≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum



Similar posts:

Whether Symphytum Officinale antidotes Cantharis? 2Remedy that Antidotes all other remedies and aggravations? 2does coffee antidotes Silicea?? 3Antidotes 2What Antidotes Silicea 30C and other antidote.questions 1Mercurius Antidotes Thuja 1Kali Sulph 6x Antidotes Pulsatilla 30C? 2does nux vomica antidotes all allopathic medicines? 2Coffee Smell in Office antidotes my remedy 61is there a remedy that antidotes all remedies? 2


The ABC Homeopathy Forum


Hi is it true that homeopathic remedies can antidote one another or is it an ancient thing?
  a.jaffryhotmail.com on 2020-08-04
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Ancient thing means? Did you think it was a myth? :) No. Whenever a remedy creates unwanted symptoms and there needs to be intervention homeopaths would use anti dotes. Sometimes the remedies need not be listed anti dotes. Anti doting can also be done in more than one way.
maheeru 3 years ago
Ancient meaning it's old as the materia medica has old info from 2001. For example arsenic album and china should this be taken with half an hours difference as both of them usually cancel each other out as I saw on the materia medica website ?
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago
Anti doting is dynamic in homeopathy than something static or fixed. Some anti dotes may also be complementary. In that case the canceling effect won't be absolute. Here Ars and China are complementary to each other so they are not likely to cancel each other entirely. Unless there is a reason to give them both they can be tried separately.
maheeru 3 years ago
So in this case is it better to take arsenic and china together or separately ?
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago
I do not know the case so it'd be difficult to comment. When in doubt always do them separately to evaluate them individually. Let's say there is a blood loss due to some reason while taking Ars alb, china could be used to help with weakness considering it's an acute situation. In chronic states there is no such necessity.
maheeru 3 years ago
what do you mean by in "chronic cases there is no necessity" as in taking them together or separately ?
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago
Chronic is opposite to acute. Chronic states do not pose immediate threat like acutes. So in chronic states one need not use more than one medicine at a time or quick rotation to prevent worsening of a situation.
maheeru 3 years ago
right ok yes my condition is chronic. Hence why I thought arsenic should be taken individually to china. Usually are these remedies to be taken together with a gap of 15 to 30 mins in chronic conditions ?
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago
In acutes they need to be taken with a smaller gap like half an hour gap, but if your case is chronic there is no set rules. You can separate the remedies by matter of days or even weeks. But yes you could also separate them by a gap of a few hours like three, six or eight.
maheeru 3 years ago
Right ok so I completed taking arsenic and now I am taking china I separated this from each other because I didn't want either one to cancel each other one out. Hope that's ok ? Need some reassurance that what I am doing is correct.

Also, if I was to decide to take arsenic 30c first then China 30c with a 20 to 30 min gap three times a day would this also be fine? Or vice versa so china first then arsenic ?
[Edited by a.jaffryhotmail.com on 2020-08-08 17:33:40]
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago
Again difficult to comment on specifics without knowing the case. And I don't know why you are particular about repeating one and the other within 30 minutes gap but I have given some generic advice that you can always use to good effect.
[Edited by maheeru on 2020-08-08 19:28:42]
maheeru 3 years ago
Are you a homeopath ?
[Edited by a.jaffryhotmail.com on 2020-08-08 18:49:57]
a.jaffryhotmail.com 3 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.