≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum



Remedy Finder:




Posts about Eczema

Graphites & Eczema2My boy has eye twitching and cold eczema7Eczema9dyshidrotic eczema4Scrotal Eczema65 months old baby severe eczema9Eczema4My 7 yr old son seems to have eczema7Toddler with very dry skin and eczema40childhood eczema6


The ABC Homeopathy Forum

rishimba for jealous/eczema/asthmatic 5 year old


Please help us find the constitional remedy for my 5 year old daught. Physically, she is very slim, her legs and tummy heart all the time . Her tummy hurts every morning and her legs at night. She is very active and hyper and does not like to sit still. Even for colouring, she is does not do a neat job. She likes to put her little toys and clips in bags and purses and walk around with them to show people when we go out. Then she forgets them there. She also does not like it when we wear one of her clips. Yet she will sneakily come into my room or her sister's room and secretly take what she wants , even though we tried several times to explain that its no good. Then she takes the object and just puts it anywhere and half the time it's on the floor or stuffed in another bag. She is a jealous and insecure person but is curious and likes to ask definitions to words she does not know. She is a bright kid but does not have the patience to be told what to do. She gets a cough which exacerbates her asthma. Her asthma is more of a problem then eczema. Sh
s five but she wishes she was 15 years old.
  hemraj on 2008-09-30
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Dear Rishi,

Just wanted to request you to go through this thread as well before prescribing this case:


The poster has a certain track record you would like to be aware of ;)

sameervermani last decade
dear sameer,


she is your patient. its better you deal with this case. after all, you know more about the patient's backgorund and you would be the best person to prescribe the alternative remedy in case ars alb has not produced response.

rishimba last decade
Dear Rishi ,

I am not a patient of Sameer's and nor would I like to be. He should be discouraging a fellow person from seeking a second opinion. At first I had lots of respect for him but I have yet to see a successful treatment remedy for any chronic case that he has tackled. I have followed many of his cases and he has in fact made the patients much worse and what gets me is that he can justify his point of view so easily because of his way with words and people buy into it (including myself in the past). He cannot take any critism and I don't believe he is thinking about the welfare of the patient by discouraging someone else from looking at the case. He was so impatient that you might infact help me that he posted a second post saying that I have a track record. What track record do I have...that I am a caring parent and is desperately searching for someone that can help my family. Look at his track record and please show me chronic case which he has successfully treated.

I have read many of your cases Mr. Rishimba and am interested in your help right now if you could be so kind enough to help ...that would be a blessing.
hemraj last decade
Correction: The first line should be that he should not be discouraging......
hemraj last decade

So much of miasmatic baggage in the parent, no wonder the child is facing problems !

Mr/Ms hemraj, you need treatment for yourself first as such sly disparaging remarks for someone who offered to help you, are pointing to a strong problem with you.

And, are you really taking a second opinion ? you are just here to waste everyone's time, and I will have to warn my fellow prescribers about your old habits. The fact is you are suspicious about every prescriber that offers you help and do not have the conviction to follow anyone's advice and then start stooping to such slanderous remarks to haul yourself out of the bad reputation you have built for yourself. Treat yourself of paranoia first, learn some basic respect for prescribers, and then come here posting for your child. I feel sorry for your child as her treatment is being handled by such paranoid and ill-mannered parents.

Also, in future, before making such baseless allegations and questioning my prescriptions, just go through these links and if possible talk to my patients.

Some of cases where patients are suffering from chronic disorders are listed below (there are just examples, there are many more)









Either you are blind about the above cases or maybe you are plain delusional about me persecuting you and my patients. If you have the slightest of courtesy in you, I would expect at least a passing glance on these threads, and if you don't, I could not care less.

Good bye and god bless your child

sameervermani last decade


Since the posters happened to post just now, I thought you would like to add above 2 to the list as well :)
sameervermani last decade

I've just read five of the above links that you have posted and three of them were from the same family and rishimba had started the treatment and then you felt like taking over and the other one was about a headache and ear pain for about 1month (let me emphasize that one month is not chronic) . Let's look at some cases where the child is worse off or no better such as that of hemraj. And by the way you gave her a hard time everytime she second guessed your opinion. Who has ego here and who has issues here.

Sameer, the bottom line is you had no right to interfere when I was asking Rishimba. You have influenced Rishimba negatively and you know it will be on your shoulders.

I have no paranoia other than of people who do not like to be asked why they are prescribing certain things for my child . I think by the way that you responded you need to look at your ability to take critism and maybe controlling anger.

Thankyou so much for your help in the past.

I wish you all the best in helping others from here onwards.
hemraj last decade
Correction...Lets look at the case of Sadhna and her child, not hemraj.
hemraj last decade
Sadhna has never reported back, and her child is no worse off than when she started, the final prescription was that of Pulsatilla and she probably never tried it. It is always difficult to treat infants on the forum, and, especially with parents who have a problem with each and every prescription of yours hence I take utmost care to not to spoil cases even if I am not able to treat some of them. There is not even a single patient on this website who has been aggravated by my prescriptions, irrespective of whether they got cured or not. Any one is free to read Sadhna's case and can see that the child is no worse. Infact, anyone with a sound knowledge of homeopathy will tell you that the treatment there had been so badly messed up by previous homeopaths that, it was bound to take some time to clear it up. I am pretty sure, the final picture of Pulsatilla came out just because of careful watching of responses by waiting after single doses. Now, is that caution bad ?

By, the way I have posted 10 links above. Do not read just 3 of them and go on ranting slanderous remarks :). Read carefully and then talk.

Anyways, I have made my point.

sameervermani last decade
By the way, I went through all of them and they are not complex chronic cases. My remarks are not slanderous as well and I totally do not appreciate that word. I alway end with some positive and encouraging remarks and I get the feeling that when something not so good is said about you or happens to you...then it is a big event and that person is slanderous and you always seem to justify your answers. So be it.

So again thank you for your time. Continue helping others. God bless.

PS. I know that since you love having the last word that there will be a reply from you soon.
hemraj last decade
Also Sameer, for someone who is so thorough as you, in my previous post when I stated that I read 'five' of your posts , you took that to mean '3'. Why did you do that?
hemraj last decade
Also Sameer , as you are here to help others , you should not attack them personally. Calling us 'ill-mannered' and having baggage and slanderous are all personal remarks. My remarks were simply initially stating that you should not discourage others from helping me and how you can not take critism. Which is true. I'm sure anyone following yours posts will realize that instantly. As far as your manners, I can't comment as I don't know you personally and you have no right attacking me or my family personally. I have no baggage because I usually speak truthfully and and to the point.

You basically have succeeded in not allowing me a second opinion on my daughters treatment. Congrats!!!
hemraj last decade
Hahaha they are not complex chronic cases !

'12 year boy with ADHD'

'Help for chronic fatigue syndrome and joint pain'

'Extreme cravings during cold weather'

'Binge Eating'

'A child who has suffered from various problems since birth like acid reflux, blocked tear duct'

'Hayfever, frequent colds, stiff neck'

'Chronic Hypochondria'

'Mom needs help. (Depression for mom and problems for child)'

'Chronic nosebleeds'

I will let my patients tell me whether their problems were chronic or not. :)

You are more than welcome to get second or third or fourth opinions, but we always warn each other on this forum about patients who never post feedback and here just to waste time of the prescribers.

Rishi, please feel free to advise Mr. Hemnraj. He is not 'my' patient by any means.

And, Mr. hemraj, I said '3 cases' because you had a problem about 3 of them being from one family.
sameervermani last decade
Patient ID: Sex: Age:

Please answer the following questions in a descriptive manner after careful analysis and recollection of previous experiences and happenings.

1. Describe your main suffering?

2. What other physical sufferings do you have in your body?

3. What mental sufferings / feelings do you have associated with your physical sufferings?

4. What exactly do you feel when you are at your worst?

5. When did it all start? Can you connect it to any past event or disease?

6. Which time of the day you are worst?

7. What are the things which aggravate your suffering and which are those which ameliorate the same?

8. Do your think your sufferings have relation to any external stimuli (like, change of place) or any internal biological changes in the body, like, menses (in females)?

9. When do you feel better, during hot weather or cold weather, humid or dry weather?

10. Describe your general mental set up? Are you Moody, Arrogant, Mild, Agreeable Changeable, Nervous, Suspicious, Easily offended, Quiet, Arguing, Irritating, Lazy etc.

- How do you feel before or during a thunderstorm?
- Do you like being consoled during your tough times?
- Are you sensitive to external stimuli like smell, noise, light etc?
- Do you have any typical habit or gesture like nail biting, causeless
weeping, talking to one self etc?
- How do you feel about your friends, family, your children and especially your husband / wife?

11. What are your fears and do you dream of any situation repeatedly?

12. What do you crave for in food items and what are your aversions?

13. How is your thirst: Less, Normal or Excessive?

14. How if your hunger: Less, Normal or Excessive?

15. Is there any kind of food which your body can’t stand?

16. Is your sweat normal or less or more? Where does it sweat more: Head, Trunk or Limbs?

17. How is your bowel movement and stool type?

18. How well do you sleep? Do you have a particular posture of sleeping?

19. Do you think you are able to satisfy your sexual desires in general?

20. What peculiar or strange sensation do you have in any part of your body at times? Do you sometimes feel ‘ as if…..’ in some part of the body?

21. What medications have been taken earlier by you to treat the diseases and do you have any particular symptom surfacing after the medication?

22. What major diseases are running in your family?

23. Describe, how do you look like? Describe your overall appearance.


If you are not having normal menstrual cycles, please answer the following questions:

- Are the periods early, regular or late in general? How long do they last?
- Do you suffer from any kind of physical or mental discomfort before, during or after the periods?
- Is the flow scanty, normal or excessive?
- Is the blood thick bright red or pale watery?
- Do you notice any clots in the flow?
BeginningHomeopath last decade

I dont mean to offend anyone out here but I have taken the advise of sameer as well as Rishimba. I feel that both are pretty good and both of them are out here for a good cause.If there has been something positive with I guess I would need to let people know. I was suffering from Hypochondria for about 3 years on and off and I should say that after a single dose of Ars Alb I am feeling much better. I dont think I am well qualified to judge a doctor or remedy but as long as it has worked for me it helps. I am also consulting sameer and rishimba for the problem with my wife and I am sure whatsoever remedy would be suggested by either of them after going through the post will help cure her fibroids. I have a great deal of respect for sameer/rishimba and not to forget Dr Murthy. I guess no one comes with an intention of spoiling the health of a fellow individual whom he does not know. The remedy as such may depend on how well you describe the symptoms . hence blaming someone for a wrong remedy etc is not in lines with the purpose of this forum.
umeshrajesh72 last decade
I also encourage all here to be kind to one another. Everyone here is here for the purpose of helping others with our knowledge and experience.

Homeopathy does the healing. We are merely helpers.

I have high respect for Sameer who has given excellent advice in several cases, and helped me remedy a dosing problem. There are other homeopaths here who are also offering great advice and healing patients.

Please calm down, present the information of the case carefully and accurately using the form posted.

The correct remedy taken correctly can bring tremendous good.
BeginningHomeopath last decade
dear hemraj,

everyone including yourself has the right to get a second opinion on your daughter's problem. me or any body else would definitely help you as we all prescribers are here to serve.

when we talk about rights, we should not forget the duties of the patients towards the prescribers. as a prescriber, all i would like from you to give me regular feedback and response of the patient after the suggested remedy is taken.

this gives the direction to the prescriber for follow up treatment. i have noticed that you didnt post a feedback after sameer's suggestion of ars alb.

sameer is a competent prescriber and i do not think his prescriptions would ever cause an aggravation.

i refrained from taking up your case because i also felt that ars alb was the indicated remedy and unless a response feedback is provided to the prescriber, ethically, no other prescriber should take the case.
rishimba last decade
Thanks Rishi, Beginning, and Umesh.
sameervermani last decade
I really wish you would meet my daugther and grandchildren since SAMEER has helped all of them to a new much much better life. There is no healing help to get anywhere for kids with ADHD but homeopathy as far as I know and Mr. Sameer handle them all very very carefully. They are nowadays happy, full of positive energy and do the school very fine. Also my daughter has got a new life.
Btw I am also much better since I started to follow Sameer´s description.
Mammiz last decade

Let me tell a true little story, which will perhaps make you feel a little better.

I once met a homeopath with the best bedside manner ever. She was nice, kind, pleasant, personable, and friendly.

She misunderstood the patient, telling and told them that they had the typhoid miasm (which doesn't even exist) and prescribed the incorrect dose of the incorrect medicine in the incorrect way. When the patient had more trouble, she was very nice and told them they should wait through the aggravation she had caused.

That patient was smart enough to bring their case to a real good homeopath.

This lady found another homeopath who was rude, arrogant, quick, short tempered, and gave the patient the correct remedy absolutely correctly. This lady took the remedy correctly and is now a happy, healthy, productive, joyous being who I see on occasion.

This just goes to show that it is the correctness of the choice of remedy and the correctness of how it is given that heals in homeopathy.

I suggest you begin a new topic, present your case with the form presented, and follow your little child to the health and happiness that they deserve.
BeginningHomeopath last decade
Dear all of you,

I encourage all here to be kind to one another. This forum is unique and everyone that is prescribing here is of course doing this in purpose to helping others.

My whole family is being helped by Sameer and we all are progressing well. We are very thankful and it´s amazing that this can be done over the internet. I realize that it would be much easier if we were able to see each other but anyway the results are remarkable.

The most remarkable case is my 12 year old son that has had ADHD (not now :)). I wish you all could see his change...And all this has happened in a few months...he is now doing well in school and is a happy boy. Maybe he is not fully cured yet, new layers may arise but as long as we have Sameer I don´t worry :)

My own case is also a chronically condition since I´ve been sick for about 10 years. In about 6 months I´ve gone from not having an active life at all, spending a lot of time in bed and not being able to do things I like, to having almost full spirit now. I am enjoying life again. My condition has improved very much, I would say a 75% cure so far...Sameer picked my constitution remedy at once, Phosphorus, and this remedy took me this far. For now we are trying to peel off the last layers...

My youngest son and my husband are also being helped here by Sameer and I´m sure that these cases will proceed soon. It´s really a detective work with homeopathy and I know that Sameer puts a lot effort in our cases.

My mother is another chronic case that is receiving guidance from Sameer. Curing chronic cases (25 years of illness) won´t be done in a couple of months but yet she is improving a lot...

I appreciate the careful and slow process that Sameer is applying. The aggravations are minimized and it feels very safe.

Best wishes Pia
Tintintin last decade
To all those in support of Sameer, do you think it was right for him to state that 'he feels sorry for my child as her treatment is being handled by such paranoid and ill-mannered parents' and to say that my 'child is facing problems because of my baggage'...and also to state that I have made 'slanderous remarks'. Those were all totally rude and unnecessary remarks. If you read my first post in which both Dr. Tahira and Sameer responded , I went with Sameer. Dr. Tahira simply stated then I go with someone as qualified as Sameer. Basically she left it at that. She was upset but there were no personal attacks. I did not attack Sameer's personal character...I simply stated he should not be discouraging others from looking at my case which he clearly was. And I 'm sure whether you all will admit or not he does not like to be second guessed. But I always wished him well and I know as a parent with a child with allergies or any other health issues a parent is never truly happy until his/her child is better. Every time a child is helped , I feel very happy for the child and the family as children are truly the most innocent and beautiful creatures in the world.
hemraj last decade
Beginning Homeopath,

Thank you for somewhat seeing how I feel. Your post which sort of comments on bedside manners and hints towards someone who does not have any bedside manners (you used much stronger words) shows me that I can trust you.
hemraj last decade
'I have followed many of his cases and he has in fact made the patients much worse and what gets me is that he can justify his point of view so easily because of his way with words and people buy into it (including myself in the past).'

'He cannot take any critism and I don't believe he is thinking about the welfare of the patient'

' Look at his track record and please show me chronic case which he has successfully treated. '

^^^^ This Mr. Hemraj was personal enough an attack for me, and hence the response.

Do not try to run for cover now in my response. You started it.
sameervermani last decade
Mr. Sameer, I have never stated that you do not care about the welfare of your patients... why are you misleading your readers and patients. My sentence states that 'you are not caring about the welfare of your patients by discouraging someone else from looking at the case.' You exactly knew what I meant by this statement and you deliberately left that part out. How dare you! My comments all were based on your writings and if me stating that you can't take critism is personal and can justify your comments like: that 'you feel sorry for my child because they are being treated by paranoid and ill-mannered parents' and say I have 'baggage' then go ahead. No, these comments of yours were not at all 'slanderous.' And I guess by you stating that I started your rude and personal comments you are justifying you finishing it. (But just to let you know...I only stated something after your second post which you said I had a track record) I guess in your books that's not starting it. Anyways, Mr. Sameer I refuse to waste any more of my time and commenting on this. You won. You may be good...but realize that there may be someone better and someone else more suitable for my case. I have nothing here to show whether I am a good person or not...I could be a famous research scientist or something but that would not matter here as I have no homeopathic knowledge. I think though people can see through my posts and your posts and decide who is the nicer and more fair person.


It was nice knowing you.
hemraj last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.