can for that matter refer you to David Little, a homeopath I respect a lot, and Dr. SUBRATA KUMAR BANERJEA who is considered to be a world authority on miasmatic diagnosis.
David lists Lycopodium as a grade 2 remedy for treatment of inherited sycosis and so does Dr Banerjea.
Well, I can for that matter refer you to David Little, a homeopath I respect a lot, and Dr. SUBRATA KUMAR BANERJEA who is considered to be a world authority on miasmatic diagnosis.
David lists Lycopodium as a grade 2 remedy for treatment of inherited sycosis and so does Dr Banerjea.
sameervermani last decade
Dear Mr Sameer,
I have got spring water. It's mountain spring water. I'll take the medicine as you have prescribed.
When should you update you with the developments?
I have got spring water. It's mountain spring water. I'll take the medicine as you have prescribed.
When should you update you with the developments?
kumarprakash last decade
'You are not the first person to propose shifting Lyc to that miasm, although it has not as yet ever been done'
It was suggested even by Dr. Kent. Please look :
http://www.homeoint.org/books3/kentmm/lyc.htm
Regards
Niel
It was suggested even by Dr. Kent. Please look :
http://www.homeoint.org/books3/kentmm/lyc.htm
Regards
Niel
Niel Madhavan last decade
Dear Mr Sameer,
It's been one week since I took the medicine in the manner you had suggested.
But, there is no significant change in my condition as such.
Rather, I feeling more sleepy and lethargic. And for last three days, I have been suffering from pain in my legs (from knee to feet) which has been intense in left leg. I felt this pain originates from knees. It starts sometime in day (I can not tell the exact time) and becomes intense in evening.
I used to be a professional artist (western dance) some nine years ago. I used to spend seven eight hours in physical labour while taking dance classes then. May be I am suffering from pain in legs now because of this past as I have completely stopped doing it. There is no heavy physical exercise in life now.
My mental condition is comparatively better than past. It actually started improving since after the first dose of Lyco. I can feel some clarity in my mind and writing skills. But this fluctuates.
There fluctuation in mood also. Sometime I feel depressed, sad for long hours for no reason.
I have noted that I do not feel like copulating these days. There is some aversion, I don't know why. I want but my mind and body does not favour. I can not be persistent on it for long time.
Regards,
Prakash
It's been one week since I took the medicine in the manner you had suggested.
But, there is no significant change in my condition as such.
Rather, I feeling more sleepy and lethargic. And for last three days, I have been suffering from pain in my legs (from knee to feet) which has been intense in left leg. I felt this pain originates from knees. It starts sometime in day (I can not tell the exact time) and becomes intense in evening.
I used to be a professional artist (western dance) some nine years ago. I used to spend seven eight hours in physical labour while taking dance classes then. May be I am suffering from pain in legs now because of this past as I have completely stopped doing it. There is no heavy physical exercise in life now.
My mental condition is comparatively better than past. It actually started improving since after the first dose of Lyco. I can feel some clarity in my mind and writing skills. But this fluctuates.
There fluctuation in mood also. Sometime I feel depressed, sad for long hours for no reason.
I have noted that I do not feel like copulating these days. There is some aversion, I don't know why. I want but my mind and body does not favour. I can not be persistent on it for long time.
Regards,
Prakash
kumarprakash last decade
Dear Mr Sameer,
I want to share something with you.
I have downloaded a software 'Brainwave Generator'. This is really great and helpful in streamlining brainwaves. You can also check it out.
I want to share something with you.
I have downloaded a software 'Brainwave Generator'. This is really great and helpful in streamlining brainwaves. You can also check it out.
kumarprakash last decade
Dear Prakash,
Please take a single dose of MEDORRHINUM 200c as follows:
Dissolve 2 drops in 120 ml spring water, and take a spoon from there. Make sure nothing enters the mouth 1 hr before and 1 hr after the dose.
Report in 2 weeks. (This medicine is slow to develop action).
Please take a single dose of MEDORRHINUM 200c as follows:
Dissolve 2 drops in 120 ml spring water, and take a spoon from there. Make sure nothing enters the mouth 1 hr before and 1 hr after the dose.
Report in 2 weeks. (This medicine is slow to develop action).
sameervermani last decade
Mt Veermani,
After much effort, I got the medicine today. But it is not of reckweg's brand but willmar Schwabe's, an indian product manufactured in Noida.
The medicine was so far not available with most of the shops in Delhi I approached here.
I'll take it today and would promptly update you after two weeks.
Regards,
Prakash
After much effort, I got the medicine today. But it is not of reckweg's brand but willmar Schwabe's, an indian product manufactured in Noida.
The medicine was so far not available with most of the shops in Delhi I approached here.
I'll take it today and would promptly update you after two weeks.
Regards,
Prakash
anjalisrivastava last decade
Hello Mr Veermani,
I took MEDORRHINUM 200c on September 30.
It seem to be working somewhat. There o some change in my condition.
However I feel sleepy and lethargic but it is not that intense as the case was in past.
I feel pain in my legs (from knee to feet) only sometimes.
My mental condition has also improved to some extent. There is some clarity in thought process but still I am not very fast and fall victim to conflicting thought. Several logics and assertions come to my my mind at a time and confuse me at a time when I start to write.
There is improvement in my sexual behaviour.
Procrastination still persisting. Head is full of dandruff with intense itching on scalp.
What next ?
Regards,
Prakash
I took MEDORRHINUM 200c on September 30.
It seem to be working somewhat. There o some change in my condition.
However I feel sleepy and lethargic but it is not that intense as the case was in past.
I feel pain in my legs (from knee to feet) only sometimes.
My mental condition has also improved to some extent. There is some clarity in thought process but still I am not very fast and fall victim to conflicting thought. Several logics and assertions come to my my mind at a time and confuse me at a time when I start to write.
There is improvement in my sexual behaviour.
Procrastination still persisting. Head is full of dandruff with intense itching on scalp.
What next ?
Regards,
Prakash
anjalisrivastava last decade
vikas_grower last decade
Hello Mr Veermani,
I took MEDORRHINUM 200c on September 30.
It seem to be working somewhat. There o some change in my condition.
However I feel sleepy and lethargic but it is not that intense as the case was in past.
I feel pain in my legs (from knee to feet) only sometimes.
My mental condition has also improved to some extent. There is some clarity in thought process but still I am not very fast and fall victim to conflicting thought. Several logics and assertions come to my my mind at a time and confuse me at a time when I start to write.
There is improvement in my sexual behaviour.
Procrastination still persisting. Head is full of dandruff with intense itching on scalp.
What next ?
Regards,
Prakash
I took MEDORRHINUM 200c on September 30.
It seem to be working somewhat. There o some change in my condition.
However I feel sleepy and lethargic but it is not that intense as the case was in past.
I feel pain in my legs (from knee to feet) only sometimes.
My mental condition has also improved to some extent. There is some clarity in thought process but still I am not very fast and fall victim to conflicting thought. Several logics and assertions come to my my mind at a time and confuse me at a time when I start to write.
There is improvement in my sexual behaviour.
Procrastination still persisting. Head is full of dandruff with intense itching on scalp.
What next ?
Regards,
Prakash
kumarprakash last decade
Hello Prakash,
These are all very encouraging signs indeed.
I would recommend, waiting for about 10 more days, as Medorrhinum is a very long acting remedy. We should give your body more time to respond.
The next step will be Medorrhinum 1M, so you can procure it, but do not take it without talking to me.
Sameer
These are all very encouraging signs indeed.
I would recommend, waiting for about 10 more days, as Medorrhinum is a very long acting remedy. We should give your body more time to respond.
The next step will be Medorrhinum 1M, so you can procure it, but do not take it without talking to me.
Sameer
sameervermani last decade
I am sorry for being completely non-responsive for these many months. I have been facing so many problems and so been not able to focus on my wellness. Another discouraging factor was that I was unable to get Medorrhinum 1M from the market here despite trying for it several times.
Can I still expect my remedy ?? I really need it. I hate people calling me bald and giving some funny nickname for that.
And since I was unable to live a normal marital life, I have started taking some narcotic susbtance these days to empty my mind, to remove stress . I want to get rid of it because this is really gonna be addictive again
Prakash
Can I still expect my remedy ?? I really need it. I hate people calling me bald and giving some funny nickname for that.
And since I was unable to live a normal marital life, I have started taking some narcotic susbtance these days to empty my mind, to remove stress . I want to get rid of it because this is really gonna be addictive again
Prakash
kumarprakash last decade
It is not possible that you will not get this remedy in Delhi.
However, I think you have to get off that 'narcotic' substance before you can expect any benefit.
Please take a dose of Medorrhinum 1M, Dissolve 2 drops of Med 1M in 120 ml spring water, stir and take a sip from there.
Report in 14 days after the dose.
However, I think you have to get off that 'narcotic' substance before you can expect any benefit.
Please take a dose of Medorrhinum 1M, Dissolve 2 drops of Med 1M in 120 ml spring water, stir and take a sip from there.
Report in 14 days after the dose.
sameervermani last decade
I am still not addicted to the narcotic substance. I can quit it. But there is a problem. I smoke and chew tobacco. I can quit smoking for one-two days but can't live without chewing tobacco for more than one-two hours.
Is it possible to take the remedy under these circumstances?
I do not have any other addition. No tea, no coffee, no junk food, no alchohol.
Prakash
Is it possible to take the remedy under these circumstances?
I do not have any other addition. No tea, no coffee, no junk food, no alchohol.
Prakash
kumarprakash last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.