The ABC Homeopathy Forum
proving Vs Aggravation Page 3 of 3
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
This is his concept of proving.
Quote
If you consume 8 to 10 spoons of common salt in the morning on empty stomach..you will 'prove'...Natrum Mur.
Unquote
and this man claims to be a homeopath.!!!
I rest my case here.
i have better things to do,than educating a person of this sort of caliber.
Quote
If you consume 8 to 10 spoons of common salt in the morning on empty stomach..you will 'prove'...Natrum Mur.
Unquote
and this man claims to be a homeopath.!!!
I rest my case here.
i have better things to do,than educating a person of this sort of caliber.
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Arnica 6C ....one dose every day does not cause 'proving'.....so stop lambasting Joe !!
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Re: The theory of suppression From Ryelink on 2006-10-24
could/would Arnica 6c taken indefinetely cause supression?
Re: The theory of suppression From generalmanager on 2006-10-24
It is possible.
say, a person who has hypertension uses Arnica,and if acts suppressively,he may get diabetes,which is the next tier.
If arnica is used for diabetis,and if acts suppresively,the person may get heart problems.
However,here the operative phrase is 'IF IT ACTS SUPPRESIVELY'.Though thereotically all medicines can suppress if used indiscriminately,the danger is more with deep acting medicines.
with short acting remedies like arnica the danger is less.
the maximum duration of action of Arnica is around a week, in ideal circumstances,and it is very likely that in majority of the cases,it is about a day,considering the very low potency of 6C.
So,even if you repeat arnica in 6c,particulary as a succussed water dose,daily,there may not be much harm,but, it is better to stop after a few weeks,assess the situation, and if it proved beneficial, stop it for the time being, and repeat it only when the same symptoms surface again.
could/would Arnica 6c taken indefinetely cause supression?
Re: The theory of suppression From generalmanager on 2006-10-24
It is possible.
say, a person who has hypertension uses Arnica,and if acts suppressively,he may get diabetes,which is the next tier.
If arnica is used for diabetis,and if acts suppresively,the person may get heart problems.
However,here the operative phrase is 'IF IT ACTS SUPPRESIVELY'.Though thereotically all medicines can suppress if used indiscriminately,the danger is more with deep acting medicines.
with short acting remedies like arnica the danger is less.
the maximum duration of action of Arnica is around a week, in ideal circumstances,and it is very likely that in majority of the cases,it is about a day,considering the very low potency of 6C.
So,even if you repeat arnica in 6c,particulary as a succussed water dose,daily,there may not be much harm,but, it is better to stop after a few weeks,assess the situation, and if it proved beneficial, stop it for the time being, and repeat it only when the same symptoms surface again.
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dear Murthy,
If i give some one nat mur specially for problems like shrieking, living in past, learning disabilty and also for constipation etc. After using the drug for sometime shrieking increases and continue, constipation also increases ... we may say its a good sign. but what will we say if it develops mouth blisters. As nat mur is also a treatment of mouth blisters ...that means its proving the drug?
But sometimes we know constipation itself develops mouth and tongue blister.
So we should consider whether blisters is another symtom developing of nat mur or its just outcome of constipation which is an aggravation of nat mur and it should consider a good sign.
What step one should take? Keep continuing the drug (i'm taking about very chronic case)?
or
Wait for some more time to see the result as you know in chronic case we need to wait for some more time.
(what if blisters stay only for 3-4 days and get okay after using ointment etc.)
Dipika
If i give some one nat mur specially for problems like shrieking, living in past, learning disabilty and also for constipation etc. After using the drug for sometime shrieking increases and continue, constipation also increases ... we may say its a good sign. but what will we say if it develops mouth blisters. As nat mur is also a treatment of mouth blisters ...that means its proving the drug?
But sometimes we know constipation itself develops mouth and tongue blister.
So we should consider whether blisters is another symtom developing of nat mur or its just outcome of constipation which is an aggravation of nat mur and it should consider a good sign.
What step one should take? Keep continuing the drug (i'm taking about very chronic case)?
or
Wait for some more time to see the result as you know in chronic case we need to wait for some more time.
(what if blisters stay only for 3-4 days and get okay after using ointment etc.)
Dipika
Dipika last decade
If it is an aggravation of the medicine, it should subside with in a week.
If the patient never had mouth ulcers in his life, and getting now,after administration of the medicine, it is an accessory symptom.
In both cases,you have to stop the medicine, and wait for atleast a week or two,and retake the case afterwards.
If the patient never had mouth ulcers in his life, and getting now,after administration of the medicine, it is an accessory symptom.
In both cases,you have to stop the medicine, and wait for atleast a week or two,and retake the case afterwards.
♡ gavinimurthy last decade
Dear Murthy,
I was taken Selenium-6 for one month and Selenium-30 weekly dose for another one month for my erectile disfunction and prostatic fluid secretion. But it result pain and inflammation in prostate, which disable erection.
For antidote this aggravation, I have taken Pulsatillah-30 two dose in the gap of two hours and get positive result within two days. My main aggravaion was pain in center of prostate, which has reduced by this antidote; and erection is enabled. But other aggravation like pain and tightness in left and right prostate still exist and also suffer urine urgency come in a second. In order to eliminate rest of these problems, I again took antidote (Pulsatilla) after one week in same way. But now the problems still exist, and my testicle was temporarily affected by antidote remedy.
Dear Doctor, can you please tell, what should I do now? Is the antidotes I already taken is enough for me and I have just to wait for results? Usually how many days needed to completely eliminate an aggravation?
Is it necessary to take the total dose and potency of antidote to be same as the potency and dose of original remedy which caused aggravation?
I was taken Selenium-6 for one month and Selenium-30 weekly dose for another one month for my erectile disfunction and prostatic fluid secretion. But it result pain and inflammation in prostate, which disable erection.
For antidote this aggravation, I have taken Pulsatillah-30 two dose in the gap of two hours and get positive result within two days. My main aggravaion was pain in center of prostate, which has reduced by this antidote; and erection is enabled. But other aggravation like pain and tightness in left and right prostate still exist and also suffer urine urgency come in a second. In order to eliminate rest of these problems, I again took antidote (Pulsatilla) after one week in same way. But now the problems still exist, and my testicle was temporarily affected by antidote remedy.
Dear Doctor, can you please tell, what should I do now? Is the antidotes I already taken is enough for me and I have just to wait for results? Usually how many days needed to completely eliminate an aggravation?
Is it necessary to take the total dose and potency of antidote to be same as the potency and dose of original remedy which caused aggravation?
patient25 last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.