The ABC Homeopathy Forum
pankaj varma attention please. Page 2 of 4
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Murthy,
If Lyco not taken by him ..his pain would travel right up to the leg.
I know those definitions...have been reading them for more than 20 years. You don't have to teach them to me.
I still repeat...you haven't co-related all the symptoms and seen the total picture.
By making comments as reproduced below, you compel me to say what I say:
*********
These are the consequences of not heeding to well meaning advice.
Hope the prescriber can sort out the mess he is responsible for.
If not, we will help you.
Murthy
************
If you make such biased comments again and again....I will return it back to you in the same tone.
You are yourself showing the lack of depth in your ability in applied homeopathy.
By making such comments you are also trying to confuse the receiver of the suggestions.
If you accept suggestions like mine and try to improve your skills...you will become a much better homeopath.
Pankaj Varma
If Lyco not taken by him ..his pain would travel right up to the leg.
I know those definitions...have been reading them for more than 20 years. You don't have to teach them to me.
I still repeat...you haven't co-related all the symptoms and seen the total picture.
By making comments as reproduced below, you compel me to say what I say:
*********
These are the consequences of not heeding to well meaning advice.
Hope the prescriber can sort out the mess he is responsible for.
If not, we will help you.
Murthy
************
If you make such biased comments again and again....I will return it back to you in the same tone.
You are yourself showing the lack of depth in your ability in applied homeopathy.
By making such comments you are also trying to confuse the receiver of the suggestions.
If you accept suggestions like mine and try to improve your skills...you will become a much better homeopath.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Just for your information...in my library I have a number of books just on medical terminology.
Some of them have been with me for over 20 years.
Some of them have been with me for over 20 years.
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Sajjad Bhai (Sajjad Akram)...has given very good advice to everyone here (on another thread). I am reproducing the same:
********
We are not on trial here.Every body suggest to the best of his abilities.I have already told there are so many ways to prescribe and they are all successful.Hanemmanian method is the best of all but not the only one.
Be good and do good.
sajjad.
*********
Pankaj Varma
********
We are not on trial here.Every body suggest to the best of his abilities.I have already told there are so many ways to prescribe and they are all successful.Hanemmanian method is the best of all but not the only one.
Be good and do good.
sajjad.
*********
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Wow.
Another misleading statement.
Please show me a single source where his present condition is linked to sciatica.
The patient is being misled with wrong diagnosis, and wrong medicine.
What is 'the picture' of Lyco seen now?
Please elaborate.
No body is on trial here. But the patient's right for correct information, proper diagnosis, and treatment can't be taken lightly.
I told manytimes, I don't have to learn from people who exhibit half baked knowledge.
It is better we accept our mistakes and learn from others who are more knoweldgable.
Arguing without substance will take us nowhere.
Murthy
Another misleading statement.
Please show me a single source where his present condition is linked to sciatica.
The patient is being misled with wrong diagnosis, and wrong medicine.
What is 'the picture' of Lyco seen now?
Please elaborate.
No body is on trial here. But the patient's right for correct information, proper diagnosis, and treatment can't be taken lightly.
I told manytimes, I don't have to learn from people who exhibit half baked knowledge.
It is better we accept our mistakes and learn from others who are more knoweldgable.
Arguing without substance will take us nowhere.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
We often hear this word 'applied homeopathy'?
Without understanding the basics of homeopathy, how any body can apply it?
Without knowing what is sciatica, how can one prescribe medicines thinking that it is sciatica?
Murthy
Without understanding the basics of homeopathy, how any body can apply it?
Without knowing what is sciatica, how can one prescribe medicines thinking that it is sciatica?
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Here is an example of how to take case, how to select a medicine, how to give a medicine, and how to be confident about results.
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/87958/
Those who try to teach me , may please open their eyes, and start learning 'proper' homeopathy.
Murthy
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/87958/
Those who try to teach me , may please open their eyes, and start learning 'proper' homeopathy.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
I was expecting a similar reply, and it came promptly.!!
All this has become too familiar now, to predict exactly.
Dear Sanvar
Please don't take any more medicines now. The relief you got from your teeth problems is due to the root canal treatment you had. Not because of Merc.sol.!!
Please wait for a week, and post all your symptoms,as on that day,once again.Don't leave out anything.
We will help you,in real claasical way.
Murthy
All this has become too familiar now, to predict exactly.
Dear Sanvar
Please don't take any more medicines now. The relief you got from your teeth problems is due to the root canal treatment you had. Not because of Merc.sol.!!
Please wait for a week, and post all your symptoms,as on that day,once again.Don't leave out anything.
We will help you,in real claasical way.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Murthy....the thread is addressed to me...when the man wants your advice...he will ask you...then butt in!!
Don't waste everyones time with your 'half baked knowledge'
Don't waste everyones time with your 'half baked knowledge'
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
and ...there are some threads where they are asking you for advise....spend your time there and give your guidance there. I will come there later and do the post-audit.
Pankaj Varma
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
'Joe, Murthy has the right to post in threads where you have already answered.'
This is the rule of the forum as told by Simon.
Perhaps you need to be told by name, once again.
Murthy
This is the rule of the forum as told by Simon.
Perhaps you need to be told by name, once again.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Nobody should get away with a wrong diagnosis, and wrong prescription. That includes me.
All are most welcome, to dissect my prescriptions, and ask for clarifications.
I will be too happy to answer.
I am also open for correction, in case I make a mistake. It is possible that someone else can see from a deferent angle, and prescribe a better medicine.
Forums are meant for discussions. These are not the private clinics of X,Y,Z.
Here there is accountability. Any body can question your prescription, and if the prescription is based on proper study, it is not at all difficult to justify it.
Only those, who dish out prescriptions out of their hat, feel uncomfortable when questioned.
Murthy
All are most welcome, to dissect my prescriptions, and ask for clarifications.
I will be too happy to answer.
I am also open for correction, in case I make a mistake. It is possible that someone else can see from a deferent angle, and prescribe a better medicine.
Forums are meant for discussions. These are not the private clinics of X,Y,Z.
Here there is accountability. Any body can question your prescription, and if the prescription is based on proper study, it is not at all difficult to justify it.
Only those, who dish out prescriptions out of their hat, feel uncomfortable when questioned.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Murthy, Pankaj,
You both have valid points in what you say, but the way you say them is not conducive to a peaceful and pleasant forum. CALM DOWN!
You both mean well, but keep your claws in.
Yes Pankaj, please avoid comments like ' Murthy has to still learn a lot about application of homeopathy...'
But Murthy, you are in no position to point the finger if you then go on to say undermining things like 'Wow. Another misleading statement. '
You BOTH need to calm down before you respond to each other's posts.
Doctors and scientists disagree with each other all the time, and in part that is what keeps the system on track. But you don't see arguments and fights in hospitals do you? If you did, how would that make the patients feel? We really can't go on this way.
It is starting to seem as if the only way to keep peace on the forum is to suspend both of you, but I really don't want to do that.
Simon
You both have valid points in what you say, but the way you say them is not conducive to a peaceful and pleasant forum. CALM DOWN!
You both mean well, but keep your claws in.
Yes Pankaj, please avoid comments like ' Murthy has to still learn a lot about application of homeopathy...'
But Murthy, you are in no position to point the finger if you then go on to say undermining things like 'Wow. Another misleading statement. '
You BOTH need to calm down before you respond to each other's posts.
Doctors and scientists disagree with each other all the time, and in part that is what keeps the system on track. But you don't see arguments and fights in hospitals do you? If you did, how would that make the patients feel? We really can't go on this way.
It is starting to seem as if the only way to keep peace on the forum is to suspend both of you, but I really don't want to do that.
Simon
♡ moderator last decade
Dear Simon
I am a lot restrained than I was.
If you feel even statements like you pointed out need to be avoided, I will follow your advice.
I only wish people have the largeheartedness to accept mistakes, and contribute to useful discussions.
I thought maheeru disagrred with me in one of my prescriptions, but, I accepted it humbly, though later he calrified, he didn't mean that way.
Similar thing happened with Rajiv, but within the next one hour the facts were clarified. I was not peevish then.
I never had an opportunity to differ with Rishimba, but I am sure he will take it in the right spirit, if the occassion comes.
There are many instances, when I supported the prescriptions of Dr.Deoshlok, Joe and even Pankaj.
It shows that I don't have any bias towards anybody.
It is unfortunate that some people felt that they are being dethroned from their 'resident prescriber' status, and are hell bent to drive out all others, especially me.
Once they knew they can't do it by fair means, they started attacking , by calling names, and when I retaliated, complained to you, and got me suspended once.
They want to see the same thing repeated again, but I am glad you are wiser now.
I will show maximum restraint. I promise you.
I want to see this forum to be the visiting place,for patients, who can be confident of the advice they are getting.
I want them to feel safe, by knowing that all prescriptions are being counterchecked.
is it not good for the patients and the forum?
Anyway, I rest my case here.
Murthy
I am a lot restrained than I was.
If you feel even statements like you pointed out need to be avoided, I will follow your advice.
I only wish people have the largeheartedness to accept mistakes, and contribute to useful discussions.
I thought maheeru disagrred with me in one of my prescriptions, but, I accepted it humbly, though later he calrified, he didn't mean that way.
Similar thing happened with Rajiv, but within the next one hour the facts were clarified. I was not peevish then.
I never had an opportunity to differ with Rishimba, but I am sure he will take it in the right spirit, if the occassion comes.
There are many instances, when I supported the prescriptions of Dr.Deoshlok, Joe and even Pankaj.
It shows that I don't have any bias towards anybody.
It is unfortunate that some people felt that they are being dethroned from their 'resident prescriber' status, and are hell bent to drive out all others, especially me.
Once they knew they can't do it by fair means, they started attacking , by calling names, and when I retaliated, complained to you, and got me suspended once.
They want to see the same thing repeated again, but I am glad you are wiser now.
I will show maximum restraint. I promise you.
I want to see this forum to be the visiting place,for patients, who can be confident of the advice they are getting.
I want them to feel safe, by knowing that all prescriptions are being counterchecked.
is it not good for the patients and the forum?
Anyway, I rest my case here.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dear friends,
'large heartedness to accept mistakes....'. I think that is the key.Respect for others is another and respectfully agree to have some disagreements is another.
If one repeats a deep acting remedy like Lyco, Sulphur, Merc. for weeks or months together in dry dose, then there is every likelihood of proving symptoms developing.There is no point pretending that it does not happen or will never happen.Because in that case we will have to discard all the provings conducted from Hahnemann onwards as downright 'fantasy'.
But the fact is that homeopathy is based on 'proving symptoms'.Provings happen and when they hapen the prescriber should be 'large hearted' enough to accept it and then go ahead to antidote it.Not such a big deal to lose one's sleep or 'self esteem' over.
There has never been a homeopath who has not caused an unintended proving or two on the patients.That is part of the game.It is as simple as that.
So again lets stop quarreling and move on with helping the patients who visit here.
Best of luck to all.
Rajiv
'large heartedness to accept mistakes....'. I think that is the key.Respect for others is another and respectfully agree to have some disagreements is another.
If one repeats a deep acting remedy like Lyco, Sulphur, Merc. for weeks or months together in dry dose, then there is every likelihood of proving symptoms developing.There is no point pretending that it does not happen or will never happen.Because in that case we will have to discard all the provings conducted from Hahnemann onwards as downright 'fantasy'.
But the fact is that homeopathy is based on 'proving symptoms'.Provings happen and when they hapen the prescriber should be 'large hearted' enough to accept it and then go ahead to antidote it.Not such a big deal to lose one's sleep or 'self esteem' over.
There has never been a homeopath who has not caused an unintended proving or two on the patients.That is part of the game.It is as simple as that.
So again lets stop quarreling and move on with helping the patients who visit here.
Best of luck to all.
Rajiv
♡ rajivprasad last decade
Murthy,
Your input is valued here. As is Pankaj's.
If you can phrase your disagreements 100% inoffensively, without undermining anyone, everyone will be happy.
For example on this thread: 'Hope the prescriber can sort out the mess he is responsible for. '
In that sentence you imply that:
a) Pankaj has personaly caused a mess
b) You feel doubtfull he can sort it out
c) You can sort it out as you believe your skills superior.
That is undermining; intentionaly so, it seems to me.
Simon
Your input is valued here. As is Pankaj's.
If you can phrase your disagreements 100% inoffensively, without undermining anyone, everyone will be happy.
For example on this thread: 'Hope the prescriber can sort out the mess he is responsible for. '
In that sentence you imply that:
a) Pankaj has personaly caused a mess
b) You feel doubtfull he can sort it out
c) You can sort it out as you believe your skills superior.
That is undermining; intentionaly so, it seems to me.
Simon
♡ moderator last decade
Dear Simon
A man is conditioned by his experiences. The earlier quarrels do have an influence on how we react to a particular situation.
Any way, your advice is well taken, and I will be far more restrained than I was.
However I am not abdicating my right to reply as 'civilly' as possible, if I am being persecuted for no fault of mine, with uncalled for advices, name calling etc.
Murthy
A man is conditioned by his experiences. The earlier quarrels do have an influence on how we react to a particular situation.
Any way, your advice is well taken, and I will be far more restrained than I was.
However I am not abdicating my right to reply as 'civilly' as possible, if I am being persecuted for no fault of mine, with uncalled for advices, name calling etc.
Murthy
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
dear pankaj varma,
despite the ongoing controversy on whose posting is right,iwould like to requote what you have said.WHEN THE RIGHT TIME COMES GOD WILL PROVIDE AN ABLE PHYSICIAN TOO.
meanwhile i took the medicine you have prescribed.the branch like pain has gone away but the usual mild stiffness and pain on moving the neck to the right is there.your prescription has done me good by increasing my energy level and decreasing flatulence.my neck problem decreases absolutely after sleep.on waking and movement it starts again.after a brisk walk the right side shoulder becomes heavey and the neck hurts too.please advise further.
warm regards,
sanvar
despite the ongoing controversy on whose posting is right,iwould like to requote what you have said.WHEN THE RIGHT TIME COMES GOD WILL PROVIDE AN ABLE PHYSICIAN TOO.
meanwhile i took the medicine you have prescribed.the branch like pain has gone away but the usual mild stiffness and pain on moving the neck to the right is there.your prescription has done me good by increasing my energy level and decreasing flatulence.my neck problem decreases absolutely after sleep.on waking and movement it starts again.after a brisk walk the right side shoulder becomes heavey and the neck hurts too.please advise further.
warm regards,
sanvar
sanvar last decade
Hmm, I must have missed the comment by Moderator above, but it again seems odd that the time was taken to give a detailed warning to you Murthy, as was me, but never to anyone else, despite their comments being equally as offensive AND ongoing...odd.
Anyway, all water under the bridge I guess.
-Jacob.
Anyway, all water under the bridge I guess.
-Jacob.
JCS2006 last decade
Sanvar,
Pl .see your tongue in the mirror and tell me the colour of the coating on it.
Sleep pattern? Explain how you feel all 24 hours.
Headache?
Mood?...pleasant, grief, irritated, angry ???
Constipation?? Loose motions ??
Age , M/F ??
Pankaj Varma
Pl .see your tongue in the mirror and tell me the colour of the coating on it.
Sleep pattern? Explain how you feel all 24 hours.
Headache?
Mood?...pleasant, grief, irritated, angry ???
Constipation?? Loose motions ??
Age , M/F ??
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
dear pankaj varma,
the following is response to your query.
tongue---coated white at the base.
sleep good but always wake up once at around between 3 am to 4 am.after that sleep not as deep as before.
sometimes headache mostly on the right side.deep and gnawing.
always better towards the evening.mood is rather always anticipating the uncertain future,anger and grief related to past life,which is lessened by faith in almighty.sometimes lack of self confidence and faer as if done something wrong.
stools with a lot of flatus and sputtering and semi solid usually twice in the morning.the second stool always with force and gushing sort of loose.
age 51 male
please advise.
warm regards,
sanvar
the following is response to your query.
tongue---coated white at the base.
sleep good but always wake up once at around between 3 am to 4 am.after that sleep not as deep as before.
sometimes headache mostly on the right side.deep and gnawing.
always better towards the evening.mood is rather always anticipating the uncertain future,anger and grief related to past life,which is lessened by faith in almighty.sometimes lack of self confidence and faer as if done something wrong.
stools with a lot of flatus and sputtering and semi solid usually twice in the morning.the second stool always with force and gushing sort of loose.
age 51 male
please advise.
warm regards,
sanvar
sanvar last decade
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
dear pankaj varma,
took prescribed medicines.digestion improved,flatulence diminished.energy level good esp towards the evening.after the doses,the left wisdom tooth gums inflamed with a little pain on the left side extending to the eye sides and nose with desire to clear throat with expectoration from the left nose but inside the throat.wandering pains in the legs and sometimes hands everyday in different locations.visited dentist and he said it was because of the receding gums i was having this gums problem.feel much better mentally.thanks a lot and please advise further soon.
warm regards,
sanvar
took prescribed medicines.digestion improved,flatulence diminished.energy level good esp towards the evening.after the doses,the left wisdom tooth gums inflamed with a little pain on the left side extending to the eye sides and nose with desire to clear throat with expectoration from the left nose but inside the throat.wandering pains in the legs and sometimes hands everyday in different locations.visited dentist and he said it was because of the receding gums i was having this gums problem.feel much better mentally.thanks a lot and please advise further soon.
warm regards,
sanvar
sanvar last decade
When ever a person takes Sulphur...aggravation is expected.
The physicals show some signs of aggravation ...whereas mentals improve.
Seems to be the case.
Wait for 2 days and then post feed back.
24 hours after the Sulphur dose you can take Merc. Sol. again....the tooth ache will go away.
Sulphur also has the ability to heal the gums.
Pankaj Varma
The physicals show some signs of aggravation ...whereas mentals improve.
Seems to be the case.
Wait for 2 days and then post feed back.
24 hours after the Sulphur dose you can take Merc. Sol. again....the tooth ache will go away.
Sulphur also has the ability to heal the gums.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Dear Sanwar,
I have reviewed your case in totality again. There have been many posts here that have caused distractions.
Anyway, Take Merc. Sol. 200c ...24 hours after Sulphur dose taken by you.
24 hours after taking Merc Sol...start Carbo Veg. 30C ....two doses per day...for a week.
(It is the medicine for receding gums + flatulence + low energy...will take care of all those symptoms).
Sulphur and Merc. Sol. were necessary to clear presence of miasms.
Pankaj Varma
I have reviewed your case in totality again. There have been many posts here that have caused distractions.
Anyway, Take Merc. Sol. 200c ...24 hours after Sulphur dose taken by you.
24 hours after taking Merc Sol...start Carbo Veg. 30C ....two doses per day...for a week.
(It is the medicine for receding gums + flatulence + low energy...will take care of all those symptoms).
Sulphur and Merc. Sol. were necessary to clear presence of miasms.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
dear pankaj varma,
took prescribed medicines.energy level good,flatulence diminished and abdomen feels light.stiffness in the neck and shoulder reduced.awake very early in the morning with pain somewhere along the right hip nerve and around late morning intoxicated feeling which goes off with rise of the day always feel better towards the evening and night.the gums swelling has subsided with a very mild pain while chewing in the previously swollen gums.with your advice after a long long time i have started feeling better and i hope i will be cured.thank you and god bless you.
sanvar
took prescribed medicines.energy level good,flatulence diminished and abdomen feels light.stiffness in the neck and shoulder reduced.awake very early in the morning with pain somewhere along the right hip nerve and around late morning intoxicated feeling which goes off with rise of the day always feel better towards the evening and night.the gums swelling has subsided with a very mild pain while chewing in the previously swollen gums.with your advice after a long long time i have started feeling better and i hope i will be cured.thank you and god bless you.
sanvar
sanvar last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.