The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Need cure from Chronic Anal Fissure Page 2 of 5
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hello,
Two weeks is gonna end tomorrow. problems are still persisting. Any further advice what I should do? I am actually a bit tired because I have been trying homeopathy for last 7 months but no improvement so far. Your kind advice is greatly appreciable in this regard. thanks
Two weeks is gonna end tomorrow. problems are still persisting. Any further advice what I should do? I am actually a bit tired because I have been trying homeopathy for last 7 months but no improvement so far. Your kind advice is greatly appreciable in this regard. thanks
mohin1 last decade
♡ Joe De Livera last decade
Hi Mohin-
I noticed you also posted on Nawaz's thread for this.
You have a choice here-
You can try the Aloe prescribed by Zady on this thread.
You can go to http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/407924
and work with Fitness and try the Graphites 200c that he suggested.
Please chose and work with one person.
Thanks,
Simone717
I noticed you also posted on Nawaz's thread for this.
You have a choice here-
You can try the Aloe prescribed by Zady on this thread.
You can go to http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/407924
and work with Fitness and try the Graphites 200c that he suggested.
Please chose and work with one person.
Thanks,
Simone717
♡ simone717 last decade
hello simone,
thank you for your advice. you are right. I actually wanted the advice of daktarsaab. but since he is not available at the moment, I asked few other doctors. hope I did not offend anyone.
thank you for your advice. you are right. I actually wanted the advice of daktarsaab. but since he is not available at the moment, I asked few other doctors. hope I did not offend anyone.
mohin1 last decade
No, but Fitness and Zady have already spent time studying-
I would let Nawaz know right away so he does not
go study your case also and then you pick someone else-
this takes a lot of time-
I know having Zady and Fitness both prescribe was
not intentional, so I would ask one of them to go ahead
with you and not have Nawaz study unless for sure
you are going to go with him and know that now.
I would let Nawaz know right away so he does not
go study your case also and then you pick someone else-
this takes a lot of time-
I know having Zady and Fitness both prescribe was
not intentional, so I would ask one of them to go ahead
with you and not have Nawaz study unless for sure
you are going to go with him and know that now.
♡ simone717 last decade
thank you for the wise input. in that case I would request you to advice me with whom should I continue, in terms of medical expertise and experience. I think you can suggest me since I am a bit new in this forum. thanks a lot again.
mohin1 last decade
Hi- Zady and Fitness are both very good homeopaths and they already studied
your case- remember no two homeopaths will look at a case the same way.
Either one of them will do a fine job, so I suggest you flip a coin.
Just let Nawaz know you don't need his help, so he does
not do any work.
Best,
Simone717
[message edited by simone717 on Tue, 25 Feb 2014 23:33:44 GMT]
your case- remember no two homeopaths will look at a case the same way.
Either one of them will do a fine job, so I suggest you flip a coin.
Just let Nawaz know you don't need his help, so he does
not do any work.
Best,
Simone717
[message edited by simone717 on Tue, 25 Feb 2014 23:33:44 GMT]
♡ simone717 last decade
The problem here is that we hardly have any kind of case for prescribing on. If your previous homoeopaths were prescribing on the kind of information you have given here, it is no wonder you have failed to get any kind of relief.
The questionnaire that has been used here is not appropriate for providing a good homoeopathic case. There are far too many leading questions which pervert the kind of information you are providing to us. Many times I notice you simply answered the question in regards to the examples that are given, and this is a terrible method for eliciting symptoms.
It really needs to be updated and made more in line with homoeopathic philosophy for case-taking, rather than attempting to make it easy to find specific remedies.
Questions should be open, and we should only be using more directive confirming questions after a certain amount of spontaneous information has already been provided.
I can only find 2 peculiar symptoms given so far. The case really needs to be expanded on before any confident prescription can be made.
Perhaps if you can describe more about the following things, your case might open up a little more and provide some accurate directions towards curative medicines. There are a lot of cues for delving more deeply into your case, but nothing has been pursued as yet.
(Try to be very descriptive, especially discussing what makes the condition worse, what makes it better, when it happens, and anything that tends to occur alongside or at the same time. Short answers are not good answers in homoeopathy)
Depression (this is probably the most important symptom in the case, if we can get enough information about it, feelings, thoughts, behaviours, what makes it worse and better, when it occurs and so on)
Emotional character
Silent character
Excitement during a thunderstorm (exactly what is this feeling)
Exactly what external stimuli are you sensitive to, and what is your reaction?
Do you have any negative feelings towards your family, or they towards you?
Does your attachment to them cause any kind of problem?
What are your fears?
Even if your dreams do not repeat, are there any themes, images, or patterns to them?
Why can you not eat spicy or sweet things much?
What is your stool like when it is not normal?
How easily do you get back to sleep after being woken by slight noise? How slight would the noise need to be to wake you?
If you feel being honest, thoughtful, caring and keeping your word makes you different from others, how do you see other people?
Describe more on your Shyness
That may provide us with a better quality of symptoms for suggesting a medicine.
The questionnaire that has been used here is not appropriate for providing a good homoeopathic case. There are far too many leading questions which pervert the kind of information you are providing to us. Many times I notice you simply answered the question in regards to the examples that are given, and this is a terrible method for eliciting symptoms.
It really needs to be updated and made more in line with homoeopathic philosophy for case-taking, rather than attempting to make it easy to find specific remedies.
Questions should be open, and we should only be using more directive confirming questions after a certain amount of spontaneous information has already been provided.
I can only find 2 peculiar symptoms given so far. The case really needs to be expanded on before any confident prescription can be made.
Perhaps if you can describe more about the following things, your case might open up a little more and provide some accurate directions towards curative medicines. There are a lot of cues for delving more deeply into your case, but nothing has been pursued as yet.
(Try to be very descriptive, especially discussing what makes the condition worse, what makes it better, when it happens, and anything that tends to occur alongside or at the same time. Short answers are not good answers in homoeopathy)
Depression (this is probably the most important symptom in the case, if we can get enough information about it, feelings, thoughts, behaviours, what makes it worse and better, when it occurs and so on)
Emotional character
Silent character
Excitement during a thunderstorm (exactly what is this feeling)
Exactly what external stimuli are you sensitive to, and what is your reaction?
Do you have any negative feelings towards your family, or they towards you?
Does your attachment to them cause any kind of problem?
What are your fears?
Even if your dreams do not repeat, are there any themes, images, or patterns to them?
Why can you not eat spicy or sweet things much?
What is your stool like when it is not normal?
How easily do you get back to sleep after being woken by slight noise? How slight would the noise need to be to wake you?
If you feel being honest, thoughtful, caring and keeping your word makes you different from others, how do you see other people?
Describe more on your Shyness
That may provide us with a better quality of symptoms for suggesting a medicine.
♡ Evocationer last decade
Hello Evocationer,
Thank you for reviewing the case. Here are the info you wanted.
Depression (this is probably the most important symptom in the case, if we can get enough information about it, feelings, thoughts, behaviours, what makes it worse and better, when it occurs and so on)
--- There are two kinds of depression that happens to me. One is for the anal fissure and cyst in scrotum. Other is for my personal issues like business and relations. I will elaborate one by one.
As for the fissure and cyst, I become depressed when the problem increases or not curing. Fissure is affecting my work life since i can not sit properly or for a long time. I can not excersise or even run. Also I am not sure if it's curable with homeopathy. And I really dont want to go for surgery. I can not plan for marriage because I have lost the confidence because of fissure and cyst. When I think about these issues, I become depressed. Also try to imagine someone who is standing for the most part of the day. Even when sleeping, i can not lie down straight.
And for the business and personal matters, depression does not come easily as it comes for the fissure and cyst. usually I am a patient person but when the business goes down and for example,i have fight with my fiance, all the issues combine together and depression comes on.
When I am depressed, people can easily understand it by looking at my face. My face becomes pale and I loose weight when it goes for a long time. I also feel like giving up everything when depression happens, I lose my temper easily and shout sometime though I regret it later.
Emotional character
--- I am very emotional. Though I dont like to show off. I am mostly emotional about my fiance and my family. If problem happens in these two cases, it affects me mentally. I like to help people and appreciate their kind words.
Silent character
--- I am not much of a talker with everyone. I usually like to listen to what people want to say. Thats one reason why people share even their secrets with me. I like quite environment and dont like noise. I am not a clean freak but i dont like dirty things and dirty people. Specially who have smelly mouth or smelly sweat.
Excitement during a thunderstorm (exactly what is this feeling)
-- Its hard to explain. Thunderstorm means a possibility of rain or storm. I like both of them. Sometime thunderstorm makes me shiver too but the excitement part is more.
Exactly what external stimuli are you sensitive to, and what is your reaction?
-- Can you please make this question more clear?
Do you have any negative feelings towards your family, or they towards you?
-- Sometime I have negative feelings toward my family. It happens when they fail to understand or they behave rudely or when they shout. But it goes away eventually.
Does your attachment to them cause any kind of problem?
-- Sometime I can not take independent decision because of them. For example, if I want to settle abroad, this attachment will cause a problem for me.
What are your fears?
-- I fear of losing my credibility to people, losing my honor. I also fear of losing my fiance.
Even if your dreams do not repeat, are there any themes, images, or patterns to them?
-- I have not found any pattern so far.
Why can you not eat spicy or sweet things much?
-- I like them very much, but if I start eating much, my body does not allow. I either have vomiting feelings or acidity.
What is your stool like when it is not normal?
-- It becomes hard or bigger in size. Sometimes it becomes very soft which also causes problem for the fissure. In both cases, i feel burning sensation in the rectum. Sometime if I eat chocolate or chocolate pastry, stool becomes blackish.
How easily do you get back to sleep after being woken by slight noise? How slight would the noise need to be to wake you?
-- Its not very easy but not very hard either. Depends on how tired I was. Even the sound of a miscall can wake me up.
If you feel being honest, thoughtful, caring and keeping your word makes you different from others, how do you see other people?
-- I would like the same behavior from other people too. But if by any chance I dont see it, I consider myself better than them.
Describe more on your Shyness
-- I am shy around the girls, sometime I feel nervous. I used to be a good public speaker, but lately i have lost my confidence. I feel shy to say NO to anyone. If I give loan, I feel shy to ask for it.
regards
Thank you for reviewing the case. Here are the info you wanted.
Depression (this is probably the most important symptom in the case, if we can get enough information about it, feelings, thoughts, behaviours, what makes it worse and better, when it occurs and so on)
--- There are two kinds of depression that happens to me. One is for the anal fissure and cyst in scrotum. Other is for my personal issues like business and relations. I will elaborate one by one.
As for the fissure and cyst, I become depressed when the problem increases or not curing. Fissure is affecting my work life since i can not sit properly or for a long time. I can not excersise or even run. Also I am not sure if it's curable with homeopathy. And I really dont want to go for surgery. I can not plan for marriage because I have lost the confidence because of fissure and cyst. When I think about these issues, I become depressed. Also try to imagine someone who is standing for the most part of the day. Even when sleeping, i can not lie down straight.
And for the business and personal matters, depression does not come easily as it comes for the fissure and cyst. usually I am a patient person but when the business goes down and for example,i have fight with my fiance, all the issues combine together and depression comes on.
When I am depressed, people can easily understand it by looking at my face. My face becomes pale and I loose weight when it goes for a long time. I also feel like giving up everything when depression happens, I lose my temper easily and shout sometime though I regret it later.
Emotional character
--- I am very emotional. Though I dont like to show off. I am mostly emotional about my fiance and my family. If problem happens in these two cases, it affects me mentally. I like to help people and appreciate their kind words.
Silent character
--- I am not much of a talker with everyone. I usually like to listen to what people want to say. Thats one reason why people share even their secrets with me. I like quite environment and dont like noise. I am not a clean freak but i dont like dirty things and dirty people. Specially who have smelly mouth or smelly sweat.
Excitement during a thunderstorm (exactly what is this feeling)
-- Its hard to explain. Thunderstorm means a possibility of rain or storm. I like both of them. Sometime thunderstorm makes me shiver too but the excitement part is more.
Exactly what external stimuli are you sensitive to, and what is your reaction?
-- Can you please make this question more clear?
Do you have any negative feelings towards your family, or they towards you?
-- Sometime I have negative feelings toward my family. It happens when they fail to understand or they behave rudely or when they shout. But it goes away eventually.
Does your attachment to them cause any kind of problem?
-- Sometime I can not take independent decision because of them. For example, if I want to settle abroad, this attachment will cause a problem for me.
What are your fears?
-- I fear of losing my credibility to people, losing my honor. I also fear of losing my fiance.
Even if your dreams do not repeat, are there any themes, images, or patterns to them?
-- I have not found any pattern so far.
Why can you not eat spicy or sweet things much?
-- I like them very much, but if I start eating much, my body does not allow. I either have vomiting feelings or acidity.
What is your stool like when it is not normal?
-- It becomes hard or bigger in size. Sometimes it becomes very soft which also causes problem for the fissure. In both cases, i feel burning sensation in the rectum. Sometime if I eat chocolate or chocolate pastry, stool becomes blackish.
How easily do you get back to sleep after being woken by slight noise? How slight would the noise need to be to wake you?
-- Its not very easy but not very hard either. Depends on how tired I was. Even the sound of a miscall can wake me up.
If you feel being honest, thoughtful, caring and keeping your word makes you different from others, how do you see other people?
-- I would like the same behavior from other people too. But if by any chance I dont see it, I consider myself better than them.
Describe more on your Shyness
-- I am shy around the girls, sometime I feel nervous. I used to be a good public speaker, but lately i have lost my confidence. I feel shy to say NO to anyone. If I give loan, I feel shy to ask for it.
regards
mohin1 last decade
Exactly what external stimuli are you sensitive to, and what is your reaction?
-- Can you please make this question more clear?
When you answered this question previously, you just said 'Yes I am'. What I am asking is - to what are you sensitive. Just saying 'yes' is not enough information.
External stimuli is anything that comes from the outside, to which you have a strong reaction, positive or negative. You have already spoken of Thunderstorms and Noise. So, is there anything else?
-- Can you please make this question more clear?
When you answered this question previously, you just said 'Yes I am'. What I am asking is - to what are you sensitive. Just saying 'yes' is not enough information.
External stimuli is anything that comes from the outside, to which you have a strong reaction, positive or negative. You have already spoken of Thunderstorms and Noise. So, is there anything else?
♡ Evocationer last decade
Ok there are a few choices of remedies I believe, based on the answers you have given.
I believe Staphysagria is the first choice based on the following:
Angers easily but feels bad about their anger
Suppressed emotions, sensitive emotionally but tends not to show it
Ailments from rudeness, wounded honour
Yielding disposition, unable to say no
Feels better than others who are not acting in an honourable way
Timidity when interacting with women
Fear of separation from spouse/partner
Fear to appear in public
Desire to be treated gently, kindly
There is some differentiation here with Sulphur and Lycopodium as well, but overall I feel the case best suits Staph.
Are you able to get hold of 200c, or 30c if that is not available?
I believe Staphysagria is the first choice based on the following:
Angers easily but feels bad about their anger
Suppressed emotions, sensitive emotionally but tends not to show it
Ailments from rudeness, wounded honour
Yielding disposition, unable to say no
Feels better than others who are not acting in an honourable way
Timidity when interacting with women
Fear of separation from spouse/partner
Fear to appear in public
Desire to be treated gently, kindly
There is some differentiation here with Sulphur and Lycopodium as well, but overall I feel the case best suits Staph.
Are you able to get hold of 200c, or 30c if that is not available?
♡ Evocationer last decade
thank you for your kind advice. Let me check with the local store. please give me detailed instruction on how to take the remedy- time,doses,restrictions,etc.
thanks again.
thanks again.
mohin1 last decade
If you are able, get a liquid potency.
Post again when you have the remedy and I will give you instructions.
Post again when you have the remedy and I will give you instructions.
♡ Evocationer last decade
hello,
I have got the medicine u told to collect. Its in liquid form and 200c. Let me know further instruction please.
I have got the medicine u told to collect. Its in liquid form and 200c. Let me know further instruction please.
mohin1 last decade
Alright. I only want you to take ONE dose to begin with. Follow these instructions.
Hit the bottom of the bottle against the palm of your hand very firmly, 3 times. Place 3 drops into 200 ml of clean water in a cup and stir thoroughly. Take 2 teaspoons out of this water into your mouth and hold there for 20 seconds, then swallow. Throw the water in the cup out.
That is one dose. Wait 3 days and let me know what kind of response you have had. I do not want you to repeat the remedy until I tell you to do so.
Good luck.
Hit the bottom of the bottle against the palm of your hand very firmly, 3 times. Place 3 drops into 200 ml of clean water in a cup and stir thoroughly. Take 2 teaspoons out of this water into your mouth and hold there for 20 seconds, then swallow. Throw the water in the cup out.
That is one dose. Wait 3 days and let me know what kind of response you have had. I do not want you to repeat the remedy until I tell you to do so.
Good luck.
♡ Evocationer last decade
thank you very much.
Can you please tell me what kind of reaction I should be expecting? should I take it in empty stomach or not?what kind of food will I avoid?
And I forgot to ask you, is this for the anal fissure or cyst? thanks again.
Can you please tell me what kind of reaction I should be expecting? should I take it in empty stomach or not?what kind of food will I avoid?
And I forgot to ask you, is this for the anal fissure or cyst? thanks again.
mohin1 last decade
You do not need to avoid any food or drink, and you do not need to have an empty stomach. Our remedies do not work like conventional drugs and are absorbed in a different way.
The remedy is prescribed for the overall state you presented. In homoeopathy we try not to prescribe just on the local symptoms (the ones in specific locations of the body) unless there is something very peculiar about them. We treat the disturbance in the vital force, which is reflected in the mental, emotional, and general state of the person. By doing this, the vital force then goes to work to cure those local symptoms.
I would expect that the first thing that would happen is that you would feel an aggravation of symptoms - it may be just a few or all of your symptoms (including the emotional ones). After that I would expect that there would be a feeling of being generally better, even if the physical symptoms remain slightly worse or the same. Over time that improvement should flow down into the physical symptoms as well, which may happen with or without further doses of the remedy.
Aggravation usually starts within 1-2 days, peaks around 3-5 days, and should be noticeably diminishing around 7 days. This is only a rough guideline and different people have different time frames for their responses.
The remedy is prescribed for the overall state you presented. In homoeopathy we try not to prescribe just on the local symptoms (the ones in specific locations of the body) unless there is something very peculiar about them. We treat the disturbance in the vital force, which is reflected in the mental, emotional, and general state of the person. By doing this, the vital force then goes to work to cure those local symptoms.
I would expect that the first thing that would happen is that you would feel an aggravation of symptoms - it may be just a few or all of your symptoms (including the emotional ones). After that I would expect that there would be a feeling of being generally better, even if the physical symptoms remain slightly worse or the same. Over time that improvement should flow down into the physical symptoms as well, which may happen with or without further doses of the remedy.
Aggravation usually starts within 1-2 days, peaks around 3-5 days, and should be noticeably diminishing around 7 days. This is only a rough guideline and different people have different time frames for their responses.
♡ Evocationer last decade
dear doctor,
I am reporting back since 3days have passed. I have noticed no significant changes so far. physical symptoms are same as before. only for cyst, 2 cyst have burst out. waiting for your kind suggestion. thanks
I am reporting back since 3days have passed. I have noticed no significant changes so far. physical symptoms are same as before. only for cyst, 2 cyst have burst out. waiting for your kind suggestion. thanks
mohin1 last decade
I have around 20 cysts, big and small. 2 of them have burst. And I think i am feeling a little better than before (anal fissure).
By the way, i have seen a thread of yours where you suggested a set of questions. I have prepared the answers. If you allow, i can post it for your convenience. thanks for the reply.
By the way, i have seen a thread of yours where you suggested a set of questions. I have prepared the answers. If you allow, i can post it for your convenience. thanks for the reply.
mohin1 last decade
Yes I would appreciate that, so that if this prescription does not work as well as I hope, I can suggest another that is more suitable.
The reason I wanted you to report at 3 days is to assess whether your reaction is too great. This has not been the case, so what I would like you to do is wait until 7 days have passed, and then we will do an assessment of all symptoms to see what kind of changes are taking place.
The reason I wanted you to report at 3 days is to assess whether your reaction is too great. This has not been the case, so what I would like you to do is wait until 7 days have passed, and then we will do an assessment of all symptoms to see what kind of changes are taking place.
♡ Evocationer last decade
hello,
I think its been 6days since I took the medicine.
Here is the link for the questions I answerd.
abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/421660/
Thanks
I think its been 6days since I took the medicine.
Here is the link for the questions I answerd.
abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/421660/
Thanks
mohin1 last decade
hello,
today is the 8th day since I took the medicine.
one thing I forgot to mention in the answers. sometime I feel a vein or lump type thing (not sure) in the adjacent walls around the main wound (thin small flesh) of the anus. after every stool, I can feel it more if I touch that area. I am really worried if its the symptom of anal fistula ! waiting for your kind suggestion.
today is the 8th day since I took the medicine.
one thing I forgot to mention in the answers. sometime I feel a vein or lump type thing (not sure) in the adjacent walls around the main wound (thin small flesh) of the anus. after every stool, I can feel it more if I touch that area. I am really worried if its the symptom of anal fistula ! waiting for your kind suggestion.
mohin1 last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.