≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum



Similar posts:

Allergic Rhinitis from 7 yrs, Asthma from 2 years 68Chronic Asthma for over 21years now 360asthma in 18 years girl 1Allergic Asthma for the last 10 years and using foracort 200 6Allergic Asthma for the last 1.5 years 2514 years of asthma 4Asthma 3 1/2 yearsold 2Asthma for 2 1/2 years old. 5My eight years old asthma/hayfever 7


The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Asthma in 6 years old daughter Page 8 of 8

This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
To Dis

I would like to have your report on the present status of your daughter's Asthma.

Your last report was on May 24 and I presume that she is much better today.
Joe De Livera last decade
I would said so far it is under control.. No attack at all, but if I cut down the dosage the cough will increase.
So doctor ask me to start another new medicine but I'll tried to get it next week.
Mercurius cynatus 200C in liquid one dose in 2 drops.
Belladona 3c in liquid one dose 2 drops of water.
Take 2 time daily morning and afternoon for 3 months.
dis43686 last decade
Yesterday night my daughter had an bad attack again. It seems the old medicine Ipec and samlid as well as calc carb can't control it.
She can't eat nor drink any water and keep on vomitting and the wheezing is very loud no matter I give her ipec every 30 minutes.
So no choice today morning when to see doctor was diagnose with Bronchitis and bad infection on the lung cost the water and food can't go in, as per normal being prescribed antibiotics and presnesolone.
dis43686 last decade
dear dis,
i happened to read some of your older posts. and i found you mentioning in 2006 that your daughter is suffering from chronic urticaria.

what happened to the urticaria? is it cured? i infer that this is the same child you are talking about. (if so, did the asthma start after the urticaria was cured?).
sriram last decade
Yes the Urticaria was cured by one of the local homeopath after 1 years of testing and the last remedies cured my daughter was hepar Sulph 30 C taken for 2 weeks.
Yes is the same child , roughly around that time, the asthma come.. and I had tried various way of curing but till now still doesn't have something that cured her.
dis43686 last decade
dear dis,
you said, 'Yes is the same child , roughly around that time, the asthma come..'

then this is a sure case of SUPPRESSION. the urticaria eruptions were suppressed and the disease went deeper inside and became asthma.

sriram last decade
To Sriram

Congratulations, I believe that you have discovered the root cause of this girl's Asthma

Can you suggest how this case can now be dealt with from now on ?
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,
Thanks for your appreciation. As you know, I am not a doctor! just a fan of homeopathy which has helped me in several tough situations in life when I myself suffered terribly from asthma and a host of other ailments.

I think the suppression will have to be brought out again through homeo remedies - and the disease will change from asthma to urticaria and then the urticaria will have to be treated and cured with great care avoiding suppression.

It is not advisable to administer any remedy without knowing more about the patient.

In the repertories, following remedies are mentioned:
RESPIRATION, ASTHMATIC - eruptions, after suppressed: ant-c, Apis, Ars, calc, Carb-v, cupr, Dulc, Ferr, graph, hep, Ip, mez, Psor, PULS, rhus-t, sec, Sulph

A remedy has to be selected from this list matching the patient's symptoms.

{Also the repertory of Knerr mentions just 2 remedies,
[Respiration] Asthma; Eruption; Urticaria, from suppressed(2): 4:Puls, 3:Apis

Also, please go through this article:


I also understand that the patient's father prefers the treatment to be continued under Dr Prashanta Banerjee - in which case, he would have to bring to the notice of Dr.Prashanta that the asthma started after the urticaria was treated.

sriram last decade
To Sriram

Glad to note that you too are not qualified like me and are involved in Homeopathy purely for the satisfaction that you get in helping anyone who seeks help. You may perhaps not be aware that I am 81 years of age and I believe that I am testimony to the efficacy of Homeopathy which I have used exclusively for as long as I can remember. I only resort to drugs on a SOS basis and the last time I took an antibiotic was 2 years ago after surgery for an Inguinal Hernia after which I walked out of the hospital and only used Arnica 30c as the analgesic to the surprise of the surgeon and the nurses.

I believe that you are aware that it was I than suggested to the father Ong Chong Kiat to consult Dr Prasanta Banerji as my therapy was not helping his daughter and it is possible that your theory about suppression may be the root cause of the problem. Ong can discuss this matter with Prasanta and ask for his assistance on the basis of your theory.
Joe De Livera last decade
I'm actually waiting for Dr Prasantha to be back as at the moment he is out of town not in india, and only be back on 2nd of August.
dis43686 last decade
Hi Joe, Sai Ram and Diss.

I just have gone through the all the sequence of the posts. Please note that I am not homeo doctor; interested in Homeo and reading homeo book based my requirements.

I would like to mention about my daughters case. My daugther had rash (eruptions) on the buttocks. Allopathic doctors used to suggest some ointments (having steroids). After applying ointments it cures. Then she gets penmonia. Then we used anitiboitics and other allopathic medicines for pnemonia. Then pnemoian cures. Then get the rash back. Like that pnemoia and rash were alternating. It has taken about a year me to undestand that these two are alternating.

When I got interest in homeo and studying the books I found in the book - LECTURES ON HOMEOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA
by JAMES TYLER KENT. Under GRAPHITES he mentioned that - 'When eruptions or discharges have disappeared suddenly from any cause and grave chronic phenomena have followed Graphites is one of the medicines to be studied. ' Other GENERALS of Gaphites also matached for my daughter.

Then I got Graphites 30c and gave 3 doses in one day with 4 hrs gap. The rash was completely cured in 2 weeks. Repeated again 3 more doses, after two weeks, one day with 4 hrs gap.

This was about 2 months ago. Till now no symptoms of pnemonia (cough etc) seen and rash is also gone.

I am not sure if DISS case is also similar or not.

In the list of remedies that Sairam has mentioned from Repertory has Graphites; which suited for my daugther.

So, it may be good to study the other symptoms of patient in this case and suggest a suitable remedy.

Best Regards.
Libra1010 last decade
My daughter case is slightly different from urs.. as the urticaria had been almost 4 years never attacked. Now just have asthma and pneumonia and sometimes bronchitis... but not urticaria coming back.. So I not sure whether is supression issue or what.
dis43686 last decade
dear libra,
thanks for posting about your daughter's case cured with Graphites.

dear dis,
your daughter's case i believe is a classic case of suppression. if the disease moves from the periphery to the center and from less important organ (skin) to more vital organ (lungs) then it is definitely a case of Suppression.

when the disease was prevented from expressing itself through the skin, it went inward and attacked the lungs.

sriram last decade
Oh okay... will discuss this with Dr Prasantha but was informed that he will be in india on 8th of August.. so it takes a few week before I can discuss with him.
dis43686 last decade
Had been taken the new medicine for my daughter for 1 week. The new medicine result is not good.. after taking the new medicine she seems to be have bad sneezing everyday and today she had a flu and end up she cough very badly seems like nothing can stop the cough. I suspect is due to the flu discharge drop to her throat and cause cough.
Anybody have any good remedy for me to give her.
dis43686 last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.