≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum



Similar posts:

Anal fissure/ fistula 2Anal Fissures or Fistula 13Anal Fissures or Fistula 10Hernia (right inguinal) for years, now piles and possible anal fissure/fistula 3Anal Fissure and Fistula 4Fistula and anal fissure 12Anal Fistula - Fissure 1anal fissure and anal fistula 3Help before surgery for Anal Fistula - Fissure 13


The ABC Homeopathy Forum


This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hi Nawaj,
From your post it seem that you do not have any knowlege about fistula or the reason for its development. Fistula is no way connected with pilesand your post is very misguiding regarding the same. Please refrain from giving such post.
I have taken the medicine prescribed by Joe and had found the same quite useful. I had also recommended the same to some of my relative and they too have benefited which show that Jowpathy is working.
I once again request you not to misguide the patient in this way.
hectech last decade
To Hectec

I presume that you have read my long post to Nawaz explaining in detail the reason why I do not subscribe to the strict conventional therapy that classical homeopathy dictates as I have discovered throughout the long years that I have spent in helping patients with my Joepathy, that the manner that I use standard homeopathic remedies is more positive in curing the patient, in comparison to the remedies that 'classical' homeopaths prescribe, which do not seem to have the same success rate that I have in helping patients like you and so many thousands of others who would vouch for the fact that Joepathy works remarkably well. There are many patients who have been under the treatment of 'classical' homeopaths who were not able to cure their ailments and were cured sometimes overnight by me.

I believe that it is the conceit of people like Nawaz who I presume is a qualified homeopath that impels them to challenge my therapy simply because he was brainwashed into believing during his college days that my direct 'this for that' therapy cannnot work. What is worse is that many classical homeopaths have warned my patients that my Joepathy may cure them in the short term but that they will be soon overtaken by other more dangerous diseases like Cancer ! I find it very surprising that Nawaz persists in criticizing me on this thread as he can read the reports of many patients who have confirmed that they were CURED by my Joepathy. I am even more surprised to note that a qualified homeopath cannot differentiate a Fistula from a Hemorrhoid and yet persists in criticizing me.

I am glad that you posted your own case here as it may help skeptics like Nawaz to open their eyes to the fallacy that patients can only be cured by remedies that are prescribed by the use of 'classical' homeopathy.

To me it is not the Joepathy nor the classical homeopathy used to cure a patient that is relevant. It is the eventual cure of the patient that matters.

I shall quote Hahnemann who as you may know is the founder of Homeopathy below:

ß 1
The physicianís high and only mission is to restore the sick to health, to cure, as it is termed

ß 2
The highest ideal of cure is rapid, gentle and permanent restoration of the health, or removal and annihilation of the disease in its whole extent, in the shortest, most reliable, and most harmless way, on easily comprehensible principles.
Joe De Livera last decade
As usual, EGO, emotions, pre-judging, ridiculing the truth (First Phase), contradictions and a waste of productive time. I have not criticized, but, to extend a helping hand and support.

If the current remedies are working, then, why the patients are complaining? Unless we consider a change in remedies, NO change will come in correcting the problem.

Please try to understand, I am not misguiding, criticizing or questioning the respectable and loveable people involved. Truth is a Truth, it takes a little time before it is accepted as self-evident.

No confrontations please, let's move forward to help others and surely I don't want to waste my productive time.

nawazkhan last decade
Dear Mr.Nawazkhan,

Thanks for the positive way you have responded to Mr.Joe's post. I like it. Everyone understands that the ultimate reason for this forum is to HELP people who are in need.

Mr.Nawazkhan, you and Mr.Joe had all together different perspective on this ailment. But you can guide some other patients who like your ways of treatment so that we might have another proven way of treating Fistula. Please feel free to do so. I hope Mr.Joe doesn't mind.

Others, lets be supportive for everyone who is willing to help patients in this forum.

Sorry If I sounded stupid. I just thought I should let everyone know how I feel and we should do.

Mr. Joe, I has little constipation yesterday right after I had Oat Meal as my breakfast. Because of this I see the cycle starting again with the less PUS though.

Is Oats need to be avoided as well ? Please let me know.

rajhomeo75 last decade
TO MR. Joe,

Mr. Joe, I has little constipation yesterday right after I had Oat Meal as my breakfast. Because of this I see the cycle starting again with the less PUS though.

Is Oats need to be avoided as well ? Please let me know.

rajhomeo75 last decade
Hi Joe,
To your post I would like to say I am taking the following:

ferrum phos 6x 2 tablets x 2 per day
silicea 6x 2 tablets x 3 per day
nat phos 6 x 2 tablets x 2 per day
also arnica 30c in liquid form 3 times per day

i take one dose when i wake up in the morning about 8am. then one doz in the evening about 6 or 7 pm then one in the night before bed. I have been using polyfax after BM but i take shower after BM and then i use cream using rubber gloves.

please let me know if i hv to make any change...i am still very optimistic!
fortjames last decade
To Nawaz

'If the current remedies are working, then, why the patients are complaining? Unless we consider a change in remedies, NO change will come in correcting the problem. '

You are obviously unaware of realities in the treatment of Fistulas the etiology of which I have spelled out in great detail based on my research in my post above. Read it again and try to appreciate the reason why patients sometimes, NOT ALWAYS, complain of a return of their anal problems which I have invariably solved successfully.

There is no question of EGO in my response to you or to the others who have interfered with my therapy which one of my detractors finally admitted was correct and that he was barking up the wrong tree for years. We are the best of friends even today.

It is when you try to misguide my patients that I am compelled to protest as I have done in my response to you as it is important that the cure of the patient's ailment is permitted to continue without your irresponsible suggestions.

You are welcome to visit this thread but please DO NOT INTERFERE with my therapy in the greater interest of my patients as many have confirmed that they were CURED by it.
Joe De Livera last decade
To Raj

The answer is clear.

Do not eat Oat Meal which as you have already experienced has a tendency to harden stools.
Joe De Livera last decade
To Fort

You can stop the Silicea 6x and observe your response but continue with the other remedies.
Joe De Livera last decade
[edited by moderator]
...I am using your Joepathy since 6/8/2010 and from 27/8/2010 I had reduced the dose of Sil 6x to once daily as per your advice, all other dose remain same. From 17/9/2010 small amount of pus has started coming out of the fistula opening on the skin. Shall I again increase the dose of Sil 6x. Also to inform you that my problem of pain inside anus after BM has reduced after the pus has came out yesterday.
hectech last decade
To Hectec

I do not advise you to increase the dose of Silicea as it is a deep acting remedy and should be used only when essential.

Let us observe if the discharge of pus stabilizes and we can then decide if it is necessary to increase the frequency.
Joe De Livera last decade
I wish to inform that Neosporin is available in two forms in India. The 5 gram pack is for both skin and opthalmic use and M.R.P. is Rs. 24 but sold at Rs. 22. The other is 20 gram pack for skin ailments with M.R.P. Rs. 58 and sold for Rs.55.
I think the one for skin at Rs. 55 is better for our purpose.
The composition of both is the same.
Kanhayalal Sharma
maruvihag last decade
To Kanhayalal

Thank you for the information which will help those who suffer from Ano rectal ailments.

It would be useful if you can also indicate the brand of the Neosporin Ointment which I can prescribe to patients.
Joe De Livera last decade
Dear Joe,

[edited by moderator]

I am doing OK except there was little PUS in drops for the past 2 days. COntinuing the theraphy as dictated by you. Shall keep you posted.

rajhomeo75 last decade
To Raj

I appreciate your kind thoughts and support which are the reason why I spend a few hours daily on visiting the ABC as I have done since it was first founded by Simon Broadley. As you are perhaps aware, I boycotted this forum for 3 years due to the interference from another classical homeopath, but the pleas of many patients on this thread to return, impelled me to do so a year ago in November 2009.

I can assure you that I shall not desert this thread in the future although there is still some interference from Nawaz, as too much is at stake from the standpoint of my patients.

I am glad that you have visited my website. It is my contribution to Homeopathy which I feel has been badly distorted by many self seeking individuals who have distorted this precious science by making it more and more complicated by insisting the the patient's ailment must never be treated directly as, according to them, it is the totality of the symptoms that must be treated and that with just one single remedy. I used to prescribe on this basis but discovered that it was quite impossible to achieve any cure and the patient was left helpless. It was when I experimented with Joepathy that I succeeded in curing my patients on this and other threads on this and other forums. As a result my rate of success in cures increased by leaps and bounds and I encountered this interference from the classical types who were obviously jealous of my success in curing patients.

Please be assured that I am not the only Homeopath to use the direct 'This for That' form of therapy aka Joepathy as there are many others who have seen the light. Please visit:


Banerji Protocol of Treatment

The Banerji Protocol is a new method of treatment using homeopathic medicines. Specific medicines are prescribed for specific diseases. Diseases are diagnosed using modern/state of the art methods. This is done because modern diagnostic approaches incorporate and help in the selection of medicines so that specific medicines could be easily prescribed for specific diseases. This is not practiced in classical homeopathy.

The concept of specific homeopathic medicine for a disease based on symptoms was first perceived and practiced by Late Dr. Pareshnath Banerji. With the passage of time and the availability of new diagnostic tools like Ultrasonography, MRIs, cancer markers and other advanced tests, we were able to further streamline the treatment protocols accurately. The efficiency of this streamlining is reflected by the encouraging results of The Banerji Protocol.

In The Banerji Protocol of treatment, mixtures of remedies or frequent repetitions of the remedies are used when required. This is not practiced in classical homeopathy. The combination of two potentized medicines, we use, are made in a meaningful way based on years of clinical experiments and observations by us. They are mixed for special advantages in treatment, so that the aggravation due to drugs can be checked, side effects of the medicines can be abated, quick and uneventful recovery can be ensured in a much shorter time.

Specific homeopathic medicines are also used for supportive care. Homeopathic medicines prescribed on constitutional grounds may play a useful role in supportive and palliative for patients with malignant disease.

The Banerji Protocol is scientific, logical and is based on all modern diagnostic tools and is very realistic.

I am glad that Dr Banerji who is a qualified Classical Homeoapth has decided to boldly express his thoughts on the Classical therapy that was promoted by those who were brainwashed to only use the classical approach to healing.

The reason for this interference in my therapy suddenly dawned on me many years ago and I discovered that the real reason was MONEY in the fees that the classical homeopath generates by ensuring that the patient returns every week for that next classical remedy and each visit does not come cheap as some homeopaths charge $750 per visit.

In my case I have never accepted any financial remuneration from the thousands of patients I have treated and it was the satisfaction that I received from curing a patient that keeps me active on this and other Forums today in spite of the interference that I still have to face from those who are jealous of my Joepathy.

To me the interest of the patient comes first. Not the method used to cure him. It is the satisfaction that I receive from a cure that I look for and I am convinced that the good God favours me with good health which at my advanced age of 82 is priceless and is a tribute to my own use of Homepathic remedies to keep me in a state of health that is the envy of many who are half my age.
Joe De Livera last decade
HI Joe,

Thanks for the information in your post. I really appreciate that Homoeopaths are open for change and using latest method like MRI etc to find out the real status of the ailment.

I strongly believe that when the mix these 2, homeopathy and allopathy there will be success soon and the treatment will be effective.

Joe, I am noting in my case that my external Piles is still giving me some issues now and then. I feel at times little constipated ( no food change) and right after that I feel the pain in the external piles area. When I touch the external growth I feel the pain.

I suspect this could be still stopping the complete cure in my Fistula. If so, do you think I need to add some medicines for my Piles also ?

If Yes, what is that ? Please let me know.

Also, I red somewhere (ABC forum) that to seal the complete cure for Fistula, a dose of Tuber Cullinum 1M need to be taken. What does this would do ? I am just curious..

rajhomeo75 last decade
Dear respectable and lovely people on this thread. I am not your enemy. My goal is only to extend a helping hand.

Again, I am not criticising or have any hidden agenda. Please take a positive appraoch, please do not assume and please do not go into panic. Truth is very powerful. Facts are facts.

According to forum rule 1, I would like to express my opinion for the benefit of all.

Arnica, taking for life as recommended by some people here or long term usage of Arnica causes various ill effects on human health.

'The long term usage of arnica montana has adverse effects on the body organs such as liver, kidney, and heart. In severe cases, it has resulted even in organ damage. Thus, the side effects of arnica montana can even lead to death in some'.

To see the above comment, you may visit at http://www.buzzle.com/articles/arnica-montana-side-effects.h....

In order find more on the long term use of Arnica Montana, you may perform search thru google.

However, let me get to the point, reading this thread, I have come to the conclusion that the people who are taking ARNICA for life are showing symptoms of its effects. Therefore, please try to understand, I care for you guys, I am not your enemy and no way I have any worldly gain or any other objective. Since the prolonged use of Arnica has severe impact on your muscular tissues, please take the following remedy.

Berberis Vulgaris Q 4 drops in 2 sips of water, 3 times a day, for at least one month.

Please use a little more quantity of TURMERIC powder in your daily meals (while cooking).

Please do not hesitate to ask any Q's regarding Anal Fistula remedy(s) as the symptoms change during this illness.

Kind Regards
nawazkhan last decade

I cannot remember you mentioning your Hemorrhoids up to today.

The remedy is Hamamelis 200 in the Wet dose taken twice daily.

You will stop the Arnica as long as you take the Hamamelis as Arnica is listed as an antidote in Boericke.
Joe De Livera last decade
Hi Joe,

Sorry about it and I had mentioned about the same long time back. Sorry again if I hadn't.

I shall order the medicine and start the same once i have it.
I think I have the pills. Can I Use it ?

rajhomeo75 last decade
The pellets of any remedy can be used as a temporary stopgap.

For a more positive effect, you must make the remedy with 87% Ethanol and use it in the Wet dose.
Joe De Livera last decade
Hello Joe

I am a 31 year old male, (had gall bladder surgery 12 years ago and take cholestyramine every day for the loose bowels) and I've had an anal abscess for a few years and it kept getting bigger and it would slightly burst and feel better for a few days and then it would start getting swollen all over again. finally about 6 weeks ago, i was taking a hot bath and I was cleaning it heavily and the skin over it came off and left a raw open wound.. I read that Manuka honey is good for rebuilding the tissue when applied to the wound, and I have been using it for the past month and it seems to be healing slowly. i can tell that there is a fistula hole at the center. I have been using your jeopathy regimen exactly as you prescribe it for everyone on here, while i was using the honey.
It seems to be healing little by little, however a week ago, I started getting red bumps all over my abdomen, buttocks, back, arms, and almost everywhere on my body. They are not itchy, except the ones on the buttocks and groin. it seems that they have multiplied in my abdomen over the days.
do you think it could be an infection from the healing open fistula or a reaction to the remedies (silica, nat phos, Ferr phos, arnica)? I would really appreciate your feedback. thank you very much.
nyc31 last decade

I note that you are taking Cholestyramine daily to replace the bile you lack after surgery. I believe that this is the causative factor for your Anal problems and the bumps you describe and you can consult your doctors for an alternative brand which can hopefully settle all your problems.

It is very unlikely that the Joepathy you are using can be the cause.
Joe De Livera last decade
'The pellets of any remedy can be used as a temporary stopgap.' This is a statement made today on this forum by a senior, respectable and dedicated individual.

In my considered opinion, the above statement is false.

Because, millions of patients around the world are taking homeopathic remedies in the shape of pellets, made by Boiron, Washington Homeopathic Products, Hyland and many others and they get cured. It works permanently, not a temporary fix.

If the pellets are stopgap, then, Boiron and others should stop making remedies in pellets.

nawazkhan last decade
The anal fistula patients with TUBERCULOSIS issues are recommended to take


one dose, Once a week.

Although the above remedies are considered the same, but, there are slight differences.

Please compare your symptoms with TUBERCULINUM and BACILLINUM and find out which remedy is the best fit. However, TUBERCULINUM is taken when symptoms are constantly changing and other remedies have failed. Patient feels tired, gets cold in no time, wants constant changes, motion causes intense fatigue and aversion to work etc.

This will help in the timely healing and cure of anal fistula.

nawazkhan last decade
If Hemorrhoids, in addition to anal fistula are there, then, please consider taking Hamamelis 200C depending upon the following symptoms?

1. The anus feels raw and sore.
2.Bleeding hemorrhoids
3. Feeling of pulsation in the rectum.
4. Symptoms may be worse from warmth.
5. The lower back aches.

If the above symptoms are not there, then, please match your symptoms with the following important remedies for Hemorrhoids and consider taking after the best match with your symptoms? Please select one or more from the following list depending upon your hemorrhoids symptoms.

1. Aesculus hippocastanum
2. Graphites
3. Thuja
4. Aloe
5. Calcarea Fluorica
6. Arnica montana
7. Ignatia
8. Pulsatilla
9. Sulphur
10. Nux Vomica

Good luck and please never hesitate to ask any questions.

nawazkhan last decade

My symptoms are matching with the remedy for Hamamellis and so I am going to take that. Mr. Joe had advised me to take 2 doses daily and I am following that.

Also, can you please let me know what does it mean by ' TUBERCULOSIS '. I am matching with the symptoms you have mentioned here
Patient feels tired, gets cold in no time, wants constant changes, motion causes intense fatigue and aversion to work etc. '

Does this mean that I have TUBERCULOSIS ? Please let me know.

rajhomeo75 last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register


Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.