The ABC Homeopathy Forum
IBS & Anosmia Page 3 of 4
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
The reason homoeopaths spend years studying is to learn these kinds of things is because human health is complicated. When people simply pick up a materia medica and start prescribing, they make huge errors out of ignorance. We have 200 years of experience, philosophy, methods. It is not simple, it is not easy, it is a complex scientific art that requires much dedication and intelligence. Computer programs have added to the illusion that simply throwing symptoms into a search function makes you a homoeopath - it does not. Not by a long shot.
As you can see from Kent's lecture, and this has been my experience as well over 20 years of face-to-face clinical treatment of patients, is that what happens after a patient takes a remedy is not always simple and clear-cut. While the medicinal effect of a remedy can be moderated with dosage and care, there are other things going on over which we have little control. The body itself, the vital energy, must reach very far at times to bring people back to health, to reverse the ravages of disease. This should not be confused with the simple pure primary effect of a homoeopathic medicine. This is how nature herself brings us back from the brink of death. Homoeopathy respects these laws. We do not use spells or enchantments to just 'wish' people back to health, we are not faith healers or those who channel divine healing. We can only utilise what nature has given us to provide cure to those in need.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 08 Nov 2011 02:38:24 GMT]
As you can see from Kent's lecture, and this has been my experience as well over 20 years of face-to-face clinical treatment of patients, is that what happens after a patient takes a remedy is not always simple and clear-cut. While the medicinal effect of a remedy can be moderated with dosage and care, there are other things going on over which we have little control. The body itself, the vital energy, must reach very far at times to bring people back to health, to reverse the ravages of disease. This should not be confused with the simple pure primary effect of a homoeopathic medicine. This is how nature herself brings us back from the brink of death. Homoeopathy respects these laws. We do not use spells or enchantments to just 'wish' people back to health, we are not faith healers or those who channel divine healing. We can only utilise what nature has given us to provide cure to those in need.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 08 Nov 2011 02:38:24 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Patients are sick and come to this forum for help. Is it fair to make them more sick for days, weeks and months?
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Did you even bother to read Dr. Kent's lecture or my comments?
That question makes no sense if you have. Why don't you offer comment on the article and the points raised.
Who decides fair? Are you God, that you can decide what suffering there is in the world, or how the human body works to create healing?
I have attempted to keep this at the level of an intellectual debate rather than an emotional one. Feel free to engage in the debate based on the arguments and observations I have presented here.
I would add a comment though in response to yours - Is it fair to give people unrealistic expectations of homoeopathy and of nature?
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 08 Nov 2011 04:26:21 GMT]
That question makes no sense if you have. Why don't you offer comment on the article and the points raised.
Who decides fair? Are you God, that you can decide what suffering there is in the world, or how the human body works to create healing?
I have attempted to keep this at the level of an intellectual debate rather than an emotional one. Feel free to engage in the debate based on the arguments and observations I have presented here.
I would add a comment though in response to yours - Is it fair to give people unrealistic expectations of homoeopathy and of nature?
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 08 Nov 2011 04:26:21 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Really no time, no interest, no need and no requirement to read already seen these aggravating article and comments. No room for arguments. Your statements are out of line and false, therefore, completely rejected.
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Would someone please describe the complete symptoms covered by the remedy Nux Vomica 200C? This will really help this patient.
♡ nawazkhan last decade
As usual, you avoid any argument or discussion about homoeopathic philosophy. I assume this is because with no training or clinical experience, you don't really understand it.
I have no idea why you challenge me like this when you cannot support anything you say.
Why not just ask the homoeopaths you work with - perhaps one of them can help you to grasp some of these homoeopathic teachings? Seems like you have a resource at your disposal that could really aid you.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Wed, 09 Nov 2011 20:07:51 GMT]
I have no idea why you challenge me like this when you cannot support anything you say.
Why not just ask the homoeopaths you work with - perhaps one of them can help you to grasp some of these homoeopathic teachings? Seems like you have a resource at your disposal that could really aid you.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Wed, 09 Nov 2011 20:07:51 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Reminder, please describe the complete symptoms covered by the remedy Nux Vomica 200C? This will really help this patient.
♡ nawazkhan last decade
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Lol is that really the best you can do.
Ah well as usual this has gone nowhere yet again.
I guess Radar doesn't tell you how homoeopathy works does it Nawaz - no program to help you with that.
Such a shame there are so few homoeopaths to actually discuss philosophy any more. No challenge at all :(
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Thu, 10 Nov 2011 04:40:24 GMT]
Ah well as usual this has gone nowhere yet again.
I guess Radar doesn't tell you how homoeopathy works does it Nawaz - no program to help you with that.
Such a shame there are so few homoeopaths to actually discuss philosophy any more. No challenge at all :(
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Thu, 10 Nov 2011 04:40:24 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Hello,
I took 4x pillules of Nux Vom 30c 3 times a day for 3 days. It's been 5 days since I stopped taking this and the 30c dosage did not take away all of the aggravation symptoms previously incurred by taking the 200c dosage.
I still have a very nervous stomach, especially in the evenings, and have started to suffer from anxiety, which gets worse as the day goes on. I also haven't had a decent night's sleep for a couple of weeks and am knackered (when I wake up, I can't get back to sleep as my stomach feels that uncomfortable). My bowel symptoms are no better. Is there anything else I can do to counteract the Nux Vom 200c, or what is the next step? I don't feel great at all.
Chelsea
ps It does feel that my initial symptoms have returned (before I even started getting IBS, I had a nervious stomach, was anxious and quite nervous).
I took 4x pillules of Nux Vom 30c 3 times a day for 3 days. It's been 5 days since I stopped taking this and the 30c dosage did not take away all of the aggravation symptoms previously incurred by taking the 200c dosage.
I still have a very nervous stomach, especially in the evenings, and have started to suffer from anxiety, which gets worse as the day goes on. I also haven't had a decent night's sleep for a couple of weeks and am knackered (when I wake up, I can't get back to sleep as my stomach feels that uncomfortable). My bowel symptoms are no better. Is there anything else I can do to counteract the Nux Vom 200c, or what is the next step? I don't feel great at all.
Chelsea
ps It does feel that my initial symptoms have returned (before I even started getting IBS, I had a nervious stomach, was anxious and quite nervous).
Chelsea33 last decade
Sir Nawaz Khan,
you follow the rules of modern homeopathic therapy but Dr. David follows the classic way.
He believes that no homeopathic remedy can give complete cure with out aggravating symptoms.
I feel so sorry for him and his patients bcs of his this offensiveness and for the unnecessary sufferings of patients.
I support and like ur prescription system u follow and as well the patients also. So you must keep going ur way.
Dr. Showrav
Chemist and Homeopathic practitioner and researcher
Bangladesh
you follow the rules of modern homeopathic therapy but Dr. David follows the classic way.
He believes that no homeopathic remedy can give complete cure with out aggravating symptoms.
I feel so sorry for him and his patients bcs of his this offensiveness and for the unnecessary sufferings of patients.
I support and like ur prescription system u follow and as well the patients also. So you must keep going ur way.
Dr. Showrav
Chemist and Homeopathic practitioner and researcher
Bangladesh
♡ Dr. Showrav last decade
'I guess Radar doesn't tell you how homoeopathy works does it Nawaz - no program to help you with that. '
I don't have Radar. Again, guess and assumption by you. Ignored. I completely reject all of your other false statements.
I really don't care and have any interest to read your fruitless posts on this thread. I came here to read what Chelsea and Dr. Showrav are saying.
You must get off my back and let me do my work.
I don't have Radar. Again, guess and assumption by you. Ignored. I completely reject all of your other false statements.
I really don't care and have any interest to read your fruitless posts on this thread. I came here to read what Chelsea and Dr. Showrav are saying.
You must get off my back and let me do my work.
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Dear Chelsea,
Sorry for all inconvenience that may have been caused due to unfortunate events.
I would like you to take Kali Phos 30C, 4 pellets dissolved in 1/4 cup of mineral water, 3 times a day, for 2 days.
Please report progress in a timely manner to deal with your changing symptoms.
Many many prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
Sorry for all inconvenience that may have been caused due to unfortunate events.
I would like you to take Kali Phos 30C, 4 pellets dissolved in 1/4 cup of mineral water, 3 times a day, for 2 days.
Please report progress in a timely manner to deal with your changing symptoms.
Many many prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Hi Dr. Showrav,
I would like to welcome you to ABC Forum.
Your comments are greatly appreciated.
Please keep up the good work.
Many prayers for your success and happy life.
Regards
Nawaz
I would like to welcome you to ABC Forum.
Your comments are greatly appreciated.
Please keep up the good work.
Many prayers for your success and happy life.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Chelsea I have advised you on what I believe to be the best way to handle this. However it appears, that as often happens on here, other people are hellbent on interfering.
You are part way down the path to cure. The proces has to be continued. Using 30c to interfere is not helpful, as I stated before you took it. If anything it has only prolonged the problem, as can clearly be seen. Waiting around to see what happens is also of no value. The treatment needs to be continued. You are not suffering from a side effect of Nux-vomica - the remedy has started what Dr. Kent called 'house cleaning' - the process of rebalancing the body. But as often happens with most patients each dose only takes you so far through it, and further doses must be given to continue. This is my experience in clinic as well.
It is foolish to abandon a remedy that has helped a patient. However, this is the normal procedure for some practitioners on this site, to jump randomly from remedy to remedy without waiting or following up on the process that has been instigated.
You are welcome to follow other advice if you wish, but you must choose one person to follow as you can see that there is a great difference with how I practice and how others do. I don't want to sit here arguing over every little aspect of treatment and Nawaz is counting on that by causing such trouble.
When following up a case I always attempt to proceed caustiously, rationally, and systematically. Cure is not always easy, it may require patience and some hard work. It also requires careful assessment of the reactions and the direction to make sure you really do achieve cure. It also requires a practitioner to 'learn' the way a specific patient reacts, so that by careful adjustment of dosage UNNECESSARY aggravations can be modified and even avoided.
Frankly I don't want to be constantly forced into defending remedy choices like this. I cannot know the remedy is right, until enough testing with it is done. I am willing to accept a remedy is wrong once I get a chance to do that. I can have confidence in it of course, but it is the results that must be the primary indication.
Choosing to 'smooth over' the symptoms, which we call palliation, is certainly less painful. It also will never cure anyone. Orthodox medicine is the master of palliation, for all the good it does chronically ill patients hoping to recover. We would be fools to try to copy them considering their overall lack of success in improving people's lives and health, and yet there is a continuing trend amongst therapists to do so.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 15 Nov 2011 02:14:43 GMT]
You are part way down the path to cure. The proces has to be continued. Using 30c to interfere is not helpful, as I stated before you took it. If anything it has only prolonged the problem, as can clearly be seen. Waiting around to see what happens is also of no value. The treatment needs to be continued. You are not suffering from a side effect of Nux-vomica - the remedy has started what Dr. Kent called 'house cleaning' - the process of rebalancing the body. But as often happens with most patients each dose only takes you so far through it, and further doses must be given to continue. This is my experience in clinic as well.
It is foolish to abandon a remedy that has helped a patient. However, this is the normal procedure for some practitioners on this site, to jump randomly from remedy to remedy without waiting or following up on the process that has been instigated.
You are welcome to follow other advice if you wish, but you must choose one person to follow as you can see that there is a great difference with how I practice and how others do. I don't want to sit here arguing over every little aspect of treatment and Nawaz is counting on that by causing such trouble.
When following up a case I always attempt to proceed caustiously, rationally, and systematically. Cure is not always easy, it may require patience and some hard work. It also requires careful assessment of the reactions and the direction to make sure you really do achieve cure. It also requires a practitioner to 'learn' the way a specific patient reacts, so that by careful adjustment of dosage UNNECESSARY aggravations can be modified and even avoided.
Frankly I don't want to be constantly forced into defending remedy choices like this. I cannot know the remedy is right, until enough testing with it is done. I am willing to accept a remedy is wrong once I get a chance to do that. I can have confidence in it of course, but it is the results that must be the primary indication.
Choosing to 'smooth over' the symptoms, which we call palliation, is certainly less painful. It also will never cure anyone. Orthodox medicine is the master of palliation, for all the good it does chronically ill patients hoping to recover. We would be fools to try to copy them considering their overall lack of success in improving people's lives and health, and yet there is a continuing trend amongst therapists to do so.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Tue, 15 Nov 2011 02:14:43 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Dear Chelsea,
After completing Kali Phos 30C for 2 days, please take Sulphur 200C, empty stomach when you get up in the morning, 4 drops in 1/4 cup of mineral water, only one dose please.
Then, you will continue with Nux Vomica 30C, one dose at 4:00PM and one dose at bed time, for 3 days.
More prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
After completing Kali Phos 30C for 2 days, please take Sulphur 200C, empty stomach when you get up in the morning, 4 drops in 1/4 cup of mineral water, only one dose please.
Then, you will continue with Nux Vomica 30C, one dose at 4:00PM and one dose at bed time, for 3 days.
More prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Hello,
I have started taking the Kali Phos so it will be easier to just stick with Nawaz's advice from now on. I am about to order the Sulphur 200c but it's going to take a few days to get here and I can only get tablets. Would tablets be ok?
Chelsea
I have started taking the Kali Phos so it will be easier to just stick with Nawaz's advice from now on. I am about to order the Sulphur 200c but it's going to take a few days to get here and I can only get tablets. Would tablets be ok?
Chelsea
Chelsea33 last decade
Alright as you wish. Good luck then.
I will be around if you need me.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Wed, 16 Nov 2011 00:09:44 GMT]
I will be around if you need me.
[message edited by brisbanehomoeopath on Wed, 16 Nov 2011 00:09:44 GMT]
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
Hi,
Tablets will be OK too. Please dissolve 4 pills in 1/4 cup of mineral water to prepare your dose.
Please take the Sulphur 200C dose first, then, after that start on Nux Vomica 30C.
More prayers for you.
Regards
Nawaz
Tablets will be OK too. Please dissolve 4 pills in 1/4 cup of mineral water to prepare your dose.
Please take the Sulphur 200C dose first, then, after that start on Nux Vomica 30C.
More prayers for you.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
David: Thank you for the good wishes.
Nawaz: I took the sulphur and the nux vom as directed and I am suffering from severe insomnia. What do you recommend? I really need to get a good night's sleep tonight :(
Kind Regards
Chelsea
Nawaz: I took the sulphur and the nux vom as directed and I am suffering from severe insomnia. What do you recommend? I really need to get a good night's sleep tonight :(
Kind Regards
Chelsea
Chelsea33 last decade
What is really happening at the time of sleep? Is your mind up at that time? Is your sleep interrupted? Are there any dreams?
When did you stop taking Nux Vomica 30C?
Are there any other mental and physical issues at the moment?
When did you stop taking Nux Vomica 30C?
Are there any other mental and physical issues at the moment?
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Hello,
I stopped taking the nux vom yesterday. During the first day of the recent treatment plan (which is when I took the sulphur), I experienced an extreme flare up of my IBS symptoms (severe gas). The flare-up died down the next day and I am now going to the loo quite frequently.
With regard to the insomnia, I still need the sleeping tablets to drop off (been taking those for years), but I've been waking up earlier and earlier every night and not been able to get back to sleep. I'm feeling a bit anxious and 'nervy' all of the time.
A few other interesting things have happened. It's a bit embarassing, but some symptoms that I used to have for as long as I remember (up until I started suffering from the IBS and insomnia) have returned. That is, itching down below while I'm asleep and biting the skin around my fingernails.
With regard to my mental health, I am feeling quite 'teary', but that could be due to the lack of sleep.
Given the little I know about homeopathy, I think that we are on the right track with the nux vom, but need to find the right dose? What do you think?
Kind Regards
Chelsea
I stopped taking the nux vom yesterday. During the first day of the recent treatment plan (which is when I took the sulphur), I experienced an extreme flare up of my IBS symptoms (severe gas). The flare-up died down the next day and I am now going to the loo quite frequently.
With regard to the insomnia, I still need the sleeping tablets to drop off (been taking those for years), but I've been waking up earlier and earlier every night and not been able to get back to sleep. I'm feeling a bit anxious and 'nervy' all of the time.
A few other interesting things have happened. It's a bit embarassing, but some symptoms that I used to have for as long as I remember (up until I started suffering from the IBS and insomnia) have returned. That is, itching down below while I'm asleep and biting the skin around my fingernails.
With regard to my mental health, I am feeling quite 'teary', but that could be due to the lack of sleep.
Given the little I know about homeopathy, I think that we are on the right track with the nux vom, but need to find the right dose? What do you think?
Kind Regards
Chelsea
Chelsea33 last decade
Hi,
Thanks for the addl. info.
Please take a dose of Kali Phos 30C as you took before and let me know the response tomorrow.
Do you have Coffea Cruda and Passiflora at home, if yes, what potencies?
More prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
Thanks for the addl. info.
Please take a dose of Kali Phos 30C as you took before and let me know the response tomorrow.
Do you have Coffea Cruda and Passiflora at home, if yes, what potencies?
More prayers for your good health.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Hi Nawaz,
Just got your msg. I managed to get a half decent sleep last night. Should I take a dose of kali phos tonight though?
I don't have any of the remedies you suggested, are you thinking antidotes?
Chelsea
[message edited by Chelsea33 on Sat, 26 Nov 2011 15:17:02 GMT]
Just got your msg. I managed to get a half decent sleep last night. Should I take a dose of kali phos tonight though?
I don't have any of the remedies you suggested, are you thinking antidotes?
Chelsea
[message edited by Chelsea33 on Sat, 26 Nov 2011 15:17:02 GMT]
Chelsea33 last decade
Hi,
Please take Kali Phos 30C, 4 pills nicely dissolved into 1/4 glass of mineral water, 3 times a day, for 3 days.
Please report progress in a couple of days.
'are you thinking antidotes?'
No, these are remedies for sleep.
Many prayers for you.
Regards
Nawaz
Please take Kali Phos 30C, 4 pills nicely dissolved into 1/4 glass of mineral water, 3 times a day, for 3 days.
Please report progress in a couple of days.
'are you thinking antidotes?'
No, these are remedies for sleep.
Many prayers for you.
Regards
Nawaz
♡ nawazkhan last decade
Hello,
I am suffering from severe insomnia-this has been happening ever since I took the first dose of nux vom a few weeks back. I am waking up at 2/3am and there's nothing I can do to get back to sleep. I've never had insomnia so bad. My life has been severely negatively affected-aswell as the insomnia, I'm suffering from bad nerves and anxiety.
I don't want to take any more homeopathicc remedies. but is there anything I can take to antidote the effects of the nux vom?
Chelsea
I am suffering from severe insomnia-this has been happening ever since I took the first dose of nux vom a few weeks back. I am waking up at 2/3am and there's nothing I can do to get back to sleep. I've never had insomnia so bad. My life has been severely negatively affected-aswell as the insomnia, I'm suffering from bad nerves and anxiety.
I don't want to take any more homeopathicc remedies. but is there anything I can take to antidote the effects of the nux vom?
Chelsea
Chelsea33 last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.