Another try to mt chronic throat problem. Help please _{Page 12 of 13}

hehe :)

thanks

Space them by 3 hours.

Silica is multi-miasmatic (i.e. it can hit multiple miasms) , but it is one of the few remedies we have for the 'Tubercular miasm' which seems to be the dominant miasm or the most active miasm in your case.

Miasmatic consideration helps us eradicate the root cause of chronic diseases.

Perhaps, Dr. Organon can explain more.

Dear Joaquin,
The other guys are too eager to help you.

Let them finsih...if they don't succeed....will take over.

Best wishes
Pankaj Varma

I've been following this thread and wanted to point out something that I think is important in this case that I have not seen anyone comment on. The first time I read the pts questionnaire posted on pg 4 of this thread I noticed 2 life events that the pt said affected this illness.

Here's the quote:

'My problem is recurrent rhinopharyngitis (or so called by physicians). It began 16 years ago approx. when I started University. At the beginning I thought it was a normal thing, because everybody has sore throat sometimes, but one day climbing a mountain with my friends (it was cold and snowing) I could see how all of them overtake me going to peak, even two who used to smoke very often. I felt there was not enough air for me. The next day I was on bed with fever and with infection in my throat.
I thought ok, it was cold, I sweat (because I sweat very easily, even in winter), then I catched a cold.
In this period I passed all autumn-winter seasons with a simple pullover, now I must wear a coat, a scarf, gloves and I know, more or less, when I will fall ill again.'
...
'Owing to this allergic tests, a doctor sent a vaccine, but at third dose my body reacted worse than before (approx 9 years ago).'

He says that this started 16 yrs ago when he began college. Then he says that it got worse 9 yrs ago when he was given a vaccine (allergy shot?), the 3rd in a series.

Joaquin, can you say more about what happened to you 16 yrs ago? Did you get a series of vaccinations or anything to attend collge? Something happened to you at that time to cause your health to decline. It is even possible that it was merely the stress of moving away from home or of studying for classes. Another possibility is the climate or other environmental factors like the building you slept in or spent a lot of time in. Think about it a little.

It appears that the worsening of your condition may have occured 9 yrs ago when you received a 'vaccination' was this a series of allergy shots? These are commonly used by classical allergists to treat allergies. Some say they work; some say otherwise. Some say they increase their health problems.

These major life/health changing events should be important to those working on your case.

Orgeno...In one of the posts.....some one called you 'arrogant' mate.....

Look for the medicine for that...for your self.

As per your own words you are very capable.....

Dear Joaquin,

My recommendation was Silicea 30C, and I think Dr. Organon also agreed with the same.

Taking it as 3 doses 3 hour apart is a gentler way, than taking 3, 30C doses spaced at half hour.

All discussions here are pointless if you finally don't take the remedy. You have to take it to see if it works.

We can only tell if Nit-ac is needed later after you take Sil. No one here can predict the exact course of an illness or the sequence of remedies needed. Part of homeopathy is about careful observation and not prejudicing your self to pre-conceived 'planned' remedies.

Sameer.

Okay, good luck !

Hi Joaquin

This is the risk you have to face when being treated on the net. The prescriber may disappear/ be forced to leave due to hundred and one reasons.

Finally, it is patients like you who are in the middle of treatment who are going to suffer.

I understand you are in touch with a homeopath. can you discuss these remedy suggestions with him? Better still, if you can make him read this thread, by taking a print out to him.

He has seen you, and observed you. We didn't. It really makes a lot of difference for homeopathic prescribing.

One thing is for sure. Your hernia is not going to diappear in a week ot two. Even with correct medicines ,it is going to take time.

Think about continuing with your present homeopath. You can always discuss the progress of the caase here.

Murthy

Hi Joaquin,

'Dr' Organon was suspended for the way he addressed other members. I make no judgement as to his effectiveness as a homeopath, merely that his presence here was not going to keep the peace.

He joined with a series of different email addresses, so I have no idea which, if any, he looks at. You can contact him through his site:

organonhomoeopathy.forumup.com

Best Wishes,
Simon

Joaquin,
You asked me to help.
I am watching this thread every day and reading every post.
Will step in at an appropriate time.

Post more details about your hernia problem.

Best wishes,
Pankaj Varma

'Man is deriving innumerable benefits from Nature and enjoying the amenities provided by it in various ways. But what is the gratitude he is offering to Nature and God? Man is forgetting the Divine who is the Sole Provider of everything. This is the reason for his falling prey to various difficulties and calamities. While he is receiving countless benefits from Providence , he is offering nothing in return to Nature or God. This shows how unnatural and heartless man's behaviour is. When we are enjoined to return good for evil, how unbecoming is it to fail even to return good for good? Man should learn the great lesson Nature is trying to teach him - the lesson of doing service with no expectation of return.'

Sai Baba

Dear Joaquin,

Whether one believes in Sai Baba or not, this is the truth of life.

And I am a follower of Sai Baba.

If you are not satisfied with the advice given by others, I will come back.

Pankaj Varma

Pankaj

Please avoid bringing up yet another controversy by bringing up Sai Baba once again.

You were restrained in that aspect for a long time and please keep it that way.

This site won't miss these teachings I believe. There are many sites for propagating the teachings of Babas.

Murthy

Gavini,
If you don't like such posts ...you can ignore them and move on to the next.

Some people like them coz they are able to understand the belief pattern you 'are coming from' !!

Dr.Beek is also posting his belief patterns here. He thinks a man will not fall sick if he forgives others for their mistakes. (See his latest post from...Alexthink).

As per his theory....you are in the high risk zone....if you have to find faults with every post.

For your own sake ...ignore a few things in life...

Pankaj Varma

The concluding remark from Alexthink in that post:

Quote
I repeat over and over again: man was given a brain for a reason, not for decoration. Think about what is said here and draw your own conclusions. Forgive your stresses – it isn’t necessary to go chasing after whoever you think is the cause of your troubles, look inside.
Forgiveness is the key.
Regards,
Dr.Beek

Unquote

Dear Joaquin and all others who are reading this thread,


It is easy to pick up the basic teachings of homeopathy from books and then cut and paste them here.
A lot is available on the net.

Many new comers here get impressed with that kind of stuff.

The typical reaction is 'Ah ha! These guys are quite knowledgeable about what they are dealing in !'

But....but...when it comes to actually handling peoples problems ....many of those people lack experience....and fumble with the cases.

That is what is happening here.

Talking of concensus in selecting the remedy ....one is reminded of the well known joke:

7 brothers of varying heights ventured to cross a river. The river water level was 5 ft from the river bed. Whereas the average height of the brothers was 5 ft 6 inches.

So the eldest said 'fine !...lets go ahead'.

When they crossed over..... to their utter dismay.....they discovered that three brothers were missing.

Don't rely on averages all the time !!

Pankaj Varma

Dr. Sunny Bakshi is a well known homeopath and a well qualified homeopath in New Delhi.

He has earned a lot of awards and medals for his skills in homeopathy. Those are diiplayed in his clinic in NDSE, New Delhi.

He is the owner of Baksons... a well known manufacturer of homeo meds.

If a patient visits his clinic, he / she is first interviewed by a full fledged qualified BHMS homeopathic doctor (junior).....who makes a detailed report on the patient's problem and suggestions for the med(s) to be given.

Then the patient has to wait. When his /her turn comes.... he /she is taken to
Dr. Sunny Bakshi.

Many times Dr. Bakshi changes the recommendation of the med(s) and is seen guiding his junior doctors about the change.

This is just to let you know that.... fully qualified doctors also make mistakes.

There is no substitute for experience. Mere knowledge of books is not enough.

Pankaj Varma